Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 rules 1
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 rules 1
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, Smt. Saraswati Devi, and Smt. Dropadi Devi formed a partnership on 4th April 1975 to manufacture and sell GUDAKHU under the trade mark “STAR,” registered in their joint names. They also held copyright in the artistic work “STAR.” The partnership was dissolved effective 31st March 1986. On the same day, a new partnership named M/s. Kalinga Gudakhu Factory was formed with four partners including Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal. Disputes arose between these partners, leading Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal and others to form a new partnership and claim assignment of the trade mark “STAR.” Meanwhile, another partner started using a similar mark “5 STAR.” The plaintiff firm filed suit seeking permanent injunction restraining defendants from using the trade mark “STAR BRAND” or any deceptively similar mark. The plaintiff also sought a temporary injunction, which was opposed and is the subject of this application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff had exclusive right to use the trade mark “STAR BRAND” after the dissolution of the original partnership and formation of a new partnership.
  2. Whether the defendants could be restrained by a temporary injunction from using the trade mark and label identical or deceptively similar to the plaintiff’s registered trade mark and label.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Addanki Narayanappa, Appellants v. Bhaskara Krishnappa, AIR 1966 Supreme Court 1300 Trade mark owned by a partner becomes property of the partnership firm upon formation. The court held that the trade mark “STAR” became the property of the new partnership firm, making all four partners owners of the trade mark and copyright.
Sohan Lal, Appellants v. Amin Chand & Sons, (1973) 2 SCC 608, AIR Supreme Court 2572 Exclusive right to use a trade mark does not vest in a single partner when the mark is held by a partnership firm. The court applied this principle to deny the plaintiff exclusive use of the trade mark and refused the temporary injunction against defendants.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the ownership of the trade mark and copyright following the dissolution of the original partnership and the formation of a new partnership firm. It noted that although Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal became owner of the trade mark under the dissolution deed, the new partnership firm continued the business under the same trade mark and label. Relying on established precedents, the court held that the trade mark became the property of the new partnership, with all partners jointly owning it. Consequently, the plaintiff could not claim exclusive rights to the trade mark or label. Therefore, the defendants could not be restrained by a temporary injunction from using the mark.

Holding and Implications

The application for temporary injunction is dismissed.

The court’s decision directly affects the parties by allowing the defendants to continue using the trade mark “STAR BRAND” and similar labels. The ruling clarifies that trade mark ownership vests in the partnership firm collectively rather than in an individual partner post-dissolution and formation of a new partnership. No new precedent was established beyond applying existing Supreme Court rulings. The parties are directed to maintain and submit six-monthly accounts to the court during the pendency of the suit. No order as to costs was made.

    Kalinga Gudakhu Udyog v. Konark Gudakhu Factory

    1. Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, Smt. Saraswati Devi, and Smt. Dropadi Devi entered into a partnership by means of a deed of partnership dated 4th April, 1975. The partnership was to carry the business of manufacturing and sale of GUDAKHU at Udit Nagar, Rourkela. The said three partners were the registered owners of the Trade Mark “STAR” in class 3 under number 314975 dated 9.5.76, in respect of GUDAKHU being tooth powder made from tabacco for sale in the States or Bihar & Orissa. The three partners were also owners of the copyright in respect of artistic work “STAR” attached with the certifiacte under registartion No. A-34376/81. According to this certificate Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal one of the partners was an author of this work.

    2. The partnership was dissolved by a deed dated 9th April, 1986 w.e.f 31.3.1986

    3. On the same day another partnership under the name and style of M/s. Kalinga Gudakhu Factory at Rourkela was constituted w.e.f 1.4.1986 This firm had 4 partners namely S/Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, Om Parkash Aggarwal; Arun Kumar Aggarwal and Shri Sunil Kumar aggarwal. It appears that disputes arose between the partners. Thereafter, Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, Sunil Aggarwal, two partners of M's. Kalinga Gudakhu Factory and Shri Sanjay Aggarwal formed a new partnership firm to carry out the same business. Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, applied for registration of the assignment on 29th December, 1987 alleging that the said trade-mark had been assigned to him. The certificate was granted by the Registrar on 29th January, 1988 in favour of Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal. Shri Om Parkash Aggarwal, the other partner of M/s. Kalinga Godakhu Factory, it appears also started the business in the name of Konark Gudakhu Factory and started using the trade mark “5 STAR” and label Gudakhu.

    4. Feeling aggrieved plaintiff firm filed this suit for permanent injunction restraining the defendants, its servants, agents, representatives and dealers and or other persons on its behalf from manufacturing, selling or otherwise dealing in the tooth powder made of Tobaccu under the Trade mark “STAR BRAND” which was registered in the name of the plaintiff under the Trade & Merchandise Mark Act, 1958 or under any other mark which was identical. Consequential reliefs were also claimed.

    5. In this suit the plaintiff has filed this application under Order 39 rules 1 & 2 for grant of temporary injunction restraining the defendants from using the impugned trade mark ‘STAR BRAND’ and artistic label entitled “STAR BRAND GODAKHU” or any other mark identical with or deceptively similar to the aforesaid registered trade mark and label of the plaintiff. This application was opposed.

    6. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. As noticed above three persons namely Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, Smt. Saraswati Devi and Smt Dropdi Devi were registered owners of the trade-mark “STAR”. They were also registered owners of copyright in the label “STAR” under the registration No. A-34736/81. It is correct that under Column No. 7 of this certificate the name of the author is given as Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal. It is, however, apparent from Column No. 11 and 12, that all these partner were owners of the copyright.

    7. Thus firm was dissolved by a dissolution deed dated 9th April, 1986 w.e.f 31.3.1986 Under the dissolution deed Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal became the owner of the Trade Mark. However, on the same date, i.e, on 9th April, 1986 another partnership came into existence with 4 partners with Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, Om Parkash, Arun Kumar Aggarwal and Shri Sunil Kumar Aggarwal. It is not disputed that the partners carried on the said Gudakhu business under the same trade mark and with the same label and same brand name.

    8. In the circumstances, as held in Addanki Narayanappa, Appellants v. Bhaskara Krishnappa (dead) and thereafter his heirs and others, Respondents, AIR 1966 Supreme Court 1300 the Trade Mark which was the property of Shri Ram Niwas Aggarwal, one of the partners, became the property of this firm. In other words all the four partners became the owners of the trade mark “STAR” and the copyright in question. The said firm has not been admittedly wound up. Consequently, as held in Sohan Lal, Appellants v. Amin Chand & Sons, (1973) 2 SCC 608 : AIR SUPREME COURT 2572 the plaintiff had no right to exclusive use of the trade mark and the label and the defendants could not be restrained by a temporary injunction from using the said trade mark and label.

    9. I consequently, dismiss the application. The parties, however, as directed by Supreme Court, in the above mentioned case, are directed to maintain accounts and submit six monthly accounts to this court during the pendency of the suit. No orders as to costs.

    10. Consequently, the order dated 12th July, 1988 stands vacated.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kalinga Gudakhu Udyog v. Konark Gudakhu Factory
    (Aug 1, 1989)