Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Case Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India was filed by Shri Mahabir Prasad, who at the time of filing was working as Prakhand Vikash Padadhikari at Kurhani, Muzaffarpur, and has since retired. The petitioner challenged the validity of an order dated 23 June 1970 (Annexure 1) which imposed certain punishment on him.

Relevant facts stated in the opinion: the petitioner was appointed as an Agricultural Overseer in 1937 and promoted to Superintendent, class II of the Bihar Agriculture Service, on 16 August 1963. In 1964 he was posted as Superintendent of Agriculture School at Pusa. He was placed under suspension by an order dated 1 December 1967 and treated as under suspension from 3 January 1968. A departmental proceeding on thirteen charges was initiated and an enquiry conducted by Shri Ehsan Ahmad, concluding on 5 December 1969. After considering the enquiring officer's report, the State did not impose any major punishment. By Annexure 1 the State Government censured the petitioner, directed an entry in his C.R., declared the period of suspension to be treated as on duty for pension and gratuity but ordered that the petitioner would not receive anything beyond the subsistence allowance already received during suspension, and vacated the suspension from the date of the order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the portion of the impugned order directing that "the period of suspension be treated as on duty for the purposes of pension and gratuity but he will not get anything more beyond the subsistence grant already received by him during the period of suspension" is valid in the absence of an opportunity given to the petitioner to show cause.
  2. Whether Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code (being in pari materia with Rule 54 of the Fundamental Rules) required that the petitioner be afforded a reasonable opportunity to show cause before clauses (3) and (5) of Rule 97 were applied.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the petitioner did not contest the order of censure but contended that the portion of the order treating the period of suspension as on duty for pension and gratuity while denying any pay beyond subsistence allowance was invalid because the petitioner was not given an opportunity to be heard before that part of the order was passed.
  • Counsel relied on the Supreme Court decision in M. Gopalkrishna Naida v. The State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1968 Supreme Court 240) to support the principle that an officer must be given a reasonable opportunity to show cause before such provisions of the rules are applied.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M. Gopalkrishna Naida v. The State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1968 Supreme Court 240) The principle that Fundamental Rule 54 (and rules in pari materia) requires authorities to act in accordance with justice and fair play and to afford a reasonable opportunity to an officer to show cause before applying clauses that affect pension/allowances. The court treated this decision as directly analogous and relied upon it to hold that Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code (in pari materia with Rule 54) imposed a duty to give the petitioner a reasonable opportunity to show cause; absence of such opportunity rendered the impugned portion of the order invalid.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court accepted the petitioner's submission that the cited Supreme Court authority was materially similar: in that case an officer suspended pending enquiry was ultimately not found guilty, yet the Government applied rules to treat the period as on duty for pension purposes while denying pay beyond subsistence, without affording a reasonable opportunity to show cause. The Supreme Court held that Fundamental Rule 54 requires authorities to act according to justice and fair play and to afford a reasonable opportunity to the officer to show cause before applying the relevant clauses.

The court observed that Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code, 1952 is in pari materia with Rule 54 of the Fundamental Rules. Therefore, the petitioner should have been given an opportunity to show cause why clauses (3) and (5) of Rule 97 should not be applied to him. Because no such opportunity was afforded, the court found the impugned portion of Annexure 1 (the direction limiting payment to subsistence allowance while treating the period as on duty for pension and gratuity) to be invalid.

The court further stated it would be open to the competent authority to reconsider the matter afresh (de novo) after giving the petitioner a reasonable opportunity to show cause. The court did not disturb the order of censure and made no order as to costs. The concurrence of S.K. Jha, J. is recorded.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The portion of the impugned order contained in Annexure 1 which reads "The period of suspension be treated as on duty for the purposes of pension and gratuity but he will not get anything more beyond the subsistence grant already received by him during the period of suspension" is struck down as invalid.

Direct consequences:

  • The specific direction denying any payment beyond subsistence allowance while treating the suspension period as on duty for pension/gratuity has been declared invalid.
  • The competent authority may reconsider the question de novo after giving the petitioner a reasonable opportunity to show cause.
  • The order of censure in Annexure 1 was not challenged and remains unaffected by this decision.
  • There will be no order as to costs.

