Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two plaintiffs instituted a suit seeking a declaration that a decree passed against them in O. S. No. 461 of 1918 (District Munsif's Court, Parvathipur) was not binding on them and for delivery of possession of the property which, under that decree, appeared to have been obtained by the 1st defendant (the decree-holder in the previous suit).

In the District Munsif's Court the plaintiffs' suit was dismissed. On appeal the learned Subordinate Judge (the lower appellate Court) found that the 1st plaintiff at least was a major on the date of the compromise on which the prior decree was passed and held that the prior decree was not binding on both plaintiffs. The lower appellate Court therefore granted a decree in favour of both plaintiffs declaring the previous decree not binding and for delivery of possession.

The 1st defendant appealed to this Court. The appeal concerns whether the prior decree was binding on the plaintiffs, particularly in light of issues of minority/majority, the nature of the prior decree (adjudication versus compromise), and the effect of actions taken by a guardian ad litem.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a judgment or decree given by a competent Court against a defendant who attained majority during the pendency of the suit is void or not binding on that person if he did not take steps to replace the guardian ad litem or otherwise appear himself.
  2. Whether a decree resulting from a compromise (contract or consent) entered into on behalf of a party by a guardian ad litem is binding on a party who had in fact attained majority at the time the compromise was entered into.
  3. Whether, where the prior decree was founded on compromise, issues such as the actual age of a party, collusion between guardian and opposing party, or gross negligence of the guardian ad litem must be determined before declaring the compromise (and hence the decree) binding or voidable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (1st defendant / vakil for the appellant)

  • The lower appellate Court was wrong to treat the prior decree as not binding on the plaintiffs even on the ground that the 1st plaintiff was a major at the time of the compromise.
  • Reliance on the decision of Sadasiva Aiyar and Napier, JJ., in Seshagiri Rao v. Hanumantha Rao to support the proposition that a judgment given against a defendant who attained majority during the pendency of the suit is not a nullity and that there is no provision in the Civil Procedure Code obliging a plaintiff to apply for discharge of the guardian ad litem of a defendant who had ceased to be a minor.

Respondent's / Other Arguments (as represented in the opinion)

  • Mr. Jagannadha Doss (for the respondent) drew attention to the review judgment Tanguturi Jagannadham v. Seshagiri Rao, suggesting that on review the earlier judgment had been treated as voidable or avoided; the Court analysed that review judgment and treated the action taken on review as setting aside a subsequent sale for lack of proper notice to a person who had become a major.
  • The plaintiffs (as argued in the lower Courts) contended that both of them had attained majority on the date of the compromise and decree (or even on the date of the previous suit itself).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Seshagiri Rao v. Hanumantha Rao That the Civil Procedure Code contains no provision obliging a plaintiff to apply for discharge of the guardian ad litem of a defendant who had ceased to be a minor; a minor defendant who attains majority may come on record and conduct his defence, but if he does not and allows the case to proceed as though still a minor, he is deemed to have elected to abide by the judgment; a judgment against such a defendant is not a nullity. The Court agreed with this decision for the proposition that a judgment given after a defendant attains majority is not automatically void; the Court relied on the principles in analysing binding effect of adjudications as distinct from decrees obtained by compromise.
Tanguturi Jagannadham v. Seshagiri Rao (review) The review judgment set aside a sale (a separate proceeding) because proper notice had not been served on the party who by that time had become a major; at first impression it might appear to have voided the earlier judgment, but on closer reading the review court treated the sale as a separate proceeding and set it aside for lack of notice. The Court considered the review decision and concluded that the review court's action was limited to setting aside the sale as a separate proceeding for lack of notice; it did not amount to declaring the original judgment a nullity. The opinion relied on this interpretation in distinguishing the present facts.
Sundararama Reddi v. Pattabhirama Reddi Supports the proposition that mere attainment of majority by a defendant during pendency, without his taking steps to continue the defence, does not suffice to render a validly pronounced judgment non-binding on him. The Court cited and agreed with this decision alongside Seshagiri Rao to support the general rule regarding adjudications and the binding nature of judgments on defendants who have become majors but did not replace the guardian ad litem.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in stages, addressing both the general rule about judgments against defendants who attain majority during the pendency of litigation and the distinct situation where a decree arises from a compromise or contract.

