AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 2(d) of the above said Act. Under sub-clause (ii) of S. 2(d),
  • CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • S. 2(o) of Consumer Protection Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 2(d) of the above said Act. Under sub-clause (ii) of S. 2(d),
  • CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • S. 2(o) of Consumer Protection Act.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Kerala Public Service Commission & Ors. v. P.P. Ravendran

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was filed by the Kerala Public Service Commission (the Service Commission) and its District Officer, Palghat, challenging a notice issued by the Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Ernakulam, on an application filed by the second respondent, P.P. Ravendran. The State of Kerala was impleaded as third respondent.

The second respondent had applied for the post of peon in the Panchayat Common Service, Palghat District, in response to a Service Commission notification. Selection involved a written test followed by an interview. His name appeared in the short list published on 3-4-1990 and, after interview, he was placed at rank No. 5 in a supplementary list for Ezhavas. The final ranked list came into force on 12-9-1990.

Believing he should have been in the main ranked list, the second respondent applied for re-checking of marks on 26-9-1990, paying Rs. 10. The Service Commission rejected the re-checking application as out of time, stating the application for re-checking must be filed within 30 days of publication of the short list. The second respondent then filed a complaint before the Consumer Court on 20-10-1990, claiming to be a consumer who had hired the Service Commission's services. The Consumer Court issued notice to the Service Commission.

The Service Commission filed the present writ petition on 7-1-1991 challenging that notice; a stay was granted and the matter was referred to a Division Bench. The second respondent was served but did not file a counter-affidavit or appear. The High Court proceeded to decide the matter on its merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this case constituted an exceptional circumstance permitting the High Court to exercise its discretion under Article 226 to interfere with a Consumer Court notice (contrary to the general rule of non-interference with Consumer Court jurisdiction).
  2. Whether the Public Service Commission's functions and the candidate's payment (Rs. 10 for re-checking) brought the matter within the scope of "services" and "consumer" as defined under the Consumer Protection Act (in particular S.2(d) and S.2(o) as they stood before the 1993 Ordinance), i.e., whether the candidate could be treated as having "hired" the Commission's services for a consideration.

Arguments of the Parties

Service Commission (Writ Petitioners) — Summarised Arguments

  • The Service Commission argued that the re-checking application by the second respondent was out of time because the statutory period for re-checking (where a short list is published) is 30 days from the publication of the short list.
  • It contended that the second respondent's assumption — that the time limit was one month from the short list or two months from the ranked list — was factually incorrect, because the longer period (with reference to the ranked list) applies only where the ranked list is prepared on the basis of written test alone without interview.
  • The Commission maintained that it is a constitutional body exercising functions under Articles 315–323 of the Constitution, exercising exclusive statutory/constitutional functions in recruitment, and therefore its activities are not services "hired" by a candidate within the meaning of the Consumer Protection Act.
  • Consequently, the Commission sought quashing of the Consumer Court's notice and dropping of the complaint proceedings.

Second Respondent / Complainant — Summarised Contentions (from his complaint)

