AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 26-A of the Adhiniyam (hereinafter called the Board)
  • Sub-clause (b) of Clause (iii) of Section 17
  • section 26-1 or section 33
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 26-A of the Adhiniyam (hereinafter called the Board)
  • Sub-clause (b) of Clause (iii) of Section 17
  • section 26-1 or section 33
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — A.N. Gupta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The bench heard a bunch of 12 writ petitions together because common questions arose. The petitioners are rice millers of Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh, and the sole opposite party is Krisbi Utpadan Mandi Samiti, Saharanpur ("Mandi Samiti").

The rice millers purchase paddy both from inside and outside the Mandi Samiti's market area; they pay market fee on purchases. From the paddy they produce rice, 60% of which is given to the State as levy under the U.P. Rice & Paddy (Levy & Regulations of Trade) Order, 1985; the remaining 40% (the "released share") is sold in the open market.

A legal rule from the Supreme Court (Ram Chandra Kailash Kumar v. State of U.P.) holds that market fee is a single-point levy in one market area: rice produced from paddy purchased outside the market area and sold outside that area attracts no market fee to the Mandi Samiti; rice produced from outside paddy but sold within the market area attracts market fee.

The core factual dispute in these petitions relates to rice produced from paddy purchased outside the market area that the petitioners contend was sold or despatched outside the Mandi Samiti's market area (and therefore not subject to market fee). The Mandi Samiti contends that, under the Explanation to section 17 of the Uttar Pradesh Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964 ("Adhiniyam"), any specified agricultural produce taken out of a market area by or on behalf of a licensed trader is presumed, unless contrary is proved, to have been sold within that area.

Procedurally: following earlier directions given by this Court in Sri Mahalaxmi Sugar Works (1987), many petitioners submitted prescribed statements for years 1988-89 to 1991-92, some after notices. Initial assessments were made and fees paid by petitioners. After a change of Secretary, the Mandi Samiti issued reassessment notices (1993) alleging insufficient proof that sales or despatches were made outside the market area; demand notices threatened licence suspension and recovery as arrears of land revenue. The petitioners filed these writ petitions seeking quashing of second demand notices and a declaration that reassessment was illegal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in the absence of any provision in the Adhiniyam or Rules for re-assessment, the Mandi Samiti is empowered to make a re-assessment of market fee after an initial assessment has been completed.
  2. Whether the presumption under the Explanation to section 17 of the Adhiniyam (that produce taken out of a market area is presumed sold within the area unless contrary proved) operates to place on the petitioners the burden of proving despatch/sale outside the market area, and whether the petitioners complied with that burden.
  3. Whether the statutory scheme (Adhiniyam and Rules) provides adequate procedural machinery (gate-passes, returns, time-limits, hearing and appeals/revision) to safeguard both the Mandi Samiti's right to collect fees and the traders' rights against unfair reassessment or harassment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The rice produced from paddy purchased outside the market area and sold/despatched outside the market area is not liable to market fee payable to the Mandi Samiti (relying on the single-point levy principle as stated by the Supreme Court).
  • They had filed returns/statements (some voluntarily, some on notices) giving details of purchases, production, levy and released rice and despatches; initial assessment was made and market fee was paid accordingly; therefore reassessment cannot be made.
  • Required documents for the earlier years were not readily available at the time of later notices; they requested time (three months, per their representation) to trace relevant documents and sought discharge of the notices.

