AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit concerns certain immovable properties said to have been endowed for the Arthajama Kattalai of the Sri Nageswaraswami temple, Kumbakonam. Prior to 1918 Periaswami Mudaliar enjoyed the properties and performed the kattalai. There is a dispute whether the properties were wholly dedicated to the trust or were only subject to a charge in favour of the trust.

On Periaswami's insolvency the Official Receiver sold the properties as Periaswami's properties subject to the rights of the kattalai. Defendant 1 purchased them in August 1918 (though the formal sale deed from the Official Receiver was executed only in August 1920). For some years before 1918 the properties had been in the possession of a tenant.

In 1919 Periaswami applied to the Divisional Magistrate, Kumbakonam, asserting the trust character of the properties, alleging that he had resumed possession in March 1919, and seeking an order under Section 144 or Section 145, Criminal P.C. The Magistrate, by order Ex. I dated 17 February 1920, held that defendant 1 was in possession and declared him entitled to possession until evicted in due course of law.

The present plaintiff is Periaswami's mother, Periaswami having died in August 1928. The plaint refers to events in November 1925 and suggests the plaintiff became entitled to the trusteeship either from November 1925 or from Periaswami's death in August 1928. Besides defendant 1, two other defendants were impleaded: the trustee of Nageswaraswami temple and another person associated with the Arthajama Kattalai by an Endowments Board scheme. Arrangements had been made for the carrying out of the kattalai by payments from defendant 1 out of the suit properties.

The lower court disposed of the case on the plea of limitation under Article 47 of the Limitation Act. The present appeal raises the question whether Article 47 bars the plaintiff's suit which was instituted more than three years after the Magistrate's order Ex. I.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Article 47 of the Limitation Act bars a suit instituted more than three years after a Magistrate's order made under Section 145, Criminal P.C., in respect of possession of immovable property.
  2. Whether an order under Section 145, Criminal P.C., when entered in proceedings involving trust property (and entered against a trustee) binds the trust and subsequent trustees (i.e., whether a successor trustee is bound by such an order because he "claims under" his predecessor).
  3. Whether a claimant who acquires a new or "fresh" title after the Magistrate's order (for example, by death of a predecessor or by execution of a sale deed) can escape the operation of Article 47.
  4. Whether the plaintiff in this case (the mother and successor to Periaswami) is a person not bound by the Magistrate's order or not claiming under a person so bound, so as to avoid the limitation bar.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The plaintiff is not a person bound by the Magistrate's order under Section 145, Criminal P.C., nor is she claiming under a person so bound; therefore Article 47 should not bar her suit.
  • Reliance was placed on a statement in Mahomed v. Ganapathi (1900) 13 Mad 277 that "one dharmakartha does not derive his title from his predecessor", supporting the proposition that successors do not necessarily claim through predecessors.
  • It was suggested that Article 28 (Limitation Act) consequences might lead to a trust being deprived of property after three years; concerns were raised about that consequence.
  • It was argued that at the date of the Magistrate's order Periaswami was not entitled to possession because the lessee had the right to remain until an advance of Rs. 500 was repaid; this fact (gleaned from the Magistrate's order and the Official Receiver's sale deed) was relied on to challenge the premise of Periaswami's possession.
  • The appellant invoked decisions (Bolai Chand Ghosal v. Samiruddin Mandal (1892) 19 Cal 646 and Subbalakshmi Ammal v. Narasimiah 1927 52 MLJ 482) in connection with arguments about redemption or fresh title, and argued that a fresh title accrued to the plaintiff on Periaswami's death and/or that Periaswami obtained a fresh title when the Official Receiver executed the sale deed to defendant 1.