  • The second respondent alleged he was entitled to be included in the main ranked list (rather than the supplementary list) and that a re-checking of marks would show this entitlement.
  • He paid Rs. 10 for re-checking and claimed to be a "consumer" who had hired the services of the Service Commission, thereby invoking the jurisdiction of the Consumer Court.
  • The second respondent did not, however, file a counter-affidavit or appear at the hearing before the High Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Georgekutty v. State of Kerala, 1993 (2) KLT 755 : 1993 (2) KLJ 644 Established the normal rule that High Courts will not entertain parallel litigation on the question of jurisdiction of Consumer Courts, given the appellate hierarchy created under the Consumer Protection Act; allowed only rare exceptions. The Court treated Georgekutty as the starting point but examined whether the present matter fell within the rare exceptions permitting interference; ultimately concluded this case was an exception.
Tulasi Enterprises v. Andhra Pradesh State Consumer Commission, Hyderabad, AIR 1991 AP 326 Authority followed on the proposition that High Courts generally should not intervene in matters over which Consumer Courts have jurisdiction. The Court followed this decision as part of the line of authorities establishing the normal non-interference rule, but still found the present case exceptional.
Ansal Properties & Industries (P) Ltd. v. Shri Chander Bhan Kohli, 1991 (1) CP 679 Another authority supporting the limited role of High Courts in entertaining writs interfering with consumer forum jurisdiction. The Court relied on this earlier decision alongside Tulasi Enterprises in framing the general principle of non-interference.
Calcutta Metropolitan Development Authority v. Union of India, AIR 1993 Cal. 4 Decision of a High Court on related jurisdictional issues; its approach was noted by the Court. The bench expressly stated that it dissented from this Calcutta High Court decision while following the other authorities mentioned.
Mira Chatterjee v. Public Service Commission, AIR 1958 Cal. 345 Recognised that a Public Service Commission is a constitutional body charged with constitutional rights, duties and obligations. The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that the Service Commission's functions arise from the Constitution and regulations thereunder and are not the sort of "services" that candidates "hire" under the Consumer Protection Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by acknowledging the general rule that it will not normally entertain writ petitions challenging notices or preliminary orders of Consumer Courts, citing Georgekutty and other authorities. The Court reiterated that interference by a High Court in matters concerning Consumer Court jurisdiction should be rare and exceptional.

The central question was whether this matter fell within those rare exceptions. The Court analysed the constitutional status and functions of Public Service Commissions by reference to Articles 315–323 of the Constitution. It outlined the constitutional scheme: the establishment of Public Service Commissions for the Union and each State, provisions governing appointment and removal of members, the power to make regulations (Art. 318), duties to conduct examinations for appointments (Art. 320), and other constitutionally mandated functions and reporting requirements.

On that basis the Court reasoned that recruitment by the Service Commission is founded on a constitutional mandate and that the Service Commission occupies a special, constitutionally protected status. Relying on Mira Chatterjee, the Court concluded that a Public Service Commission is a constitutional body charged with constitutional duties and obligations.

The Court then examined the statutory definitions in the Consumer Protection Act (specifically S.2(d) and S.2(o), as they stood before the 1993 Ordinance). It emphasised the word "hire" in the definition of a consumer who has engaged services for a consideration. The Court found that, notwithstanding the payment of Rs. 10 for re-checking, the second respondent could not be said to have "hired" the services of the Service Commission because the Commission was performing constitutional functions under regulations made pursuant to the Constitution and exercising an exclusive prerogative in recruitment.

Concluding from the foregoing that the Service Commission's activities were not the sort of services contemplated by the Consumer Protection Act and that the candidate could not be treated as a consumer for this purpose, the Court determined that this matter was an exceptional case warranting interference under Article 226. On that basis the notice issued by the Consumer Court was quashed and the Consumer Court was directed to drop all proceedings pursuant to the complaint.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The writ petition is allowed; the notice issued by the Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Ernakulam is quashed and the Consumer Court is directed to drop all proceedings pursuant to the complaint filed by the second respondent.

Implications for the Parties: The direct effect is that the Service Commission's challenged notice was set aside and the complaint in the Consumer Court was to be discontinued. The Court treated the case as an exceptional instance in which the High Court should exercise its discretion under Article 226, on the grounds that Public Service Commissions act pursuant to constitutional provisions and their functions are not services "hired" by candidates under the Consumer Protection Act (as the definitions stood before the 1993 Ordinance).

The opinion frames this decision as an exception to the normal rule of non-interference with Consumer Court jurisdiction; it does not purport to create an expansive new rule beyond the circumstances and reasoning stated in the judgment.


This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not include information beyond that text.

    Kerala Public Service Commission v. Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum

    Jagannadha Rao, C.J:— This writ petition is filed by the Kerala Public Service Commission and its District Officer, Palghat questioning the notice issued by the Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Ernakulam upon anapplication filed before it by the second respondent, one P.P Ravcendran. The State of Kerala is impleaded as third respondent.