First, the Court accepted and relied on the principle in Seshagiri Rao (and Sundararama Reddi) that where a competent Court adjudicates the matters in controversy on the merits, a judgment given against a defendant who attained majority during the pendency of the suit, and who did not take steps to come on the record, is not necessarily a nullity. The rationale is that a plaintiff is dominus litis and has election rights; a defendant does not have the same right of election, and if the defendant does not bring the fact of his majority to the Court's notice, he is deemed to have elected to abide by the adjudication.

Second, the Court distinguished decrees based on adjudication from decrees resulting from compromise. The Court observed that a compromise is effectively a contract: when a decree is passed on compromise, it is necessary to consider whether the underlying contract was valid and binding on the party seeking to set it aside. A compromise entered into on behalf of a minor and sanctioned by the Court can bind that minor, but where one purportedly minor party was in fact a major at the time of the compromise, the guardian ad litem (or previous guardian) lacks legal authority to bind that major by contract merely because he had previously acted as guardian.

Applying these principles, the Court held that:

  • With respect to the 1st plaintiff: The lower appellate Court's conclusion that the prior decree was not binding on him was correct in result because the 1st plaintiff was found to have been a major at the time of the compromise. The Court explained that the lower appellate Court reached this conclusion though for somewhat different reasons; nonetheless, the outcome is sustained because a guardian ad litem cannot bind a person who had attained majority by entering into a contract on his behalf.
  • With respect to the 2nd plaintiff: The lower appellate Court had not recorded any finding as to his age (deeming it unnecessary since it regarded the decree as one and single and not binding on at least one of the plaintiffs). This Court considered it necessary to determine the actual age of the 2nd plaintiff because, if the decree was based on contract/consent, the validity of the contract on his behalf depends on whether he was a minor on the date of the compromise. If the 2nd plaintiff is found to have been a major, the same considerations as for the 1st plaintiff apply (the compromise would not bind him); if he was a minor, further issues such as collusion between his guardian and the opposite party or gross negligence of the guardian ad litem would have to be tried and determined.

The Court also considered the review decision in Tanguturi Jagannadham v. Seshagiri Rao and concluded that it did not alter the general principle: the review court on that occasion set aside a sale for lack of notice in a separate proceeding rather than declaring the original judgment void.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal is partly allowed and partly dismissed; the judgment is confirmed as to the 1st plaintiff and reversed as to the 2nd plaintiff, and the matter is remanded to the lower appellate Court for further enquiry and disposal on the points indicated.

Specific consequences and directions:

  • The decree of the lower appellate Court in favour of the 1st plaintiff (declaring the previous decree not binding on him) is confirmed.
  • As to the 2nd plaintiff, the judgment and decree of the lower appellate Court are reversed; the case is remanded to the lower appellate Court to determine the 2nd plaintiff's age on the date of the compromise and, if he was a minor, to try and determine other questions such as alleged collusion between the guardian and the plaintiff in the previous suit or whether the guardian ad litem acted with gross negligence.
  • Because the prior decree against the 1st plaintiff has been declared not binding on him and that declaration is confirmed, the 1st defendant-appellant will be entitled, if so advised, to require that the previous suit be reopened and adjudicated in accordance with law as against the 1st plaintiff.
  • The costs of the appeal are reserved and will be disposed of by the lower appellate Court.
  • The case is remanded to the lower appellate Court (K. S. D. Case remanded).

Implications beyond the parties: The opinion confines itself to the direct effects and directions between the parties and the need for the lower appellate Court to determine outstanding factual issues. The Court's reasoning reaffirms existing authorities on the binding effect of adjudications against defendants who attain majority and stresses the different legal considerations applicable where a decree is founded on compromise; no broader new precedent beyond the application of cited authorities is stated in the opinion.