Mandi Samiti's Arguments

  • Under the Explanation to section 17, any specified produce taken out of a market area by a licensed trader is presumed sold within that area unless the contrary is proved; petitioners failed to furnish proof of despatch/sale outside the market area.
  • What was done initially was an assessment of fees in respect of rice sold within the market area; subsequently, on review, the Mandi Samiti discovered (or alleged) that released rice may have been sold outside the market area and thus sought to impose further fee — i.e., reassessment.
  • The Mandi Samiti argued that if reassessment were not allowed it could lead to evasion of fees by traders (in collusion with staff), thereby frustrating the purpose of the Adhiniyam.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Chandra Kailash Kumar v. State of U.P., 1980 Supp SCC 27 : AIR 1980 SC 1124 Market fee is a single-point levy in one market area; if paddy bought outside and rice produced is sold within the market area, market fee is payable; if both purchase and sale are outside, no fee is payable to that Mandi Samiti. The Court relied on this principle to frame the dispute and to explain when market fee becomes payable; it also referenced the Supreme Court's suggestion that statutory machinery be added to the Adhiniyam for levy/collection procedures.
Sri Mahalaxmi Sugar Works, Farid Nagar v. State of U.P., 1987 UP LB EC 957 Challenged the vires of the Explanation to section 17; the High Court did not strike it down but issued directions to mitigate hardship to traders and protect lawful fee collection. The Court noted that Mandi Samitis and traders had been following those 1987 directions; it modified and expanded those directions (e.g., timelines, gate-pass procedure, scrutiny periods and re-assessment conditions) and made them applicable statewide.
Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Calcutta Division v. National Tobacco Co. of India Ltd., (1972) 2 SCC 560 Interpretation of the word "levy" to include both imposition of tax and assessment (though "levy" does not include "collection" in that authority). The Court used this interpretation to observe that section 17(iii)(b) empowers Mandi Samitis to "levy and collect," and to highlight the need for clear procedural machinery (assessment vs. collection) given those powers.
Bharat Steel Tubes Ltd. v. State of Haryana, (1988) 3 SCC 478 Where no limitation period is prescribed under a statute, assessments should be completed expeditiously within a reasonable time determined by circumstances. The Court invoked this principle to stress that, in absence of statutory timetables, adequate procedural provisions must be provided and that assessments/re-assessments must respect reasonable time-frames; it influenced the Court's imposition of specific time limits in its directions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise manner. First, it identified the factual matrix and the limited nature of the dispute: whether rice produced from outside-purchased paddy and claimed to have been sold/despatched outside the market area was liable to market fee when the Mandi Samiti alleges no proof of such outward sale.

The Court analysed the statutory provision: section 17(iii)(b) empowers a Committee (Mandi Samiti) to "levy and collect" market fee. The Explanation to section 17 creates a presumption that any specified produce taken out of a market area is presumed sold within that area unless the contrary is proved, thereby placing an evidentiary burden on the trader.

The Court observed a significant procedural gap: neither the Adhiniyam nor the Rules contain detailed machinery for taking goods out of market areas, filing returns, conducting hearings for assessment, limitation periods for completion of assessment or re-assessment, or redressal processes. Bye-laws and required machinery had not been framed by the Mandi Samitis, the Board, or the State despite earlier judicial suggestions (including by the Supreme Court in Ram Chandra).

The Court reviewed past remedial directions (Sri Mahalaxmi Sugar Works) under which traders and Mandi Samitis had been operating. It noted that many petitioners had filed proforma statements (some voluntarily, some after notices) detailing purchases, production, levy rice and released rice, and despatches. Initial assessment orders (and fee payments) were made referencing those returns.

The Court then confronted the central contention about reassessment. Petitioners argued that once an assessment had been made and fee paid, the Mandi Samiti had no authority to reassess in absence of any statutory provision allowing re-assessment. The Mandi Samiti contended that additional fees were imposed subsequently to account for rice sold outside the market area (i.e., that the initial assessment did not cover everything).

The Court accepted the petitioners' position that, because the returns filed by petitioners contained full details and the initial assessment order dealt with the entire assessment, the Mandi Samiti lacked power to effect a re-assessment in the absence of statutory authority for re-assessment. The Court acknowledged the Mandi Samiti's concern about potential evasion, but concluded that that concern did not justify allowing reassessment where no enabling provision exists.

Nonetheless, balancing the competing considerations (preventing harassment/evasion and ensuring lawful fee collection), the Court determined that some additional, limited procedural safeguards and timelines should be adopted statewide to fill the practical gap until statutory machinery is provided. The Court therefore modified the earlier 1987 directions and issued expanded directions including (inter alia): gate-pass entitlement on production of documents; filing of statements within twelve weeks; notice after twelve weeks to file within 10 days; scrutiny within three months and passing of appropriate orders; levy if return is incorrect or not filed; and, importantly, a limited re-assessment power where material comes into possession after assessment, exercisable within six months of the assessment order and preceded by a show-cause notice stating grounds.

