Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff instituted a suit for recovery of khas possession against multiple defendants, alleging that some defendants were tenants-at-will and that defendant 4 (the present appellant) was a subtenant under them. Prior to this suit, in 1922 the plaintiff had instituted an earlier suit against three of the present defendants and predecessors of others. In that earlier suit one group of heirs (heirs of Kissen Chand) had not been properly made parties because the person served had died before institution of the suit. On discovery of that defect the plaintiff applied to withdraw the earlier suit with liberty to institute a fresh one. In July 1923 the trial Court permitted withdrawal with liberty, on condition that the plaintiff pay costs of defendant 3 within 15 days as notified in the order sheet, failing which the suit would be considered dismissed with costs. The notified costs were Rs.16-11-6; the plaintiff deposited Rs.16-9-3 on 28 July 1923 (short by 2 annas 3 pies). Thereafter the plaintiff served fresh notices in July 1927 and instituted the present suit on 25 April 1929 claiming the same relief (recovery of khas possession).

Issue 2 in the present suit asked whether the suit was barred by res judicata arising from the previous proceedings. The Munsif dismissed the present suit on the ground that the earlier suit had effectively been dismissed without liberty (because the cost condition was not fully complied with) and therefore the present suit was not maintainable. The plaintiff appealed; the Subordinate Judge set aside the Munsif's decree, held that the previous dismissal was no bar to the present suit, and remanded the suit for trial on the merits with a direction to allow parties to adduce further evidence if requested. Defendant 4 has appealed against the Subordinate Judge's decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, construing Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule (3) of the Code (corresponding to Section 373 of the Code of 1882), the present suit is barred because the earlier suit was dismissed for non-compliance with the condition of payment of costs (i.e., whether the dismissal of the earlier suit prevents institution of the later suit in respect of the same "subject-matter").
  2. Whether the Subordinate Judge was correct in remanding the case to the trial Court with a direction that parties be given opportunity to adduce further evidence (i.e., whether the appellate Court should have disposed of the appeal on the record rather than remanding with a blanket direction permitting fresh evidence).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (defendant 4)

  • The principal contention relied on a construction of O. 23, R. 1, sub-R. (3) (and the corresponding language in S. 373 of the Code of 1882) to argue that because the earlier suit was dismissed for failure to comply with the condition for liberty (payment of costs), the present suit must be regarded as barred as being in respect of the same subject-matter.
  • As a subsidiary point the appellant challenged the Subordinate Judge's remand order and the direction that parties be allowed to adduce further evidence, contending that the appellate Court should have disposed of the appeal on the merits instead of remanding with such a direction.
  • Counsel for the appellant (Mr. Mukherjee) argued that certain precedents (from Madras and Bombay High Courts) deal with suits where the cause of action was incomplete due to defective notice, and that those cases were distinguishable where notice had been given (so that the principle should not apply where notice had been served and the sufficiency of notice had not been decided). The Court recorded this argument but found it unnecessary to decide that specific point because the facts showed the notices in the earlier suit were defective (one person served had died and heirs had not been served).