    2. The second respondent, the said P.P Ravcendran filed a complaint before the above said Consumer Court alleging that he was an applicant for the post of peon in the Panchayat Common service, Palghal District in response to a notification issued by the Service Commission and that selection to the post was finalised by a written test followed by interview. Second respondent-complainant was called for interview and his name was included at rank No. 5 in the supplementary list for Ezhavas. The short list of Candida tes eligible to be called for interview on the basis of their success in the written examina tion was published on 3-4-1990 and the second respondent'sname was included therein. The ranked list for the post was finalised and brought into force with effect from 12-9-1990. According to the above said complainant, his name should have been included in the main ranked list itself and not in the supplementary list. He felt that a re-checking of the marks would reveal that he should have been included in the main ranked list.

    3. Therefore, he applied to the Commission by paying Rs. 10/- for re-checking. This he did on 26-9-1990-5 months and 22 days after the publication of the short list and 14 days after the publication of the ranked list. The said application was rejected by the Service Commission on the ground that the complainant should have filed an” application for re-checking within 30 days of the publication of the short list of candidates eligible to be called for interview. Thereafter, the complainant again moved the District Officer saying that he was under the impression that the period prescribed was one month after the publication of the short list or two months after the publication of the ranked list. This assumption on the part of the second respondent is, according to the Service Commission, factually wrong. In cases where short list is published, the period is 30 days from the publication of the short list. That is the only period during which application for re-checking could be filed. The period fixed with reference to the ranked list applies only to cases where the ranked list is prepared on the basis of written test alone without interview. Therefore, the second respondent was given a further reply by the District Officer by letter dated 16-10-1990. Thereafter, the second respondent filed a complaint before the Consumer Court on 20-10-1990 claiming to be a consumer who has hired the services of the Service Commission. The Consumer Court issued notice to the Service Commission. Questioning the said notice, this writ petition is filed by the Service Commission on 7-1-1991 and stay was granted. Thereafter the matter was referred to a Division Bench for consideration. In this matter, the second respondent has been served, but has not filed any counter affidavit nor has he appeared through counsel. We are, therefore, proceeding to decide the matter on merits.

    4. At the outset, we have to mention that normally this Court is not entertaining writ petitions wherein notice of the Consumer Courts or preliminary orders of the Consumer Courts are questioned. In an elaborate judgment in Georgekutty v. State of Kerala (1993 (2) KLT 755 : 1993 (2) KLJ 644) we stated that inasmuch as the hierarchy of appellate authorities have been created under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, this Court will not entertain a parallel litigation on the question of jurisdiction of Consumer Courts. The said courts are competent to decide the questions of jurisdiction. Having said so, we observed that, however, in very rare cases this Court could still interfere. In the above said judgment we mentioned in paragraph 9 as follows:

    “What we have stated above is to be the normal rule. There may indeed be rare cases which are expressly excluded by the very provisions of the Consumer Protection Act or other rare cases which may warrant interference by the High Court. But that should be a rare exception and not the rule”.

    5. In so doing, we followed an earlier decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Tulasi Enterprises v. Andhra Pradesh State Consumer Commission, Hyderabad (AIR 1991 AP 326) and of the Delhi High Court in Ansal Properties and Industries (P) Ltd. v. Shri Chander Bhan Kohli (1991 (1) CP 679) and we dissented from the decision of the Calcutta High Court in Calcutta Metropolitan Development Authority v. Union of India (AIR 1993 Cal. 4). Recently, we have disposed of a batch relating to doctors in hospitals in OP 869 of 1991 and connected cases on 6-10-1991 wherein we refused to interfere. In yet another batch filed by the Central Board of Secondary Education in OP 4847 of 1991 and connected cases, we again refused to interfere.

    6. The first question before us is whether the case on hand wherein the Kerala Public Service Commission and its District Officer, who were the respondents before the Consumer Court (writ petitioners before us) can be treated as an exceptional case falling within the rare exceptions mentioned in our above said judgments. Having heard learned counsel for the Service Commission, we have come to the conclusion that this case must be treated as falling within the rare exceptions.