Court's Responses (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The court rejected the contention that Article 47 should never be applied to trust properties and held that Section 145 relates to possession and is applicable whether the claimant is a private owner or claiming on behalf of a trust.
  • If a trustee purported to act on behalf of the trust, the order should be interpreted as binding the trust itself, and succeeding trustees filing suit to set aside such an order would be acting on behalf of the trust and thus be within the scope of Article 47.
  • The observation in Mahomed v. Ganapathi was treated as requiring qualification and was contrasted with Privy Council authority in Gnanasambanda Pandara Sannadhi v. Velu Pandaram (1900) 23 Mad 271.
  • The court noted that questions of redemption and whether a lessee's right made Periaswami's possession false were not properly raised in the pleadings nor supported by the lease deed before the court; hence it was unnecessary to decide whether a redemption suit would be barred by Article 47 in the present pleadings.
  • The court considered the appellant's invoked authorities (Bolai Chand Ghosal and Subbalakshmi Ammal) to be beside the point on the facts and pleadings of this case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahomed v. Ganapathi (1900) 13 Mad 277 at p. 280 Statement that "one dharmakartha does not derive his title from his predecessor" (used to support that a successor trustee may not claim under a predecessor). The court qualified this statement and treated it with "considerable qualifications", holding it cannot be read to defeat the principle that successors may claim under predecessors in many circumstances.
Gnanasambanda Pandara Sannadhi v. Velu Pandaram (1900) 23 Mad 271 (Privy Council) Authority indicating that an heir's entitlement is through and from his predecessor (quotation: "The respondent Velu can only be entitled as heir to his father Nataraja and from and through him"). Used by the court to show that the broad observation in Mahomed v. Ganapathi is not correct without qualification and to support the proposition that successors can claim through predecessors.
Srinivasacharlu v. Subudhi (1912) 23 MLJ 348 Cited in argument as an instance where a suit could be brought on behalf of the trust by someone who could be said not to be claiming under the trustee who was party to the Section 145 order. The court observed that if such a situation exists (a person not claiming under the trustee who was party to the order) the title of the trust may be protected; this observation was made to explain that such exceptions do not alter the result in the present case.
Bolai Chand Ghosal v. Samiruddin Mandal (1892) 19 Cal 646 Cited in connection with arguments about fresh title or redemption rights. The court held the citation to be beside the point for the facts and pleadings before it and did not apply the decision to alter the outcome in this appeal.
Subbalakshmi Ammal v. Narasimiah 1927 52 MLJ 482 Cited in connection with the redemption / fresh title arguments invoked in the appeal papers. The court regarded the decision as not relevant to the central issue on the present pleadings and facts, and did not treat it as changing the result.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court approached the matter primarily as a question arising under Article 47 of the Limitation Act in relation to an earlier Magistrate's order made under Section 145, Criminal P.C.

The court reasoned that Section 145 deals with the question of possession of immovable property and that its application does not depend on whether the claim is asserted by a private owner or on behalf of a trust. If there is a bona fide dispute between a trust and a third person and the other conditions of Section 145 are satisfied, the Magistrate has jurisdiction irrespective of the trust character of the property.

The court rejected the appellant's contention that Article 47 should not be applied to trust properties in the context of possession proceedings. It held that if a trustee purports to act on behalf of the trust in Section 145 proceedings, the proper interpretation is that the trust itself was a party to those proceedings and that the trust (and therefore successors acting for the trust) are bound by the Magistrate's order. The court considered it contrary to the purpose of possession proceedings — which require prompt settlement of possession disputes — to allow succeeding trustees to challenge such orders after an indefinite period.

The court dealt with the authorities relied upon by the appellant. It qualified the broad statement in Mahomed v. Ganapathi and relied upon Privy Council authority in Gnanasambanda Pandara Sannadhi v. Velu Pandaram to support the proposition that successors may claim through predecessors. The court also observed that doctrines of adverse possession have been applied in a way that once adverse possession starts, it operates against the then trustee and against successors.

The court acknowledged a submission that Section 28 of the Limitation Act might lead to serious consequences (i.e., possible deprivation of trust property on expiry of three years). It declined to resolve whether lapse of three years will in every case extinguish title, observing instead that in some circumstances (for example, where someone not claiming under the trustee who was party to the Section 145 order brings a suit) the trust's title might be protected (citing Srinivasacharlu v. Subudhi as an example).

A further factual-point raised by the appellant — that at the date of the Magistrate's order Periaswami was not in fact entitled to possession because of the lessee's right to remain until repayment of an advance of Rs. 500 — was noted to be unsupported by the pleadings or issues in the lower court and the lease deed was not before the appellate court. The court therefore did not decide whether a properly framed suit for redemption would be barred by Article 47 on the present pleadings.

On the question of whether a "fresh title" accrued to the plaintiff on Periaswami's death or to Periaswami by reason of the execution of the sale deed by the Official Receiver, the court found no basis on the facts and pleadings before it to accept that argument and held there was no scope for applying the principle that Article 47 will not bar a claim based on a subsequently acquired title.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The lower court's decision upholding the plea of limitation under Article 47 was affirmed. The appellant was ordered to pay costs, and to pay to the Government the court-fee payable on the Memorandum of Appeal.

Implications (direct effects stated in the opinion):

  • The plaintiff's suit (which was instituted more than three years after the Magistrate's order Ex. I) was barred by Article 47 on the facts and pleadings of this case, as the lower court had held.
  • The court's reasoning indicates that orders under Section 145, Criminal P.C., when entered in proceedings where a trustee acts on behalf of a trust, may bind the trust and succeeding trustees for limitation purposes under Article 47 (i.e., a successor trustee is ordinarily treated as claiming through his predecessor in such circumstances).
  • The opinion notes limited protective scenarios (for instance, a suit by someone not claiming under the trustee who was a party to the Section 145 order) in which the trust's title might still be protected, but on the facts before the court no such protection applied.
  • Stodart, J. added that insofar as the interests of the trust are concerned, there remains a remedy to set aside a transfer by a former manager, and that limitation for such an action is 12 years from the death of the transferor under Article 134(b) (this is an additional procedural note provided in the judgment).