Other Parties / Respondent Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the other parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kamini Kanta v. Ram Nath, 1894 21 Cal 265 Interpreting the term "matter" (in S. 373 of 1882) to mean the right in the property which the plaintiff sought to enforce (i.e., a narrower meaning). Noted as one of the cases where the word "matter" was held to refer to the right sought to be enforced; considered in the comparative discussion of meanings but the Court aligned with the narrower construction ultimately rejected by the Court in favour of the Full Bench approach.
Gopal Chandra Banerjee v. Purna Chandra Banerjee, 1906 4 CWN 110 Similar view as Kamini Kanta: "matter" refers to the right sought to be enforced (narrow interpretation). Noted among the decisions reflecting the narrower meaning; included in the survey of conflicting authorities regarding "matter" / "subject-matter."
Achuta Menon v. Achutan Nayer, 1898 21 Mad 35 Madras High Court view that "matter" means the subject of legal action or the facts constituting whole or part of a ground of action (a broader meaning). Described as adopting a broad meaning that could bar subsequent suits even where the plaintiff acquired a new title later; this broader view was identified as having been followed by certain Madras decisions until overruled.
Machana Uajhala v. Gorugantulu Yaggamma, 1910 8 IC 1066 Followed the broader Madras approach (i.e., Achuta Menon). Cited as one of the decisions that adhered to the broader interpretation of "matter."
Sennava Reddiar v. Venkatachala Reddiar, 1915 28 IC 91 Followed the broader Madras approach. Cited as another decision following Achuta Menon (broader meaning).
Singa Reddi v. Subba Reddi, AIR 1917 Mad 512 (Full Bench) Full Bench overruling Achuta Menon: held that where cause of action and relief in the second suit are not the same as those in the first suit, the second suit is not in respect of the same "subject-matter" for the purpose of O.23, R.1, sub-R.(3). The Court accepted and applied this Full Bench view as controlling: it held that where cause of action and relief differ, the second suit is not barred as being in respect of the same subject-matter.
B. Chenchuram Naidu v. Muhamed Bahavuddin Sahib, AIR 1933 Mad 3 Held that "subject-matter" means the series of acts or transactions alleged to exist giving rise to the relief claimed (thus distinguishing incomplete and complete series of acts). Noted and its reasoning (series of acts or transactions) accepted as relevant; the Court observed the analogy with Bombay decision and applied the series-of-acts approach to conclude the suits were not of the same subject-matter where the earlier cause was incomplete.
Rakhmabai v. Mahadeo Narayan, AIR 1917 Bom 10 Bombay High Court (Scott, C.J.) explanation: "subject-matter" means the series of acts or transactions alleged to exist giving rise to the relief claimed; a completed series differs from an incomplete one (e.g., where notice to quit was then given later). Cited and quoted by the Court; applied to show that if the first suit's series of acts was incomplete (no valid notice), a later suit based on a completed series is not in respect of the same subject-matter.
Section 373 of the Code of 1882 (statutory provision) Provision corresponding to O. 23 R. 1 of the present Code; used to compare language and meaning ("matter" vs "subject-matter"). The Court compared the present rule with S. 373, noted the recasting of words, and treated the law as practically the same; used the historical interpretation to frame the question of meaning of "subject-matter."

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in the following analytical steps (as set out in the opinion):

  1. Identify the controlling statutory provision: the dispute turned on construction of Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule (3) of the Code (which corresponds to Section 373 of the Code of 1882). The Court compared the language of the current provision with S. 373 (noting that "matter" in the earlier Code is rendered as "subject-matter" in the present rule) and observed that the recasting of words was intended to secure uniformity rather than to change the law.
  2. Survey conflicting judicial interpretations of the words "matter"/"subject-matter." The Court described two opposing lines:
    • One line (e.g., Kamini Kanta; Gopal Chandra) treated "matter" as referring to the right in the property sought to be enforced (a narrower conception).
    • Another line, prominent in Madras decisions (e.g., Achuta Menon and the cases that followed), adopted a broader definition of "matter" or "subject-matter" (drawing on Anderson's Dictionary) to mean the subject of legal action or the facts constituting a ground of action; under that approach a later suit based on a subsequently acquired title might still be barred if it concerned the same property.
  3. Note the Full Bench decision (Singa Reddi v. Subba Reddi) which overruled the broader Madras approach and held that where the cause of action and the relief claimed in the second suit are not the same as in the first suit, the second suit is not brought in respect of the same subject-matter for the purpose of O.23, R.1, sub-R.(3).
  4. Consider analogous decisions from Bombay and Madras (Rakhmabai; B. Chenchuram Naidu) which stated that "subject-matter" may properly be understood as the series of acts or transactions giving rise to the relief claimed (thus distinguishing an incomplete series in the first suit from a completed series in a later suit).
  5. Apply the legal principles to the facts: here the Court concluded that although the earlier order allowing withdrawal with liberty was not fully complied with (the plaintiff's deposit was short by 2 annas 3 pies, so the earlier suit must be regarded as dismissed without liberty), the question remained whether that dismissal barred the present suit. The Court found that the notices served before the institution of the first suit were defective because one of the persons served had died and the heirs (who were named defendants) had not been served. On that factual basis the Court concluded the line of authority represented by Rakhmabai and the Full Bench in Singa Reddi applied.
  6. Reach a conclusion on the first issue: the Court held there was no room to contend that the case-law relied upon (Madras and Bombay authorities treating incomplete and complete series of acts differently) was inapplicable; accordingly the Subordinate Judge was right in holding that the present suit should not have been dismissed on the ground that the previous suit had been withdrawn without liberty being reserved.
  7. Consider the second contention concerning the remand and directions given by the Subordinate Judge: the Court held the Subordinate Judge was not correct in remanding the case to the trial Court with the blanket direction to allow parties to produce further evidence. The Court reasoned that evidence had already been adduced on all issues and there was no complaint that evidence had been excluded. Therefore the appellate Court should have dealt with the appeal on the merits on the existing record; if fresh evidence were necessary on a particular point the appellate Court could call for it in exercise of appellate powers, but there was no reason to give the case a renewed lease of life by remanding with such a direction.
  8. Result of the reasoning: the Court disagreed with the appellant on the main point (maintainability) but upheld the appellant's second contention and modified the order of the Subordinate Judge accordingly.