K. S. D.Case remanded.

    Lanka Sanyasi v. Lanka Yerean Naidu

    This second appeal has arisen from a suit which was instituted by two plaintiffs for a declaration that a decree passed against them in O. S. No. 461 of 1918 on the file of the District Munsif's Court at Parvathipur was not binding on them and also for possession of the property which under that decree appears to have been obtained by the 1st defendant in this litigation who was the decree-holder in the previous suit. In the District Munsif's Court the plaintiffs' suit was dismissed, but in the lower appellate Court the learned Subordinate Judge having arrived at the finding that the 1st plaintiff at least was a major on the date of the compromise on which the decree was passed held that the decree was not binding on both the plaintiffs and therefore granted a decree in favour of both the plaintiffs declaring that the previous decree was not binding on them and also for delivery of possession of the property. It has been argued by the learned vakil for the appellant before us that even on the ground on which the lower appellate Court held that the previous decree was not binding on the plaintiffs namely, that the 1st plaintiff at least was a major, the lower appellate Court was wrong in considering that a decree passed against persons who are on the record as minors in the belief that they continued up to the time of the decree as minors would not be binding on them. For this purpose the learned vakil for the appellant referred to the decision of Sadasiva Aiyar, and Napier, JJ., in the case of Seshagiri Rao v. Hanumantha Rao(1). In that case the learned Judges have clearly pointed out that there are no provisions in the Civil Procedure Code relating to suits by and against minors obliging a plaintiff to apply for discharge of the guardian ad litem of a defendant who had ceased to be a minor. There are provisions in the Civil Procedure Code for a minor plaintiff on attaining majority electing to go on or not to go on with a litigation. That is obviously in view of the fact that the plaintiff is in a position to elect either to go on or not to go on with a litigation to which he is a party because he is dominus litus. No such consideration is available in respect of the defendant. A defendant having been made a party defendant to the action may no doubt confess judgment but has no such right of election as the plaintiff has. That is probably the reason why no provisions have been made in the Civil Procedure Code in respect of a minor defendant attaining majority. Apparently, therefore, we must take it as found by the learned Judges in that case, that the minor defendant who comes of age may, if he thinks fit, come on the record and conduct the defence himself. If, however, he does not do so and allows the case to proceed as though he was still a minor without bringing to the notice of the Court the fact of his having attained majority, then he must be deemed to have elected to abide by the judgment or adjudication by the Court with respect to the matters in controversy on the basis of the suit at the time. That is how the learned Judges came to the conclusion in that case that a judgment given by a competent Court against a defendant, albeit a defendant who had during the pendency of the suit attained majority having ceased to be a minor, is not a nullity. That view is based on sound principle. But the difficulty in this case has arisen from a contention that was put forward by Mr. Jagannadha Doss on behalf of the respondent who drew our attention to the judgment of the same learned Judges on an application for review made to them in that very case. The judgment on review by the learned Judges is reported in Tanguturi Jagannadham v. Seshagiri Rao. At first sight it appeared as though on this decision the learned Judges came to the conclusion that because they discovered that the application to set aside the sale of the property sold in execution was within time they regarded the judgment itself as either voidable or avoided. But on a closer examination of the case there seems to be no doubt whatever that what the learned Judges did on review was merely to set aside the sale treating it as a separate proceeding and because in respect of that proceeding there was no proper notice served on the party who had, by that time become a major. As we respectfully agree with the decision of the learned Judges in Seshagiri Rao v. Hanumantha Rao and also with another judgment of this Court in the case of Sundararama Reddi v. Pattabhirama Reddi it follows that the mere circumstance that a minor defendant had attained majority during the pendency of the suit and has not elected to continue the defence himself is not sufficient to enable him to have declared as not binding on him the judgment duly pronounced by the Court. If that were all, there would be very little further difficulty in this case. But it turns out that the decree sought to be set aside was not the result of the adjudication by the Court of the matters in controversy in the previous suit between the parties. The ultimate judgment of the Court was based on a compromise. That compromise was entered into by the plaintiffs in the previous suit and by the second defendant in this suit acting both for himself and on behalf of his younger brothers, the plaintiffs in this litigation. Whatever may be the principles that are applicable to the binding nature of an adjudication by the Court on a defendant who though he becomes a major does not take the necessary steps to have the guardian ad litem discharged, it seems