AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • villages.27. Rule 2 of the Settlement Rules
  • cases.28. Rule 26 of the Settlement Rules
  • Rule 1(c) of the Settlement Rules
  • Rule 13 of the Settlement Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • villages.27. Rule 2 of the Settlement Rules
  • cases.28. Rule 26 of the Settlement Rules
  • Rule 1(c) of the Settlement Rules
  • Rule 13 of the Settlement Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Sarjoo Prosad, C.J.; Ram Labhaya, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Ten petitioners (residents of village Padumani-Kismat, Mouza Namati, District Nowgong) sought a writ of mandamus or other appropriate relief directing the State of Assam and other opposite parties not to interfere with land settlements previously made in their favour and to refrain from reducing the areas allotted to each petitioner.

On 2-12-1949 the Deputy Commissioner of Nowgong allotted 200 bighas of 'Sarkari' waste land among the ten petitioners at 20 bighas each. The petitioners reclaimed, occupied and cultivated the lands, paid instalments of premium (premia) and revenue; three instalments were admitted paid and the petitioners asserted they had paid the fourth. No pattas had been issued, but boundaries had been demarcated by the Mandal.

Subsequently some persons sought conversion of the lands into a grazing reserve but the Settlement Officer, after enquiry, rejected those objections and confirmed the settlements. Nearly two years after the allotments, the Under Secretary to the Government of Assam wrote (letter No. RSG 107/52/53 dated 1-5-1952) that although the Government did not wish to interfere with the settlements, it considered 20 bighas per head to be excessive and directed reduction to 15 bighas per head and re-allocation of the remaining area to other landless persons. Pursuant to that letter, the Settlement Officer notified the petitioners (notice dated 20-4-53) that their allotments were reduced to 15 bighas each. The petitioners sought administrative recall of those orders unsuccessfully and then challenged the reductions by way of this writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Provincial Government (State of Assam), by executive letter directing reduction of previously made allotments, had lawful authority to reduce allotments already made by the Deputy Commissioner and Settlement Officer (i.e., whether the Government could, under Rule 2 of the Settlement Rules or otherwise, invalidate or reduce completed allotments).
  2. Whether the petitioners, who had been allotted land, paid premia and revenue and occupied and cultivated the land (though pattas had not yet been executed), had a legal right enforceable by a prerogative writ under Article 226 of the Constitution to prevent the Government's interference.
  3. Whether the alternative remedy by suit (civil action) was adequate and effective, or whether exceptional circumstances justified relief under Article 226.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented by Mr. Fakhruddin Ahmed)

  • The settlements were validly made by competent officers (Deputy Commissioner and recognised by the Settlement Officer) and, once made, it was not open to the Government to interfere and reduce the settled areas.
  • Because the petitioners had paid premia (in instalments) and revenue and had occupied and cultivated the land, they had acquired a valuable right or property interest in the lands (subject to the rules under which the settlement was made) that warranted protection by the Court.
  • The notification governing these settlements (Notification No. 4587 dated 12-9-41) envisaged allotments normally about 30 bighas per family; the petitioners received about 20 bighas each—less than the normal standard—and in any event the rules did not permit the Government to reduce completed allotments.

Respondents' / Government's Arguments (as presented by Mr. Medhi and the Government Advocate)

  • Reliance upon Section 11 of the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation and Rule 1(c) of the Settlement Rules: a 'settlement-holder' who is not a 'land-holder' has no rights beyond those expressed in his settlement lease; an annual lease confers only a right of user for the year and no transferable or inheritable rights beyond the year.
  • Reliance upon Rule 2 of the Settlement Rules: disposal of waste lands vests in the Deputy Commissioner "subject to the general or special orders of the Provincial Government"—the Government may therefore issue orders affecting allotments.
  • General suggestion that because the allotments might be in the nature of annual settlements, petitioners could not compel renewal or that the Government retained supervisory control that justified reduction.