Holding and Implications

Holding: 1. The dismissal of the previous suit for non-payment of the full notified costs operated as a dismissal without liberty; however, the present suit is not barred by that dismissal because the causes of action/series of acts giving rise to the relief in the earlier suit were incomplete (due to defective notices) and the second suit was not in respect of the same "subject-matter" within the meaning of O.23, R.1, sub-R.(3).

2. The order of the Subordinate Judge remanding the suit to the trial Court with a direction that the parties be permitted to adduce further evidence was modified: the case is to be sent back to the Subordinate Judge who will proceed to deal with the appeal on the merits as an appellate Court would ordinarily do.

Implications / Consequences:

  • The direct effect is that the present suit is not held to be barred by the dismissal of the earlier suit; the Subordinate Judge's conclusion on that substantive point is upheld.
  • The remedial procedure imposed by the Subordinate Judge (remand with a general direction to allow fresh evidence) is disapproved and replaced by an instruction that the Subordinate Judge should decide the appeal on the merits as an appellate court, considering the evidence already on record and exercising appellate powers to call for additional evidence only if specifically necessary.
  • The Court ordered no costs in this appeal.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying and preferring the Full Bench/Bombay-Madras analyses described in the reasoning; the decision's immediate practical effect is limited to the parties and the proper disposition of the appeal in this case.

Final Disposition: Order modified; case to be dealt with on the merits by the Subordinate Judge as an appellate Court; no order for costs.

    Bhagaban Das Mahesri v. Prosanna Dev Raikot And Others

    1. This appeal has been preferred by defendant 4 in a suit which was instituted against him and some other defendants for recovery of khas possession of certain lands, it being alleged in the suit that the other defendants were tenants-at-will under the plaintiff and that defendant 4 was a subtenant under them. The order from which this appeal has been preferred is an order passed by the Subordinate Judge of Jalpaiguti by which the learned Judge, having set aside the decision of the Munsif dismissing the suit has remanded the suit for decision on the merits on the evidence in the record and on such further evidence which the parties might like to produce in the suit. The Subordinate Judge has also given a direction that if an opportunity was asked for by any of the parties to adduce any further evidence the trial Court should give him that opportunity. In order to understand the contentions which have been put forward in this appeal is necessary to set out a few facts. In 1922, the plaintiff of the present suit had instituted another suit against the present defendants or rather against three of them and the predecessors of the others. That suit was instituted on service of notice on all the defendants who were made parties to the suit, with the exception of the heirs of one Kissen Chand, who had been served with notice but had died before the suit has been instituted. On this defect being found, application was made for withdrawing the suit with liberty to institute a fresh one. This application was granted sometime in July 1923, when an order was made and permission to withdraw with liberty to instituted fresh suit was given on condition that the plaintiff would pay the costs of the defendant within 15 days from the date when such costs, would be notified in the order sheet. It was further ordered that on default of such payment the suit would be considered as dismissed with costs. On 14th July 1923, it was noted in the order sheet and notified to the parties that the costs of defendant 3 amounted to Rupees 16-11-6. On 28th July 1923, the plaintiff deposited Rs. 16-9-3; that is to say the amount deposited was short by 2 annas 3 pies. Thereafter, the plaintiff in July 1927 served fresh notices upon the defendants and on the basis of those notices instituted the present suit on 25th April 1929. The reliefs claimed in both the suits were the same, namely, the relief in the shape of recovery of khas possession. One of the grounds, taken in defence in the present suit was that by reason of the order which the Court had made in the previous suite, and which was not fully complied with as stated above, the present suit was not maintainable. This matter formed the subject of an issue, namely, issue 2 which however was worded in these words: “Is the suit barred by res judicata?” Upon the other points that were taken, several other issues were framed.

    2. The Munsif dismissed the suit holding that it failed on the ground that the condition upon which liberty was reserved to the plaintiff to institute at fresh suit after his withdrawal of the previous one not having been complied with, the previous suit must be regarded as having been dismissed without any liberty reserved and that consequently the present suit was not maintainable. The Munsif did not consider it necessary to deal with the other issues which had been framed. The plaintiff thereupon preferred an appeal. The Subordinate Judge who dealt with that appeal held; that the dismissal of the previous suit was no bar to the institution of the present one and overruling the decision of the Munsif on issue 2 as stated above, he set aside the decree which the Munsiff had made and remanded the case for trial by the Munsif with the directions to which we have already referred. From this decision, as already stated, defendant 4 has preferred the present appeal.

