Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 7 of Chapter III or rule 23 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules
  • provisions of Rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules,
  • provisions of rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A or the Kerala Education Rules,
  • Rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules.
  • rule 92 of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules
  • rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Service Rules
  • rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 7 of Chapter III or rule 23 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules
  • provisions of Rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules,
  • provisions of rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A or the Kerala Education Rules,
  • Rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules.
  • rule 92 of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules
  • rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Service Rules
  • rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner worked as an Arabic teacher in a school managed by the fifth respondent in two leave-vacancy spells: from 2-6-1975 to 28-8-1975 and from 21-7-1976 to 19-1-1977 while the permanent Arabic teacher Shri Abdul Rahman was on leave. The permanent teacher retired on 30-6-1983, creating a vacancy effective 1-7-1983. The petitioner made representations to the Manager and the Assistant Educational Officer asserting a preferential right of appointment under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules. Those representations were not disposed of, leading the petitioner to file O.P. No. 6593 of 1983, which resulted in a judgment directing the Assistant Educational Officer to dispose of the representation.

Meanwhile the sixth respondent was appointed by the Manager with effect from 1-7-1983. Pursuant to the court direction, the Assistant Educational Officer conducted an enquiry and by Ext. P1 (dated 6-12-1983) refused to approve the appointment of the sixth respondent on the ground that the petitioner had a claim to preference under rule 51-A. The Manager (fifth respondent) appealed to the District Educational Officer, who by Ext. P2 (dated 6-4-1984) dismissed the appeal and affirmed Ext. P1. A revision before the Director of Public Instruction was dismissed by Ext. P3 (dated 10-12-1984).

After these administrative decisions in the petitioner's favour (Exts. P1–P3), the petitioner filed the present Original Petition complaining that the Manager was not appointing her despite those orders, and sought a writ of mandamus directing the fifth respondent to appoint her as Arabic teacher in the M.M.J.B. School, Vellaloor, in compliance with rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules. The petitioner also sought directions to respondents 1–4 to take action against the Manager under rule 7 of Chapter III or rule 23 of Chapter V to compel appointment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to preference for appointment to the vacancy of Arabic teacher under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules.
  2. Whether the petitioner forfeited or relinquished her preferential claim by written letters allegedly given to the Manager in 1975 and 1976.
  3. Whether the petitioner’s continued service in another school since 19-1-1977 operates to extinguish her preference under rule 51-A.
  4. Whether the Manager could treat the claim as forfeited without following the procedure prescribed in Note (2) to rule 51-A (i.e., sending appointment order by registered post with acknowledgement due and subsequent notices).
  5. Whether the Manager is obliged to appoint the petitioner despite a revision said to have been filed under rule 92 of Chapter XIV-A and whether any interim order had been obtained to bar such appointment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner relied upon the provisions of rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules asserting a preferential right to appointment to the vacancy arising on 1-7-1983.
  • Counsel for the petitioner referred to the rule's conditions and (as recorded) to an ILR decision cited in the opinion; the petitioner's broader position was that she had a subsisting preferential claim which had been upheld by Exts. P1–P3 and which the Manager was not giving effect to.

Fifth Respondent (Manager)'s Arguments

  • The Manager disputed the petitioner's claim to preference on two principal grounds: (a) that the petitioner had been working in another school since 19-1-1977 (implying loss of preference if appointed in a permanent vacancy elsewhere), and (b) that the petitioner had abandoned her claim to future vacancies by letters of relinquishment dated 26-6-1975 and 21-7-1976 allegedly signed by the petitioner.
  • The Manager further asserted that a revision under rule 92 of Chapter XIV-A had been filed against Ext. P3 on 12-3-1985 and contended he was not obliged to appoint the petitioner until that revision was disposed of by the Government.
  • The Manager relied on earlier judicial authority cited in the opinion to support the contention that relinquishment or abandonment may exclude consideration for future vacancies (as argued by his counsel).
  • The Manager also argued that the vacancy arose several years after the petitioner was relieved from the school (a gap of six years), and that this affected the vigor of the petitioner's claim.

