Advocates appeared :
Shri. JOYDEEP CHATTERJI, learned Counsel for the appellant/accused.
Shri. P. B. VARALE, learned APP for the Respondent - State.
dated 28-06-2001.
2. The facts, as are necessary for the decision of this appeal, are re-produced thus.
PW-10 PSI Sudhakar Suradkar, who was working as PSI in the Police Station, Ajintha. On 29-12-1999, he received a wireless message from control room regarding the deceased Durgabai having been admitted in the hospital with burns. He accordingly deputed Head Constable Bagul to record the statement of Durgabai at Ghati Hospital. On 30-12-1999, he visited the scene of the offence and recorded the scene of the offence panchanama at Exh-14 in the presence of PW-5 Prabhu Sakhale. From the scene of the offence, he attached kerosene can, a bottle smelling of kerosene, a match-box and nylon saree pieces. He also attached burnt saree pieces from the place where the deceased had fallen on the road.
3. The accused came to be arrested on 30-12-1999, on the basis of a crime which was registered on the basis of dying declaration at Exh.24, recorded by PW-7 Bharatsingh Chavan, Special Executive Magistrate. Injured Durgabai succumbed to her injuries and Inquest Panchanama at Exh-27 was conducted. The dead-body was sent for post-mortem and the post-mortem was done by PW-8 Dr. Sunil Tapse. The report of the post-mortem is at Exh-26. The deceased had, according to PW-8 Dr. Tapse, suffered 85% burns. The muddemal property was sent to Chemical Analyser and the report of the Chemical Analyser shows that the clothes of the deceased, seized by the police, tested positive for the presence of kerosene. After completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet against the appellant came to be filed.
4. After committal of the case to the Court of Sessions, the learned Trial Court, by Exh-3, framed a charge against the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. The prosecution, in support of its case, examined in all ten witnesses. The defence of the appellant/accused was of total denial.
5. In order to appreciate and consider the submissions advanced by the learned Counsel for the appellant, it is useful to make a reference to the evidence of the witnesses. PW-1 Namdeo, the father of the deceased, stated that the marriage of deceased Durgabai with the appellant/accused was solemnised about a year and half before the incident. This was a second marriage of deceased Durgabai as her earlier marriage had been dissolved by a decree of divorce. According to PW-1 Namdeo, Durgabai used to visit his house frequently. A day previous to the day of the incident, Durgabai had visited his house and had requested for some money for getting herself examined from the medical practitioner as she was feeling pain in her body. He accordingly gave her Rs.20/- and she went to the dispensary of PW-6, Dr. Achut Lele. In the evening, when he returned from his field, his wife PW-4 Janabai told him that deceased Durgabai had not returned from the dispensary of PW-6 Dr. Lele. He, therefore, advised his wife PW-4 Janabai to go to the house of the accused and to find out what the matter was. Accordingly, on the next day, in between 9.00 a.m. to 10.00 a.m., PW-4 Janabai went to the house of the accused. She returned at about 11.00 a.m. And informed him that, Durgabai had told PW-4 Janabai that Dr. Lele had told Durgabai that she was suffering from Typhoid. PW-4 Janabai then asked the accused as to why he did not bring any medicine for Durgabai. At that time, the appellant/accused was drinking liquor. On hearing this, PW-1 Namdeo went to his agricultural field. At about 3.30 p.m., his nephew Balaji came and informed him that the accused had set Durgabai ablaze. Balaji further informed him that the accused had sprinkled kerosene on Durgabai and lit her with a match-stick. On hearing this, PW-1 Namdeo immediately went home and then went to the house of the accused. Meanwhile, Durgabai had been taken to the Sillod Hospital by his brother Gangadhar and his wife PW-4 Janabai. He, therefore, returned back to his house. On the next day morning, since Durgabai was taken to Government Medical College Hospital, Aurangabad, he and other relatives went to Aurangabad and met deceased Durgabai in that hospital. He asked her as to how she had received the injuries and Durgabai told him that she was asking the accused to bring medicines for her, but the accused was telling her that she was feigning illness. Durgabai further informed PW-1 Namdeo that the accused had poured kerosene on her and had set her ablaze with a match-stick. Durgabai survived agony of 85% burns for a period of nine days and ultimately, on 10th day, she succumbed to her injuries.