Table of Precedents Cited

No case law precedents (reported judicial decisions) were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in two related strands: (A) whether the Government's executive letter and the Settlement Officer's steps reducing allotments were legally competent; and (B) whether extraordinary relief under Article 226 should be granted.

A. Authority to Reduce Completed Allotments

  1. The court examined the statutory and regulatory framework governing the relevant allotments: Notification No. 4587-R dated 12-9-1941 (a Development Rate Scheme), provisions of the Settlement Rules (notably Rule 2 and Rule 1(c)), and provisions of the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation (including Section 11 and the definition of 'settlement-holder' in Section 3(h)).
  2. The notification established the scheme's substantive terms: premium Rs.2 per bigha payable in four equal annual instalments, allotments to be occupied and cultivated, a normal allotment size (about 30 bighas for landless families), a four-year occupation period after which unoccupied portions would be deemed cancelled, and an explicit provision that "an allottee or an annual settlement-holder shall have no transferable right or interest in the land covered by his allotment or annual patta."
  3. The Chief Justice rejected the respondents' submission that Section 11 and Rule 1(c) could be read to deprive the petitioners of any subsisting enforceable rights prior to patta execution. The petitioners had paid premia and revenue, reclaimed and cultivated the lands, and the settlement had been recognised by the Settlement Officer; thus they had rights at least for the period of the premia instalments and for the four-year occupation period established by the notification.
  4. On the meaning of Rule 2 (which vests disposal of waste land in the Deputy Commissioner "subject to the general or special orders of the Provincial Government"), both judges held that Rule 2 must be interpreted consistently with the Regulation's broader scheme and could not be read to permit the Provincial Government to, by subsequent executive fiat, nullify or reduce specific completed allotments. The words "general or special orders" were read as relating to existing orders that bind the Deputy Commissioner at the time of disposal, not as authorising the Government to undo completed allotments subsequently.
  5. Ram Labhaya, J. expanded on the distinction between an "allottee" under paras 6–8 of the notification and an "annual settlement-holder." He explained that the allottee received a four-year period to occupy land, that partial cancellation on non-occupation is contemplated by the notification, and that the allottee's rights under the notification (including restrictions on transfer and succession rules) indicate the allotment is not merely a one-year lease. Thus a completed allotment under the notification is not properly equated with an annual lease which would be terminable each year without further consequence.
  6. The court further analysed Rule 26 and the powers of the Commissioner: though the Commissioner can confirm or cancel settlements under limited circumstances, the exercise of those powers is controlled and not intended to permit the Provincial Government to act as an unrestricted revisional or appellate authority to cancel completed individual settlements. The Government's reduction of completed allotments was held to be an unauthorized interference beyond the executive scope provided by the rules and Regulation.
  7. Regarding Section 11 (settlement-holder's rights limited to those in the lease), the court observed the practical realities: where land has been surveyed, delivered, reclaimed and cultivated, premiums and revenue paid and pattas delayed through no fault of the allottee, rights arise from the rules and the conduct of the administration; Section 11 cannot be read to permit cancellation without legal grounds or compensation simply because pattas were not yet executed.

B. Appropriateness of Relief under Article 226

  1. The court considered and rejected the respondents' contentions that petitioners had an adequate alternative remedy (a suit) and that extraordinary relief should not be granted because petitioners were merely annual settlement-holders.
  2. The judges found the facts undisputed and the Government orders lacking legal justification. The pursuit of a long civil suit would produce harassment and undue hardship when the executive order was an impermissible attack on the petitioners' rights; therefore the alternative remedy was not an adequate or effective substitute under the circumstances.
  3. Both judges emphasised that whether the tenure is technically an "annual lease" was not critical to relief: even if the petitioners were annual lessees, the administrative records did not show any reason they would be denied renewal for at least the period in which they had satisfied the conditions (e.g., four years and payment of instalments). The Court declined to order immediate issuance of pattas, leaving such measures to the competent officers, but it held that the Government's reduction steps must not be given effect.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The application is allowed and the Rule made absolute.

