AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion — S.S. Sudhalkar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Insurance Company (appellant) challenged an award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal. The claim petition had been filed by the widow and daughter of the deceased, Ajit Singh, who died in a motor accident. The Tribunal had awarded compensation (including interest at the rate of 12% per annum) to the claimants, and the Insurance Company appealed against that award. The present opinion records the hearing of that appeal and concludes with the dismissal of the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there was collusion between the claimants and the driver/owner, in light of an apparent discrepancy in the vehicle number recorded in the FIR (640) and the vehicle number insured with the appellant (040), and whether the Tribunal's finding as to the identity of the vehicle (Matador No. 040) is sustainable.
  2. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased's monthly income at Rs. 3,000, given a claimed basic pay scale of Rs. 950–1800.
  3. Whether the rate of interest awarded by the Tribunal (12% per annum) should be reduced, including whether delay in litigation justifies a reduction of interest.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Insurance Company)

  • There was collusion between the respondents-claimants and the driver and owner of the vehicle; the FIR records the vehicle number as 640 whereas the vehicle insured with the appellant bears number 040.
  • Because of the discrepancy in the vehicle number in the FIR, the respondents-claimants' evidence should be discarded or treated with suspicion.
  • The deceased's income was assessed incorrectly by the Tribunal; the proper basis for assessing income should be the basic pay scale of Rs. 950–1800, and therefore the Tribunal's finding of Rs. 3,000 per month is erroneous.
  • The Tribunal erred in awarding interest at 12% per annum; reliance was placed on Kaushnuma Begum v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., which, according to the appellant, suggests a lower rate (9%) is reasonable in changed economic conditions.
  • Delay in the proceedings, according to the appellant, should preclude awarding interest at the rate of 12% per annum.

Respondents' / Tribunal-supporting Material (as reflected in the opinion)

  • Witnesses deposed that the vehicle number was 040 (not 640), and the Tribunal found that the vehicle involved was a Matador bearing No. 040.
  • Deposition of PW2 (Senior Assistant, PHC Sahnewal, Ludhiana) stated that although the basic pay scale was Rs. 950–1800, the deceased's salary was about Rs. 3,500–4,000 per month, supporting the Tribunal's assessment of Rs. 3,000 per month as not erroneous.
  • The Tribunal had already awarded interest at 12% and the respondents relied on the Tribunal's findings and supporting evidence; the opinion does not record further distinct submissions from the respondents' counsel beyond the evidence relied upon by the Tribunal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kaushnuma Begum v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (reported in 2001 ACJ 428) Consideration of an appropriate rate of interest under the Motor Vehicles Act; noted that earlier 12% had been considered reasonable but changes in economy/RBI policy justified a lower rate (court in that case fixed 9% per annum). The court distinguished the present case from Kaushnuma Begum: Kaushnuma involved circumstances where the Supreme Court fixed interest at 9% (and the award in that case was not originally made by the Tribunal). The present Court did not accept the appellant's submission to reduce the rate on that basis.
Rathi Menon v. Union of India (reported as 2001 (2) T.A.C 250 (SC)) Affirmation of awarding interest at 12% per annum (in that case the Supreme Court directed payment with 12% interest). The court noted that Rathi Menon, delivered after Kaushnuma Begum, awarded interest at 12% and used this as authority supporting confirmation of the Tribunal's 12% interest award in the present case.
United India Insurance Company Ltd v. Narendra Pandurang Kadam (1995 (1) TAC 621 (SC)) Principal that interest may be awarded but not from a date earlier than the date of the claim; Section 110-CC (as cited) indicates interest can be fixed by the Tribunal but cannot be made payable from a date earlier than the date of claim. The court cited this three-Judge judgment to explain the permissible temporal scope of awarding interest and to support the analysis of when interest may properly run. The opinion refers to paragraph 8 of that judgment.
Dr. (Mrs.) R.K. Tandon v. Om Parkash (2000 (1) TAC 212 (SC)) Support for awarding interest at 12% per annum and for awarding interest from the date of application; the Supreme Court in that case ordered interest at 12% from the date of application. The court relied on this decision to support the proposition that 12% interest is awardable and that awarding interest from the date of application is justified; it used this as a basis to confirm the Tribunal's 12% interest award.
Bhanuprasad Maganlal Bhatnagar v. Pravin Tapubhai Naik (Division Bench, Gujarat High Court, 1981 (22) Gujarat Law Reporter 1271) Principle that insurers/ tortfeasors benefit from the use of money during litigation; therefore, it is appropriate that insurers bear the burden of interest for the period of delay. The court relied on this Division Bench judgment to reject the appellant's contention that delay should defeat or reduce interest; the court adopted the view that the insurer benefits from delay and so should bear interest liability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by addressing each of the appellant's primary contentions in turn and applied the Tribunal's factual findings together with cited authorities to reach its conclusion.

