AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • Section 169, Bengal Tenancy Act,
  • Section 65, Bengal Tenancy Act.
  • Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C.,
  • 8, Bengal Tenancy Act,
  • Section 47, Civil P.C.
  • Section 73, T. P. Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • Section 169, Bengal Tenancy Act,
  • Section 65, Bengal Tenancy Act.
  • Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C.,
  • 8, Bengal Tenancy Act,
  • Section 47, Civil P.C.
  • Section 73, T. P. Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a landlord, had obtained a decree for rent in Rent Suit No. 2 of 1924 in respect of a sepatni tenure. The tenure was sold and realised Rs. 7,005. After deducting the plaintiff's claim under the decree, approximately Rs. 5,267 remained as surplus sale-proceeds in favour of the defendant. The tenure was sold on 15 August 1927 and the sale confirmed on 17 September 1927.

Prior to the sale the appellant instituted another rent suit (Suit No. 12 of 1927) for rent due from May 1925 to May 1927 for Rs. 3,900. That suit (No. 12 of 1927) was decreed after confirmation of the sale (17 September 1927), and the appellant attached the sale-proceeds deposited in Court in execution of that later decree.

The respondent, who held a prior mortgage from the tenant, brought a suit on the mortgage obtaining a preliminary decree in September 1927 and a final decree in November 1927. On 15 November 1927 the respondent, in execution of his mortgage decree, attached Rs. 5,093 of the sum deposited in Court as surplus sale-proceeds. It is noted that for rent from January 1924 to May 1925 the appellant was paid a certain amount out of the sale proceeds under Section 169, Bengal Tenancy Act.

Both parties applied to the executing Court for payment of the surplus sale-proceeds. The Subordinate Judge of Birbhum held that the respondent (the mortgagee decree-holder) had the right to the surplus sale-proceeds in preference to the appellant. The appellant appealed against that order. The respondent raised a preliminary objection that no appeal lies from the order, asserting it was made under Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C.; the appellant contended the order was under Section 47, Civil P.C., and therefore appealable.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order appealed from was one under Section 47, Civil P.C., and therefore open to appeal (i.e., whether the respondent was a "representative" within the meaning of Section 47).
  2. Whether a decree for rent obtained after the sale of the tenure can create a charge on the tenure or on the surplus sale-proceeds representing the tenure (i.e., whether such a decree is a decree under Chapter 8 / Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that his decree for rent conferred preference over the respondent's claim because it was a rent decree.
  • The appellant argued that the respondent was a "representative" of the judgment-debtor within the meaning of Section 47, Civil P.C., and therefore the matter was governed by Section 47, making the order appealable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent claimed that the surplus sale-proceeds should be paid to him under Section 73, Transfer of Property Act (T. P. Act).
  • The respondent raised a preliminary objection that the order of the Subordinate Judge was made under Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C., from which no appeal lies, and therefore the appeal was incompetent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ishan Chandra Sirkar v. Beni Madhab Sirkar [1897] 24 Cal 62 Judicial interpretation of "representative" in Section 47 to include not only legal heirs but also a representative-in-interest such as a purchaser of the judgment-debtor's interest who is bound by the decree. Used to explain scope of "representative" under Section 47 and to consider whether the respondent could be treated as bound by the appellant's decree.
W. Sheriff v. Dina, Nath Mukherjee [1886] 12 Cal. 258 Earlier view that lessee, purchaser, mortgagee or transferee might be a "representative" of the judgment-debtor within Section 47. Recounted as representing a long-prevailing view on who qualifies as a representative; contrasted with the broader definition in Ishan Chandra Sirkar.
Surendra Narain Singh v. Gopi Sundari Dasi [1905] 32 Cal. 1031 Support for the wider meaning of "representative" that includes persons who may in fact or by operation of law be bound by the decree though their interest accrued prior to the decree. Referred to for the proposition that the definition of "representative" can include persons bound by decree even if their interest pre-dated the decree.
Basanta Kumar Bose v. Khulna Loan Company [1915] 26 I.C. 197 Held that where a landlord obtained a decree for rent before sale of a patni, the landlord's claim attached to the tenure and became a first charge under Section 65, Bengal Tenancy Act (with reference to special Patni Regulation provisions). Cited as authority for the proposition that a decree obtained before sale could transfer the statutory charge to the surplus sale-proceeds; the court noted the emphasis in that case on the fact that the decree was obtained before the sale but did not adopt this view for present facts.
Sattya Shanhar Ghosal v. Monmohan Guha [1918] 43 I.C. 996 Followed Basanta Kumar Bose on the point concerning pre-sale decrees and the landlord's charge under the regulation/Act. Referenced as a subsequent case following Basanta Kumar Bose; indicates existence of judicial support for the pre-sale-decree rule, but the present court did not adopt Basanta Kumar Bose's view for the facts before it.
Gour Mazumdar v. Hemanta Kumari Debya [1856] 12 Cal. 5970 Authority for the proposition that the purchaser at an auction sale purchases free from liability for rent for previous years. Relied upon to support the statement that a purchaser at the previous auction sale took the tenure free from liability for past rent and that the tenure could not be sold again in execution of the later decree.
Mathura Mohan Saha v. Nalin Chandra Dutt [1916] 34 I.C. 180 Also supports the proposition that a purchaser at a prior auction takes the property free of liability for previous years' rent. Relied upon alongside Gour Mazumdar to show that the earlier purchaser was not liable for past rent and that the later rent decree could not effect a sale of the same tenure.
A. H. Forbes v. Mahraj Bahadur Singh A.I.R. 1914 P.C. 111 Considered what kind of decree is a decree under Chapter 8 (Section 65) of the Bengal Tenancy Act; held that where the landlord had lost his interest before bringing suit and obtaining decree, that decree did not create a first charge under Section 65. Used to explain and support the principle that a decree obtained when the landlord-tenant relationship had ceased (or landlord had lost interest) cannot be treated as creating the statutory first charge on the tenure or sale-proceeds; the court applied this reasoning to conclude the appellant's post-sale decree was not a Chapter 8 decree.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the threshold procedural question: whether the impugned order was one made under Section 47, Civil P.C., which would make it appealable, or under Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C., from which no appeal lies. Central to that question was whether the respondent could be regarded as a "representative" of the judgment-debtor within the meaning of Section 47.