Applying these principles to the petitions, the Court allowed the writ petitions in part: it quashed the alleged re-assessments and the demand notices in respect of the assessment years 1988-89 to 1991-92, and issued the modified directions to be followed by all Mandi Samitis in the State.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions are allowed in part. The Court quashed the re-assessments and the demand notices insofar as they relate to the years 1988-89 to 1991-92, and issued modified procedural directions for all Mandi Samitis in the State.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The specific reassessments and demand notices for the years 1988-89 to 1991-92 (challenged in these petitions) are quashed.
  • The Court prescribed statewide procedural directions to regulate gate-passes, time-limits for filing statements (twelve weeks), notices after expiry (10 days), scrutiny timelines (three months), consequences for incorrect or non-filed returns, and a constrained right of re-assessment (within six months and on specified grounds with a show-cause notice).
  • The Court emphasized the absence of full statutory machinery in the Adhiniyam and urged that the State Government should provide appropriate machinery; it also recommended delegation of adjudicatory powers by the Board to deal with practical difficulties.
  • The Court made no order as to costs.

Note: The Court fashioned interim procedural rules to bridge statutory lacunae until the legislature or relevant authorities provide full machinery. These directions alter how Mandi Samitis must operate in practice but arose from the Court's equitable exercise of powers in the absence of explicit statutory procedures.

    Ram Karaa v. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti, Saharanpur Through Its Secretary Respondeat.

    A.N Gupta, J.:— Since common questions are involved for decision in this bunch of 12 writ petitions, they are being disposed of by one judgment.

    2. The petitioners in all these writ petitions are rice millers of Saharanpur in the State of Uttar Pradesh and the sole opposite party is Krisbi Utpadan Mandi Samiti, Saharanpur (hereinafter referred to as Mandi Samiti). These rice millers purchase paddy from inside as well as outside the market area of the Mandi Samiti after paying market fee. Rice is produced by the petitioners out of the paddy so purchased. Sixty per cent of the rice so produced is given by the petitioners to the State Govt, as levy in accordance with the provisions of U.P Rice & Paddy (Levy & Regulations of Trade) Order, 1985 and the remaining 40%, retained by them called the released share is sold by the petitioners in the open market. In accordance with the decision given by the Supreme Court in the case of Ram Chandra Kailash Kumar v. State of U.P, 1980 Supp SCC 27 : AIR 1980 SC 1124 maket fee is not payable by the petitioners on the said rice sold by them in the market area of the Mandi Samiti as it was held in that case that the market fee is a single point levy in one market area. In the said case it has further been held that in case paddy is purchased from outside the market area and if the rice produced out of it is sold within the market area of the Mandi Samiti, the traders shall be liable to pay the market fee to the Mandi Samiti It is not disputed that in case the paddy is purchased from outside the market area and the rice produced out of it is also sold or sent outside the market area of the Mandi Samiti, no market fee would be payable to it. The dispute in these petitions is confined to that part of the rice which was produced out of the paddy purchased by the petitioners from outside the maket area of the Mandi Samiti and its sale or despatch, according to the petitioners, was made outside the market area of the Mandi Samiti. The contention of the petitioners is that out of the paddy purchased by them from outside the market area of the Mandi Samiti, they produced rice some of which was seat or sold by them outside market area of the Mandi Samiti and, therefore, no market fee is payable by them to it on the said despatches/sales. On the other hand, the contention of the Mandi Samiti is that since the petitioners failed to furnish the proof of despatch or sale of rice outside its market area, it shall be presumed that they sold the said rice within its market area according to the provisions contained in Explanation to section 17 of the Uttar Pradesh Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam; 1964 (hereinafter called the ‘Adhiniyam) which may be extracted here:—

    “Explanation—For the purpose of clause (iii), unless the contrary is proved, any specified agricultural produce taken out or proposed to be taken out of a market area by or on behalf of a licenced trader shall be presumed to have been sold within such area and in such case, the, price of such produce presumed to be sold shall be deemed to be such reasonable price as may be ascertained in the manner prescribed.”

    3. This explanation lays down a presumption that unless the contrary Is proved, any specified agricultural produce (rice is also one of the specified agricultural produce) taken out of the market area shall be presumed to have been sold within such area. The vires of this explanation was challenged through a writ petition in this Court in the case of Sri Mahalaxmi Sugar Works, Farid Nagar v. State of U.P, 1987 UP LB EC 957 but this Court did not declare the said explanation as ultra vires but instead of doing so issued following directions in order to mitigate the hardship caused to the traders and to safeguard payment of market fee to Mandi Samiti in accordance with law.