    3. The principal question which has been raised on behalf of the appellant in this appeal depends upon a construction of O. 23, R. 1, sub-R. 3 of the Code, and it is really upon the meaning that is to be attached to this sub-rule that we have to decide the question as to whether the present suit is barred or not. There can be no dispute that the order which was passed by the trial Court in the previous suit allowing the plaintiff to withdraw from the suit with liberty to institute a fresh one on condition that the plaintiff should pay the costs of defendant 3 within 15 days, such costs being notified in the order sheet and there having been a further order made by that Court to the effect that in case of default in the payment of such costs within the time aforesaid, the suit should be considered as dismissed, we think it must be held that upon the default which has occurred on the part of the plaintiff in not putting in the whole amount of the costs even though the amount which was deposited was short only by 2 annas and 3 pies, must operate as amounting to a dismissal of the suit without any liberty reserved. But then the other question will arise and that is this, whether by reason of the dismissal of the previous suit in the circumstances to which reference has been made, the present suit, which has been started on issuing fresh notices on the defendants and upon the cause of action which, it is said, arose on the service of such notices, should be regarded as being not maintainable by reason of the dismissal of the previous suit. In determining this question one has to consider what is the meaning of the word, “subject-matter” which is to be found in O. 23, sub-R. (3), R. 1, O. 23 of the present Code corresponds to S. 373 of the Code of 1882. S. 373 of the Code of 1882 consisted of three paragraphs. The first of those paragraphs is reproduced in the first two sub-rules of R. 1, O. 23. There is not much difference between the contents of para. 1, S. 373 and of the first two sub-rules of R. 1, O. 23 The wording has been recast, but what is to be found in the said paragraph is substantially reproduced in these two sub-rules. Para. 2, S. 373 contained these words,

    “was to be precluded from bringing a fresh suit for the same matter or in respect of the same, part.”

    4. Sub-R. 11, R. 1(3) says,

    “shall be precluded from instituting a fresh suit in respect of such subject-matter or such, part of the claim.”

    5. So, the material difference between the two provisions of the law consists in this that whereas in para. 2, S. 373 the word “matter” was used in sub-R. (3), R. 1 we find the expression “subject-matter.” Now, it has been held in a number of cases to which specific reference need not be made that this alteration has been made only with the object of securing uniformity of expression, for, in S. 373 in para. 1 the word ‘subject-matter” was used and in the other the word “matter” was used. The law, therefore, practically remains the same now as it was under the Code of 1882. Now, S. 373 of the Code of 1882 was interpreted in two different phases by the Courts. In the cases of Kamini Kanta v. Ram Nath . 1894 21 Cal 265. and Gopal Chandra Banerjee v. Purna Chandra Banerjee . 1906 4 CWN 110., this Court expressed the view that the word “matter” used in S. 373 did not mean the property concerned in the suit but that it had reference to the right in that property which the plaintiff was seeking to enforce in it. A very different view was taken by the Madras High Court in the case of Achuta Menon v. Achutan Nayer . 1898 21 Mad 35., In that case, the learned Judges referring to Anderson's Dictionary of law held that the term “matter” in a context like that in S. 373 means,

    “the subject of legal action, consideration, complaint or defence or the fact or facts constituting the whole or a part of a ground of action or defence.”

    6. The logical result of accepting this definition was that even though the plaintiff's suit had been dismissed by reason of the fact that he had failed to comply with the condition under which, liberty was reserved to him for the institution of a fresh suit, a fresh suit upon a different cause of action or upon a different title subsequently acquired but for the same property would have to be held as not maintainable. Indeed, in that case, what happened was that the plaintiff had tried to eject the defendant in the earlier suit upon a title derived in the year 1980, and subsequent to the dismissal of that suit under the aforesaid circumstances he derived a fresh title in 1892, and it was held that the fresh suit in which the title subsequently acquired was litigated upon was barred by reason of the dismissal of the previous suit. This view of the Madras High Court was adhered to in several decisions of that Court amongst which reference may be made to the cases of Machana Uajhala v. Gorugantulu Yaggamma . 1910 8 IC 1066. and Sennava Reddiar v. Venkatachala Reddiar . 1915 28 IC 91.. Subsequently, however, there was a reference to a Full Bench in the year 1916, and the Full Bench in the case of Singa Reddi v. Subba Reddi . AIR 1917 Mad 512 overruled the decision in the case of Achuta Menon v. Achutan Nayer, and the other cases which had followed it and agreeing with the view taken by this Court held that,

    “without attempting an exhaustive definition of all that may be included in the term “subject-matter,” it should be held that where the cause of action and the relief claimed in the second suit are not the same as the cause of action and the relief claimed in the first suit, the second suit cannot be considered to have been brought in respect of the same subject-matter as the first suit within the meaning of O. 23, R. 1, sub-R. (3) of the CPC.”

