Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • TAMIL NADU REVENUE RECOVERY ACT
  • S. 52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act
  • S. 11 of the U.P Agricultural Credit Act, 1973
  • Constitution (Third Amendment) Act, 1954,
  • W.P Agricultural Credit Act, 1973,
  • S. 52-A of the Tamil Nadu Act
  • S. 11 of the U.P Act
  • Uttar Pradesh Act
  • U.P Act or S. 11
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • TAMIL NADU REVENUE RECOVERY ACT
  • S. 52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act
  • S. 11 of the U.P Agricultural Credit Act, 1973
  • Constitution (Third Amendment) Act, 1954,
  • W.P Agricultural Credit Act, 1973,
  • S. 52-A of the Tamil Nadu Act
  • S. 11 of the U.P Act
  • Uttar Pradesh Act
  • U.P Act or S. 11
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — B.P. Jeevan Reddy, C.J. (Uttar Pradesh Agricultural Credit Act, 1973 — Section 11)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Uttar Pradesh Legislature enacted the W.P. Agricultural Credit Act, 1973, effective 1-1-1974, to facilitate flow of credit for agricultural production and development through banks and other institutional agencies. Section 11 provides for recovery of dues of a bank through a prescribed authority and makes such recovery final, binding and executable as a decree of a civil court; it also bars suits in civil courts for recovery of sums due to banks for financial assistance given to agriculturists.

The petitioner is an agriculturist who, in 1981, took a loan of Rs. 65,000/- from the State Bank of India, Mainpuri, for purchasing a tractor. He defaulted on instalments; the bank issued a recovery certificate to the Tahsildar, Bhongaon, to recover Rs. 1,18,611.80 p. plus interest and charges, and recovery was initiated as arrears of land revenue. The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the recovery proceedings. This Court stayed the recovery proceedings by an order dated 17-3-1988 on condition of depositing Rs. 25,000/- within two weeks.

At the hearing the petitioner's counsel raised (though not pleaded in the writ) the legal contention that Section 11 of the U.P. Agricultural Credit Act is ultra vires the State Legislature because banking is a subject under Entry 45 of the Union List (List I) and that the State cannot legislate on banking; reliance was placed on the Madras High Court decision in G.N. Venkataswamy v. Tamil Nadu Small Industries Corporation Ltd., AIR 1981 Madras 318.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 11 of the Uttar Pradesh Agricultural Credit Act, 1973 is ultra vires the legislative competence of the State Legislature because it intrudes upon the Union subject of "Banking" (Entry 45, List I).
  2. Whether the pith and substance of the Uttar Pradesh enactment relates to agriculture, land and relief of agricultural indebtedness (matters in the State List and Concurrent List) or to banking (Union List).
  3. Whether the Madras High Court decision in G.N. Venkataswamy (declaring S.52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act ultra vires) is applicable to the Uttar Pradesh Act and, in particular, to Section 11.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Section 11 is a law relating to banking and therefore within the exclusive domain of Parliament (Entry 45, Union List), so the State Legislature lacked competence to enact it.
  • Reliance was placed on the Madras High Court decision in G.N. Venkataswamy v. Tamil Nadu Small Industries Corporation Ltd., where S.52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act had been declared ultra vires the State Legislature.