Respondents 1–4 / Government Pleader (as recorded)

  • The Government Pleader stated that in the revision filed by the Manager the only ground taken before the Government was that the petitioner had been appointed against a leave vacancy (not a permanent vacancy).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
ILR. 1972 (1) Kerala 266 Stated that on relinquishment of the claim against the next vacancy, a teacher entitled to preference under rule 51-A need not be considered for vacancies arising thereafter. The decision was referred to in the course of submissions (support was sought to be drawn from it). The court did not rest its decision on this precedent to deny the petitioner's claim; instead the court assessed whether the facts showed the petitioner had in fact lost preference, finding no specific and positive averment that she had been appointed to a permanent vacancy elsewhere.
ILR. 1972 (2) Kerala 266 Was relied upon by counsel for the fifth respondent to support a contention of forfeiture of preferential claims under rule 51-A as it then stood. The court observed that the law has since been changed by the incorporation of Notes 1 and 2 to rule 51-A (notifications dated 18-7-1972 and 26-4-1977). Consequently the court held that the earlier decision could not be applied so as to justify treating the petitioner’s claim as forfeited where the procedural safeguards in Note (2) had not been followed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed, in turn, the contentions raised by the Manager and other respondents, anchoring its analysis in the statutory rule (rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A) and the administrative orders Exts. P1–P3:

  1. On the contention that the petitioner lost preference because she was continuously working in another school since 19-1-1977, the court emphasized that rule 51-A removes preference only where the person has been appointed in a permanent vacancy in a school under another educational agency. The court found no specific and positive averment that the petitioner had been so appointed in a permanent vacancy. The Government Pleader confirmed that in the Manager's revision the only ground was that the petitioner had been appointed against a leave vacancy. Thus the court did not accept the submission that the petitioner's claim was lost by reason of her continued employment elsewhere.
  2. On the alleged forfeiture by reason of written letters of relinquishment dated 26-6-1975 and 21-7-1976, the court noted that the Assistant Educational Officer had considered the merits of this contention in Ext. P1 and that Ext. P1 had been affirmed by Exts. P2 and P3. The court recorded that the matter was pending in further revision before the Government, and concluded that it was unnecessary and inappropriate for the court to re-examine the question of bona fides already considered concurrently by the original, appellate and revisional authorities.
  3. The argument that the lapse of time (six years between relief from the school and the vacancy) negated the claim was rejected because the rules contained no specified temporal limitation for asserting the preferential claim; the court could not accept the submission that the passage of time extinguished the entitlement.
  4. With respect to the earlier judicial decision relied upon by the Manager (ILR.1972 (2) Kerala 266), the court observed that the law had been changed by the incorporation of Notes 1 and 2 to rule 51-A (by notifications dated 18-7-1972 and 26-4-1977). Note (2) prescribes a specific procedural method by which a Manager must inform a teacher entitled to preference of an appointment and the manner in which forfeiture may be inferred (registered post with acknowledgement due, a 14-day period to join, and a further 7 clear days notice before forfeiture is regarded as having occurred).
  5. The vacancy in question arose on 1-7-1983, which was after the incorporation of Note (2). The court found it admitted that the Manager had not sent either an order of appointment or the further intimation required by Note (2). Because the Manager had not resorted to the specific procedure prescribed by the rule (Note (2)), the Manager was not entitled to treat the petitioner's preferential right as forfeited.
  6. In consequence of the above, and in light of Exts. P1–P3 (which had already refused approval of the sixth respondent's appointment), the court concluded that the Manager — a statutory functionary — was obliged to recognize the petitioner's preferential right and to appoint her to the vacancy that arose on 1-7-1983, subject to the outcome of any competent proceedings pending before the Government.
  7. The court also clarified practical consequences: if the petitioner failed to comply with the appointment within the time limits specified in Note (2), the Manager would then be justified in making alternate arrangements; and if the petitioner had been in service elsewhere during any part of the relevant period with approval and remuneration, the claim to remuneration in respect of the appointment to the Manager's school would be limited to periods during which the appointment was approved and remuneration had not been paid.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The Original Petition is allowed and the fifth respondent (Manager) is directed to appoint the petitioner as Arabic teacher with effect from the date of the vacancy, 1-7-1983.

Implications and Directions

  • The appointment direction must be complied with by the Manager within a period not exceeding one month from the date of the judgment.
  • The appointment is made subject to the result of any competent proceeding pending before the Government (including any revision filed under rule 92 of Chapter XIV-A); the Manager had not obtained an interim order from the Government that would prevent appointment.
  • If the petitioner fails to comply with the appointment order in exercise of her preference within the time specified in Note (2) to rule 51-A (i.e., the rule-prescribed joining periods and notices), the Manager will then be justified in making alternative arrangements.
  • If the petitioner has been in approved service in another school for any portion of the period from 1-7-1983 and has received remuneration pursuant to such approval, any claim for remuneration arising from the appointment ordered by the court will be limited to periods during which the appointment is approved and remuneration has not already been paid.
  • There will be no order as to costs.