1. Vehicle identity and alleged collusion

The appellant argued collusion based on a discrepancy between the vehicle number in the FIR (640) and the vehicle number insured with the appellant (040). The court observed that witnesses had deposed the vehicle number as 040 and that the Tribunal had examined evidence and held that the vehicle involved was a Matador bearing No. 040. The court asked the appellant whether any evidence was placed on record to show that vehicle number 640 was also a Matador; the appellant conceded no such evidence had been led. Given the absence of evidence to support the appellant's suggestion that 640 was the Matador, and seeing the Tribunal's fact-finding, the court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's finding and rejected the collusion argument.

2. Assessment of deceased's income

The appellant contended that the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased's income at Rs. 3,000 per month, contending the proper basis was the basic pay scale of Rs. 950–1800. The court considered the deposition of PW2 (Senior Assistant at PHC Sahnewal), which the appellant had relied on; PW2 stated that although the pay scale was Rs. 950–1800, the deceased's salary was about Rs. 3,500–4,000 per month. The court reasoned that when the witness himself mentioned a higher actual salary despite a lower basic scale, the Tribunal's assessment of Rs. 3,000 could not be said to be erroneous. Accordingly, the court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's assessment of income.

3. Rate of interest

The appellant argued that the Tribunal's award of interest at 12% per annum should be reduced and relied on Kaushnuma Begum, where the interest rate was lowered (to 9%) due to changed economic conditions. The court analyzed the precedents and their circumstances:

  • The court noted that Kaushnuma Begum involved particular facts (including that the Tribunal had not originally awarded compensation and the Supreme Court subsequently fixed a figure and a rate), and that Kaushnuma's holding need not govern the present case.
  • The court observed that the Supreme Court in Rathi Menon (delivered after Kaushnuma Begum) had awarded 12% per annum; it also cited United India Insurance Co. v. Kadam for the proposition that interest cannot run from an earlier date than the date of claim, and Dr. (Mrs.) R.K. Tandon for support of awarding 12% from the date of application.
  • The court expressly stated it was not awarding interest afresh but only confirming the Tribunal's award of 12% per annum; it also expressly declined to express an opinion on whether an interest already awarded at a lower rate should be enhanced to 12%.
  • Addressing the appellant's contention that delay should preclude awarding interest at 12%, the court rejected that contention and relied on the principle (as stated in the Gujarat High Court decision cited) that insurers benefit from the custody/use of the amount during the period of litigation and therefore it is appropriate that insurers bear interest liability for the delay.

On these bases, the court refused to reduce the rate of interest and confirmed the Tribunal's 12% interest award.

Final assessment

After considering the evidence and the relevant authorities, the court concluded there was no merit in the appellant's challenges to the Tribunal's findings on (i) identity of the vehicle and alleged collusion, (ii) assessment of income, and (iii) the rate of interest. The court found no infirmity requiring interference with the Tribunal's award.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED. The Tribunal's award (including the rate of interest at 12% per annum) was confirmed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The Tribunal's award stands and the Insurance Company remains liable to pay the compensation as fixed by the Tribunal, together with interest at 12% per annum as previously ordered.
  • On broader precedent: The court confirmed the Tribunal's award by applying and distinguishing prior authorities; it did not purport to lay down a new rule or depart from existing Supreme Court authority cited in the opinion. The court expressly stated that it was confirming the rate of interest as awarded by the Tribunal and did not express an opinion on whether interest awarded at a lower rate in some other case ought to be enhanced to 12%.

Appeal dismissed (as recorded in the opinion).

    United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Smt. Pinki Walia

    S.S Sudhalkar, J.:— The Insurance Company is challenging the award of the Tribunal. The claim petition was filed by the widow and daughter of deceased Ajit Singh who died in the motor accident.