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The orders of the Settlement Officer (notice dated 20-4-53) reducing the allotments from 20 bighas to 15 bighas and the Provincial Government's executive letter (No. RSG 107/52/53 dated 1-5-1952) directing such reduction are declared to be without jurisdiction and are not to be given effect so as to prejudice the settlements already made in favour of the petitioners.
  • The petitioners' settlements as originally made (20 bighas each) are protected from the challenged executive interference; the Court did not, at this stage, direct issuance of pattas but left that to the officers competent to make settlements and issue pattas to exercise their judicial or quasi-judicial discretion under the law and rules.

Broader implications: The Court concluded that the Provincial Government, by executive order, cannot lawfully undo or partially cancel completed allotments made under the notification and Settlement Rules; interference with completed allotments is permissible only by the statutory appellate/revisional mechanisms under the Land and Revenue Regulation. The Court granted relief under Article 226 because an alternative remedy by suit was not adequate or efficacious in all the circumstances.

Order: Application allowed; Rule made absolute; Government's reduction orders set aside and shall not be given effect so as to prejudice existing settlements.

    Abdul Gani And Others v. Settlement Officer, Nowgong And Others

    Sarjoo Prosad, C.J:— These ten petitioners have prayed for a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate Writ directing the State of Assam not to interfere with the settlement of lands already made in their favour, and the other opposite parties to refrain from reducing the areas settled with each of the petitioners under orders of the State Government.

    2. The material facts may be stated thus. The petitioners claim to be residents of village Padumani-Kismat in Mouza Namati, in the District of Nowgong. On their application, the Deputy Commissioner of Nowgong, by his order, dated 2-12-49, allotted 200 bighas of ‘Sarkari’ lands at the rate of 20 bighas to each of them. The petitioners made investments in reclaiming the lands and occupied and cultivated the same. They have been also paying the instalments of premia in respect of the lands allotted to them, for which they hold receipts, and have also made payments of the revenue regularly. It appears that subsequent to the allotments, some persons approached the authorities for converting those lands into a grazing reserve, but the Settlement Officer of Nowgong, after making due enquiries, rejected their objections and confirmed the settlements made with the petitioners. Since then the petitioners have been all along cultivating the lands according to the area of 20 bighas allotted to each of them and have been in peaceful occupation of the same. The boundaries of the lands in their respective occupation have also been demarcated by the ‘Mandal’, though, so far no ‘pattas’ have been issued to the petitioners. Nearly two years thereafter the Settlement Officer of Nowgong received a letter from the Under Secretary to the Government of Assam, wherein it was stated that although Government did not want to interfere with the settlement of lands already made with the petitioners, Abdul Gani and 9 others, Government considered that the allotment of lands at 20 bighas per head was more than what was justified, and that it should be reduced to 15 bighas per head. The Settlement Officer was accordingly requested to take necessary action to allot the lands at 15 bighas per head and give the remaining area to other landless people. This was by letter No. RSG 107/52/53, dated 1-5-1952 (Annexure ‘A’ to the petition). Page: 47The Settlement Officer then sent copy of the above Government order to the petitioners and informed them that by virtue of that order, the petitioners were given 15 bighas of land in place of 20 bighas each settled with them. This again was almost a year afterwards by notice, dated 20-4-53, Annexure ‘B’. The petitioners then moved the authorities concerned for recall of those orders, but were unsuccessful. The above orders are questioned by the petitioners as without any sanction in law and unwarranted interference with the settlements already made with the petitioners.