    7. There are two other decisions, one of the Madras High Court and other of the Bombay High Court to which reference is also necessary. In the Madras High Court in the case of B. Chenchuram Naidu v. Muhamed Bahavuddin Sahib . AIR 1933 Mad 3 which was a case in which the plaintiff as landlord had instituted a suit in ejectment against a tenant but the suit was allowed to be withdrawn on the ground that there was absence of the requisite notice to quit but no liberty was reserved to the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit and thereafter the plaintiff instituted another suit after having given the necessary notice, it was held that the second suit was not a suit in respect of the same subject matter because the word “subject-matter” in O. 23, R. 1 means,

    “the series of acts or transactions alleged to exist giving rise to the relief claimed.”

    8. The learned Judges purported to follow the decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Rakhmabai v. Mahadeo Narayan . AIR 1917 Bom 10. In the case last mentioned, Scott, C.J, has explained the meaning of the word “subject matter” in these words:

    “The question is whether the previous suit was a suit for the same “subject-matter” within the meaning of O. 23, R. 1. We are of opinion that “subject-matter” means, to use the word of O. 1, R. 1, the series of acts or transactions alleged to exist giving rise to the relief claimed. Obviously, the first series of acts or transactions which formed the basis of the first suit was incomplete, or the plaintiff would have been able to prosecute his suit to decree. It was incomplete because there was no notice to quit. The second series of acts of transactions is complete because the notice to quit has been given, and therefore, the two suits are not in respect of the same “subject-matter.”

    9. It may be pointed out that the case of Rakhmabai v. Mahadeo Narayan also was a case in which the first suit was withdrawn upon the ground that the notice which had been served was defective and, therefore, the cause of action was incomplete. It has been argued by Mr. Mukherjee appearing on behalf of the appellant that these cases are distinguishable because although if a suit is instituted without service of notice upon the defendant and thereby the cause of action becomes incomplete and therefore the suit is allowed to be withdrawn, in a case where notice has been given and nothing is decided as to whether the notice is sufficient in law or not the principle laid down in the Madras and Bombay High Courts to which reference has been made should not be held to apply. It is not necessary for our present purposes to go into a discussion of this question because as a matter of fact in the present case the notices that were served before the institution of the first suit were defective fey reason of the fact that one of the persons who had been so served was dead and the suit had been instituted against his heirs who were persons on whom no notice had been served. We are of opinion, that there is no room for the contention that the decision in the last-mentioned case is not applicable to the present case. We hold, therefore, that the Subordinate Judge was right in holding that the suit should not have been dismissed for the reason that the previous suit had been withdrawn without any liberty being reserved to the plaintiff. A second contention has been put forward on behalf of the appellant and that turns upon the directions that had been given by the Subordinate Judge in the order of remand. The Subordinate Judge, as we have already stated, has sent the case back on remand to the trial Court and has given a further direction that Court should give the parties an opportunity to produce such further evidence as they might desire. We are of opinion that the learned Subordinate Judge was not right in making such an order of remand in the present case. In the first place, evidence had been adduced by the parties with regard to all the issues which had been framed and there was no complaint before the learned Judge nor is there any complaint before us to the effect that any evidence was shut out. In these circumstances, the learned Subordinate Judge instead of sending the case back to the trial Court should have dealt with and disposed of the case on the merits and upon such evidence as there was already on the record. Of course, if on a consideration of that evidence the Subordinate Judge came to the conclusion that fresh evidence on a particular point was necessary there was nothing to prevent him from calling for such evidence in the exercise of the powers which an appellate Court always has. There is no reason, however, why afresh lease of life to the case would be given by sending the case to the Munsiff and then tying up his hand with a direction that the parties will be at liberty to produce such fresh evidence. The result is that although we disagree with the appellant in his main contention which he has put forward as regards the maintainability of the present suit, we uphold his second contention and order that the order of the Subordinate Judge will be modified and that an order will be recorded that the case be sent back to the Subordinate Judge who will proceed to deal with the appeal on the merits as an appellate Court would ordinarily do. There will be no order for costs in this appeal.

    R.K

    10. Order modified.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhagaban Das Mahesri v. Prosanna Dev Raikot And Others
    (Aug 9, 1933)