    “(1) Every trader proposing to take out the goods manufactured or produced in the market area shall be entitled to issue of gate passes from the Mandi Samiti if he produces documents to establish that the goods were being taken out of the market area. Necessary entries shall be made by Mandi Samiti in records maintained by it;

    (2) A trader taking out goods shall file a statement before the Mandi Samiti within six weeks indicating therein that the goods were sold by the Commission agent or by the petitioners themselves inside or outside the market area;

    (3) In case the traders do not file the statement the Mandi shall issue notice to the traders after expiry of six weeks to file the statement within 10 days of receipt of notice;

    (4) If the return is filed the same shall be scrutinised by the Mandi Samiti and if it is satisfied about its correctness, then it shall pass appropriate orders levying fee. If the sale has been made in the market area and exempting in case, it has been made outside the market, area;

    (5) In case the return of trader is found to be incorrect or he omits to file his return despite notice by Mandi Samiti then the Mandi Samiti shall levy market fee on trader on the goods which had been taken out and for which gate pass had been issued.”

    4. It is common case of the parties that ever since the aforesaid directions were given by this Court, the traders as well as all the Mandi Samiti in the State have been acting in accordance with the said directions. In accordance with the aforesaid direction No. (2) some of the petitioners in respect of the years 1988-89 to 1991-92 furnished statements to the Mandi Samiti on the proforma prescribed by it. In the said statement quality and quantity of paddy purchased from outside and inside the market area of the Mandi Samiti, quantity of rice produced out of it, quantity of rice given in levy, quantity of released rice left with the petitioners, quantity of rice sold inside the market area of the Samiti and quantity of rice despatched outside the market area of the Maadi Samiti were given. Some of the petitioners, who did not voluntarily furnish the said satecnents, furnished the same on the notice given to it by the Mandi Samiti. An official of the Mand Samiti verified some of these statements. Thereafter. Secretary of the Mandi Samiti sent communication to the petitioners levying market fee. In the said communication sent in the year 1990-91 in respect of the said assessment years, it was mentioned that after mixing the paddy purchased from inside the market area with the paddy purchased from outside the market area and after giving levy rice, market fee is being levied on the local sales of the rice in accordance with the decision given by the Supreme Court/High Court. The petitioners were called upon to deposit the market fee within three days otherwise a threat was given to realise the same as arrears of land revenue under section 20 of the Adhiniyam. The petitioners paid the said market fee. However, after change of the Secretary communications in January and February, 1993 were seat to the petitioners by the new Secretary of the Samiti alleging that the petitioners after mixing the paddy purchased inside the market area with the paddy purchased outside the market area and after giving levy rice to the Govt, the petitioners ‘possibly’ would have sold the released rice but market fee has not been paid by them on the sale of such vice. The petitioners were called upon to furnish the statements in the prescribed proforma for the years 1988-89 to 1991-92 within ten days. These communications were duly replied to on behalf of the petitioners by their Association called Foodgpains Dealers' & Rice Millers Association, Saharanpur vide their letter dated 22-3-1993 contending, inter alia, that the assessment of market fee had already been made which was paid accordingly and, therefore, reassessment cannot be made. It was further mentioned that the required documents and proofs were now not available in respect of the said years and in case it was necessary, the same can be traced out if time of three months was given. At the end, a request was made for discharging the notice. Thereafter, the Secretary of the Mandi Samiti sent a communication in March, 1993 to the petitioners informing them that they failed to produce the required evidence and documents within ten days as required to prove that the sale of rice as alleged by the petitioners, was made outside the market area and, therefore, the petitioners were liable to pay the market fee as if the sales were made inside the market area and market fee was levied therein which is considerable. The petitioners were called upon to pay the market fee within three days otherwise action, according to law, including suspension of licence and realisation as arrears of land revenue shall be initiated. After receipt of the said notices the petitioners have filed these writ petitions with the prayers that the second demand notices be quashed and to declare reasessment of market fee as illegal.

    5. Before proceeding further it may be mentioned that Sub-clause (b) of Clause (iii) of Section 17 of the Adhiniyam which lays down powers of the Committee, empowers the Mandi Samiti to ‘levy and collect’ market fee which runs as follows:

    “17. Powers of the Committee—A Committee shall, for the purpose of this Act, have the power to—

    (i) .........................

    (ii) ........................

