AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Intermediate Education Act, the U.P Secondary Education Services Commission and Selection Boards Act, 1982 (U.P Act No. 5 of 1982)
  • 1981, Rule 9 of U.P Secondary Education Service Commission Rules 1983 and Regulation 6 of Chapter II of Intermediate Education Act, 1921
  • Regulation (6)1 of Chapter II of the Regulations of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921
  • Regulation 3 of chapter II of Regulations of the Intermediate Education Act
  • Rule 9 of U.P Secondary Education service Commission Rules, 1983
  • Section 18 of Act No. 5 of 1982
  • Education Act, 1921
  • Rule 4(2).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Intermediate Education Act, the U.P Secondary Education Services Commission and Selection Boards Act, 1982 (U.P Act No. 5 of 1982)
  • 1981, Rule 9 of U.P Secondary Education Service Commission Rules 1983 and Regulation 6 of Chapter II of Intermediate Education Act, 1921
  • Regulation (6)1 of Chapter II of the Regulations of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921
  • Regulation 3 of chapter II of Regulations of the Intermediate Education Act
  • Rule 9 of U.P Secondary Education service Commission Rules, 1983
  • Section 18 of Act No. 5 of 1982
  • Education Act, 1921
  • Rule 4(2).
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Sudhir Narain, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was appointed as an ad hoc lecturer in Sanatan Dharam Intermediate College, Muzaffarnagar by an appointment letter dated 18 January 1991. Suresh Pal (respondent No. 3) filed a writ petition in this Court claiming entitlement to promotion as a lecturer. The learned Single Judge quashed the appellant's appointment to the post of lecturer in Economics and directed that respondent No. 3 be considered for appointment as a lecturer in Economics.

Relevant factual chronology as stated in the opinion:

  • Respondent No. 3 (Suresh Pal) was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in L.T. grade on 6 September 1974 and was later confirmed in that post.
  • Sri N.C. Mittal was working as a permanent lecturer in Economics and, on his retirement, a vacancy to the post of lecturer in Economics arose. (The opinion records retirement dates in different paragraphs: one place states 30th June, 1988; another paragraph records 30th January, 1988.)
  • The Committee of Management (respondent No. 2) notified the vacancy to the Higher Education Service Commission through the District Inspector of Schools and decided to make ad hoc appointments by direct recruitment; the post was advertised on 21 January 1989.
  • In pursuance of the selection, the appellant was selected and the District Inspector of Schools (respondent No. 1) approved the appointment; an appointment letter was issued to the appellant on 28 January 1991.
  • Respondent No. 3 claimed he was entitled to promotion to the post of lecturer in Economics and filed the writ petition, which resulted in the Single Judge quashing the appellant's appointment. This appeal followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the grant of a lecturer's pay scale to a teacher (by government order) equates to placement in the "lecturer's grade" such that the teacher cannot be promoted thereafter to a substantive post of lecturer.
  2. Whether the term "grade" in the relevant statutes and rules (Removal of Difficulties order 1981 para 4(2), Regulation 6(1) of Chapter II of the Intermediate Education Act 1921, and Rule 9 of U.P. Secondary Education Service Commission Rules 1983) should be interpreted as denoting a pay scale or instead as denoting the substantive post/cadre of lecturer.
  3. Whether the Committee of Management could proceed to appoint the appellant by direct recruitment without considering promotion of respondent No. 3 in accordance with statutory provisions (Section 18 of Act No. 5 of 1982 and related regulations).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Respondent No. 3 had been given the lecturer's pay scale on 24 January 1991 with retrospective effect from 1 January 1986 pursuant to a Government Order dated 28 February 1990; therefore he should be treated as being in the lecturer's grade and could not claim promotion to the post of lecturer.
  • The argument relied on para 4(2) of the U.P. Secondary Education Services Commission (Removal of Difficulties) Order, 1981, which provides that every vacancy in the post of a teacher in lecturer's grade may be filled by promotion by the seniormost teacher of the institution in the trained graduate (L.T) grade.
  • Relying on statutory framework (Intermediate Education Act 1921 regulations, U.P. Act No. 5 of 1982 and U.P. Secondary Education Service Commission Rules 1983), it was submitted that the law contemplates distinct grades — C.T., L.T. and lecturer's grade — and that “grade” should be read as inclusive of pay-scale status.

