1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2015
PRESENT
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE VINEET SARAN
AND
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE B MANOHAR
STRP NOS.329/2014 & 482-487 OF 2014
IN
STA NOS. 2570 – 2576/2012
BETWEEN:
The State of Karnataka,
Rep. by the Secretary,
Finance Department,
Vidhana Soudha,
Bangalore.
….Petitioner
(By Sri. T.K.Vedamurthy, HCGP)
AND:
M/s. Manyata Promoters Pvt. Ltd.,
Richmond Road,
Bangalore – 560 025
Represented by its Dealer.
….Respondent
(By Sri. K.P.Kumar, Senior Advocate a/w
Sri. S.Siva Kumar, adv.,)
2
These STRP’s are filed under Section 65(1) of
Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, against the judgment
and order dated: 23.01.2014 passed in STA.No’s.2570
to 2576/2012 on the file of Karnataka Appellate
Tribunal, Bengaluru, allowing the appeals.
These revision petitions coming on for admission
this day, B.MANOHAR J,. delivered the following:
O R D E R
The Revenue has preferred these revision petitions
challenging the order dated 23-01-2014 made in STA
Nos.2570-2576/2012 passed by the Karnataka
Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
Tribunal’ for short) holding that the assessee is entitled
for the benefit of refund of tax paid on purchase of
inputs as Special Economic Zone Developer (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the SEZ’ for short) for the tax period
from April 2009 to March 2010.
2. The assessee is a Private Limited Company and is
a registered dealer under the provisions of the
3
Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the KVAT Act’ for short) having TIN
No.29070284329. Dealer is a developer of Special
Economic Zone, at Rachenahalli, Nagavara Outer Ring
Road, vide order dated 23-4-2007, issued by the
Development Commissioner, Cochin, SEZ, Cochin, the
authorities specified by the Central Government in this
behalf. As per the policy of Government of India, as a
SEZ Developer, the assessee is entitled for refund of
input tax paid on purchases from the local registered
dealers and the contractors. The assessee filed returns
in Form VAT-100 before the jurisdictional LVO-020 as
prescribed under the KVAT Act for the Tax period from
April 2009 to May 2010 and claimed refund of input tax
paid on purchases on the ground that the assessee is a
developer of SEZ at Rachenahalli. The dealer has
submitted a detailed purchase statement and SEZ
monthly report copies for verification. The Assessing
Officer after verifying the purchase statement submitted
4
by the dealer noticed that the dealer has claimed input
tax credit in a particular tax period related to purchase
of some other months. Accordingly, issued an
endorsement dated 31-3-2011 proposing to disallow the
input tax claimed by the dealer. In response to the said
endorsement, the dealer has filed objections to the said
proposition notice contending that no where in the
KVAT Act, it is stated that the purchasing dealer has to
claim input tax credit on the same period, in which the
bills have been raised by the selling dealers. Section 10
and other Sections of the KVAT Act do not state
anywhere that the purchasing dealer has to claim input
tax credit in the same month vis-a-vis the dates of the
invoices raised by the selling dealer. The sale of goods
is completed only after the goods purchased are cleared
by their Purchase Department and in some cases, by
their Technical Consultants. Hence, it is unavoidable
that the bills raised by the Suppliers in a particular
month are processed only in subsequent months
5
leading to the accounting of these purchases in their
books of account in the month in which the bills of the
Suppliers are recognized and accounted as purchased.
The objections filed by the dealer has been examined
with the provisions of KVAT Act by the Assistant
Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, by its proceedings
dated 26-05-2011, relying upon Section 35(4) of the
KVAT Act and has disallowed refund of input tax to the
extent of Rs.5,18,64,074/- while allowing refund of
input tax to an extent of Rs.84,95,621/-. Being
aggrieved by the order dated 26-5-2011, the dealer filed
an appeal before the Joint Commissioner of Commercial
Taxes, (Appeals)-I, Bangalore (hereinafter referred to as
‘the First Appellate Authority’ for short). The First
Appellate Authority allowed the appeal in part except
disallowing the refund with respect to the belated claims
of input tax claims made in the monthly returns for the
purpose of refund. Being not satisfied with the order