The court did not purport to lay down an absolute rule as to whether the lapse of three years will in every case extinguish title; it limited its decision to the facts and pleadings before it and dismissed the appeal on the basis that the present suit sought to vindicate the plaintiff's right to remain in possession and perform the trust and was barred by Article 47.

    Jagathambal Anni (Deceased) And Others v. Periathambi Nadar (Deceased) And Others S

    1. The only question for determination in this appeal is a point arising under Article 47, Lim. Act. The suit properties are said to have been endowed for the Arthajama Kattalai of Sri Nageswaraswami temple in Kumbakonam. Prior to 1918 one Periaswami Mudaliar seems to have been enjoying these properties and performing the kattalai. It is in dispute between the parties whether the properties have been wholly dedicated to the trust or are only subject to a charge in favour of the trust. On Periaswami's insolvency, the Official Receiver sold these properties as Periaswami's properties subject to the rights of the kattalai and defendant 1 purchased them in August 1918, though the formal sale deed was executed by the Official Receiver only in August 1920. For some years prior to 1918 the properties had been in the possession of a tenant. In 1919 Periaswami filed an application before the Divisional Magistrate, Kumbakonam, setting forth the trust character of these properties and his management thereof and claiming that on the termination of the lease he had himself resumed possession in March 1919. He complained that the present defendant 1 was interfering with his possession and asked for an order under Section 144 or Section 145, Criminal P.C. (vide Ex. I-A). The Magistrate passed his order Ex. I on 17th February 1920 holding that defendant 1 (then 1st counter-petitioner) was in possession and declared him entitled to possession until evicted in due course of law. The present plaintiff is the mother of Periaswami who died in August 1928.

    2. The plaint refers to certain events that took place in November 1925 and suggests that the plaintiff became entitled to the trusteeship of the Arthajama Kattalai either from November 1925 or from Periaswami's death in August 1928. Besides defendant 1 who was declared to be in possession by the Magistrate, two other defendants were impleaded as parties to this suit, one being the trustee of Nageswaraswami temple and the other a gentleman who had been associated with the Arthajama Kattalai by some scheme framed by the Endowments Board. It would appear from their statements that arrangements have latterly been made for the carrying out of the Kattalai by payments to be made by defendant 1 from out. of the suit properties. It is not therefore so much the question of the interests of the trust that is in dispute in this suit as the question of the plaintiff's right to remain in possession and perform the trust. The question whether she is beneficially entitled to the surplus income if any has been mooted, but as the lower Court has disposed of the ease only on the plea of limitation, it is not at present possible to say anything as to the beneficial interest, if any, in the surplus.

    3. The plea of limitation was raised under Article 47 on the ground that this suit has admittedly been instituted more than three years after the date of Ex. 1. The learned Subordinate Judge upheld this -objection. It was contended before him that the plaintiff is not a person bound by the order of the Magistrate nor one claiming under a person so bound. This argument has been repeated before us though in a slightly modified form. We do not think there is much force in that argument.

    4. It is too much to contend that Article 47 should never be applied to the trust properties. Section 145, Criminal P.C., relates to the question of possession of immoveable property and its application does not depend upon whether the claim is made by a private owner or on behalf of a trust. If there is a bona fide dispute between a trust and a third person and the other conditions of the section are satisfied, there is no reason why it should not fall within the cognisance of the Magistrate under Section 145; nor is there any reason why to an order passed by a Magistrate in such a case, Article 47 should not be applied. If this is the correct position, what is the justification for holding that it is only the particular trustee who was a party to a proceeding under Section 145 that must be held bound by that order or by the limitation prescribed in Article 47. If the trustee purported to act on behalf of the trust, the proper interpretation of the order will be that the trust itself was a party and must be held bound by that order, and whichever trustee may subsequently file a suit to set aside that order will really be acting on behalf of the trust. In these circumstances it seems to us opposed to the very idea underlying possession proceedings and the necessity of having a question of that kind settled promptly, that we should accede to the appellant's contention that wherever the interests of a trust are concerned orders under Section 145 can be questioned after an indefinite length of time by succeeding trustees.