The court reviewed authorities on the meaning of "representative." It explained that Ishan Chandra Sirkar v. Beni Madhab Sirkar expanded the term to include not only legal representatives (heirs, executors, administrators) but also representatives-in-interest such as purchasers of the judgment-debtor's interest who are bound by the decree. Earlier authorities (for example W. Sheriff v. Dina, Nath Mukherjee) had taken a view that lessees, purchasers, mortgagees or transferees could be "representatives," but the Pull Bench (Ishan) decision gave a wider and more nuanced meaning. The court also cited Surendra Narain Singh as supporting the inclusion of persons bound by the decree even if their interest accrued earlier.

The court then turned to the decisive factual distinction in the present case: the appellant's rent decree (the one under which he sought payment from the surplus) was obtained after the tenure had already been sold and the previous sale had been confirmed. The court observed that a tenure sold in execution of an earlier decree could not be sold again in execution of a later decree, and that the earlier purchaser took the tenure free from liability for rent for previous years (citing Gour Mazumdar and Mathura Mohan Saha).

The court emphasized that a decree obtained after the sale could operate as a charge on the tenure or its sale-proceeds only if it was a decree under Chapter 8 (Section 65) of the Bengal Tenancy Act. It considered the authorities on what constitutes a Chapter 8 decree. Basanta Kumar Bose (and its follow-up in Sattya Shanhar Ghosal) had held that a landlord's decree obtained before sale attached as a first charge under Section 65; those decisions stressed the importance of the decree having been obtained before sale. But the court did not adopt Basanta Kumar Bose's approach for the present facts and expressly reserved its opinion on that case.

The court relied especially on Forbes (A. H. Forbes v. Mahraj Bahadur Singh), where the Judicial Committee held that a decree obtained after the landlord had lost his interest did not create a first charge under Section 65. The Judicial Committee's observation (quoted by the court) identified the governing idea of Chapter 8 as the subsistence of the landlord-tenant relationship that gives rise to those rights and obligations.

Applying that principle, the court found that on the date the appellant obtained his rent decree the landlord-tenant relationship had ceased (because the tenure had already been sold). The court concluded that the appellant's post-sale decree was not a decree under Chapter 8 / Section 65 and did not create a statutory charge on the tenure or on the surplus sale-proceeds representing the tenure. Consequently, the respondent was not a person bound by the decree and therefore was not a "representative" within the meaning of Section 47, Civil P.C.

Because the order of the Subordinate Judge could only have been made under Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C., and there is no appeal from an order under that provision, the appeal was held to be incompetent.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal was dismissed as incompetent because the order appealed from was an order under Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C., and not an order under Section 47, Civil P.C.; accordingly no appeal lay.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The appellant's appeal was dismissed with costs of four gold mohurs.
  • The court affirmed that the respondent (mortgagee decree-holder) had the right to the surplus sale-proceeds in preference to the appellant insofar as the Subordinate Judge's order was concerned and the appeal was not maintainable.
  • The court expressly stated that this order would not in any way affect any rights the appellant might have under Section 169, Bengal Tenancy Act, or any other provision of law.