    (iii) levy and collect;

    (a) such fees as may be prescribed for the issue or renewal of licences, and

    (b) market fee, which shall be payable on transactions of sale of specified agricultural produce in the market area at such rates, being not less than one percentum and not more than (two) percentum of the price of the agricultural produce so sold, as the State Govt, may specify by notification, and such fee shall be realised in the following manner—

    (1) if the produce is sold through a commission agent, the commission agent may realise the market fee from the purchaser and shall be liable to pay the same to the Committee;

    (2) if the prodnce is purchased directly by a trader from a producer the trader shall be liable to pay the market fee to the Committee:

    (3) if the produce is purchased by a trader from another trader, the trader selling the produce may realise it from the purchaser and shall be liable to pay the market fee to the Committee; and

    (4) in any other case of sale of such produce, the purchaser shall be liable to pay the market fee to the Committee; Provided that no maket fee shall be levied or collected on the retail sale of any specified agricultural produce where such sale is made to the consumer for his domestic consumption only;..........

    6. Explanation to Section 17 has already been extracted which raises a presumption of all the sales having been made within the market area unless contrary is proved. Although sub-clause (b) to clause (iii) of Section 17 of the Adhiniyam empowers the Mandi Samiti to levy and collect market fee but no procedure for taking out the goods out of the market area for sale or otherwise, filing of return, for hearing at the time of assessment limitation for completion or assessment, power of re-assessment and the like, has been laid down either in the Adhiniyam or in the Rules framed thereunder. It appears that even bye-laws as provided under section 39 of the Adhiniyam, have neither been framed by Mandi Samiti nor by the State Agricultural Produce Markets Boards constituted under section 26-A of the Adhiniyam (hereinafter called the ‘Board’) which is apex body of the entire set up. This Is despite the fact that the Supreme Court as early as in the year 1980 in the case of Ram Chandra Kailash Kumar (Supra) had drawn attention of the State Government to this aspect of the matter and suggested incorporation of machinery provisions in the Adhiniyam. When, inspite of the said observations of the Supreme Court, the State Government took no steps to this behalf, this Court was compelled to Issue directions in the year 1987 in the case of Shri Mahalakshmi Sugar Works (Supra). Inspite of sereral amendments having been incorporated in the meantime in the Adhiniyam no provisions as indicated above have been enacted. Had this been done, there would have been no need to file these writ petitions and the traders would have been spared of undue harassment oaused to them thereby. It is high time that the State Govt, takes appropriate steps to provide full machinery for levy and collection of fees under the Adhiniyam.

    7. It is significant that under section 17(iii)(a) of the Adhiniyam every Mandi Samiti has been empowered to levy and collect' fees. The Supreme Court in the case of Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Calcutta Division v. National Tobacco Company of India Limited, (1972) 2 SCC 560, has interpreted the word levy to Include both Imposition of tax as well as Assessment. According to the said decision the word levy does not include Collection but, as observed above, Mandi Samitis have been empowered under section 17(iii)(a) to collect fees also. Similarly, the Supreme Court in the case of Bharat Steel Tubes Limited v. State of Haryana, (1988) 3 SCC 478, has laid down that where no period of limitation is prescribed under the Statute, assessment should be completed expeditiously within a reasonable time which would depend upon the circumstances of each case. In these circumstances, it is imperative that adequate provisions should be made in this behalf for hearing and redressal of the grievances etc. of the persons who are required to pay the fees.

    8. It Is no doubt true that under section 32 of the Adhiniyam the Board has been vested with the powers of revision so as to satisfy itself as to the legality and propriety of any decision or order passed by the Mandi Samiti but this provision in isolation is insufficient. Undoubtedly, there is a provision of appeal before the Board under section 25 of the Adhiniyam but this power of appeal relates to section 17(ii) and not to section 17(iii) which empower the Mandi Samiti to levy and collect fees and therefore, power of appeal under section 25 is not available to the traders on whom fees is imposed. The Board consists of 16 persons but it may delegate its powers to any sub-committee appointed by it or to the Director or to the Member-Secretary of any other officer of the Board. Similarly, under section 33 of the Adhiniyam, the Board may delegate any of its powers subject to such conditions and restrictions and in such manner as may be specified therein, by regulations to the Director. Till the full machinery provisions are provided by the State Government, the Board will be well advised to delegate its powers for adjudication of disputes arising out of levy and collection of fees as provided under section 26-1 or section 33 of the Adhiniyam.

