Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Ram Narain Sahu v. Lachmi Prasad Sahu

    Ross, J.:— The plaintiffs are the appellants. They brought a suit against the defendant for money said to have been borrowed by the defendant's father under sarkhats. Subsequently, in 1971 Sambat, a hundi for Rs. 4,400 was executed by the defendant's father but was not paid alter the due date of payment had expired. They, therefore, sued claiming Rs. 5,016-11-6 and the defence was that the hundi was not genuine and that no money was borrowed. The learned Subordinate Judge, although holding on the merits of the case that the debt had been incurred, dismissed the suit because of the defects in the hundi itself. One of the plaintiffs supported the claim by his own evidence saying that the debt originally incurred was, sums of Rs. 1,550 and Rs. 1,500, which were borrowed under two sarkhats, Exhibits 1 and 2. These were renewed by Exhibits 3 and 4 and finally the hundi in suit acknowledged the total liability which had then amounted to Rs. 4,400. On behalf of the respondent the evidence of witnesses Nos. 3 and 4 was attacked on the ground that these witnesses were dependant upon the plaintiffs and were chance witnesses and gave no reasonable explanation of their presence at the transaction to which they deposed. The evidence of these two witnesses does not appear to be of any particular value; but, on the other hand, nothing has been said against witness No. 5 who deposed that he saw the defendant's father write the hundi with his own hand. The plaintiffs' account-books referred to this hundi transaction and the defendant has given no real rebutting evidence. His own account-books have not been produced, nor has any writing of the defendant's father been shown be throw any doubt upon the genuineness of the hundi. It must, therefore, be held on the evidence, in agreement with the learned Subordinate Judge, that the debt was incurred and that the money claimed in suit is due.

    2. The question then is, whether there is any good reason why the plaintiffs should not get a decree. The reason which has been given by the Subordinate Judge is that the hundi has not been stamped according to law. It is written on two stamp-paper? each bearing a stamp of Rs. 2-4-0 instead of on a single stamp paper of Rs. 4-8-0 and the defect is that the document is embodied on one of these papers only while the other, which is pasted on it, has no writing on its face but only an acceptance on the back. I am not prepared to differ from the view of the Subordinate Judge that an instrument executed in this way does not comply with the provisions of section 13 of the Stamp Act. The document may, therefore, not be available as a hundi, but I see no reason why it should not be used as an acknowledgment of the existing debt.

    3. It is objected that the suit is not framed in this way but is framed as a suit on the hundi, and if the hundi itself is defective the claim must fail.

    4. But the plaint does refer to the monetary transactions under the sarkhats and, fairly construed, it seems to me to be a claim for money evidenced by the hundi; whether the hundi can be referred to by the Court as a negotiable instrument or merely as an acknowledgment of an existing debt does not appear to be a matter of much material importance.

    5. The principle of the case of Sheikh Akbar v. Sheikh Khan(1) is clearly applicable to the facts of the present case, Garth, C.J, there said.:

    “When a cause of action for money is once complete in itself, whether for goods sold, or tot money lent, or for any other claim, and the debtor then gives a bill or note to the creditor for payment of the money at a lucre time, the creditor, if the bill or note is not paid at maturity, may always, as a rule, sue for the original consideration, provided that he has not endorsed or lost or parted with the till or not, under such circumstances as to mate the debtor liable upon it to some third person.”

    6. There is nothing in the present case to bring the facts within the exception here laid down and, in my opinion, the plaintiffs are entitled to succeed on the original consideration, the liability for which was acknowledged in the document described as a hundi. The result is that the appeal must be decreed with costs and the suit decreed with costs.

    7. Das, J.:— I agree.

    8. Appeal accepted.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Narain Sahu v. Lachmi Prasad Sahu
    (Jan 26, 1921)