Broader implication: The decision rests on the principle that the statutory first charge under Chapter 8 / Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act requires the subsistence of the landlord-tenant relationship at the time the decree is obtained; a decree obtained after the relationship has ceased will not be treated as creating that statutory charge. The court did not purport to overrule earlier decisions but declined to adopt Basanta Kumar Bose for the present facts and reserved opinion on that case.

    The Official Trustee Of Bengal v. Purna Chandra Roy And Anr.

    1. This is an appeal by the decree-holder in a rent execution case against an order of the Subordinate Judge of Birbhum passed under the following circumstances : The appellant obtained a decree for rent in Rent Suit No. 2 of 1924 in respect of a sepatni tenure of which he was the landlord. The tenure was sold and a sum of Rs. 7,005 realized. Deducting the plaintiff's claim under the decree, a sum of Rs. 5,267 odd was left outstanding as surplus sale-proceeds in favour of the defendant. The tenure was sold on 15th August 1927 and the sale was confirmed on 17th September 1927. Before the sale of the tenure the plaintiff had instituted another rent suit being Suit No. 12 of 1927 for rent due from May 1925 to May 1927 for Rs. 3,900. The Suit No. 12 of 1927 was decreed after the confirmation of the sale on 17th September 1927 and the appellant attached the sale-proceeds deposited in Court in execution of that decree. In the meantime . the respondent who held a previous mortgage of the tenure from the tenant brought a suit upon the mortgage and obtained a preliminary decree in September 1927 and the final decree in November 1927. On 15th November 1927 the respondent in execution of his mortgage decree attached the sum of Rs. 5,093 out of the sum in deposit in Court as surplus sale proceeds. It should be noted here that for the rent for the period from January 1924 to May 1925 the appellant was paid a certain amount out of the sale proceeds under Section 169, Ben. Ten. Act.

    2. Both parties having applied to the executing Court for payment of the surplus sale-proceeds the question that arose between the parties was as to which of them had the claim to the amount. The appellant claimed to have preference over the claim of the respondent on the ground that his decree was a rent decree. The respondent on the other hand claimed that the surplus sale proceeds should be paid to him under Section 73, T. P. Act. The learned Subordinate. Judge examined the claim of both the parties and held that the respondent, mortgagee decree-holder, had the right to the surplus sale proceeds in preference to the appellant. From this order this appeal has been preferred. A preliminary objection has been taken on behalf of the respondent that no appeal lies in this case the order passed by the lower Court being one under Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C. The appellant on the other hand contends that the question decided by the Court below was one under Section 47, Civil P.C., and as such is appealable.

    3. The question therefore that falls for determination is whether the order appealed from is one under Section 47 and as such open to appeal. Section 47 contemplates questions arising between parties to the suit or their representatives; and it has been argued on behalf of the appellant that the respondent in this case is a representative of the judgment debtor in his rent decree. Now the expression "representative" in the section has not been defined in the Code, but it has been judicially interpreted in the Pull Bench case of Ishan Chandra Sirkar v. Beni Madhab Sirkar [1897] 24 Cal 62 where it has been defined as meaning not only the judgment-debtor's legal representative that is his heir, executor or administrator but it also means his representative-in-interest and includes the purchaser of his interest who so far as such interest is concerned is bound by the decree. The question as to when a party may be said to be bound by a decree has been decided in a number of cases. The view that prevailed for a long time was as expressed in W. Sheriff v. Dina, Nath Mukherjee [1886] 12 Cal. 258 that a lessee, purchaser mortgagee or transferee since the decree is a representative of the judgment-debtor within the meaning of Section 47. But the Pull Bench case of Ishan Chandra Sircar v. Beni Madhab Sirkar [1897] 24 Cal 62 has given it a wider meaning as including a person who may by operation of law or in fact be bound by the decree though his interest had accrued previous to the decree : see the case of Surendra Narain Singh v. Gopi Sundari Dasi [1905] 32 Cal. 1031.

    4. In the present case the fact which has to be borne in mind is that the decree for rent obtained by the appellant, in execution of which he has attached the surplus sale-proceeds was obtained after the sale of the tenure. There is no direct authority on the point as to whether the holder of a decree for rent after the sale of the tenure in execution of another decree for rent is a person who ... can claim a first charge upon the, surplus sale proceeds. But there is authority for holding that if a decree for rent was obtained before the tenure was sold in execution of another rent decree the charge created by law on the holding would be transferred to the surplus sale proceeds. The point was elaborately considered in Basanta Kumar Bose v. Khulna Loan Company[1915] 26 I.C. 197. That was the case of the sale of a patni and the question had to be considered with reference to the special provisions of the Patni Regulation. The landlord there had obtained a decree for rent before the sale of the patni by the Collector and it was held that the decree having been obtained before the sale, the landlords' claim for rent must be taken to attach to the tenure and became a first charge under Section 65, Bengal Tenancy Act. In the judgment it appears that a great point was made of the fact that the decree was obtained before the sale of the tenure. This was followed by Nalini Ranjah Chatterjee, J., in Sattya Shanhar Ghosal v. Monmohan Guha [1918] 43 I.C. 996. The other learned Judge (Smither, J.), who was a member of the Bench was of opinion that on a proper construction of section 17 of the regulation the landlord's, claim for rent though he had obtained a. decree therefor before the sale of the patni was a mere personal claim against the outgoing tenant.