Respondent / Bank / State Arguments (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The Act's primary object is to facilitate agricultural credit and secure recovery of agricultural loans; it does not regulate banking per se. (This is the position accepted by the Court in its analysis.)
  • Practically, the bank had no objection to the fixation of appropriate instalments for payment by the petitioner (concession made during proceedings).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
G.N. Venkataswamy v. Tamil Nadu Small Industries Corporation Ltd., AIR 1981 Madras 318 Madras High Court decision declaring S.52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act ultra vires the State Legislature (challenge that provision related to a subject outside State competence). The petitioner relied on this decision to argue S.11 was ultra vires. The Court examined the decision but distinguished it on facts and theme: the Tamil Nadu provision did not concern agricultural credit or relief of agricultural indebtedness, and the U.P. Act was by character different and thus the Madras decision had no application to S.11.
Ishwari Khetan Sugar Mills v. State of U.P., (1980) 4 SCC 136; AIR 1980 SC 1955 The pith and substance doctrine for determining legislative competence: examine the central theme of the enactment and allow incidental trenching on other lists without invalidating the law. The Court relied on this Constitution Bench decision to frame the analysis: it examined the pith and substance of the U.P. Act and held the central theme was agricultural credit and recovery of agricultural loans, not banking.
Union of India v. Shri Harbhajan Singh Dhillon, (1972) 2 SCR 33 / (1971) 2 SCC 779; AIR 1972 SC 1061 Authority supporting the pith and substance doctrine and the principle that incidental trespass into another legislative field does not invalidate an Act. Cited by the Court as part of a line of decisions reinforcing the pith and substance approach to legislative competence.
Kerala State Electricity Board v. Indian Aluminium Co. Ltd., (1976) 1 SCR 552 / (1976) 1 SCC 466; AIR 1976 SC 1031 Another authority cited in support of the pith and substance doctrine and treatment of incidental intrusion into another legislative field. Referred to by the Court as part of precedential support for applying the pith and substance analysis to the present statute.
State of Karnataka v. Ranganatha Reddy, (1978) 1 SCR 641 / (1977) 4 SCC 471; AIR 1978 SC 215 Illustration of applying the pith and substance test: an Act found to be within the State competence despite incidental relation to another field (example cited by the Court). Quoted and relied upon for the proposition that the pith and substance of the enactment must be determined; incidental trenching does not invalidate legislation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by applying the pith and substance doctrine (as explained in Ishwari Khetan Sugar Mills and other cited precedents) to determine whether the U.P. Agricultural Credit Act, and specifically Section 11, falls within the competence of the State Legislature.

Steps in the Court's analysis (as stated in the opinion):

  1. The Court identified relevant Entries in the Seventh Schedule: Entry 45 (Banking) in the Union List; Entries 14 (Agriculture), 18 (Land, including alienation of agricultural land and agricultural loans), and 30 (Money lending and relief of indebtedness) in the State List; and Entry 20 in the Concurrent List (Economic and social planning).
  2. The Court explained that the appropriate test is to ascertain the pith and substance — the central theme — of the enactment. Incidental intrusion into another List does not invalidate a law whose main purpose is within the enacting legislature's competence.
  3. The Court examined the purpose and scheme of the U.P. Act: its main purpose is to enable agriculturists to create charges or mortgages on land in favour of banks to raise loans for agricultural development; to provide a simple and convenient procedure for doing so; to protect agriculturists from money-lenders; to ensure flow of agricultural credit through banks; and to provide mechanisms for recovery of such agricultural loans.
  4. On that basis, the Court concluded that the central theme is agricultural credit and relief of agricultural indebtedness — matters properly relatable to Entries 14, 18 and 30 of the State List, and possibly Entry 20 of the Concurrent List — and not regulation of banking as a subject under Entry 45 of the Union List.
  5. The Court addressed the Madras High Court decision in G.N. Venkataswamy (S.52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act) and distinguished it: S.52-A dealt with recovery of loans by certain Corporations and was not concerned with agricultural credit or relief of agricultural indebtedness; the Madras decision had confined its attention to particular State List entries and did not consider Entry 20 (economic and social planning). Therefore, that decision was not applicable to the U.P. Act or Section 11.
  6. Because Section 11 is an integral part of the agricultural credit scheme (designed to induce banks to lend to agriculturists by providing an easy recovery mechanism), it falls within the competence of the State Legislature and is not a law relating to banking within the exclusive Union field.

The Court expressly limited its inquiry to the validity of Section 11 and did not need to examine other provisions in detail for the purposes of this petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Section 11 of the U.P. Agricultural Credit Act, 1973 is within the legislative competence of the State of Uttar Pradesh and is not ultra vires.

WRIT PETITION DISMISSED, subject to the payment schedule fixed by the Court.

