The Petitioners have been convicted under sec. 225B, I.P.C, for resisting execution of a certain warrant for the arrest of a witness named Musstt. Malie whose attendance was desired in the case No. 610 of 1910. We granted this Rule on the ground that the action of the Court issuing the warrant of arrest was illegal and vitiated the subsequent proceedings including the conviction of the Petitioners for resisting an invalid process. The warrant was issued under sec. 90 of the Criminal Procedure Code which provides that the Court must record its reasons in writing before adopting that extreme measure. It appears from the order-sheet of the case No. 610 of 1910 that no summons was issued on Musstt. Malie. Warrant was ordered in the first instance. That procedure appears to have been illegal inasmuch as on the face of the order-sheet no reasons were recorded by the Court issuing the warrant. Nor has the Magistrate submitted any explanation to elucidate the matter.
On the warrant itself there is a printed form, in accordance with the form No. 7 of Sch. V of the Code of Criminal Procedure, reciting that “whereas I have good and sufficient reason to believe that he (the witness) will not attend as a witness on the hearing of the said complaint unless compelled to do so,” but the natural meaning of sec. 90 is that the Court should record its reasons in writing. The adoption of a stereotyped printed form is not, in our opinion, a sufficient compliance with the imperative language of the section. The printed form may be intended for the information of the person whom it is sought to arrest. But that is a different matter. We think, therefore, that the conviction is unsustainable.
We may add that the incident appears to have been greatly magnified. Musstt. Malie duly appeared in Court and gave her evidence.
The convictions and sentences are therefore set aside. We direct that the Petitioners be discharged from bail.
The Rule is made absolute.
B.C
Rule made absolute.