    3. In the report submitted by the Settlement Officer of Nowgong, the material facts are substantially admitted. He has not disputed that 200 bighas of ‘Sarkari’ waste lands in the village in question were allotted to the petitioners on 2-12-49 at the rate of 20 bighas each, as per orders of the then Deputy Commissioner, Mr. N. Kidwai. Since the allotments, the petitioners have admittedly paid three ‘kists’ of premium. The report shows that the fourth kist was due, but Mr. F.A Ahmad on behalf of the petitioners stated that they had since paid the fourth ‘kist’ also.

    4. It is also not disputed that they have been paying the land revenue in respect of the lands settled. The report shows that in view of the Government letter referred to above, the Settlement Officer reduced the allotments from 20 bighas to 15 bighas each. The settlement is reported to be not under the Colonisation Scheme, as suggested by the petitioners, but under the Development Rate Scheme (D.R.S) covered by Government Notification No. 4587, dated 12-9-41. A copy of the notification has been forwarded with the report of the Settlement Officer. The Officer further states that the area being under re-settlement operation, ‘pattas’ in respect of the settlements will be issued in the normal course of procedure.

    5. It appears from the above Government notification in relation to the said scheme that the waste lands in Namati and other villages should be settled at the rate of Rs. 2/- per bigha. This premium was payable in 4 equal instalments spread over four years, out of which the first instalment was to be paid on allotment, and the subsequent instalments in the succeeding three years. It also shows that the allotment, in the case of families having no lands of their own, will be normally about 30 bighas each though in other cases it may be less, and the Officer or the Sub-Deputy Collector in charge of the administration of the rules may allot reduced areas or even refuse allotment. In cases of allotments made, the allottees were to cultivate the land allotted and to reside thereon. They were to occupy the area allotted within four years of the allotment and, if any portion remained unoccupied on the conclusion of the period, it was to be deemed to that extent to have been cancelled. The land revenue and local rates were to be charged on the basis of the extent of land occupied from the year of occupation at the rate sanctioned by Government in respect of the village, or non-cadastral area (wherein the land lies) provided that it shall not be deemed to re-open, with a view to re-assessment, settlements already made. An important provision of the notification is that

    “an allottee or an annual settlement-holder shall have no transferable right or interest in the land covered by his allotment or annual patta;”

    any such transfer would entail cancellation of the allotment or the re-settlement as the case may be. But where a pattadar or lessee dies, the patta or allotment would ordinarily be granted to his heirs. The Sub-Deputy Collector in charge of the scheme of administration of these rules was to work under the control of the Deputy Commissioner and was to possess the powers of an Assistant Settlement Officer and Assistant Survey Officer and was competent to decide all disputes regarding allotment and occupation of land. This notification is dated 12-9-41 and purports to be made under R. 2 of the Settlement Rules framed under the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, in connection with the settlement of land in the villages mentioned therein, including Namati, where the disputed lands are.

    6. It is contended by Mr. Fakhruddin Ahmed on behalf of the petitioners that the settlements in the present case being admitted and having been validly made by the Deputy Commissioner and recognised by the Settlement Officer who were competent officers to make the settlements, it was no longer open to the Government to interfere with these settlements and reduce the areas settled. The petitioners having paid the premia and the revenue payable in respect of these lands, they had acquired a valuable right of property in these lands subject to the rules already framed. The rights and remedies of the parties will now be governed by the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, and Government could not go beyond their own rules affecting the settlements already made in favour of the petitioners. It is further pointed out that in view of the scheme itself, the area to be normally settled was about 30 bighas per family, and the petitioners obtained the settlement of only about 20 bighas of land each, which was much less than the normal standard.

    7. The contentions, in my opinion, are well-founded. Mr. Medhi on behalf of respondents has been at pains to discover some authority in law to support the orders in question. In the first place, he refers to S. 11, Land and Revenue Regulation, which provides that a ‘settlement-holder’ who is not a ‘land-holder’, has no rights in the land held by him beyond such as are expressed in his settlement lease. There are no documents of settlement leases in the present case, but the scheme notified by Government, under which the settlement appears to have been made, shows that “the allottee or an annual settlement-holder” had “no transferable right or interest in the land covered by his allotment or annual patta”. It is accordingly urged that it being in the nature of an annual lease, it could not enure beyond a period of one year, and under Rule 1(c) of the Settlement Rules framed under the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, it conferred no right in the soil beyond a right of user for the year for which it was given, and Page: 48it also conferred no right of transfer or inheritance beyond the year of issue.

