AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 41, rules 5 and 6. These provisions are:5.(1)
  • Order 41, rule 6(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Order 41 rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 41 rule 6(2), Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order 41, rule 5(1) Civil Procedure Code,
  • ORDER 41 RULE 5 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 115 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 47 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • provisions of Order 41, rule 6(2)
  • sub-rule (1) or sub-rule (2)
  • sub-rule (3) to rule 6
  • Order 41, rule 6(2).
  • Order 11, rule 6(2)
  • Order 41, rule 6
  • Order 41, rule 5
  • Order 41, rule
  • sub-rule (3),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 41, rules 5 and 6. These provisions are:5.(1)
  • Order 41, rule 6(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Order 41 rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 41 rule 6(2), Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order 41, rule 5(1) Civil Procedure Code,
  • ORDER 41 RULE 5 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 115 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 47 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • provisions of Order 41, rule 6(2)
  • sub-rule (1) or sub-rule (2)
  • sub-rule (3) to rule 6
  • Order 41, rule 6(2).
  • Order 11, rule 6(2)
  • Order 41, rule 6
  • Order 41, rule 5
  • Order 41, rule
  • sub-rule (3),
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition for revision challenges the order of the Sub Judge, 1st Class, Sunam, dated 22nd August 1964, which refused the judgment-debtor's prayer to stay the sale of immovable property under Order 41, rule 6(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure until the appeal was disposed of. The petitioner was subject to a money decree against which a Regular First Appeal was pending in this Court. An interim stay of execution was initially granted but later vacated after the decree-holders applied for its vacation. The executing Court had passed an order for sale of the property, following which the judgment-debtors applied for a stay of sale under Order 41, rule 6(2), which was dismissed by the Sub Judge. The present revision petition was filed challenging that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the executing Court is obligated to stay the sale of immovable property under Order 41, rule 6(2) upon application by the judgment-debtor, despite a prior refusal of stay under Order 41, rule 5 by the appellate Court.
  2. Whether the order refusing stay of sale by the Sub Judge was a correct exercise of jurisdiction in light of the provisions of Order 41, rules 5 and 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  3. Whether the prior refusal of stay under Order 41, rule 5 by the appellate Court precludes the executing Court from granting stay under Order 41, rule 6(2).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The learned Sub Judge failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in him by law by refusing to stay the sale under Order 41, rule 6(2).
  • The High Court’s earlier order refusing stay under Order 41, rule 5 did not preclude the Sub Judge from granting stay under Order 41, rule 6(2).
  • The executing Court is obligated to stay the sale on such terms as to giving security or otherwise until the appeal is disposed of.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The order of Capoor J. refusing stay under Order 41, rule 5 finally concluded the matter.
  • The refusal to stay sale by the Sub Judge was justified as the High Court had already dealt with the stay application.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Firm Phallu Mal Hira Lal v. Banarsi Das, A.I.R 1924 Lah. 631 Executing Court's obligation to stay sale under Order 41, rule 6(2) Held that the executing Court cannot summarily reject application under rule 6(2) and must stay sale on suitable terms.
Firm Phaggu Mal Mata Din v. Banarsi Das, A.I.R 1924 Lah. 671 Appealability of refusal to stay sale under Order 41, rule 6(2) Held refusal to stay sale is appealable and Court must act under rule 6(2) when application is made.
Sankar Das v. Kasturi Lal, A.I.R 1925 Lah. 69 Conditions for stay under Order 41, rule 6(2) Held that requiring full deposit before stay defeats rule's object and is invalid.
P.C Thirumalai Goundar v. Town Bank Ltd. Pollachi, A.I.R 1934 Mad. 709 Conditions for stay of sale under Order 41, rule 6(2) Held Court may impose conditions such as deposit of decretal amount for stay.
Ram Nath Singh v. Raja Kamleshwar Prasad Singh Conditions for stay under Order 41, rule 6(2) Supported Madras High Court's view allowing imposition of conditions for stay.
Gian Chand v. Manohar Lal, A.I.R 1929 Lah. 68 Application of Order 41, rule 6(2) after sale but before confirmation Held rule 6(2) applies even after sale but before confirmation of sale.
Yelamanchili Satyanarayanamma v. Yelamanchili Nageswara Rao, (1959) 2 And. W.R 439 Stage of application under Order 41, rule 6(2) Held application under rule 6(2) must be before sale; after sale stage is different and trial Court can refuse confirmation.
Dhirendra Nath Roy v. Sailaj Kumar Bose, A.I.R 1940 Cal. 582 Jurisdiction to stay sale under Order 41, rule 6(2) despite refusal under rule 5 Held that refusal of stay under rule 5 does not bar Court from granting stay under rule 6(2) on suitable terms.
Jugal Prasad Missir v. Jadubans Naraiyan Missir, I.L.R 1941 Pat. 483 Adverse comment on Allahabad High Court's interpretation of rule 6 Supported view that sale shall be stayed under rule 6(2) and criticized contrary interpretation.
Har Narain Sahi v. Sadhu Govind Rai Interpretation of sub-rule (3) to rule 6 as complementary to rule 5 Decision was adversely commented upon; court held sale shall be stayed under rule 6(2).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the interplay between Order 41 rules 5 and 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Rule 5 generally governs stay of execution pending appeal and requires sufficient cause and security, but does not automatically stay execution upon filing appeal. Rule 6(2) specifically mandates the executing Court to stay sale of immovable property on application by the judgment-debtor and on such terms as to giving security or otherwise until the appeal is disposed of.

