Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Rahim-Un-Nissa v. Badri Das

    Richards and Tudball, JJ.:— This appeal arises out of a suit on foot of a mortgage dated the 17th of May, 1904. The plaintiffs stated in the plaint that the mortgage was made to satisfy a certain decree obtained on the 25th of February, 1901, on foot of a mortgage, dated the 6th of February, 1895. They therefore claimed that their mortgage had priority over the defendant's mortgage. The defendant claimed under a mortgage, dated the 25th of April, 1904, made by the last male owner of the property in favour of his wife, who is the present appellant. It appears that when the decree, dated the 25th of February 1901, had been obtained, the decree-holder accepted from the judgement-debtor a sale-deed of a certain part of the mortgaged property in full discharge of the decree. Possession, however, it is said, was never given, and it is admitted that the adjustment of the decree was never certified to the court. Subsequently, the decree-holder put the decree into execution. The judgement-debtor objected, pleading the adjustment. The court refused to recognize the adjustment, because it had not been certified according to law, and directed the property to be sold. Before the property was sold, however, the judgement-debtor asked for sanction to prosecute the decree-holder for fraudulently executing the decree which had been satisfied. The result of all this was the mortgage of May, 1904, on foot of which the present suit has been instituted. The amount of the mortgage was the amount of the decree of February, 1901. The court below has decreed the plaintiffs claim giving the plaintiff the priority which was claimed. In appeal here it is contended that the decree of the 25th of February, 1901, was fully discharged by the sale-deed of 1903, and that the plaintiffs mortgage is only entitled to the priority of its actual date. Reliance has been placed upon the case of Nakta Ram v. Moti Ram. In that case, no doubt, it was decided that where the decree-holder took a usufructuary mortgage in discharge of a mortgage decree, he could not fall back upon the original mortgage on foot of which he had obtained his decree. This decision was considered in the case of Kanhaiya Lal v. Chedda Singh, and a Bench of two Judges expressed their dissent. In the case of Shyam Lal v. Bashir-ud-din(3), it was held that where a third person advanced money for the purposes of satisfying a mortgage decree for sale of the property and took a mortgage for the amount so advanced, he was entitled to the benefit of the prior incumbrance, as against the incumbrances which had been created between the original mortgage and the new security. The same view seems to have been taken by both the High Courts of Calcutta and Madras. Mr. Hamilton, on behalf of the appellant, contends that the decree was actually satisfied by the sale-deed, and that the subsequent mortgage was a new arrangement altogether in which not only the old mortgage debt was satisfied but also a criminal charge compromised. We cannot take this view. It is clear that owing to the fact that the adjustment of the decree was not certified the property could be sold in execution of the decree, notwithstanding any adjustment. If the sale had taken place and the property had been sold to a third party, the latter would have got a perfect title and the sale would have been considered to be free of all incumbrances. We feel that we must regard the position of the parties without considering the complication of the sale of 1903, that is to say, we must deal with the case on the basis that prior to the actual sale of the property on foot of the mortgage decree the decree-holder took from the judgement-debtor a fresh mortgage for the amount due on foot of the decree. In our opinion, under these circumstances and on the authorities, the mortgagee is entitled to the benefit of the prior mortgage at least to the extent of all moneys secured by that mortgage. We dismiss the appeal with costs.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rahim-Un-Nissa v. Badri Das
    (Jan 3, 1911)