    9. The Mandi Samitl also consists of several persons and it is not possible for it to assemble, hear the traders regarding levy and collection of fees and pass orders thereon. Under section 17(vii) a Mandi Samitl is empowered to appoint sub-committees, each consisting of two or more of its members, for exercising such powers, performing such duties and discharging such functions as may be assigned to them by it. It may also require Secretary to perform its functions regarding levy and collection of fees. Under Rule 56 there is a provision of constitution of only one sub-committee called ‘Disputes Sub-committee’ but it does not pertain to the disputes arising out of levy and collection of Mandi fees. The only provisions regarding levy add collection of fees are contained in Rules 56 and 58 which lay down no detailed procedure and are totally insufficient for the purpose. In these circumstances the Mandi Samiti may act as mentioned above in order to mitigate the hard-ship caused to the traders and in order to have better collection of fees.

    10. It was argued by learned counsel for the petitioners that once the Mandi Samiti had made assessment it was not open to it to make re-assessment of the fees in the absence of any provision in the Adhiniyam for re-assessment. On the other hand, it was urged by learned counsel for the Mandl Samiti that what was done initially, was assessment of fees in respect of the rice sold within the market area of the Samiti and subsequently, fees was imposed in respect of the rice which was sold by petitioners outside the market area. We ate not impressed with the argument of the learned counsel for the Mandi Samiti because in the returns (statements) filed by the petitioners they had given full details of the entire purchases of paddy made by them from inside and/or outside the market area and the sale or despatch by them of the rice manufactured out of it. In fact, the assessment order passed vby the then Secretary of the Mandi Samitl also clearly speaks of the entire assessment. Since there is no provision for re-assessment and as the Mandi Samiti is not empowered to do so under the provisions of the Adhiniyam, it cannot be permitted to make re-assessment. It was pointed out by the learned counsel for the Mandi Samiti that if this view is taken by this Court, the traders in connivance with the staff of the Mandi Samiti may evade payment of fees and thereby the very purpose of the Adhiniyam shall be frustrated. On the other hand, learned counsel for the petitioners urged that with the experience gained and considering the change of times, some amendments are required in the directions issued by this Court in 1987 in the case of Shri Mahalakshmi Sugar Works (Supra). We have given our anxious consideration to these matters. We find that the State Government has failed to provide full machinery provisions in the Adhiniyam inspite of the observations made by the Supreme Court in the case of Ram Chandra Kailash Kumar (supra) and by this Court in the case of Shri Mahalakshmi Sugar Works (supra). We are also conscious of the faet that unscrupulous persons should not be permitted to get away from the liability of the fees if it is due. In these circumstances, while allowing these writ petitions in so far as they relate to re-assessment of the market fees in respect of the years 1988-89 to 1991-92, and quash the assessments and the demand notices issued in that behalf, modify the directions given by this Court in the case of Shri Mahalakshmi Sugar Works and issue additional directions which shall be applicable to all the Mandi Samitis situated in the State which cumulatively would read as follows:—

    (1) Every trader proposing to take out the goods manufactured or produced in the market area shall be entitled to issue of gate passes from the Mandi Samiti if he produces documents to establish that the goods were being taken out of the market area. Necessary entries shall be made by Mandi Samiti in records maintained by it;

    (2) A trader taking out goods shall file a statement before the Mandi Samiti within twelve weeks Indicating therein that the goods were sold by the Commission agent or by the petitioners themselves inside or outside the market area;

    (3) In case the traders do not file the statement, the Mandi Samiti shall issue notice to the traders after expiry of twelve weeks to file the statement within 10 days of receipt of notice;

    (4) If the return is filed, the same shall be scrutinised by the Mandi Samiti within 3 months of its filing and if it is satisfied about its correctness, then it shall pass appropriate orders levying fee. If the sale has been made in the market area and exempting in case, it has been made outside the market area;

    (5) In case the return of trader is found to be incorrect or he omits to file his return despite notice by Mandi Samiti then the Mandi Samiti shall levy market fee on trader on the goods which had been taken out and for which gate-pass had been issued;

    (6) A Mandi Samiti shall have a right to make re-assessment in case some material comes into its possession after assessment within six months of passing of the order of assessment for which it shall issue a show cause notice mentioning the grounds therein on the basis of which re-assessment is proposed to be made.

    11. The writ petitions are allowed in part with the directions given hereinabove. In the circumstances of the case, we make no orders as to costs.

    12. Petitions allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Karaa v. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti, Saharanpur Through Its Secretary Respondeat.
    (May 5, 1994)