The Court noted that although the appellate Court had refused stay under rule 5 before any sale order, no sale order had been made at that time. Therefore, the executing Court retained jurisdiction under rule 6(2) to consider the stay application on its merits after the sale order was passed.

The Court reviewed precedents from various High Courts, observing that the executing Court cannot summarily reject an application under rule 6(2) and must consider suitable terms for stay. It also distinguished the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s obiter observations in Yelamanchili Satyanarayanamma’s case, which were based on applications made after sale but before confirmation, a stage different from the present case.

Rejecting the respondents’ contention that the appellate Court’s refusal under rule 5 precluded the trial Court from acting under rule 6(2), the Court held that the trial Court must exercise its jurisdiction independently on the application under rule 6(2). The impugned order dismissing the stay application was therefore a denial of jurisdiction.

Accordingly, the Court allowed the revision petition, quashed the Sub Judge’s order, and directed the trial Court to decide the stay application under Order 41, rule 6(2) on merits, including the imposition of appropriate terms.

Holding and Implications

Petition allowed.

The Court held that the executing Court has jurisdiction and is obligated to consider and potentially grant a stay of sale under Order 41, rule 6(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, even if a prior stay under Order 41, rule 5 was refused by the appellate Court before the sale order was made. The refusal of the stay application by the Sub Judge was quashed for denial of jurisdiction. The matter was remanded to the trial Court for fresh consideration on merits with power to impose suitable terms, including security.

This decision directly affects the parties by restoring the judgment-debtors’ right to seek a stay of sale pending appeal under rule 6(2). No new precedent beyond the correct application of existing procedural provisions was established.

    Jangir Singh And Others v. Mst. Nihal Kaur And Others

    D.K Mahajan, J.:— This petition for revision is directed against the order of the Sub Judge, 1st Class, Sunam, dated 22nd August, 1964, whereby the Sub Judge refused the prayer of the judgment-debtor under Order 41, rule 6(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure. The prayer was that the sale be stayed on such terms as giving the security or otherwise as the Court may think fit until the appeal is disposed of.

    2. A decree for money was passed against the petitioner. Against that decree Regular First Appeal No. 406 of 1963 is pending in this Court. When the appeal was admitted interim stay of execution was granted. The decree-holders made an application for vacation of the interim stay. The matter, whether the stay should or should not continue, came up before Capoor J. and the learned Judge passed the following order:—

    “Mr. Puran Chand, learned counsel for the decree-holders, points out that the decree in question is a money decree and unless there are very exceptional reasons, stay of money decree is not ordered. He further points out that Shrimati Nihal Kaur decree-holder is the widow and the other decree-holders are the sons of the deceased Sahni Singh and they have no source of livelihood so that the ad interim stay order of this Court is operating as a great hardship. All that Mr. Agnihotri, on behalf of the appellants, could say in reply is that if the land of the judgment-debtors, who are in jail, is sold, they will be put to great loss. However, as there is a money decree against the judgment-debtors, it is incumbent on them to satisfy it, subject of course, to the decision in the appeal. Mr. Agnihotri prays that the judgment-debtors may be allowed a months' time to deposit the amount in Court and further that in case deposit is made the decree-holders should not be allowed to withdraw that amount unless they furnish security for restitution to the satisfaction of the executing Court and with notice to the judgment-debtor appellants. I order accordingly. If the deposit of the decretal amount is not made within a month, the decree-holders will be entitled to take out execution. No order as to costs.”

    In pursuance of this order the judgment-debtors could not deposit the decretal amount with the result that the execution was taken out in the executing Court. During the course of the execution, the executing Court passed an order for sale of the property. After this order the judgment-debtors made an application under Order 41, rule 6(2). That application has been disposed of by the learned Sub-Judge by his order, which Page: 462is the subject matter of this revision petition. The relevant part of this order reads thus:—

    “there is absolutely no occasion or reason for ordering the stay of the execution. If the stay is granted, it would not only be an unreasonable impediment on the decree-holder in the execution of his decree but it would also be in violation of the orders of the Hon'ble High Court. The application for stay is, therefore, not maintainable and is hereby dismissed.”