This summary is limited strictly to the matters and statements contained in the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added.

    Pathumma v. State Of Kerala

    1. The petitioner was working as Arabic teacher in the school managed by the fifth respondent in two spells from 2-6-1975 to 28-8-1975 and from 21-7-1976 to 19-1-1977 when the permanent Arabic teacher Shri Abdul Rahman was on leave. The teacher retired from service on 30-6-1983 resulting in a vacancy with effect from 1-7-1983 in the post of Arabic teacher. Petitioner claimed preference for appointment in representations addressed to the Manager and the Assistant Educational Officer on the basis of rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules. Since those representations were not disposed of, she filed OP. No. 6593 of 1983 and obtained a judgment directing the Assistant Educational Officer to dispose of that representation. In the meantime, the sixth respondent was appointed by the fifth respondent-Manager in that vacancy with effect from 1-7-1983. Pursuant to the directions contained in the judgment in O.P No. 6593 of 1983, the Assistant Educational Officer conducted an enquiry with notice to the Manager, and passed Ext. P1 order dated 6-12-1983 refusing to approve the appointment of the sixth Respondent for the reason that the petitioner had a claim for preference under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules. The specific case of the fifth respondent, that the petitioner had relinquished her claim to be appointed to future vacancies in the same school on the basis of letters dated 2-6-1975 and 21-7-1976 alleged to have been obtained from the petitioner, was also urged before the Assistant Educational Officer. On a consideration of the probabilities, the Assistant Educational Officer came to the conclusion that there was a coincidence of the dates of appointment of the petitioner and the dates of the alleged letters of relinquishment, and refused to accept the forfeiture of the claim of the petitioner on the basis of those letters. The fifth respondent filed an appeal before the District Educational Officer against Ext. P1. By Ext. P2 order dated 6-4-1984, the District Educational Officer dismissed the appeal affirming Ext. P1. The fifth respondent then filed a revision petition before the Director of Public Instruction, and that was dismissed by Ext. P3 order dated 10-12-1984. It is at that stage that the petitioner filed this Original Petition complaining that in spite of orders, Exts. P1 to P3, upholding her claim and refusing approval of appointment of the sixth respondent, the Manager was not appointing her in recognition of her claim for preference under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules. The petitioner seeks the issue of a writ of mandamus directing the fifth respondent to appoint her as Arabic teacher in the M.M.J.B School, Vellaloor in compliance with the provisions of rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules, as also to direct respondents 1 to 4 to take action against the fifth respondent under rule 7 of Chapter III or rule 23 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules so as to compel the fifth respondent to appoint the petitioner as Arabic teacher in the above school.

    2. The fifth respondent has filed a counter affidavit. It is stated that the petitioner was appointed in two spells of leave vacancies in 1975 and 1977. The claim of the petitioner for preference under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules is sought to be controverted on two grounds viz., that the petitioner was already working in another school since 19-1-1977 and that the petitioner bad abandoned her claim for preference under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules for appointment in future vacancies by letter of relinquishment written by her to the Manager. It is further submitted that a revision under rule 92 of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules has been filed against Ext. F3 order by the fifth respondent on 12-3-1985, and the Manager is not obliged to appoint the petitioner as teacher in his school until after disposal of the revision by the Government.

    3. Counsel for the petitioner referred me to the provisions of rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A or the Kerala Education Rules, which provide that preference in future appointment would not be available to a teacher otherwise entitled to such preference if that person has been appointed in a permanent vacancy in a school under any other educational agency. Support is sought to be drawn from the decision of this court reported in ILR. 1972 (1) Kerala 266, where it is stated that on relinquishment of the claim against the next vacancy, a teacher who is entitled to preference under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Education Rules need not be considered for vacancies arising thereafter. As far as the first of these submissions is concerned, the petitioner may lose preference under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A only if she has been appointed in a permanent vacancy in a school under any other educational agency. There is no specific and positive averment that the petitioner has been so appointed in a permanent vacancy in another school under any other educational agency. The Government Pleader appearing for the respondents 1 to 4 submits that in the revision petition filed by the fifth respondent-Manager, his only ground was that the petitioner has been appointed against a leave vacancy. I am therefore not in a position to accept the submission of the counsel for the fifth respondent that the petitioner has lost her claim for preference under rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A, because she is continuously working in another school since 19-1-1977.