The opinion does not discuss broader implications beyond the direct effect on the parties; it rests on application of established authority rather than announcing a new legal principle.

    Shri Mahabir Prasad v. The State Of Bihar And Others

    S.N.P Singh, C.J:—This writ application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been filed by Shri Mahabir Prasad, who was working as Prakhand Vikash Padadhikari at Kurhani in the district of Muzaffarpur, when the application was filed. We are informed that he has since retired from the service. In this writ application the petitioner has challenged the validity of the order dated 23rd of June 1970 contained in Annexure 1, by which certain punishment has been inflicted upon him.

    2. The relevant facts for the disposal of this application may be stated as follows. The petitioner was initially appointed as an Agricultural Overseer in the year 1937 in the Government of Bihar. He was promoted to the next higher rank of Superintendent in class II of the Bihar Agriculture Service on 16th of August 1963. In the year 1964 while the petitioner was posted as Superintendent of Agriculture School at Pusa he was placed under suspension by order of the State Government dated 1st of December 1967. He was treated to be under suspension with effect from 3rd of January 1968. A Departmental proceeding was started against him in respect of thirteen charges. Shri Ehsan Ahmad (respondent no. 2) who was then posted as Deputy Secretary to the Government in the Department of Agriculture, conducted, the enquiry. The enquiry was concluded on 5th of December 1969. The State of Bihar, after considering the report of the enquiring officer, did not inflict any major punishment on the petitioner. By the impugned order (Annexure 1) the State Government censured the petitioner and directed an entry to be recorded in his C.R The State Government further passed an order to the effect that the period of suspension be treated as on duty for the purposes of pension and gratuity, but the petitioner would not get anything more beyond the subsistence allowance already received by him during the period of suspension. By the said order suspension of the petitioner was vacated from the date of the order.

    3. Mr. Tarkeshwar Dayal, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner did not challenge the validity of the order of censure. Learned counsel however, submitted that the order of the State Government that the period of suspension would be treated as on duty for the purposes of pension and gratuity but the petitioner would not get anything more than the subsistence allowance already received by him during the period of suspension is invalid, because the petitioner was not given an opportunity to be heard before the said order was passed. In support of this contention, learned counsel relied upon a decision of the Supreme Court in M. Gopalkrishna Naida v. The State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1968 Supreme Court 240). There is substance in the contention of learned counsel. The facts of the Supreme Court case were, more or less, similar in the sense that the delinquent officer had been suspended pending the Departmental enquiry. The enquiring officer found the officer not guilty, but the Government disagreed with that finding and served a notice to show cause why he should not be dismissed. Subsequently, the Government held that the charges against the officer were not proved beyond reasonable doubt. It also held that the suspension and the Departmental enquiry “were not wholly unjustified”. The order further directed, inter alia, that the entire period of absence from duty should be treated as period spent on duty under Fundamental Rule 54(5) for purposes of pension only, but that he should not be allowed any pay beyond what he had actually received or what was allowed to him by way of subsistence allowance during the period of his suspension. The Supreme Court held that Fundamental Rule 54 contemplates a duty to act in accordance with the basic concept of justice and fair play. The authority has to afford a reasonable opportunity to the officer concerned to show cause why clauses (3) and (5) should not be applied. In that case the order was held to be invalid as no reasonable opportunity to the officer to show cause was given. Rule 97 of the Bihar Service Code, 1952, is in pari materia with rule 54 of the Fundamental Rules. The petitioner, therefore, ought to have been given an opportunity to show cause why clauses (3) and (5) of Rule 97 should not be applied in his case. As that had not been done, the application is allowed and the impugned portion of the order contained in Annexure 1 which reads “The period of suspension be treated as on duty for the purposes of pension and gratuity but he will not get anything more beyond the subsistence grant already received by him during the period of suspension” is struck down as invalid. It would be open to the competent authority to consider the question de novo, after giving the petitioner a reasonable opportunity to show cause against the action proposed against him. There will be no order as to costs.

    S.K Jha, J.:—I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Mahabir Prasad v. The State Of Bihar And Others
    (Jul 27, 1975)