    2. Learned counsel for the appellant argued that there was a collusion between the respondents-claimants and the driver and owner of the vehicle. According to the learned Counsel, the vehicle number mentioned in the FIR is 640 while the vehicle number insured with the appellant is 040. Only because of the vehicle number being differently recorded in the FIR, the evidence of the respondents-claimants cannot be discarded. Learned counsel for the appellant states that the witnesses have deposed regarding the number of the vehicle being 040 and not 640. Even then it has to be seen that the FIR has been lodged on the first information and that has to be by one person only and not by more than one. In such a case, it will not be proper to throw out the evidence only because of the wrong number mentioned in the FIR. Moreover, the vehicle involved in the accident is a Matador. We questioned the learned Counsel for the appellant as to whether any evidence has been placed on record to show that vehicle number 640 is also a Matador. He replied that no such evidence is led. The Tribunal after considering the evidence, held that the vehicle involved is ‘Matador’ bearing No. 040 and we do not find any infirmity in the finding of the Tribunal.

    3. Learned counsel for the appellant argued that the income of the deceased has not been assessed properly. According to him, the basis of assessing the income should be the pay scale of Rs. 950-1800/-. The income assessed by the Tribunal is Rs. 3000/- per month. Learned counsel for the appellant has relied upon the copies of depositions before the Tribunal which he has shown to us. He has relied on the deposition of PW2 who was Senior Assistant, PHC Sahnewal, Ludhiana. He has stated that the scale of the deceased was Rs. 950-1800/- but he has also stated that the salary of the deceased was about Rs. 3500/- to Rs. 4000/- per month. When the basic pay scale was of Rs. 950-1800/- the finding of the Tribunal that he was earning Rs. 3000/- per month cannot be said to be erroneous. We do not find any infirmity in the finding arrived at by the Tribunal.

    4. Learned counsel for the appellant Insurance Company has argued that the Tribunal has erred in awarding interest at the rate of 12% per annum. He has relied on the case of Kaushnuma Begum v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., reported in 2001 ACJ 428. It has been observed by their Lordships as under:—

    “23. Now, we have to fix up the rate of interest. Section 171 of the MV Act empowers the Tribunal to Page: 810direct that “in addition to the amount of compensation simple interest shall also be paid at such rate and from such date not earlier than the date of making the claim as may be specified in this behalf. Earlier, 12 per cent was found to be the reasonable rate of simple interest. With a change in economy and the policy of the Reserve Bank of India the interest rate has been lowered. The nationalised banks are now granting interest at the rate of 9 per cent on fixed deposits for one year. We, therefore, direct that the compensation amount fixed hereinbefore shall bear interest at the rate of 9 per cent per annum from the date of the claim made by the appellants. The amount of Rs. 50,000 paid by the Insurance Company under Section 140 shall be deducted from the principal amount as on the date of its payment and interest shall be recalculated on the balance amount of the principal sum from such date.”

    5. However, it can be seen that in the said case, no compensation was awarded by the Tribunal, holding that the accident had not taken place because of the rash and negligence driving of the driver. Aggrieved by the said rejection, the claimant moved the High Court. The Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the appeal with a very short order. It is reproduced in the judgment and is reproduced hereunder:—

    “Heard the learned Counsel for the appellant. Finding has been recorded that the jeep overturned and there were no negligence or rashness of the driver. Hence, Rs. 50,000/- has been awarded as compensation which is the minimum amount. There is no error in the order. Dismissed.”

    6. The claimants filed appeal before the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and awarded compensation of Rs. 1,80,000/- and on the amount of compensation, the rate of interest was fixed as above. It can, therefore, be seen that the award was made by the Supreme Court for the first time except Rs. 50,000/- awarded by High Court for liability for the no fault. This judgment was delivered on 3.1.2001

    7. On 13.3.2001, in judgment in the case of Rathi Menon v. Union Of India was pronounced [reported as 2001 (2) T.A.C 250 (SC)], wherein the interest was awarded at the rate of 12% from 27.6.1997 (The said date is mentioned as the date of the order passed by the Railways Claim Tribunal. However, from para No. 7 of the Judgment, it appears to be the date of filing of the petitions before the Tribunal). In that case, the Tribunal awarded total amount of Rs. 6.00 lacs to the claimants. In appeal, the Division Bench of the High Court substantially slashed down the compensation awarded to the claimant. The Supreme Court set-aside the judgment of the High Court and directed the amount to be paid, as awarded by the Claims Tribunal, with 12% interest.

