Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Triloki Nath Kotha v. Jawahir Lal Kotha & Ors.

    1. The appellant/plaintiff has challanged an order of the trial court dated 26-9-83, whereby the plaint has been returned to the plaintiff for presentation before a competent court of jurisdiction.

    2. The facts giving rise to this appeal are: that the appellant filed a suit against the respondents for partition of an ancestral property situated at Bagh Joghi Lankar, Srinagar, to the extent of his share. The respondents contested the suit and raised among other pleas, the plea that the suit has not been properly valued, the suit property being much higher value, therefore beyond the jurisdiction of the court. The court below framed two preliminary issued as under:-

    (i) Whether the valuation of the suit property has been fixed wrongly by the plaintiffs, if so, what is the correct valuation?..... OPDI

    (ii) In the suit triable by this court, if so, how? OPDI

    3. On deciding the issues, the learned trial court has returned a finding that the suit being of the nature of simple partition and the plaintiff was under obligation 'to value the suit for the entire property sought to be partitioned not to the extent of his share only, with the result the plaint has been returned to the plaintiff/appellant under order impugned for presentation before a court of competent jurisdiction, therefore, this appeal.

    I have heard learned counsel for the parties.

    4. Mr. Raina, appearing for the respondents faintly resisted the argument advanced by learned counsel for the appellant that the plaintiff is not called upon to value the suit for payment of court fee and jurisdiction purposes on the whole property but only to the extent of his share, but he also argued that the court below should have ascertained first the actual value of the property.

    5. The only point now involved in this appeal is, whether in a suit for simple partition the suitor is called upon to value and pay the court fee for the entire property, as held by the court below or to the extent of his share sought to be partitioned out of joint family property as claimed by the appellant. Generally in normal course for claim of property, the suitor is called on to pay the court fee and value the suit for purposes of jurisdiction to the extent of value of the claim based for the suit. Though the point was not seriously con­tested by Mr. Raina, but the point involved has come under the consi­deration of various High courts in the country and there is difference of opinion in this regard for valuation and payment, of court fee in a partition suit. The trial court having based his decision on a finding of High Court of Orissa reported in AIR: 1979: Orissa: 71, holding that in a simple partition suit without consequential relief, the partition suit is not to be valued for purposes of jurisdiction and court fee to the extent of suitor's claim, but for the entire property becoming subject of the partition. Same is the view of Calcutta High Court in a deci­sion reported in AIR: 1925 : Calcutta : 320, relied by their lordship in the same authority of Orissa High Court. Then is another bench rather majority of the courts which have held otherwise holding that it is the share of the party, seeking partition of the joint family property which determines value for purposes of pecuniary jurisdiction and court tee and not the entire property out of which separate share is sought for partition. Patna High Court in an earlier decision reported in AIR: 1921: Pat: 78 have given their finding in the following words: -

    "The question for determination before us is whether the valuation of the suit should be the value of the entire properties mentioned in Schs, I and II of the plaint, or that of the share of the plaintiff only in those properties, namely, the I /13th share thereof It is settled by authorities that in a suit for partition, pure and simple where the plaintiff is in posse­ssion of his share of the property and simply wants to alter the mode of its enjoyment by claiming to hold his propor­tionate share in the properties separately from the other joint holders, the Court fee payable will be Rs. 10 only under Sch. II, Art. 17, cl. 6 of the Court Fees Act)"

    That court affirmed the same view in AIR: 1953 : Pat : 342 also. The Madras High Court has taken identical view in AIR: 1947 : Mad : 273 and observed as under :-

    "For purposes of jurisdiction it is the plaintiff's interest in the property that must be valued. Where in a suit for partition the plaintiff claims that he has an undivi­ded half share in the suit properties which he seeks to have divided, the suit relates only to a half share of such properties and the value of the suit for purposes of jurisdiction is the value of such share"

    6. To the same effect are the observations made by his lordship Justice Shah, of the Bombay High Court as he then was reported in AIR;1962;Bombay: 4, in these words:-

    "In a suit for partition it is the value of the share which the plaintiff claims in the Joint family property or the property of which partition is sought, which determ­ines the pecuniary, jurisdiction of the court and not the value of the entire property."

    This view has been earlier taken by their lordships, of the Privy Council in AIR: 1944:65 observing as under:-

    "The question as to the title of the plaintiff to the share which he claimed in the joint property did not become a question respecting the whole of the joint family estate merely because if his title was established it would result in the joint family estate being partitioned."

    7. Considering the judgment relied by the learned trial court and the cases cited above, it appears that the majority of the courts in the country are of the view that in simple partition suit, it is the share sought by the suitor in the undivided joint family property which determines jurisdiction for purposes of court fee and for pecuniary jurisdiction of a court not the entire suit property out of which share is sought to be partitioned. The case in hand is a suit for simple partition where the plaintiff has-specified his share, sought to be part­itioned out of the joint family property in joint possession of the parties, No doubt, the court may have to deal with the whole property for the purposes of effecting the partition there being no additional relief except the partition of the joint family property to the extent of Plaintiffs share only, he has to value the suit for pecuniary jurisd­iction and court fee to the extent of his share not the whole property from which the separate share is sought. This view being supported by a majority of the decisions (supra) and I am inclined to follow this view in the case in band, having identical facts involved as disc­ussed. Therefore, I am of the opinion that the finding recorded by the court below that the appellant/plaintiff should have valued the suit for partition for purposes of jurisdiction and court fee as regards the entire joint family property and not to the extent of plaintiff's share sought to be partitioned out of the same, does not appear a correct view and same need to be set aside, holding that in simple partition suit, the plaintiff has to value his suit for purposes of pecuniary jurisdiction and court fee to the extent of his share claimed out of the joint family property.

    8. I, therefore, allow the appeal and set aside the finding recorded by Sub Judge (Judge, Small Causes) Srinagar dated 26-9 83, with further direction the trial court will record afresh finding on issue No.1 regarding the actual valuation of the property, as finding on this issue appears not to have been properly recorded without discussing evidence, if any led by the defendant who had to prove the same but recorded the finding relying purely on the admissions of the plaintiff.

    The trial court will record the finding on the issue after discussing evidence if any brought on record by the party concerned.

    9. The result is the appeal is accepted and the case is sent back to the court below to proceed afresh in accordance with law and the observations made. There will be, however, no order as to costs. Counsel for the parties is directed to cause their appearance before the trial court on 25-4-88.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Triloki Nath Kotha v. Jawahir Lal Kotha & Ors.
    (Mar 16, 1988)