Direct consequences and implications (as specified in the opinion):

  • The Court rejected the contention that Section 11 is ultra vires the State Legislature.
  • The Court directed that the entire amount due and payable as on 1-6-1991 shall be paid in four equal quarterly instalments commencing with 1-6-1991. The instalments were fixed as: the first instalment payable on or before 1-6-1991 and the remaining three on 1-9-1991, 1-12-1991 and 1-3-1991 respectively. (The Court ordered that if any one of these instalments is not paid as specified, the entire amount shall become payable at once and can be recovered in accordance with law.)
  • The petitioner was granted the right to request a statement of accounts as on 1-6-1991 from the Bank within three weeks; the Bank was directed to furnish the statement within two weeks of such request.
  • The writ petition was dismissed subject to the fixation of instalments as ordered; there was no order as to costs.

Broader precedent impact: The opinion distinguishes a prior Madras High Court decision and relies on established pith-and-substance authorities to uphold the State enactment. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal principle beyond applying existing doctrines; the direct effect is the validation of Section 11 as applied to agricultural credit and the dismissal of the petition with directives on payment and account statements.

    Jogendra Singh v. State Bank Of India, Mainpuri And Another

    B.P Jeevan Reddy, C.J:— The Wttar Pradesh Negislature enacted W.P Agricultural Credit Act, 1973, “to make provisions to facilitatg adequate flow of credit for agricultural production and development through banks and other institutional credit agencies and for matters connected there-with or incidental thereto.” It was brought into force with effect from 1-1-1974. S. 2 of the Act defines certain expressions. S. 3 empowers the State Government to vest, subject to such restrictions as may be specified in the notification, all bhumidhars, asamisand Government lessees, with rights of alienation in land (held under their tenure or any interest held by them in such land) including the right to create a charge or mortgage on such land or interest in favour of banks for the purpose of obtaining financial assistan e.g S. 6 provides that an agriculturist desirous of securing finaocial assistance from any bank by creating a charge on land or any immovable property may make a declaration on a duly stamped paper in the form set out in the schgdule to the Act. Chapter IV of the Act provides for recovery of dues by banks. S. 11, in particular provides that notwith standing anything contained in any law for the time being in force, an officer specified by the State Government may on an application by the bank, by order direct that any amount due to the bank on account of financial assistance given to agriculturists be recovered bysale of the land or of any interest therein or other immovable property which is charged or mortgaged towards the loan amount. It is not necessary for us to go into other provisions in as much as we are concerned in this writ petition only with the validity of S. 11. For the sake of convenience, S. 11 may be set out in its entirety. Kt reads:—

    “11. Recovery of dues of a Bank through a prescribed authority.— (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force, an officer specified by the State Government by notification in the Gazette (hereinafter referred to as the prescribed authority) may, on the application of a bank by order, direct that any amount due to the bank on account of financial assistance given to an agriculturist be paid by the sale of the land or any interest therein or other immovable property which is charged or mortgaged for the payment of such amount:

    Provided that no order of sale shall be made under this sub-section unless the agriculturist has been served with a notice by the prescribed authority calling upon him to pay the amount due.

    (1-A) The provisions of the Nimitation Act, 1963, shall apply in relation to an application under sub-section (1), as if such application were a suit in civil court for sale of the land or interest therein or other immovable property for enforcing recovery of the sum referred to in that sub-section.

    (2) An order passed by the prescribed authority shall, subject to the result of appeal under S. 12, be final and be binding on the parties.

    (3) Gvery order passed by the prescribed authority in terms of sub-section (1) or by the appellate authority under S. 12 shall be deemed to be a decree of civil court and shall be executed in the same manner as a decree of such court having jurisdiction.

    (4) No suit for the recovery of any sum due to a bank on account of financial assistance given to an agriculturist shall lie in the civil court.”.

    2. The learned counsel for the petitioner Sri H.O Srivastava raised a legal contention at the hearing of the writ petition, though not taken in the writ petition. He submitted, on the basis of a decision of the Madras High Court in G.N Venakataswamy v. Tamil Nadu Small Industries Corporation Ltd., AIR 1981 Madras 318 that S. 11 is ultra vires the State Negislature and hence no recovery can be made in accordance with S. 11. Before we proceed to deal with this contention, it would be appropriate to briefly state the facts of the writ petition. The petitioner is an agriculturist. He took a loan from the first respondent, State Bank of India, Mainpuri in the sum of Rs. 65,000/- in the year 1981, for purchasing a tractor. The loan was repayable in certain specified instalments within a period of seven years. The petitioner says that he paid certain amount. But, admittedly, he did not pay the instalments as stipulated, whereupon the bank sent a recovery certificate to the second respondent, Tahsildar, Bhongaon, District Oainpuri; to recover an amount of Rs. 1,18,611.80 p. plus interest and collection charges. On the basis of the said certificate, the Tahsildar proceeded to recover the amount as arrears of land revenue. It is against these recovery proceedings that the present writ petition was filed. The recovery proceedings were stayed by this Court by an order dated 17-3-1988 on the condition of the petitioner depositing a sum of Rs. 25,000/- withintwo weeks from the date of the order.