    7. Art. 315 of the Constitution of India provides that there shall be a Public Service Commission for the Union and a Public Service Commission for each State. The said Article and Articles 316 and 317 provide for the method of appointment and removal of members of the Service Commission. Art. 318 enables the President of India or the Governor of the Stales to make regulations as to the conditions of service of members and staff of the Service Commission. Art. 319 deals with the prohibition as to the holding of offices by members of Commission on ceasing to be such members. Then comes Arl. 320 which deals with the functions of the Public Service Commissions. The said Article provides that it shall be the duty of the Union and the State Public Service Commissions to conduct examinations for appointments to theservices of the Union and the services of the State respectively. Further, the Union Service Commission or the Slate Service Commission, as the case may be, shall have to be consulted on all matters relating to method of recruitment to civil services and civil posts and in the matter of principles to be followed in making appointments to civil services and posts and also in making promotions and transfers from one service to another as also on the question of suitability of candidates for such appointments, promotions or transfers. The Service Commissions will have to be consulted in regard to all disciplinary matters affecting a person serving under the Government of India or the Government of a State in a civil capacity etc. The regulations made by the President or the Governor, as the case may be, will have to be placed before the House of Parliament or the House of concerned Legislature as staled in Art. 320. Art. 321 deals with the power to extend functions of Public Service Commissions. Art. 322 provides for expenses of Public Service Commissions. It states that the expenses of the Union or a State Service Commission, including any salaries, allowances and pensions payable to the members of staff shall be charged on the Consolidated Fund of India or as the case may be Consolidated Fund of the Slate, It is then provided in Art. 323 that the reports of the Service Commissions shal be submitted to the President of India or to the Governor, as the case may be.

    8. It is, therefore, clear that recruitment to the Union and State services made by the various Service Commissions are based on the mandate in the Constitution of India in regard to which no other authority can recruit to any civil service or civil post under the Union of India or under any State: The Constitution gives such a special status to the Service Commissions. As pointed out by the Calcutta High Court in Mira Chatterjee v. Public Service Commission (AIR 1958 Cal. 345) ‘Public Service Commission is a constitutional body charged with certain constitutional rights, duties and obligations’. In our view, it was never intended by the Parliament to treat Service Commissions as rendering any service within the meaning of S. 2(o) of Consumer Protection Act. Nor can we say that the second respondent herein who sought recruitment through the Service Commisison as a peon is in the position of a ‘consumer’ within the meaning of the said word in S. 2(d) of the above said Act. Under sub-clause (ii) of S. 2(d), second respondent can be a consumer only if he can be said to have ‘hired’ any service of the Service Commission for a consideration. (We are here concerned with the above said definition before the amendment by the Ordinance of 1993). Emphasis here should be made on the word ‘hire’. In our view, even though the second respondent had paid Rs. 10 To the Service Commission for re-checking of the marks, he cannot be said to have hired the services of the Service Commission. As already slatted, the Service Commission is exercising functions laid down in the various regulations made aecording to the provisions of the Constitution. It derives the said obligations, duties, responsibilities and rights to thesaid regulations made under the Constitution. Weare, therefore, unable to hold that services, if any, rendered by it can be said to be hired by the candidate. As already stated, for recruitment to any posts coming within the purview of the Service Commission, no other body or authority in the State can recruit any person and il is the exclusive prerogative of the Service Commission to deal with the said recruitment. It cannot be said that its services have been ‘hired’ by the candidate.

    9. For the aforesaid reasons, we hold that this is an exceptional case in which this Court should interfere, in exercise of its discretion, under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India. The notice issued by the Consumer Court-first respondent is, therefore, quashed and il is directed to drop all proceedings pursuant to the complaint filed by the second respondent herein (petitioner before it).

    10. The Writ Petition is accordingly allowed.

    11. Allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kerala Public Service Commission v. Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum
    (Oct 15, 1993)