    It is against this decision that the present petition for revision has been preferred by the judgment-debtors. The contention of Mr. D.C Gupta, learned counsel for the petitioners is that the learned Sub Judge has failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in him by law in refusing to stay the sale. It is contended that the order of the High Court did not stand in the way of the learned Sub Judge as to the prayer under Order 41, rule 6(2). In order to properly appreciate the various decisions that have been given from time to time on this provision, it will be proper to set out the provisions of Order 41, rules 5 and 6. These provisions are:—

    “5.(1) An appeal shall not operate as a stay of proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except so far as the Appellate Court may order, nor shall execution of a decree be stayed by reason only of an appeal having been preferred from the decree; but the Appellate Court may for sufficient cause order stay of execution of such decree.

    (2) Where an application is made for stay of execution of an appealable decree before the expiration of the time allowed for appealing therefrom, the Court which passed the decree may on sufficient cause being shown order the execution to be stayed.

    (3) No order for stay of execution shall be made under sub-rule (1) or sub-rule (2) unless the Court making it is satisfied—

    (a) that substantial loss may result to the party applying for stay of execution unless the order is made;

    (b) that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and

    (c) that security has been given by the applicant for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding upon him;

    (4) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (3), the Court may make an ex-parte order for stay of execution pending the hearing of the application.

    6.(1) Where an order is made for the execution of a decree from which an appeal is pending the Court which passed the decree shall, on sufficient cause being shown by the appellant, require security to be taken for the restitution of any property which may be or has been taken in execution of the decree or for the payment of the value of such property and for the due performance of the decree or order of the Appellate Court, or the Appellate Court may for like cause direct the Court which passed the decree to take such security.

    (2) Where an order has been made for the sale of immoveable property in execution of a decree, the sale shall, on the application of the judgment-debtor to the Court which made the order, be stayed on such terms as to giving security or otherwise as the Court thinks fit until the appeal is disposed of.”

    So far as the provisions of Order 41 rule 6(2) are concerned, there can be no dispute that the executing Court must on application of the judgment-debtor stay sale of immoveable property on such terms as to giving of security or otherwise, until the appeal against its decree is disposed, of. The difficulty only arises in those cases where the judgment-debtor has gone up in appeal against the decree and had prayed for the stay of execution under Order 41 rule 5 and his prayer had been refused Page: 463by the appellate Court. There is no direct authority of this Court or that of the Lahore High Court on this point. What has been held in various cases which have arisen under Order 41 rule 6(2) was that it is incumbent on the executing Court to stay the sale in terms of Order 41, rule 6(2). In Firm Phallu Mal Hira Lal v. Banarsi Das A.I.R 1924 Lah. 631, it was held that “the executing Court could not summarily reject the application under Order 41, rule 6(2). It was obligatory on the Court to stay the sale on such terms as to giving security, or otherwise as it thought fit.” In Firm Phaggu Mal Mata Din v. Banarsi Das A.I.R 1924 Lah. 671, another decision of the Lahore High Court by Moti Sagar J. the learned Judge took the view that, “an order refusing to stay a sale of immoveable property in execution of a decree during the pendency of an appeal in the High Court under Order 41 rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Code is appealable as a decree under section 47, Civil Procedure Code. It was further held that the Court was bound to act under Order 41, rule 6(2) when an application was made by the judgment-debtor”. In Sankar Das and v. Kasturi Lal A.I.R 1925 Lah. 69, Martineau J. took the view that, “the imposition of condition that the entire decretal amount should be deposited before the sale could be stayed under Order 41 rule 6(2) was to defeat the very object of the rule, therefore, such a condition was against the spirit of the rule and could not be upheld.” This view of the learned Judge did not find favour with the Madras High Court in P.C Thirumalai Goundar v. Town Bank Ltd. Pollachi A.I.R 1934 Mad. 709 where the Division Bench of the Madras High Court took a different view. It was held in that case that the Court would impose such a condition. A similar view to that of the Madras High Court in P.C Thirumalai Goundar v. Town Bank Ltd. Pollachi A.I.R 1934 Mad. 709 was taken by a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in Ram Nath Singh v. Raja Kamleshwar Prasad Singh5. In Gian Chand v. Manohar Lal A.I.R 1929 Lah. 68, Zafar Ali J. took the same view as was taken by Moti Sagar J. in the Firm Phaggu Mat Mata Din's case A.I.R 1924 Lah. 671. The learned Judge proceeded further and held that where the property had been sold but the sale had not been confirmed, the provisions of Order 41, rule 6(2) will still apply. The observations of Zafar Ali J. run counter to those of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Yelamanchili Satyanarayanamma…* v. Yelamanchili Nageswara Rao…. (1959) 2 and. W.R 439 wherein Sanjeeva Row Nayudu, made the following observations:—

