Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts

    M. Ramachandra Reddy v. Challa Janaki And Others

    1. This revision is filed against an order made in I.A 1834/83 refusing to stay the execution of the decree in O.S 48/80 dated September 22, 1983. The respondent No. 1 herein filed the above suit for a declaration of title to the plaint schedule property and for perpetual injunction restraining the petitioner herein and two others who are the defendants 2 and 3, from interfering with her possession and enjoyment thereof. The trial Court decreed the suit, and against the decree, an appeal has been filed. An application under Order 41 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Code was filed for suspension of the operation of the decree of the trial Court. It was refused. Thus the present revision petition.

    2. It is the contention of the petitioner that in O.S 10/80 on the file of the Court of the District Munsif at shadnagar, the first petitioner and his wife, the second defendant in the suit obtained an adinterim injunction and it is subsisting Suppressing that fact the present suit was filed and therefore the order of injunction passed by the trial court is illegal. It is also contended that the petitioner and his wife have been in possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule property, that the order of injunction is subject to the appeal, and unless their possession is protected, they would suffer irreparable injury. The lower court has not rightly exercised its discretion under Order 41 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Code and has committed material irregularity in exercise thereof. The lower Court, apart from holding that the 1st respondent has been in possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule property, and that order of injunction cannot be suspended, further held that the order for injunction is not in executable decree, and therefore Order 41 Rule 5 has no application. This view of the lower court is also assailed in this revision.

    3. Under these circumstances, the first question that arises for consideration is whether an application under Order 1 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Code would lie to seek suspension of the operation of a perpetual injunction granted by the trial Court?

    4. Order 41 Rule 5(1) postulates:

    “An appeal shall not operate as a stay of proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except so far as the Appellate Court may order, nor shall execution of a decree be stayed by reasononly of an appeal having been preferred from the decree; but the Appellate Court may for sufficient cause order stay of “execution of such decree.”

    5. Therefore, the question is whether a decree of perpetual injunction is an executable decree or not? The lower court assailed that it is not executable and therefore Order 41 Rule 5(1) does not apply. I am unable to agree with the lower Court. Order 21 rule 32 adumberates that where a party against whom a decree for………… for an injunction, has been passed, has had an opportunity of obeying the decree and has wilfully failed to obey it, the decree may be enforced………for an injunction by his detention in the civil prison, or by the attachment of his property, or by both. Therefore, a decree for perpetual injunction is clearly an executable decree under Order 21 rule 32(1) of the Civil Procedure Code. The decree is clearly an executable decree, and therefore, comes within the sweep of “execution of such decree” couched under Order 41 Rule 5(1) of the Code. Thus I hold that the appellate court, in an appropriate case, if the facts and circumstances so warrant, may order stay of the execution of such decree for perpetual injunction.

    6. The immediate question that arises for consideration is whether on the facts and circumstances in this case, did the lower court commit an error of jurisdiction or material irregularity thereof in refusing to suspend the operation of the decree? The trial court, on a consideration of the entire evidence both oral and documentary, has held that the first respondent has been in possession on the date of the suit and even earlier. It has also held that the first defendant-petitioner herein is not in possession of the plaint schedule property. These findings are subject of appeal. But the question is whether there is a prima faice case made out? It is not in dispute that pending suit, an application under Order 39 Rule 1 of the Code was filed, and the trial Court granted ad interim injunction and it was made absolute which was subsisting till the date of decree when the suit has been decreed. No doubt the petitioner and his wife filed a suit in O.S No. 10/80 on the file of the Court of the District Munsif at Shadnagar, and filed an application in I.A 45/80 for ad interim injunction and ad interim injunction was granted. But in this case, on merits the trial court granted an injunction. Therefore, the interim injunction granted on prima facie evidence pending adjudication of the suit O.S 10/80, cannot have the effect of superceding the injunction granted on a full pledged trial by the trial court Under these circumstances, the lower appellate court has rightly held that the balance of convenience was in not suspending the operation of the decree of perpetual injunction. Viewed from this perspective, I hold that the lower court has not committed any material irregularity in the exercise of the jurisdiction. Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is dismissed, but in the circumstances, without costs.

    7. Any observations made herein shall be treated only for the purpose of finding out whether the lower court has committed any material irregularity in exercise of its jurisdiction, and does not impete the lower Court to go into the merits and decide the matter in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M. Ramachandra Reddy v. Challa Janaki And Others
    (Feb 1, 1984)