Respondent's Position (as presented in the opinion)

  • Respondent No. 3 claimed a right to promotion to the post of lecturer in Economics and pursued that claim before the Single Judge by way of writ petition; the Single Judge found he was entitled to promotion and quashed the appellant's appointment. The opinion does not set out further contested legal submissions of respondent No. 3 in detail.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.K. Subraman v. Union of India (Supreme Court) Illustration that the word "grade" has various shades of meaning in service jurisprudence — sometimes denoting pay scale and sometimes denoting cadre or posts; interpretation depends on context. The court quoted this authority for the proposition that "grade" can mean different things and used it to analyze whether "grade" in the education statutes means pay scale or post/cadre. The court concluded that in the statutory context at issue, "grade" should be read as denoting the post.
Hari Nandan Saran v. S.B. Dikshit Held that officials holding posts in the same scale of pay shall be taken to be on the same grade. The court observed that this precedent is not applicable to the present facts because the appellant was not claiming parity of pay scale with respondent No. 3 nor claiming discrimination on that basis.
Cham Chandra Tiwari v. D.I.O.S (Division Bench of this Court) Rule that direct recruitment is permissible only when an eligible teacher for promotion is not available in the institution. The court applied this principle to hold that, because the Committee of Management did not consider the case of promotion of respondent No. 3, the appointment of the appellant by direct recruitment was improper and was rightly set aside by the Single Judge.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a statutory and contextual interpretation of the term "grade" as used in the relevant instruments (the Removal of Difficulties order 1981 para 4(2), Rule 9 of the U.P. Secondary Education Service Commission Rules 1983 and Regulation 6 of Chapter II of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921). Key steps in the court's analysis were:

  • The court acknowledged authorities that "grade" can mean different things (including pay scale or cadre) and referred to A.K. Subraman to show that context determines meaning.
  • The court rejected the appellant's submission that the grant of a lecturer's pay scale (by a Government order dated 28 February 1990, implemented for respondent No. 3 on 24 January 1991 with effect from 1 January 1986) converted respondent No. 3 into holding the substantive post of lecturer. The court reasoned that pay scale alone does not equate to the substantive post. The mere award of a pay scale does not, without due promotion according to statutory procedure, result in the filling of a substantive post.
  • The court emphasized that promotion and occurrence of vacancies must be judged in terms of substantive posts: if a person is not appointed to a post, the grant of a pay scale cannot be treated as having filled the post.
  • The court noted procedural chronology: the vacancy was notified to the Commission on 21 January 1989, and respondent No. 3's pay scale order was only dated 24 January 1991 (operative from 1 January 1986). The District Inspector of Schools did not treat respondent No. 3 as having been appointed to the post of lecturer in Economics when approving the appellant's appointment.
  • The court relied on Section 18(1)(b) of Act No. 5 of 1982 to explain that promotion to the post of lecturer must occur "in accordance with the manner provided" under that statute and that the provision contemplates a substantive post which may be filled by promotion if the post has remained vacant for more than two months and the conditions are satisfied.
  • The court held that seniority in lecturer's grade must be counted from the date of appointment to the lecturer's post, not from the date on which the Government granted a lecturer's pay scale; it invoked Regulation 3 of Chapter II of the Regulations of the Intermediate Education Act to that effect, and stated that seniority for ad hoc appointees should follow the same principle rather than be based on a mere grant of pay scale.
  • Applying the principle from Cham Chandra Tiwari that direct recruitment is permissible only when an eligible teacher for promotion is not available or not considered, the court concluded that because the Committee of Management did not consider respondent No. 3 for promotion, the Committee's appointment of the appellant by direct recruitment was improper.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The Single Judge's order setting aside the appellant's appointment by direct recruitment was held to be correct.

Implications:

  • Direct, concrete effect: The appellant's ad hoc appointment to the post of lecturer in Economics was set aside; the Single Judge's direction that respondent No. 3 be considered for appointment was sustained by this court's dismissal of the appeal.
  • Interpretive implication limited to the case: The court held that, in the statutory context before it, the word "grade" denotes the substantive post (or cadre) to be filled by promotion; a mere grant of a higher pay scale under a government order does not itself amount to appointment to the substantive post for purposes of promotion, vacancy-filling, or seniority.
  • No broader precedent announced beyond the statutory interpretation and application to these facts: The opinion applies established principles (including those cited from A.K. Subraman and Cham Chandra Tiwari) to the facts, and directs that promotions and seniority be governed by the statutory procedures rather than by administrative grant of pay scales alone.
  • The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Disposition: Appeal dismissed.

