(Delivered by Venkataramana Rao, J.)
This is a Civil Miscellaneous Appeal against the order of the learned Subordinate Judge of Tiruvarur setting aside a sale of certain immoveable properties in execution of a decree in O.S No. 26 of 1931. The main ground on which the learned Judge set aside the sale was that the upset prices as shown in the sale proclamation were grossly low and the prices realised were far below their actual market value and that the judgment-debtor had suffered substantial injury by reason of this gross under-valuation. It will be seen that the upset prices fixed in the sale proclamation and the prices realised in pursuance of the same are exactly one-fourth of the prices which were given by the decree-holder himself. Any likely bidder who looks at the sale proclamation would consider that having regard to the smallness of the value fixed for the several items of property, they are really of very inferior quality and not worth going in for at high prices. The learned Judge therefore was certainly right in coming to the conclusion he did. We therefore see no reason to differ from his finding in regard thereto. We must point out that the obligation of settling a proper sale proclamation really rests on the Court. It is incumbent on the Court to see that all the particulars required under O. 21, R. 66, are given properly so that an intending bidder may know exactly what he is going in for. We find in this case that almost all the lots which are sought to be sold comprise large extents of property ranging from 27 to 34 acres and each of the lots comprises several survey fields with varying amounts of kist. It is very undesirable, especially in a district like Tanjore where it is well known that considerable financial depression is prevailing, that properties should be sold in such large lots. It is the duty of the Court to group the lands in small and convenient plots and offer them for sale so that it may be possible for men of ordinary means, especially the ryots in the locality, to purchase them at a fair value. If large extents are sold, it may not be possible at all to find a capitalist with the money which is required to fetch a fair value for the said property. We therefore direct the learned Subordinate Judge to group the fields into small and convenient plots after giving notice to the decree-holder and judgment-debtor and settle the sale proclamation with proper upset prices and have the properties sold.
In the result, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
N.R.R