Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 80 of the Railways Act (IX of 1890)
  • Section 15(2) of the Limitation Act
  • Section 77 of the Railway Act.11.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 80 of the Railways Act (IX of 1890)
  • Section 15(2) of the Limitation Act
  • Section 77 of the Railway Act.11.

    B. & N.W Railway Co. v. Ramsarup Lal Chaudhury .

    Coutts, J.:— The facts of the case out of which this appeal arises are shortly as follows: The plaintiff in the suit Ramsarup Lal Chaudhury, booked from Sonada Railway Station on the Darjeeling Himalayan Railway on the 17th of October, 1917, 62 bags of potatoes. The bags were booked to Marhowara Station on the Bengal and North-Western Railway. On the 20th or 21st of November out of the consignment of 62 bags, 26 bags only were delivered to the consignee, who was the same person as the consignor.

    2. He was told that the other bags would be delivered later when they were received. They were never received so the plaintiff sued the Darjeeling Himalayan Railway, the Eastern Bengal State Railway and the Bengal Northwestern Railway over whose lines the consignment should have passed, for recovery of a sum of Rs. 760 as the price of the potatoes lost and Rs. 9 as price of the bags. The whole amount claimed with interest came up to Rs. 862-12-0. The suit was decreed in the Court of the first instance against the Darjeeling Himalayan Railway and the Bengal North-Western Railway and each of these Railways appealed. The appeal of the Darjeeling Himalayan Railway was successful but the appeal of the Bengal North Western Railway failed and this Railway has now appealed to this Court.

    3. The first question for consideration is whether the Bengal North Western Railway can be held liable. Under Section 80 of the Railways Act (IX of 1890) any Railway on which a loss or destruction or deterioration has occurred would be liable. In this case it has been found that the loss occurred on the East Indian Railway but the Bengal North-Western Railway has been made liable because for the portion of the journey during which the East Indian Railway were in charge of the goods they were acting as the agents of the Bengal North-Western Railway.

    4. Ordinarily the goods would travel first over the Darjeeling Himalayan Railway, then over the Eastern Bengal State Railway and then be taken over by the Bengal North Western Railway. There was however a breach on the Bengal North-Western Railway line, and what actually occurred was that the goods after leaving the Eastern Bengal Section were handed over to the Bengal North. Western Railway Company. That Company on account of a breach on its line handed over the goods to the East Indian Railway with whom they made an arrangement that for the time being that Railway would be their agents. The goods were lost during this portion of the journey.

    5. The Bengal North-Western Railway are admittedly liable for the loss on their agent's line and the finding that the East Indian Railway were their agents is a finding of fact which is apparently correct and with which in any case we cannot interfere in Second Appeal. The Bengal North Western Railway has therefore rightly been made liable.

    6. It is contended, however, that the suit is barred by limitation, because delivery was made on the 14th of November, 1917, whereas the suit was not brought before the 3rd of December, 1918, and that the period of limitation is one year. It has been held, however, by the lower appellate Court that limitation is saved by the deduction of the period of two months' notice which was given to the Secretary of State and which under Section 15(2) of the Limitation Act the plaintiff was entitled to have excluded from the period of limitation.

    7. It is contended in appeal before us that the Secretary of State was not a necessary party to the suit and that therefore S. 15(2) has no application. This argument is based on a misconception. The suit was brought against three Railway Companies, including the Eastern Bengal State Railway and in the case of a suit against that Railway a notice to the Secretary of State was necessary and this being so the plaintiff was undoubtedly entitled to the benefit of the period of notice to the Secretary of State.

    8. It is suggested that because the Secretary of State was not a necessary party to the suit as against the other two Railway Companies the section does not apply, but this is clearly a fallacious argument in a single suit which is properly brought against several defendants if the plaintiff is entitled to deduct a certain period from the period of limitation in respect of one defendant he is also entitled to the same period of limitation in the case of the other defendants. The suit is, therefore, in my opinion, within time.

    9. Even without the exclusion of this period of two months it would however still be within time. The learned Subordinate Judge has taken the 14th of November, 1917, as the date on which delivery of the 26 bags was made he has taken this date as the starting point of limitation but this is a mistake because delivery, as he himself says in another portion of his judgment, was made on the 20th or 21st November, 1917.

    10. The suit could not be brought against the Railway Companies without issue of a notice under Section 77 of the Railway Act.

    11. This notice was given and 15 days' time was given to the Railway Companies. Consequently under S. 15(2) the plaintiff was entitled to exclude this period also and if this is excluded even without the two months allowed for notice to the Secretary of State the suit will be within time.

    12. In my opinion the suit has been rightly decided by the Courts below and I would dismiss this appeal with costs.

    13. Adami, J.:— I agree.

    14. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    B. & N.W Railway Co. v. Ramsarup Lal Chaudhury .
    (Jun 9, 1922)