M.B.Shah, J.:-
(1) The petitioner had lodged a f. I. R. With sarkhej police station on 9. 11. 1984 at about 11. 15 p. M. That the respondents - accused came with sticks, dharia, spear, bricks when he was sitting with ramanji becharji, ganpatji becharji rameshji hathiji, babuji bhathuji and manaji shakraji on a cot near parbadi at about 8. 30 p. M. Has stated that on the previous day his uncles son chhanaji budhaji had beaten one thakore ramanji bhalaji, thereafter all the respondents came there with the respective weapons mentioned in the f. I. R. Even though the complainant and witnesses tried to pacify the accused and stated that chhanaji budhaji was insane, yet they assaulted the complainant and the witnesses. Stick blows, dharia blows and spear blow were given. He had stated that all the injured persons were removed to the v. S. Hospital straightway. The investigating officer registered the said complaint for the alleged offences punishable under sections 147, 148, 149, 324, 323, 337 and 114 of the indian penal code. As the investigating officer came to know that injured thakore manaji shakraji was serious, he registered an offence punishable under section 326 of the indian penal code on 11. 11. 84. All the accused were arrested on 12. 11. 84 and with a report they were produced before the learned magistrate.
(2) As soon as they were produced before the learned magistrate, the accused respondents filed an application that they may be released on bail. On the said application the learned magistrate passed an ordered that the concerned p. S. I. And the learned dovecotes for the accused were heard, injured witness was unconscious but no certificate was produced, therefore, seriousness of the injury cannot be verified. He, therefore, ordered that all the accused should be released on bail on their executing a bond of rs. 1000/ - and furnishing a surety of the like amount with a condition that they shall remain present for investigation whenever the investigating officer calls for and other conditions.
(3) Against the said judgment and order the original complainant bas filed this miscellaneous application. It was submitted by the learned advocate for the petitioner that the learned magistrate has no jurisdiction to release the accused persons on bail because it was alleged that the accused have committed offences punishable under sections 147, 148, 149, 325, etc. He submitted that under section 326 the accused can be punished with imprisonment for life and under section 437 of the criminal procedure code the magistrate has no jurisdiction to release those persons if there appears responsible ground for believing that the accused are guilty of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life.
(4) It is true that against the accused it is alleged that they have committed offence punishable under sections 147, 148, 149, 325, etc. Under section 326 of the indian penal code sentence of imprisonment for life, can be imposed. Section 326 also provides that the court has jurisdiction to impose sentence of imprisonment for life or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years. The learned advocate for the respondents - accused, therefore, submitted that section 437 (1) (i) would not applicable because alternative punishment which may extend to ten yean is provided (or the offence under section 326. In my view, that submission of the learned advocate for the accused is without any substance. Section 437 provides that the court may release the accused on bail if there appears no reasonable ground for believing that he has been guilty of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life. If the circumstances of the case are such the court trying the accused can impose imprisonment for life for an offence punishable under section 326. Section 437 (1) (i) in terms provides that when any person accused of or suspected of the commission of any non - bailable offence is arrested and is brought before the court other than the high court or court of session, such person shall not be released on bail if there appear reasonable grounds for believing that he bas been guilty of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life. It cannot be said that this bar would not operate in respect of offences punishable with imprisonment for life or in the alternative imprisonment for ten years because the court trying the case is empowered to impose a maximum sentence of imprisonment for life. In this set of circumstances, the magistrate before whom the accused is produced would not have jurisdiction to release him on bail except in cases which fall in the excepted categories of provides to section 437 (1). Therefore, at the initial stage when the accused are produced before the) magistrate and it is alleged that the accused have committed an offence punishable under section 326, then the magistrate would not have jurisdiction to release the accused on bait.
(5) Further under sub - section (4) of section 437 of the court releases the accused on bail under sub - section (1) or sub - section (2) he is required to record in writing his reasons for doing so. The order passed by the learned magistrate on the face of it shows that he has not given any reasons why he is releasing the accused on bail. Even before him f. I. R. Was there and he ought to have verified the facts from the f. I. R. Ab no reasons are given by the learned magistrate, therefore, also the order passed by the learned magistrate require strobe quashed and set aside. It was pointed out to the learned magistrate that one injured witness was in serious condition ill the hospital and yet the learned magistrate has observed that no certificate was produced therefore, he released the accused on bail. At that initial stage the learned magistrate was not required to consider the merits or the accusation. In the case of gurcharan singh v. State (delhi admn.) , the supreme court has elaborately discussed the provisions of section 437 and has held that if a police officer arrests person on a reasonable suspicion of commission of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life and forwards him to a magistrate the magistrate at that stage will have no reasons to hold that there are no reasonable grounds for believing that the accused has not been guilty of such an offence.
(6) It would be worthwhile to quote the discussion of the supreme court in the aforesaid case in paragraph 22 which reads as under: in other non - bailable cases the court will exercise its judicial discretion in favour of granting bail subject to sub - section (3) of section 437, criminal procedure code. If it deems necessary to act under it. Unless exceptional circum. Stances are brought to the notice of the court which may defeat proper investigation and a fair trial, the court will not decline to grant bail to the person who is not accused of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life. It is also clear that when an accused is brought before the court of a magistrate with the allegation against him of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life, he has ordinarily no option in the matter but to refuse bail subject, however to the first proviso to section 437 (1) , criminal procedure code and in a case where the magistrate entertains a reasonable belief on the materials that the accused has not been guilty of such an offence. This will, however be an extraordinary occasion since there will be some materials at the stage of initial arrest, for the accusation or for strong suspicion of commission by the person of such an offence. (emphasis added). The court has further observed that the limited enquiry at the initial stage may relate to the materials for suspicion and at that stage the court is concerned with the existence of the materials against the accused and not as to whether those materials are credible or not on the merits.
(7) The learned advocate for the petitioner made a grievance that without hearing the learned police prosecutor the learned magistrate has passed this order. It seems that as the accused was produced before him under section 167 of the criminal learned code, the learned magistrate has passed the order straightway after hearing the concerned investigating officer and the learned advocate for the accused. It is not clear from the order that any objection was raise by the concerned p. S. I. That the accused should not be released on bail. If the investigating officer had not objected to the release of the respondents on bail, then no grievance could be made at this stage in this application by the complainant. It would be for the government or the other appropriate authority to inquire why the investigating officer had not objected to the bail application filed by the accused in such type of cases.
(8) In the result the application is allowed. The order passed by the judicial magistrate, first class. Narol on 12. 11. 84 in sarkhej police station crime register no. 106/84 releasing the respondents nos. 1 to 9 on bail is quashed and set aside and the bail granted to them is ordered to be cancelled. The accused - respondents nos. 1 to 9 are directed to surrender to custody on or before 26th december. 1984. It is clarified that it would be open to the accused respondents nos. 1 to 9 to file an application before the appropriate forum for releasing then on bail. Rule made absolute.