    Vipin Kumar v. District Inspector Of Schools, Muzaffarnagar

    Sudhir Narain, J.:— The appellant was appointed as adhoc lecturer in Sanatan Dharam Intermediate College, Muzaffarnagar (hereinafter referred to as the college) by the Committee of Management by appointment letter dated 18th January, 1991. Suresh Pal, respondent No. 3 filed a writ petition in this Court and the learned single Judge found that he was entitled to be promoted as lecturer and therefore quashed the appointment of the appellant to the post of lecturer in Economics and directed that respondent No. 3 be considered for appointment as a lecturer in Economics.

    2. Suresh Pal, respondent No. 3 was appointed as Assistant Teacher in L.T grade in the college on 6th September 1974. He was later on confirmed on the said post. One Sri N.C Mittal was working as permanent lecturer in Economics. He retired on 30th June, 1988 and a vacancy to the post of lecturer in Economics occurred. The Committee of Management, respondent No. 2 intimated the vacancy of the post of lecturer in Economics to the Higher Education service commission through District Inspector of Schools and further decided to make adhoc appointments by direct recruitment, it advertised the post on 21st January, 1989. The petitioner made representation to the committee of Management that he was entitled to be promoted to the post of lecturer in Economics as he was duly qualified for the said post. The Committee of Management, however, proceeded to make appointment through direct recruitment. The appellant was selected for appointment to the post of lecturer in Economics and the District Inspector of School, Muzaffarnagar, respondent No. 1, gave approval for the said appointment and in pursuance of his approval an appointment letter was issued to the appellant on 28th January, 1991. Respondent No. 3 claimed that he was entitled to be promoted to the post of lecturer in Economics but as he was not promoted to the said post he filed a writ petition in this Court and the learned Single Judge took the view that as respondent No. 3 was qualified and eligible for promotion, the appointment of the appellant by direct recruitment was illegal. We have heard Sri Ashok Khare, learned counsel for the appellant and Sri Ashok Bhushan learned counsel for the respondents.

    3. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that respondent No. 3 was given pay scale of lecturer on 24th January, 1991 with effect from 1.1.1986 by the District Inspector of School in pursuance of the G.O dated 28th February, 1990 issued by the Government. After he was granted lecturer's pay scale, he should be treated in lecturer's grade and he could not have been promoted to the post of lecturer. It is only a teacher in L.T grade who could be promoted to lecturer's grade. He placed reliance upon para 4(2) of U.P Secondary Education Services Commission (Removal of Difficulties) order 1981 which reads as under:—

    “Every vacancy in the post of a teacher in lecturer's grade may be filled by promotion by the seniormost teacher of the institution in the trained graduate (L.T) grade.”

    4. It was contended that various provisions of the Intermediate Education Act, the U.P Secondary Education Services Commission and Selection Boards Act, 1982 (U.P Act No. 5 of 1982) and the Removal of Difficulties orders framed under the provisions of the said Act, contemplate three grades, namely, C.T grade, L.T grade and lecturer's grade. Regulation (6)1 of Chapter II of the Regulations of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921 Contemplates L.T grade and C.T grade and similarly Rule 9 of U.P Secondary Education service Commission Rules, 1983 also provides for the post of L.T and C.T grades. The word used is “grade”.

    5. The Government issued an order dated 28th February 1990 which provided that those teachers who were working in L.T grade and were imparting education to students of 11 and 12 classes continuously for ten years shall be placed in lecturer's pay scale with effect from the date of completion of ten years, Respondent No. 3 in pursuance of the said Government order was given lecturer's pay scale on 24th January 1991 with effect from 1.1.1986 As he was given lecturers pay scale with effect from 1.1.1986 he should be treated in lecturer's grade and he cannot claim promotion to the post of lecturer. The grade should be taken as equivalent to pay scale in as much as it is pay scale which makes the difference in grade. This submission of the learned counsel for the appellant, if accepted, would result in anomalous position. A teacher may be raven lecturer's pay scale even though there is no vacancy to the post of lecturer. The grant of lecturer's pay scale is not correlated with the filling of vacancy in a particular post. In a college where teachers are appointed in L.T grade and they are given lecturer's pay scale, then in that situation there would not occur any vacancy to the post of lecturer and on the other hand the post may not exist but the teachers are given lecturer's pay scale. The word “grade” has different connotation in the context of a particular statute.