    4. The next submission is in relation to the implied forfeiture of the claim of the petitioner by reason of the letters of relinquishment dated 26-6-1975 and 21-7-1976 given by the petitioner to the fifth respondent-Manager. The merits of this contention were considered by the Assistant Educational Officer while passing Ext. P1 order, and that order has been affirmed in Exts. P2 and P3 orders by the appellate and revisional authorities. I am told that the matter is now pending before the Government in a further revision. It is not necessary for me to consider the merits of this contention as the same was considered by the original, appellate and revisional authorities concurrently, and the question of bona fides in obtaining the letters of relinquishment cannot and need not be considered over again by this court in these proceedings. Another submission of counsel for the fifth respondent is that the vacancy to which the claim is being urged by the petitioner arose six years after she was relieved from the school on 19-1-1977 and therefore, the claim for preference under rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the Kerala Service Rules cannot be urged as emphatically as it would otherwise have been. In the absence of any specification of any period of time within which alone the preferential claim shall be considered anywhere in the rules, I can only plead my inability to accept the submission as eliminating the claim of the petitioner for preference under rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A.

    5. As far as the question of forfeiture of the claim of the petitioner urged by counsel for the fifth respondent on the basis of the decision repored in ILR. 1972 (2) Kerala 266 is concerned I need only state that the law has been changed since then by incorporating Notes 1 and 2 to rule 51-A of Chapter XIV-A by notification dated 18-7-1972 and 26-4-1977. Note (2) provides the manner in which the Manager should intimate a teacher entitled for preference under rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the availability of the vacancy, and the circumstances under which forfeiture of the claim can be inferred. The Manager is obliged to sent an order of appointment to the teacher by registered post acknowledgement due requiring the teacher to join duty within a period of 14 days. If the teacher does not join duty in time, the Manager is obliged to give a further notice to the teacher stating that another person would be appointed instead and that the preferential right under rule 51-A would be forfeited if not exercised within another 7 clear days. If nothing is heard from the teacher during that time also, the preferential right under the rule will be regarded as forfeited.

    6. The vacancy to which the petitioner lays claim under rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A arose on 1-7-1983, which was subsequent to the incorporation of Note (2) to rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A. Admittedly, the fifth respondent had not sent an order of appointment, or the further intimation requiring the petitioner to join duty. In the absence of resort to the specific method prescribed by the rules which may lead to an inference of forfeiture of the preferential claim of the petitioner, the fifth respondent is not entitled to consider that the petitioner has forfeited the claim for appointment under rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A. This is so notwithstanding the decision referred to by the counsel for the fifth respondent, since the law as it then stood was subsequently altered by the incorporation of Notes to the rule referred to by me earlier.

    7. In the light of Exts. P1 to P3 orders, rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A, and Note (2) thereto, the fifth respondent, who is a statutory functionary, is obliged to give recognition to the right of the petitioner for preference in the matter of appointment in the vacancy which arose in the category of Arabic teacher on 1-7-1983, and the fifth respondent bad to appoint the petitioner.

    8. There will, therefore, be a direction that the fifth respondent shall appoint the petitioner as Arabic teacher with effect from the date of occurrence of the vacancy, 1-7-1983, in view of the fact that he had not been able to obtain any interim order in the revision alleged to have been filed by him before the State Government under rule 92 of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E Rules. Such appointment will, of course, be subject to the result of any competent proceeding pending before the Government. Only if the petitioner does not comply with the order appointing her in exercise of her preference under rule 51A of Chapter XIV-A of the K.E Rules within the time specified in Note (2) to that rule will the fifth respondent be justified in making any other alternative arrangement. If the petitioner has been in service in another school for any portion of the period from 1-7-1983, such appointment has been approved by the educational authorities, and she has been in receipt of remuneration pursuant to such approval, the claim of the petitioner for remuneration pursuant to her appointment in the vacancy of Arabic teacher in the fifth respondent's school with effect from 1-7-1983 will be limited to the period during which her appointment is approved and remuneration has not been paid to her. In the result, the Original Petition is allowed. The directions as above shall be complied with within a period not exceeding one month from today. There will be no order as to costs.

    9. Allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pathumma v. State Of Kerala
    (Oct 29, 1985)