    8. The petitioners' case is that so far no pattas have been issued to them, and the notification shows that at any rate the premium payable by them was payable in four equal instalments spread over a period of four years. The petitioners have been admittedly paying the premium as also the land-revenue. The settlements, therefore, were bound to enure at least for that period of four years. The settlements in the present case appear to have been made by an order, dated 2-12-49, and the Rule nisi was obtained in August last. It is, therefore, difficult to say that the petitioners had no subsisting rights in the lands, for the protection of which they could seek the intervention of this Court by virtue of a prerogative writ. Besides, the notification shows that even on the death of the allottee or the ‘pattadar’, the settlement should ordinarily be granted to his heirs, and under Rule 13 of the Settlement Rules framed under the Regulation, it was open to the Deputy Commissioner or other officer specially empowered in this behalf to convert an annual lease into a periodic lease in accordance with such instructions as may be issued from time to time for his guidance by the Provincial Government. Whatever the position may be, there is no doubt that the petitioners had a valuable right to protect arising under the above settlements of these lands, which right has been put in jeopardy by the orders complained of.

    9. Mr. Medhi then relies on R. 2 of the Rules in support of the Government order. Rule 2 runs as follows:

    “The disposal of waste land required for ordinary or special cultivation or for building purposes will, subject to the general or special orders of the Provincial Government, vest in the Deputy Commissioner, who will dispose of such land by grant, lease or otherwise in the manner and subject to the conditions set forth in the rules following provided that the Deputy Commissioner may expressly reserve any such land from settlement.”

    10. It is obvious that the Deputy Commissioner had not reserved any portion of the disputed lands from settlement, and the attempt to convert them into a grazing reserve had failed. The Provincial Government had passed orders as embodied in the notification, dated 12-9-41, for making settlements of these waste lands. Subject to this notification, the lands were vested in the Deputy Commissioner who was competent to dispose of them by lease or otherwise according to the provisions of the Rules. This the Deputy Commissioner had actually done, and I do not see how the Provincial Government, by an executive order, could affect the rights of the petitioners arising under the settlements when the Rules do not make any such exception.

    11. Mr. Medhi, however, contends that the words “general or special orders of the Provincial Government” appearing in R. 2 signify that at any stage the Provincial Government could pass ‘special orders’ regulating the settlements or nullifying the same. I do not think that R. 2 can reasonably bear such an Interpretation, because otherwise it would have the effect of completely setting at naught the provisions in the Regulation itself dealing with the right of appeal to the Commissioner or to this Court, and also the power of the Commissioner and the High Court to call for proceedings of the subordinate Courts and to pass such orders thereon as was considered to be appropriate. It is fundamental that a rule-making body cannot frame rules in conflict with or derogating from the substantive provisions of the law or statute under which the rules are framed. Rule 2, therefore, has got to be interpreted in such a way as to be consistent with the provisions of the Regulation itself. In my opinion, the words ‘general or special orders’, though somewhat broad in their import, cannot mean that at any stage, the Government can interfere with the settlements effected by the Deputy Commissioner. These general or special orders would relate to a stage when the Deputy Commissioner has not already created rights in favour of third parties. The order of the Provincial Government directing reduction of the area already settled with the petitioners is, therefore, without any warrant in law.