    6. In A.K Subraman v. Union of India,1 the Supreme Court, while considering the meaning of grade, took the view that the word grade has various shades of meaning. The relevant observation may be quoted here under:—

    “Now the question which arises for consideration is what is the meaning of the words “Vacancies in the grade of Executive Engineer” as used in the aforesaid paragraph of Rule 4(2). When does a vacancy in the grade of Executive engineer arise? To answer this question it is necessary to ascertain what are the posts which the grade of Executive Engineer consists of, for the vacancies can only be in the posts in the grade of Executive Engineer. The word “grade” has various shades of meaning in the service jurisprudence. It is sometimes used to denote a pay scale and sometimes a cadre. Here it is obviously used in the sense of cadre. A cadre may consist only of permanent posts or sometimes, as is quite common these days, also of temporary posts.”

    7. Learned counsel for the appellant placed reliance upon Hari Nandan Saran v. S.B Dikshit,2 in which it was held that the officials holding posts in the same scale of pay shall be taken to be on same grade. This case has no application to the facts of the present case inasmuch as the appellant is not claiming that he was also on the same scale of pay as that of respondent No. 3 and there was any discrimination against him.

    8. The word “grade” used in para 4(2) of the Removal of Difficulties order, 1981, Rule 9 of U.P Secondary Education Service Commission Rules 1983 and Regulation 6 of Chapter II of Intermediate Education Act, 1921 must be taken as “post” of lecturer. A teacher, who is working in L.T grade, is to be promoted to the post of lecturer's grade in the sense that he is to be promoted to the post of lecturer in an institution. A teacher may be given lecturer's pay scale but he may not be given the post. Unless he is given a post the mere fact that he has been given lecturer's pay scale will not be taken as to have given him the post of Lecturer unless he is duly promoted to the said post in accordance with the provisions of a statute.

    9. The vacancy to the post of lecturer fell vacant on the retirement of Sri N.C Mittal on 30th January, 1988 who was a lecturer in Economics. Respondent No. 3 was given lecturer's pay scale by the District Inspector of Schools by order dated 24th January 1991 with effect from 1.1.1986 and if it is taken that respondent No. 3 was already a lecturer in Economics there was no question of occurrence of any vacancy to the said post. There is no dispute that the post was treated as vacant on the retirement of Sri N.C Mittal and therefore the appellant was appointed to the said post by direct recruitment ignoring the claim of respondent No. 3.

    10. There is another aspect of the matter that the vacancy to the post of lecturer in Economics was notified by the committee of Management to the Commission on 21st January 1989 and respondent No. 3 was given lecturer's pay scale on 24th January 1991 with effect from 1.1.1986 In case he is taken to have been promoted to lecturer's grade, there was no occasion for issuing any appointment letter to the appellant to the said post. Respondent No. 3 was already claiming right of promotions to the said post and on the grant of lecturer's pay scale he could have been taken to have been promoted to the said post. The District Inspector of Schools himself did not treat respondent No. 3 as a lecturer in Economics and therefore permitted the appellant to be appointed on the post of lecturer in Economics in the college. It is thus clear that even though respondent No. 3 was given lecturer's pay scale he was not treated to have been appointed to the post of lecturer in Economics in the college.

    11. The promotion to the post of lecturer is to be made in accordance with the manner provided under Section 18 of Act No. 5 of 1982 which reads as under:—

    “Section 18(1)(b)—The post of such teacher has actually remained vacant for more than two months then the management may appoint by direct recruitment or promotion, a teacher on purely ad hoc basis from amongst the persons possessing qualifications prescribed under the Intermediate Education Act, 1921 or the regulations made thereunder.”

    12. This provision contemplates a post on which promotion is to be made and further prescribes certain qualifications for promotion.

    13. The seniority of a teacher of lecturer's grade is also to be considered from the date of appointment to the post in lecturer's grade and not from the date of payment of lecturer's pay scale. Regulation 3 of chapter II of Regulations of the Intermediate Education Act contemplates seniority from the date of appointment and the same principle has to be made applicable in case of persons appointed on ad hoc basis. The seniority cannot be fixed on the basis of grant of pay scale given by the Government under its own orders.

    14. As held by a Division Bench of this court in Cham Chandra Tiwari v. D.I.O.S, direct recruitment is permissible only when eligible teacher for promotion is not available in the institution. As Committee of Management did not consider the case of promotion of respondent No. 3 to the post of lecturer in Economics in the college, the appointment of the appellant to the post by direct recruitment was rightly set aside. In the result there is no merit in the appeal. It is accordingly dismissed. The parties shall, however, bear their own costs.

    15. Appeal Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vipin Kumar v. District Inspector Of Schools, Muzaffarnagar
    (Aug 20, 1993)