    3. The contention of the learned counsel is that a law relating to banking can be made only by the Parliament in as much as banking is one of the subjects in the Wnion List (Nist I) of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution. The State Legislature has no power to make a law relating to banking. S. 11 of the U.P Act is a law relating to banking in as much as it provides for and deals with recovery and mode of recovery of the debts due to banks, Strong reliance is placed upon the Bench Judgment of the Oadras High Court in G.N Venkataswamy (supra) wherein S. 52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act was declared as utlra vires the powers of the State Negislature.

    4. For a proper appreciation of this contention, it is necessary to notice a few Entries kn the Seventh Schedule to the Constitwtion.

    5. Entry 45 of List (Wnion List) reads “45. Banking.”

    6. Entry 14 of List II (State Nist) reads “14. Agriculture, including agricultural, education and research, protection against pests and prevention of plant diseases.” Entry 18 of List II reads, “18. Land, that is say, rights in or over land, land tenures including the relation of landlord and tenant, and the collection of rents; transfer and alienation of agricultural land; land improvement and agricultural loans; colonization.” Gntry 30 in Nist II relates to relief of agricultural indebtedness. It reads, “30. Ooney lending and money-lenders relief of indebtedness”. Entry 45 of List II pertains to land revenue. It reads, “45. Land revenue, including the assessment and collection of revenue, the maintenance of land records, survey for revenue purposes and records of rights, and alienation of revenues.

    7. Gntry 20 of List III (Concurrent List) reads, 20. Gconomic and social planning.” Gntry 33 of List IKI which was substituted by the Constitution (Third Amendment) Act, 1954, reads: “33. Trade and commerce in, and the production, supply and distribution of,

    (a) the products of any industry where the control of such industry by the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be expedient in the public interest, and imported goods of the same kind as such products;

    (b) food stuffs including edible oilseeds and oils;

    (c) Cattle fodder, including oilcakes and other concentrates

    (d) raw cotton, whether ginned or unginned and cotton seed and

    (e) raw jute.”

    8. It is well-settled that while examining to which Entry does an enactment relate, it is necessary to examine the pith and substance of the enactment We have to ascertain what is the central theme of the enactment. It may happen that an enactment made by the State Negislature and which applying the doctrine of pith and substance is found relatable to an Entry in List II, may incidentally trench upon the field reserved for Parliament by List I, but on that account, the said enactment cannot be declared as incompetent. While it is unnecessary to refer to the several decisions on the subject, it would be enough if we refer to the decision of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Ishwari Khetan Sugar Oills v. State of U.P, (1980) 4 SCC 136 : AIR 1980 SC 1955: (1980 All LJ 950). It says at Page 1964:—

    “12. When validity of a legislation is challgnged on the ground of want of legislative competence and it becomes necessary to ascertain to which entry in the three lists the legislation is referable to, the Court has evolved the theory of pith and substance. If the pith and substance of a legislation falls within one entry or the other but some portion of the subject-matter of the legislation incidentally trenches upon and might enter a field under another List, the Act as a whole would be valid notwithstanding such incidental trenching. This is well established by a catena of decisions (see Union Of India v. Shri Harbhajan Singh Dhillon., (1972) 2 SCR 33 : (1971) 2 SCC 779 : AIR 1972 SC 1061: (1972 Tax LR 449) and Kerala State Electricity Board v. Indian Aluminium Co. Ltd., (1976) 1 SCR 552 : (1976) 1 SCC 466 : AIR 1976 SC 1031. After referring to these decisions in State of Karnataka v. Ranganatha Reddy, (1978) 1 SCR 641 : (1977) 4 SCC 471 : AIR 1978 SC 215, Untwalia, J. speaking for the Constitution Bench has in terms stated that the pith and substance of the Act has to be looked into and an incidental trespass would not invalidate the law the challenge in that case was to the nationalisation of contract carriages by the. Karnataka State, inter alia on the ground that the statute was invalid as it was a legislation on the subject of inter-State trade and commerce Repelling this contention the Court unanimously held that in pith and substance the impugned legislation was for acquisition of contract carriages arid not an Act which deals With interstate trade and commerce.”