    5. It is not necessary for our present, purpose in this case to adopt the view of the law laid down in Basant Kumar's case [1915] 26 I.C. 197 though personally I am not satisfied with it and must reserve my opinion for further consideration. In this case the decree was obtained after the sale of the tenures. It cannot be disputed that in execution of this decree the tenure cannot be sold again and the purchaser at the previous auction sale purchased it free from the liability for rent for previous years: pran Gour Mazumdar v. Hemanta Kumari Debya [1856] 12 Cal. 5970, Mathura Mohan Saha v. Nalin Chandra Dutt [1916] 34 I.C. 180. The decree for rent obtained by the landlord after the sale of the tenure in execution of another decree can only create a charge upon the holding or on the sale proceeds thereof representing the holding if it can be asserted that such a decree is a decree under Chap. 8, Bengal Tenancy Act. As to what kind of decree would be a decree under Chap. 8 and create a charge on the tenure or the sale-proceeds thereof came up for consideration before the Judicial Committee in the casa of A. H. Forbes v. Mahraj Bahadur Singh A.I.R. 1914 P.C. 111. The facts of that case were no doubt different. There the landlord had lost his interest in the tenure before he brought a suit for rent for a portion of the period during which he was the Landlord and obtained a decree thereupon, tt was held that as the landlord had lost his interest at the time when he obtained the decree, it cannot be said to create a first charge under Section 65, Bengal Tenancy Act.

    6. But some observations which were made by the Judicial Committee in order to come to the conclusion at which they arrived, may be of some assistance in deciding the question before us. They minutely discussed the various provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act and laid down the principle underlying Section 65 of the Act and observed as follows:

    The governing idea throughout the multifarious provisions contained in Chap. 8 to regulate the respective rights and obligations of landlords and tenants is the subsistence o£ the relationship that gives rise to those rights and obligations.

    7. Applying this observation to the facts of the present case it would appear that on the date when the decree was obtained the relationship of landlord and tenant between the appellant and the outgoing tenants had ceased to exist. But it is argued that when the suit for rent was brought the rent was the first charge on the holding. On this point their Lordships made another observation, namely that the High Court whose decision they reversed were of opinion that as soon as rent falls into arrears, the tenure becomes ipso facto hypothecated so to speak for the debt. This view of the law seemed to thoir Lordships to be untenable; but fcho ground in support of this view was that Section 65 was created in favour of the landlord. It is difficult to say that as soon as rent falls into arrears or a suit for rent is brought it becomes a first charge and attaches to the holding. It is only when the time for enforcing the claim for rent comes that Section 65 becomes active and gives the landlords' claim preference over any other claim on the tenure. On a consideration of the reasoning adopted by their Lordships in Forbes case, I am of opinion that the decree obtained by the appellant in this case, after the tenure was sold was not a decree under Chap. 8, Bengal Tenancy Act, atid therefore it was not a charge on the surplus sale proceeds.

    8. Now suppose, if the appellant brought a suit for arrears of rent after the property had been sold and obtained a decree thereupon, could it be said that such a decree would be a decree under Section 65? I submit not. It makes no difference in principle whether the suit was brought before or after the sale of the tenure. The charge created by Section 65 would only attach when the landlords' claim is established under Chap. 8, Bengal Tenancy Act, i.e. when the decree was obtained during the continuance of the relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties. On all these considerations I am clearly of opinion that the decree obtained by the appellant after the sale of the tenure did not create a charge on the tenure on the sale proceeds as representing the tenure. It was obtained at the time when the relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties had ceased. The result is the same whether the landlords' interest was transferred before he obtained the decree or the defendant ceased to be the tenant before the decree was obtained. That being so, in my judgment the respondent is not a person who is bound by the decree and therefore is not a "representative" within the meaning of Section 47, Civil P.C. That being so the only provision of the law under which the order passed by the lower Court could have been made is Order 21, Rule 58, Civil P.C., and there being no appeal from that order this appeal is incompetent. It is therefore dismissed with costs four gold mohurs.

    9. It is to be clearly understood that our order will not in any way affect the appellant's right, if he has any, under Section 169, Bengal Tenancy Act, or any other provision of the law.

    Costello, J.

    10. I agree.

    (Their Lordships in view of the above order dismissed Revision 894 of 1928).

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Official Trustee Of Bengal v. Purna Chandra Roy And Anr.
    (Feb 14, 1930)