to us that no such considerations are available or applicable to a case where the decree of Court comes to be passed not on adjudication by the Judges but by a compromise on a contract or consent of the parties. It stands to reason and principle that an adjudication by the Court which, we may take it, in the absence of any fraud, collusion or gross negligence is an adjudication on the merits of the controversy, need not be set aside as vitiated merely because a certain defendant is found to have attained his majority without the matter being brought to the notice of the Court. But when the decree comes to be passed on a contract it becomes necessary to see whether the contract that was entered into was a contract valid and binding on the party now seeking to set aside the decree. So far, if the plaintiffs had both of them been found to be minors on the date of the compromise, then there is the fact that the 2nd defendant in this suit representing them as their guardian ad litem entered into such a contract and such contract was sanctioned on behalf of the minor defendants by the Court as being for their benefit. But the law says that such a compromise is binding on a minor if sanctioned by the Court. But when the law says that such a compromise is binding on a minor when the Court sanctions it, what the law has reference to is a contract made only for or on behalf of a minor and there could be no legal principle or reason for holding that when there is a major capable of entering into a contract apart from any question of agency any contract entered into or purported to be entered into on his behalf by some other person can be regarded as binding on him. If, therefore, the 1st plaintiff in this suit had become a major by the time the compromise agreement was entered into it follows that the mere circumstances that the 2nd defendant here was his guardian ad litem or had been previously acting as his guardian ad litem would not clothe him with the required legal right to enter into a binding contract. There is no provision or principle of the law of contracts Which would make such a contract entered into by a previous guardian ad litem binding on a party defendant who had become a major. It, therefore, follows that, so far as the 1st plaintiff in this case is concerned who has been found by the lower appellate Court to have attained majority on the date of the compromise and decree, the lower appellate Court was right in the conclusion arrived at that the decree was not binding on him, though the grounds on which it came to that conclusion were different. So far as the 2nd defendant' is concerned, the lower appellate Court has not recorded any finding with regard to his age. The contention on behalf of the plaintiffs in both the lower Courts has been that both of them had attained majority on the date of the compromise and decree or even on the date of the previous suit itself. The lower appellate Court has not recorded any finding because in its view it was unnecessary to enquire into the matter in the view it took of the decree being one and single and of its not being binding on at any rate one of the plaintiffs. Deeming this sufficient, regarding the decree as one and single the lower appellate Court did not record any finding with regard to the actual age of the 2nd plaintiff. But in the view we have taken of the matter it becomes necessary to consider the actual age of the 2nd plaintiff because if the decree as held by us was ultimately based on contract or consent the capacity or the power of the 2nd defendant in this case to enter into a valid contract on behalf of the 2nd plaintiff can only be determined by seeing whether as a matter of fact the 2nd plaintiff was on the date of the compromise a minor as he was purported to be. There are also, as Mr. Jagannadha Doss has pointed out, other issues that have not been determined by the lower appellate Court and which it would be necessary to decide if the lower appellate Court should come to the conclusion that the 2nd plaintiff was a minor. If, of course, the finding of the lower appellate Court should be that he too had attained majority and become a major the same considerations will apply to him as to the 1st plaintiff and it must be held that the contract entered into at that time on his behalf would not be binding; but if he should be found to have been a minor, then the other questions raised, such as whether there was collusion between his guardian and the plaintiff in the previous suit or whether the guardian ad litem acted with gross negligence as charged might all have to be tried and determined. It, therefore, follows that so far as the 1st plaintiff is concerned the decree of the lower appellate Court will stand confirmed. So far as the 2nd plaintiff is concerned, the judgment and decree of the lower appellate Court are reversed and the case will be remanded to the lower appellate Court for disposal having regard to all the points indicated above. As the decree passed in the previous suit against the 1st plaintiff has been declared not to be binding on him by the lower appellate Court and that decree has now been confirmed by us, it follows that so far as he is concerned the 1st defendant-appellant will be entitled, if so advised, to require that the previous suit be reopened and adjudicated in accordance with law as against the 1st plaintiff. The costs of this appeal will be reserved and disposed of by the lower appellate Court.

    K. S. D.Case remanded.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lanka Sanyasi v. Lanka Yerean Naidu
    (Sep 30, 1927)