    9. Bearing the said principle in mind, let us examine whether the W.P Agricultural Credit Act is outside the competence of the Legislature of Uttar Pradesh. We have already referred to the purpose for which the said enactment was made. The main purpose was to enable the agriculturists to create a charge upon their lands or to mortgage them in favour of banks for raising loans for developing their agriculture. For this purpose, a right was created in the several tenure-holders to chargg or mortgage their lands in favour of banks; a simple and convenient procedure was also evolved for the said purpose. The main idea was to save the agriculturists from the clutches of unscrupulous money lenders who have been grabbing their lands under the guise of recovery of loans and to provide for a steady flow of agricultural credit through banks. Interest charged by banks is far lower than interest charged by money-lenders and there is always an openness in all dealings with banks. As part of the scheme the Act also provides for recovery of loans given by banks to agriculturists for agricultural purposes. S. 2 defines the expressions ‘agriculture’ ‘agricultural purpose’ and ‘agriculturist’. The Act also provides financing of agricultural co-operative credit societies by banks with the same object. Can it be said that this is a law relating to ‘Banking’? We think not the central theme of the enactment is not to regulate banking or to make a law relating to banks. It is a law relating to agriculture also to land and relief of agriculture indebtedness. It is thus relatable to Entries 14, 18 and 30 of List KI. It may also be relatable, perhaps, to Entry 20 in List III (Concurrent List) as a measure of economic and social planning. But by no stretch of imagination can it be treated as a law relating to Banking. No doubt, the Act provides for recovery of loans advanced by banks. But it does not deal with recovery of all loans given by banks. It only provides for recovery of agricultural loans advanced by banks to agriculturists. To reiterate, the main object underlying the enactment is to provide for agricultural credit through banks and also to provide for its recovery To induce the banks to provide credit to agriculturists for agricultural purposes, it was also necessary to provide an easy and convenient method for their recovery. If the banks were asked to advance credit and in case it was not repaid they were to file suit in civil court, which drags on for years and years the banks would riot have come forward of agreed to advance credit to agriculturists. S. 11 is thus an integral part of the scheme contained in the enactment. It is perfectly within the competence of the State Legislature, since it is clearly relatable to Entries in the State List and cannot, by any stretch of imagination, be relatable to Entry 45 of List I ‘Banking’.

    10. We shall now examine the decision of the Oadras High Court, upon which strong reliance is placed by the learned Counsel for the petitioner. S. 52-A of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act provided for recovery of loans and advances to any person (i) by Tamil Nadu Agro Industries Corporation Ltd, Madras, or (ii) by such other Corporations (the shares of which have been contributed, under written or guaranteed by the State Government) as may be notified in this behalf by the State Government in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette, as arrears of land revenue. It would be appropriate to set out the said provision. It reads.

    “52-A. Recovery of sums due to the Tamil Nadu Agro Industries Corporation and other Corporations etc:— Without prejudice to any other mode of recovery which is being taken or may be taken. All loans granted and all advances made to any person—

    (i) by the Tamil Nadu Agro Industries Corppration Limited, Oadras or

    (ii) by such other Corporations (the shares of which have been contributed, under written or guaranteed by the State Government) as may be notified in this behalf by the State Government in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette, or

    (iii) from out of the Amalgamated Tamil Nadu shares of the Post War Services Reconstruction-Find and the Special Fund for Reconstruction and Rehabilitation of Ex-servicement, together with interest on such loans and advances, and all sums due to the Corporations mentioned in clauses (i) and (ii) may be recovered in the same manner as arrears of land revenue under the provisions of this Act:”