In the cross-examination, PW-1 Namdeo has admitted that there is hardly any distance between his house and the house of the accused. Durgabai was on constant visiting terms and he was unable to state whether Durgabai had faced any problems or trouble from the accused, or his parents. The accused was working on daily wages and his mother was also working on daily wages. Omission was brought out in the cross-examination about PW-4 Janabai informing him that Durgabai had not returned home and he advised PW-4 Janabai to go to the house of accused and find out what the matter was. Omission was also brought out in his cross-examination about Durgabai having visited his house a day prior to the incident and requested for Rs.20/- in order to get herself examined from a medical practitioner. Omission was also brought out about his statement that Durgabai had gone to the dispensary of Dr. Lele (PW-6) for taking treatment. Importantly, omission was brought out in respect of his statement that he had not stated before the police that when his wife had asked the accused as to why he did not provide medicine to Durgabai, he was drinking liquor. Similarly, another omission was brought out in respect of Balaji informing that accused had set Durgabai ablaze, after pouring kerosene on her. Contradiction duly proved at A was brought on record about his wife PW-4 Janabai going to the house of the accused in the afternoon to make inquiry about Durgabai. He denied to have stated the portion marked A in his statement. In the cross-examination, he has also admitted that when he reached the house of the accused at about 5 p.m., he was distraught, and therefore, did not go to the Police Station, Ajintha to lodge a complaint. According to him, he stayed at home during that night. Omission was also brought out that he had not stated in his statement that Durgabai had revealed to him at the hospital that the accused had refused to provide treatment to her alleging that she was pretending the illness.
6. PW-4 Janabai gives a different version altogether. According to her, her daughter Durgabai had come and requested PW-1 Namdeo for money for getting herself examined from medical practitioner. This was narrated to her by PW-1 Namdeo when he returned home in the evening. On the next day in the morning at about 10 a.m., she went to the house of the accused to inquire about welfare of Durgabai. She found Durgabai lying on a cot and when she asked her, Durgabai informed PW-4 Janabai that Dr. Lele had diagnosed that she was suffering from Typhoid. She asked her daughter whether she had brought medicines for herself and Durgabai replied that she had requested her husband - the appellant to get medicines for her, but he had omitted to do so. She states that the accused was not then at house. After a while, Durgabai asked for medicines, but accused suggested to her that she may purchase medicines for herself. PW-4 Janabai took tea and returned home. The vernacular deposition of this witness in this regard reads as under:-
After some time, the accused returned home and thereafter Durgabai asked about the medicines.
This portion about the accused returning home after some time is not to be found in the English translation of the deposition. According to her, quarrel was going on between the accused and deceased Durgabai over the issue of medicines. She went to her field and in the afternoon, Balaji came and informed her that Durgabai was burnt. While she was on her way home, she met her uncle-in-law on a motor-cycle, and therefore, she accompanied him to the house of the accused. According to her, Durgabai was lying in burnt condition in the lane. She asked Durgabai as to what had happened and Durgabai informed her that the accused had sprinkled kerosene on her body and had set her ablase with a match-stick. Durgabai was shifted to the Government Hospital, Sillod in a jeep. The Medical Officer at Sillod Hospital gave some treatment to Durgabai and suggested that Durgabai be taken to Ghati Hospital at Aurangabad. Accordingly, Durgabai was brought to Aurangabad and admitted in the Government Medical Hospital. In the cross-examination, PW-4 Janabai has admitted that, there was no bitterness between the accused and her daughter - Durgabai. They were leading a normal life. According to her, the accused was maintaining himself and his family by earning his wages. However, his condition was poor. Some times, work was not available in the village. In the further cross-examination, she has admitted in my presence, no talk had taken place between accused and my daughter regarding buying of medicines for Durgabai. The accused was not at the house when I went to see my daughter. When I was quitting his house, he met me on the way. (emphasis supplied).