    12. The question then arises whether in a case like this, we should interfere under Article 226 of the Constitution by issuing a prerogative writ. Two considerations are mainly urged in this connection. The first is that the petitioners have another remedy by way of a suit, and secondly, that the petitioners are merely annual settlement-holders and cannot claim that the authorities responsible for renewing or making the settlement should be compelled to do so in their favour. As to the alternative remedy, the point which needs consideration is — whether the remedy would be equally efficacious and prompt. The substantial facts in this case are undisputed. On those facts, it is an unauthorised attack on the petitioners' rights. We have noticed that the orders in question have no justification in law. In these circumstances, it would be sheer harassment of the petitioners to be left to follow a long and tedious remedy by way of a suit.

    13. On the second ground, I am doubtful if the petitioners are merely annual lease-holders. Be that as it may, the Deputy Commissioner or the Settlement Officer does not say that, for any reason, these petitioners are not entitled to a renewal of the lease; to say the least, at any rate for a period of four years, they were certainly entitled to remain in occupation of the lands from the date of the settlement in their favour. Whether at a subsequent stage, the Deputy Commissioner or the Settlement Officer would be guided by the suggestion contained in that Government letter and reduce the area under settlement with the petitioners, is not our concern at present. Nor do I think it is necessary to direct the issue of pattas in favour of the petitioners at this stage.

    14. Ordinarily, on the facts stated above, I see no reason why the petitioners should not be entitled to the issue of pattas or the renewal of the annual lease, even if it is held that they are annual lessees; but these are matters which have to be left to the officers competent and responsible for making settlements and issuing pattas. Page: 49They have to exercise their own judicial or quasi-judicial discretion in these matters subject to the law and the rules framed thereunder. The point as to the actual nature of the tenure, whether annual or permanent, was not at length argued before us even on behalf of the petitioners, and I do not feel impelled to commit myself finally on the question.

    15. All that I need say at present is that the steps taken by the Settlement Officer, reducing the area of the settlements made with the petitioners, under his notice, dated 20-4-53, and in pursuance of the illegal order of Government contained in their letter No. RSG. 107/52/53, dated 1st May, 1952, are entirely without jurisdiction. It is, therefore, directed that those orders shall not be given effect to so as to prejudice the settlements already made with these petitioners. On the above terms, the application is allowed and the Rule made absolute.

    Ram Labhaya, J.:— I agree to the order proposed. I would add a few words.

    16. It is a common ground that the land was settled on the petitioners under orders of the Government of Assam passed under R. 2 of the Settlement Rules framed under the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation vide Notification No. 4587-R dated 12-9-41.

    17. The order under R. 2 regulates settlement of land in Mouzas, Hajoi, Namati and Lanka lying outside the Nikir Hills in the district of Nowgong.

    18. Under para 5 of the order, waste land could be occupied only on application. Para 6 lays down conditions under which the allotment of land may be made. It also provides for the maximum extent of allotment in any single case. The Sub-Deputy Collector is charged with the duty of allotment. The allottee must cultivate the land allotted and must also reside on the land unless permitted by the Deputy Commissioner to reside elsewhere.

    19. Para 8 is important. It provides that the area allotted must be completely occupied within four years. If ‘any portion remains unoccupied at the expiry of four years, the allotment in respect of that portion shall be deemed to be cancelled.’ Failure to occupy results in automatic cancellation of the allotment of the unoccupied part.

    20. Land revenue and local rates are to be charged on the basis of the extent of land occupied but the ‘settlement cannot be re-opened with a view to re-assessment’.

    21. Para 10 provides that an allottee or an annual settlement-holder shall have no transferable right or interest in the land covered by the allotment or the annual patta as the case may be. The consequences that follow such a prohibited transfer are specified. In case of death of the allottee or the pattadar, the provision of the rule is that the patta or the allotment shall ordinarily be’ granted to his heirs.