    5. On behalf of the appellant reliance has been placed upon an observation in Mahomed v. Ganapathi (1900) 13 Mad 277 at p. 280, that one dharmakartha does not derive his title from his predecessor and is therefore not bound by his acts. This statement must be taken with considerable qualifications be-cause the binding character of transactions entered into by any trustee will have to be judged not on the ground whether one trustee claims under another, but on the ground whether the transaction was one justifiable under the circumstances in which it was entered into. The statement that even in a case of hereditary succession, one dharmakartha does not derive his title from his predecessor cannot be regarded as correct after the decision of the Privy Council in Gnanasambanda Pandara Sannadhi v. Velu Pandaram (1900) 23 Mad 271; at p. 281, their Lordships say:

    The respondent Velu can only be entitled as heir to his father Nataraja and from and through him.

    6. The preceding discussion in the judgment where their Lordships negative the theory of a succession of life estates in respect of the office of a trustee or the right to trust property makes clear what the observation above quoted was intended to signify. Even in the plaint in the present suit it is on the footing of a hereditary right of trusteeship that the case is stated, though incidentally reference is also made to some orders passed by the Endowments Board. The light afforded by decisions relating to adverse possession against a trust is also against the recognition of the argument that one trustee does not claim through his predecessor. There have no doubt been differences of opinion as to when the possession of an alienee from a trustee may become adverse to the trust. There has not been much difference of opinion as regards the effect of trespass on trust property or adverse possession of the office. Whatever the differences may have been as to the time when the possession becomes adverse, there has latterly been no doubt whatever that once adverse possession starts, it operates not merely against the then trustee, but against his successors as well; and this can only be on the footing that each succeeding trustee claims under his predecessor.

    7. It was suggested by Mr. Balasubramania Ayyar that it may lead to serious consequences if we should hold that by the operation of Article 47 a trust may be deprived of its properties by reason of Section 28, Limitation Act, on the expiry of three years from a Magistrate's order. It is unnecessary for us to say whether the lapse of three years will in every case necessarily extinguish the title or not. If as happened in one of the cases cited by Mr. Balasubramania Ayyar, namely, Srinivasacharlu v. Subudhi (1912) 23 MLJ 348, a suit could be brought on behalf of the trust by somebody of whom it could be said that he is not claiming under the trustee who was a party to the order under Section 145, Criminal P.C. the title of the trust may be protected. But we do not think that this consideration should prevent us from holding against the plaintiff in this case because, as already stated, it is not so much the interests of the trust that are sought to be vindicated in this suit as the plaintiff's right to remain in possession and herself get the trust performed.

    8. A new point of view was suggested before us by Mr. Balasubramania Ayyar on behalf of the appellant, namely, that at the date of the Magistrate's order Periaswami was not entitled to possession because under the terms of the lease which he had granted, the lessee was entitled to remain in possession till he was repaid an advance of Rs. 500. No reference to this circumstance appears to have been made in the pleadings or in the issues in the Court below nor have we the lease deed itself before us. This information is only gleaned from a reference to the lease in the Magistrate's order as well as in the sale-deed executed by the Official Receiver in favour of defendant 1. There is however the fact that in 1919 Periaswami did apply to the Magistrate as one in actual possession. Assuming that it was a false statement and that his right at that time was only to redeem the lessee or defendant 1 as an assignee from the lessee, the present suit is not one based on that right. Whether a properly framed suit for redemption treating defendant 1 as one entitled to remain in possession as an assignee from the lessee will be barred by Article 47 or not, it is not necessary for us to decide in the present state of the pleadings. The decisions in Bolai Chand Ghosal v. Samiruddin Mandal (1892) 19 Cal 646 and Subbalakshmi Ammal v. Narasimiah 1927 52 MLJ 482 to which our attention was invited in this connexion are beside the point. In the grounds of appeal to this Court they were invoked only on the footing that a fresh title accrued to the plaintiff on Periaswami's death,. It is now argued before us that a fresh title must be deemed to have accrued to Periaswami when the Official Receiver executed a sale deed to defendant 1. It is difficult to see how that could give any fresh title to Periaswami. The alleged redemption of the lessee by defendant 1 had taken place before Periaswami filed his petition before the Magistrate and certainly before the Magistrate's order. There is accordingly no scope here for the application of the principle that Article 47 will not bar any claim to relief on foot of a subsequently acquired title. The appeal therefore fails and is dismissed with costs. The appellant will pay to the Government the court-fee payable on the Memorandum of Appeal.

    Stodart, J.

    9. I only wish to add that so far as the interests of the trust are concerned there is always the remedy to set aside the transfer by a former manager and in that case limitation is 12 years from the death of the transferor under Article 134(b).

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jagathambal Anni (Deceased) And Others v. Periathambi Nadar (Deceased) And Others S
    (Aug 19, 1935)