    “There is a good deal of difference between the stage before the sale is held and the stage after the sale is held; for in the latter stage, the rights of third parties would come in, and there are bound to be other complications. It is for this reason that the sub-rule advisedly fixed the time when the application should be made, that is, when an order has been made for the sale of immoveable property. The learned Subordinate Judge is clearly wrong in thinking that the expressions ‘order for sale’ in Order 41 rule 6(2), Civil Procedure Code, includes the holding of the sale and the confirmation thereof.”

    3. As is apparent from what has been stated above, none of these cases deal with the points that fall for determination in this petition, Reference has also been made to Dhirendra Nath Roy… v. Sailaj Kumar Bose…Opposite Party* A.I.R 1940 Cal. 582 wherein the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court took the view that “where an order has been made for sale and an application under Order 41, rule 6 has been made to the Court, the Court should stay the sale on suitable terms and the Court must consider what terms are suitable. Page: 464The fact that the stay has been refused under Order 41, rule 5 does not justify the Court in refusing to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it under Order 41, rule 6.” Reliance was placed upon Jitendra Nath Choudhuri v. Bholanath Choudhury9 for the above proposition. It was observed by Edgley J. that “although an application for stay of execution of a decree, made under Order 41, rule 5(1) Civil Procedure Code, may have been refused by the appellate Court, still after an order for sale of immovable property in execution of the decree has been made, the Court making such order has jurisdiction to, and indeed must, stay the sale on terms as to security or otherwise.”

    4. On the other hand, in a decision of the Allahabad High Court in Har Narain Sahi…(Judgment-Debtor); v. Sadhu Govind Rai…(Decree-Holder).*10, it was observed that sub-rule (3) to rule 6 is only complementary to rule 5. This decision was, however, adversely commented upon in Jugal Prasad Missir v. Jadubans Naraiyan Missir I.L.R 1941 Pat. 483. While dealing with the Allahabad case, Chatterji J. observed as follows:—

    “With all respect to the learned Judge, I must say that this is against the express provision of the rule itself, which says that the sale shall be stayed.”

    Therefore, it will appear from what has been stated above that the only direct case on the point is of the Calcutta High Court in Dhirendra Nath Roy… v. Sailaj Kumar Bose…Opposite Party* A.I.R 1940 Cal. 582. There are certain observations in Yelemanchili Satyanarayanamma's case (1959) 2 and. W.R 439 which run counter to the view taken by the Calcutta High Court. But these observations are obiter because in that case an order under Order 41 rule 6(2) was passed after the sale had been conducted and was pending confirmation. Therefore, the stage for making an application under Order 41 rule 6(2) had passed in that case and as observed therein, the trial Court had jurisdiction, when the sale had been held, to refuse its confirmation. It appears to me that the rule laid down by the Calcutta High Court is the correct rule. The only exception I can see to it is where a sale had been ordered by the trial Court and an application is made to the appellate Court for stay of the sale and that application is rejected by the appellate Court. In such a situation the rule in the obiter observation of the learned Judge of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Yelemanchili Satyanarayanamma's case (1959) 2 and. W.R 439 will hold good.

    5. Mr. Puran Chand learned counsel for the respondents contended that the order of Capoor J. refusing stay under Order 41, rule 5, Civil Procedure Code, finally concluded the matter. This argument loses sight of the fact that no order for sale had been made when the High Court dealt with the matter. Therefore it cannot be said that the High Court was seized of the matter which fell for decision by the trial Court on the judgment-debtor's application under Order 41 rule 6(2) or that on the same matter there is a decision by the appellate Court, by reason of which the trial Court will be precluded from acting under Order 41, rule 6(2). In the present case it was open to the trial Court to consider the application of the judgment-debtors on merits and impose such conditions on the judgment debtors including conditions to the deposit of the decretal amount subject to which the order for stay under Order 41 rule 6(2) would be granted. It could not refuse the application of the judgment-debtors on the ground that the matter had been settled by this Court. As there has been a denial of jurisdiction by the trial Court to decide the matter, I would in the exercise of my jurisdiction under section 115 Civil Procedure Code, allow this petition, quash the impugned order and direct the trial Court to decide the application of the judgment-debtors under Order 11, rule 6(2) on merits. Costs will be cost in the main execution application.

    6. Parties are directed to appear before the trial Court on 14th December, 1964.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jangir Singh And Others v. Mst. Nihal Kaur And Others
    (Nov 26, 1964)