    22. It is only in this para that an allottee and an annual settlement-holder are placed on the same level in the matter of transfer and in regard to succession. The implication of this para may be that apart from allotments covered by paras 6 to 8, lands may be given on annual leases. Another possibility is that the provision in regard to annual settlements was considered necessary in view of annual settlement made before the Notification No. 4587-R, dated 12-9-1941 was issued. But it will be seen that it is only for purposes of para 10 that allotments under paras 6 to 8 are placed on the same footing with an annual settlement or lease. In other respects the incidents of the two kinds of settlement are different. An annual lease is a lease granted for one year only and confers no right in the soil beyond the right of user for the year for which it is given. Vide Rule 1(c) of the Settlement Rules. Such a lease confers no right of transfer or of inheritance beyond the year of issue or of sub-letting.

    23. Para 10 apparently deals with two kinds of settlement. An allottee, and an annual settlement-holder have not been used as interchangeable terms. An allottee under paras 6 to 8 can in no sense be regarded as a settlement-holder for one year only. This would be opposed to the very terms of the allotment, which gives him four years within which to occupy the entire land. If he fails to occupy the entire land, the allotment in regard to the unoccupied portion alone stands cancelled. This involves an implied recognition of the position that the allotment is final and enures even beyond the period of four years without renewal and that it can only be partially cancelled on the default of the allottee to occupy it in its entirety. The condition that the settlement cannot be re-opened with a view to re-assessment also shows that it is not limited to a year.

    24. Restrictions on transfer and preference of the heirs on the occasion of the death of the allottee also indicate that the tenure is not limited to a year nor is there any suggestion in the entire arrangement to the effect that it is renewable periodically. An allottee under the notification No. 4587-R cannot be appropriately described as an annual lessee. He answers the description of a settlement-holder as defined in S. 3(h).

    25. The Sub-Deputy Collector exercising the powers of the Assistant Settlement Officer and Assistant Survey Officer is invested with jurisdiction to decide all disputes regarding allotment and occupation of land, though he is to act in the exercise of the jurisdiction under the control of the Deputy Commissioner.

    26. The facts are not disputed. Land measuring 20 bighas has been allotted to each of the petitioners by order of the Deputy Commissioner, dated 2-12-49. The petitioners claim to have reclaimed the land after occupation and they assert that they are cultivating it. They have been paying land revenue regularly and they have committed no default in the payment of specified instalments towards the premium due from each. The period of four years allowed for occupation has expired and it is not the case of the opposite party that any part of the area in any case remained unoccupied. The allotment in each case is complete. Nothing remains to be done Page: 50under the notification No. 4587-R, dated 12-9-41 which specifically provides for allotment of land in certain villages.

    27. Rule 2 of the Settlement Rules under which notification No. 4587-R has been issued cannot be pressed into service by the Provincial Government for partial cancellation of a completed allotment. It vests the disposal of waste lands in the Deputy Commissioner subject to the general or special order of the Provincial Government. He is ‘bound’ also in disposing of waste lands by grant, lease, or otherwise by the requirements of the Settlement Rules. The exercise of jurisdiction vested in the Deputy Commissioner can be subject to general or special orders that may be existing at the time of the disposal of the land. He is bound by such orders when exercising his power under R. 2. The power to dispose of land under R. 2 may be taken away or reduced by any general order as was done by the Notification in question which gives a great deal of the power of the Deputy Commissioner to the Sub-Deputy Collector for allotment of land under the notification. Such general or special orders which bind the Deputy Commissioner under R. 2 ought to be in existence at the time he decides to dispose of waste lands. The Rule does not reserve any kind of appellate, revisional or supervisory jurisdiction for the Provincial Government. It does not at all justify undoing or cancelling completed settlements or allotment in individual cases.