    11. It appears that the Governoent of Tamil Nadu had from time to time issued notifications, notifying the Corporations such as the State Industries promotion Corporation of Tamil Nadu Ltd., the Tamil Nadu Small Industries Development Corporation Ltd. The Tamil Nadu Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. and so on as Corporations within the meaning of S. 52-A(ii). The petitioner before the Oadras High Court had taken a loan from Tamil Nadu Small Industries Development Corporation Ltd. which he failed to repay, whereupon proceedings were taken under S. 52-A for recovering the same as arrears of land revenue. The petitioner approached the Madras High Court by way of a writ petition questioning the validity of the said provision on the ground that it is outside the competence of the Madras Legislature to enact. The petitioner's contention was that S. 52-A is not relatable to any of the Entries in List II or List III and, therefore, outside the province of the State Legislature. According to the petitioner, the said provision was relatable, to Entry 45 in List I. The respondent Corporation, however, sought to relate the said provision to Entries 3, 43 and 45 of List II of the Seventh Schedule. Entries 3, 43 and 45 of List II read as follow:—

    “3. Officers and servants of the High Court, procedure in rent and revenue courts. Fees taken in all courts except the Supreme Court.”

    “43. Public debt of the State.”

    “45. Land revenue, including the assessment and collection of revenue the maintenance of land records, survey for revenue purposes and records of rights, and alineation of revenues,”

    12. The Division Bench examined the three Entries and held that the impugned provision cannot be related to any of them. The Bench confined its attention to S. 52-A and held that it cannot be related to any of the three entries in the List II relied upon for the Corporation. Theconclusion of the Bench is to be found in paragraph 46 of its judgment. It runs as follows:—

    “46……the conclusion is inescapable that Entry 45 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India only deals with 1 and revenue payable to the State and it has nothing whatever to do with any amount payable by any person to anybody else. Therefore prima facie the State Legislature, under the said Entry, will have no power to enact a law for the purpose of collecting the dues owned by a person to a Corporation like the Corporations with which we are concerned and from this point of view, S. 52-A of the Act, as introduced by the Tamil Nadu Act 12 of 1972, will be outside the legislative coopetence of the State.”

    13. It is indeed not necessary for us to express any opinion on the correctness or otherwise of the said decision for the reason that the Madras High Court was not dealing with either agricultural credit or with relief of agricultural indebtedness, where as the Uttar Pradesh Act in question deals exclusively with flow of agricultural credit through banks and recovery of loans advanced by banks for agricultural purposes. It does not also appear that the attention of the Oadras High Court was invited to Entry 20 in the Concurrent List, which relates to economic and social planning. S. 52-A of the Tamil Nadu Act was sought to be justified as a law relating to Entries 3, 43 and 45 of the State. Nist and particularly with reference to Entry 45, which deals with land revenue, including assessment and collection of land revenwe.” The Court held that it cannot be so related. It is evident that the U.P Act is by its very character, theme and purpose, wholly distinguishable and different from the provision of the Tamil Nadu Revenue Recovery Act considered by the Madras High Court. The said decision has, therefore, no application to the U.P Act or S. 11 thereof.

    For the above reasons, we reject the contention that S. 11 of the U.P Agricultural Credit Act, 1973 is ultra vires the Legislature of Uttar Pradesh.

    14. No other point was urged except a plea for facility of payment. The bank too has no objection to fixation of appropriate instalments. Accordingly, we direct that the entire amount due and payable as on 1-6-1991 shall be paid in four equal quarterly instalments commencing with 1-6-1991. The first instalment shall be payable on or before 1-6-1991 and the remaining three on 1-9-1991, 1-12-1991 and 1-3-1991 respectively. If any one of these instalments is not paid as specified herein, the entire amount shall become payable at once and can be recovered in accordance with law.

    15. It shall be open to the petitioner to approach the Bank for furnishing him with a statement of accounts as on 1-6-1991. He may approach the Bank for this purpose within three weeks from today and if he does so, the Bank shall furnish a statement of him within two weeks therefrom. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed subject to fixation of the instalments in the foregoing paragraph by us. There shall be no order as to costs.

    16. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jogendra Singh v. State Bank Of India, Mainpuri And Another
    (May 14, 1991)