    8. In view of the above mentioned judgments, it is required to be considered as to which of the said judgments should be followed.

    9. The judgment of three Judges of the Supreme Court in the case of United India Insurance Company Ltd v. Narendra Pandurang Kadam, reported as 1995 (1) TAC 621 (SC) has given the reasons as to why the interest has to be awarded. In paragraph 8 of the said judgment, it has been observed as under:—

    “8. Ideally a claim should be settled as soon as it is made. Because of the delay in settlement of the claim by legal process or otherwise interest may be awarded but such interest cannot be from a date earlier than the date of the claim. The language of Section 110-CC is clear that the interest can be awarded by the Court or Tribunal at such rate as it thinks fit but the interest cannot be made payable from a date earlier than the date of the claim. The contention of the appellant on this point appears to be prima facie correct.”

    10. In that case, compensation was enhanced with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of accident till payment.

    11. In the case of Dr. (Mrs.) R.K Tandon v. Om Parkash, reported as 2000 (1) TAC 212 (SC), it has been held by a Bench of two Judges of the Supreme Court as under:—

    “3. The Tribunal had awarded interest at the rate of 6 per annum from the date of the award but the High Court choose to curb it to 3 per cent per annum. In the first place, we do not appreciate the reasoning of the High Court to reduce the rate of interest. We also see no justification by the Courts below of not having awarded interest, whatever be its rate, from the date of the application. The way inflation has galloped in the past two decades and the value of the rupee eroded, we see no justification why interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum was not awardable in the instant matter. We, therefore, order that the interest on he sums modifyingly awarded by us, shall be payable from the date of application itself and at the rate of 12 per cent.”

    12. In the present case, the interest has already been awarded at the rate of 12%. It is not for the first time, as in the case of Kaushnuma Begum (supra), this Court is making the award. Moreover, in the case of Rathi Menon (supra) which has been delivered two months after the judgment of Kaushnuma Begam (supra), the interest has been awarded at the rate of 12% per annum.

    13. Therefore, the argument of learned Counsel for the appellant that the interest awarded by the Tribunal should be reduced, is not accepted. We are not by this judgment awarding the interest, but only confirming the rate of interest as awarded by the Tribunal. (We express no opinion as to if an interest is awarded at a lower rate it should be enhanced to 12%).

    14. The learned Counsel for the appellant further argued that because of the delay, which has been caused in this case, the interest cannot be awarded at the rate of 12% per annum. However, so far as the delay is concerned, Page: 811the beneficiaries of the delay in such case are the tortfeasors. They kept the custody of the amount with them for a long period. It is not proper to hold that the benefit of the delay should go to the tortfeasors. In the Division Bench judgment of the Gujarat High Court in Dr. Bhanuprasad Maganlal Bhatnagar v. Pravin Tapubhai Naik, 1981 (22) Gujarat Law Reporter 1271, it has been observed as follows:—

    “The principle underlying the aforesaid provision is self-evident. In the eye of law, the compensation would be payable to the third party on the very date of the accident. However, when the liability is disputed by the other side, it has to be determined by a competent Court. In an ideal state of affairs, one would expect it to be settled within a couple of months, but there is an inordinate time distance between what is ideal and what is real. Till the dispute is settled by the Court which in the present state of affairs takes considerable time (in the present case it has taken about seven years) the third party who is sought to be protected would be virtually altogether deprived of the benefit of the sum assured. If the liability to pay costs and interest were not thrown on the shoulders of the insurer.”

    15. It is also observed in that said judgment as under:—

    “……………Insurance Company, which is liable to pay the insured amount immediately would secure the benefit of the user of the said sum for the period during which the litigation remains pending in the Court. In other words, the insurer does earn interest on the amount which is payable at once but is paid after a lapse of years. Thus, it is the insurer who benefits by the delay occasioned in the Court. And it is, therefore, but just and proper that the insurer is saddled with the liability to this extent and is obliged to discharge the burden in respect of the item of interest.”

    16. Therefore, it is for the Insurance Company to pay the amount and if it is made to pay the interest, there is nothing wrong in it. No further argument has been advanced.

    17. In view of the aforesaid reasons, we do not find that the award of the Tribunal requires any interference.

    18. This appeal is, therefore, dismissed.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Smt. Pinki Walia
    (Jul 4, 2001)