    28. Rule 26 of the Settlement Rules also may not be relied on in justification of the order of the Provincial Government. Under this Rule, the Commissioner has the power to confirm all settlements and also to cancel any lease, or settlement made in contravention of the Rules. The exercise of this power is also subject to the general control of the Provincial Government. The note added to R. 26 by Government by its letter No. R.S 137/45/2, dated 29-11-1945 makes it clear that the power of the Commissioner is neither appellate nor revisional and has to be exercised in uncontested cases. The general control of the Provincial Government is on this jurisdiction and not on the exercise of judicial powers by competent authorities under the Land and Revenue Regulation. This para affords a clue also to the interpretation of R. 2 of the Settlement Rules. Even there, the Government was not reserving any appellate or revisional powers in itself.

    29. Allotments and settlements create legal rights. Even when no pattas are executed, the legal rights may come into existence. Interference with allotments or settlements is possible only under the Land and Revenue Regulation by the appellate or revisional authorities. It would not be open to the Government acting under R. 2 to interfere with a particular settlement on the ground that in its opinion, a settlement of a slightly smaller area would have met the needs of the case, after it has become an accomplished fact. The Government may issue, general or special orders or executive instructions for the guidance of its officers charged with the duty of making settlements but when once a settlement or an allotment is complete, it can be interfered with only on legal grounds by competent authorities under the Land and Revenue Regulation.

    30. The learned Government Advocate has also relied on S. 11 of the Land and Revenue Regulation. It defines the rights of the settlement-holder other than a land-holder. According to this section, he has no right in the land held by him beyond such as are expressed in his settlement lease. The expression ‘settlement-holder’ is defined in S. 3, cl. (h). Settlement-holder means any person other than a proprietor who has entered into an engagement with the Crown to pay land revenue and it includes a landholder. All that the definition requires is that there should be an engagement with the Government to pay the land revenue by a person other than a proprietor. The executoin of a patta is not a necessary ingredient. The engagement confers the status of the settlement-holder. But a settlement-holder can have no greater rights than those expressed in the settlement lease as provided by S. 11. This section does contemplate the execution of a settlement lease in each case; even so the provision may not be utilised to support the contention that no kinds of rights are created until the patta is actually executed. The patta or the lease deeds may take long in coming. Till then the rights will be determined by the rules under which the settlement is made or by the general law of the land. Where land is surveyed, measured and delivered to an allottee, where it is reclaimed and brought under cultivation, where premium has been paid and revenue is being paid and where execution of the patta is delayed for no fault of the settlement-holder, no unrestricted right to cancel or revoke the settlement without any refund of the money paid by him or payment of compensation for making the land culturable can be inferred from S. 11. Even if a patta is not executed, in such circumstances, there are legal rights in an allottee who has occupied the land under an allotment. In reducing the area of the allotment, the Provincial Government did not propose or purport to act under this section. It affords no answer to the contention raised on behalf of the petitioners. The order of the Government reducing the area of allotment in each case has no legal justification and is in excess of authority.

    31. I entirely agree with my Lord the Chief Justice that it is a proper case in which relief under Article 226 may be granted. Another remedy is available to the petitioners. But that remedy cannot be regarded as appropriate or effective in this case. The only material issue in the case is whether the Government had the jurisdiction to reduce the area of the settlement in the circumstances of the present case. There is no dispute on facts. The rule that the extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 may not be invoked where another remedy is available, is not invariable. Its application depends on the circumstances of each case. The petitioners held the land under allotments made in conformity with the direction contained in the notification No. 4587-R. Their tenure is not so precarious as that of an annual lessee. An annual lease is a lease for one year only. Its description as an annual Page: 51lease is anamolous and misleading. An allotment under Notification No. 4587-R does not create an annual lease which requires renewal at the expiry of each year for its continuity. On the other hand, an allottee under the notification does not stand in need of any renewal. There is no provision for renewal. The tenure is not limited to a year or to any specified time. An order which is without jurisdiction and which takes away rights of the holder of the land may appropriately be set aside under Article 226. The pursuit of the alternative remedy involves great hardship which may with abundant justification be relieved.

    32. Application allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Abdul Gani And Others v. Settlement Officer, Nowgong And Others
    (Apr 27, 1954)