Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Dawarka Prasad v. Makhu Lal

    1. This appeal arises out of a suit brought by the appellants for ejectment of the respondent from the land in dispute, on the ground that the defendant has used the land in a manner which renders it unfit for the purposes of the tenancy. In other words, the suit was a suit under the provisions of Section 155 of the Ben. Ten. Act. Now the complaint of the plaintiffs is that the defendant has erected a structure on six ??? of agricultural land which the defendant purchased from one Phagu, who was the original tenant. The defendant on the other hand maintains that the structure was not raised on the six cottahs of land which he purchased from Phagu, but on one cottah of land which was let out to the defendant for building his house and which adjoins the six cottahs. The Court of first instance thought that it was difficult to say exactly whether the disputed houses stand, over the disputed land or over one cottah of land which was settled with the defendant. He however held a local inspection and, as a result of his local inspection, came to the conclusion that a portion of the house stood on the six cottahs of land but that the remaining portion of the house stood on the one cottah of land. In the result he granted a modified decree to the plaintiffs. There was an appeal by both parties to the lower appellate Court. The respondent complained that the Court of first instance was incompetent to grant any decree at all in favour of the plaintiffs. The respondent's appeal succeeded before the lower appellate Court. The appellants on the other hand maintained that the lower appellate Court should have granted them a decree for ejectment under Section 155 of the Ben. Ten. Act. The lower appellate Court says this:

    “The learned lower Court made a careful local inquiry and was satisfied that these other structures do not stand on the six cottahs. I do not see how the appellant's contention can be accepted.”

    2. It is clear to me therefore that the lower appellate Court relied entirely upon the local investigation conducted by the Court of the first instance. The question whether a Court is entitled, under the new Code of Civil Procedure, to hold a local inquiry himself has been raised in several cases, but so far as I know, has not yet been decided. So far as the English cases are concerned, it is clear that a Court is not entitled to hold a local inspection inasmuch as it may hamper the Court in coming to a conclusion on the evidence before it. But the Code of Civil Procedure of 1882 did, undoubtedly, empower a Court to hold a local inspection, but O. 26, R. 9, which in my opinion, is a complete Code on the subject, gives no power whatever to a Court to hold a local inspection. The point is an interesting one and it is interesting to compare the wording of S. 392 of the Code of 1882 with the wording of O. 26, R. 9. S. 392 of the Code of 1882 provided as follows:

    “In any suit or proceeding in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the market value of any property, or the amount of any mesne profits, or damages or annual net profits, and the same cannot be conveniently conducted by the Judge in parson, the Court may issue a commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court.”

    3. Order 26, R. 9, however provides that:

    “In any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the market value of any property or the amount of any mesne profits, or damages or annual net profits, the Court may issue a commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court.”

    4. It will be noticed that the words occurring in S. 392, viz.; “and the same cannot be conveniently conducted by, the Judge in person” have been altogether omitted in O. 26, R. 9, and it is with reference to this that Mookerjee, J., in the case of Rai Kishore Ghose v. Kumudini Kanta Ghose(1) says as follows:

    “It may be pointed out however that O. 26, R. 9 of the Code of 1908, which corresponds to s. 392, omits the words ‘and the same cannot be conveniently conducted by the Judge in person’ and when R. 9 requires to be construed, it may be a matter for argument that the intention of the legislature was to adopt the English rule.”

    5. The English rule, as I have said before, does not allow a Judge to hold a local inspection himself. But whether under the new Code a Judge is entitled to hold a local inspection or not, it is perfectly clear that he can only hold it for the purpose of understanding the evidence and for no other purpose. He must still decide the case on the evidence adduced before him, and if he finds that it is impossible to decide the case on the evidence before him he has ample power under O. 26, R. 9, to issue a commission to such person as he thinks fit to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court. The complaint of the Courts below has been that the plaintiffs did not apply for issue of commission, but in opinion, if the Court thought that it wife impossible for it to determine the question at issue between the parties without a local investigation, it was not only competent to him to issue a commission, but it was his duty to do so, and there can be no doubt that the Court of first instance undoubtedly thought it could not do complete justice between the parties without local investigation. The fact that he himself conducted the local investigation shows conclusively that in his opinion complete justice could not be done without such an investigation.

    6. The learned vakil appearing on behalf of the respondent argues that the Court of first instance decided this case not only on the result of his local inspection but on the evidence adduced before it, I am unable to agree with the learned vakil on this point. But whatever may have been the opinion of the Court of first instance, it is to my mind clear beyond doubt that the lower appellate Court based its decision on the local inspection held by the Munsif and on nothing else. In my opinion this judgment cannot be sustained. I would therefore allow this appeal and remit the case to the lower appellate Court with a direction that the lower appellate Court should remit it to, the Court of first instance in order to enable it to decide the questions at issue to between the parties. If the Court of first instance thinks that it is unable to decide the case without a local investigation or if the plaintiff makes an application before it for the issue of a commission, then the Court of first instance will have power under O. 26, R. 9, to issue a commission to such person as it thinks fit for the purpose of holding a local investigation and to make a report to the Court.

    7. The appellants are entitled to the costs of this appeal and of the appeal to the lower appellate Court. The costs incurred in the Court of first instance will abide the result and will be disposed of by that Court. The parties will not be permitted to adduce any further evidence before the Court of first instance either on the question of damage or on any other question at all.

    V.S/R.K

    8. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dawarka Prasad v. Makhu Lal
    (Jul 9, 1919)