7. Omission has been brought that she had not stated in her statement that there was exchange of hot words between accused and deceased Durgabai on account of purchasing medicines. She has further stated that her statement was recorded by the police three days after admission of his daughter. She has also admitted that the Police Station of Sillod is adjacent to the Government Hospital of Sillod. According to her, police from Sillod had come to Sillod Hospital when Durgabai was taken there. Police had interrogated her, Durgabai and her husbands brother Gangadhar in the hospital. She has admitted not to have gone to Sillod Police Station to lodge a complaint.
8. On the perusal of the evidence of PW-1 Namdeo and PW-4 Janabai, it is apparent to us that apart from the fact that there is no consistency between the evidence of these two witnesses, the evidence suffers from falsehood, apart from the contradictions and omissions in the evidence of both these witnesses. It is true that it would be extremely harsh to expect that the evidence of any two eye witnesses should be absolutely identical. It is natural that there would be variations on the peripherals or minor aspects of their evidence, but in the event of contradictions and variations occurring in the evidence on the vital aspects of the prosecution case, the evidence of such witnesses would be rendered extremely doubtful. Apart from the fact that PW-4 Janabais evidence in respect of quarrel in between the accused and deceased Durgabai on account of purchase of medicines is falsified. According to us, the evidence in respect of the oral dying declaration made to PW-4 Janabai also appears to be doubtful. According to PW-4 Janabai, the police of Sillod Police Station had interrogated her and Durgabai. If Durgabai had, in fact, given oral dying declaration blaming the appellant/accused, it is inconceivable that either PW-1 Namdeo or PW-4 Janabai would not inform the police. Apparently, their statements were not recorded by the Sillod Police Station, atleast none is produced alongwith the charge-sheet. In the absence, it would be possible to infer that no disclosure had been made in respect of the oral dying declaration either by PW-1 Namdeo or PW-4 Janabai to the Sillod Police Station. Non-disclosure to the police at the earliest opportunity casts a shadow of doubt on the claim of these witnesses in respect of the oral dying declaration.
9. The prosecution has relied on the dying declaration at Exh-24 recorded by PW-7 Bharatsingh Chavan, Special Executive Magistrate. PW-7 Bharatsingh states that on 30-12-1999, at about 10.30 a.m., he received a message on telephone from Ghati Hospital from ASI Pawar that a woman with burns was admitted in the hospital and PW-7 Bharatsingh should come to the hospital for recording her statement. According to him at around 10.45 a.m., he contacted ASI Pawar, who handed over a letter requesting him to record the dying declaration. The said letter is at Exh-19. He, therefore, went to the ward where patients with burns are admitted. He contacted PW-9 Dr. Suresh Harbade. According to him, PW-9 Dr. Suresh Harbade examined the patient and declared that she was in fit condition to make a statement. PW-7 Bharatsingh requested the mother of Durgabai to remove herself from the ward and also requested the policeman to go away from the room. He accordingly recorded her statement. Deceased Durgabai is alleged to have stated before PW-7 Bharatsingh that she had been suffering from illness for 4 to 5 days, but her husband, the accused, was harassing her saying that she suffered from nothing and was only pretending. On 29-12-1999, at about 3.30 p.m., the appellant came in a drunken condition and poured kerosene on her and set her on fire. He obtained the thumb impression of Durgabai on the statement recorded by him. In the cross-examination, he has admitted that on the dying declaration at Exh.24, there is no endorsement that he had read over the statement of Durgabai after recording it.
10. The oral dying declaration, as deposed to by PW-1 Namdeo differs substantially from the oral dying declaration as deposed to by PW-4 Janabai. According to PW-1 Namdeo, the deceased had told him that the accused had said as she was pretending to be ill, she should bring medicines for herself. The oral dying declaration as deposed to by PW-4 Janabai was that the appellant/accused poured kerosene on Durgabai and set her on fire. In the oral dying declaration of Janabai, no reason is ascribed for setting Durgabai on fire.
11. In the dying declaration at Exh.24, she states that the appellant came home in the afternoon in the drunken condition and immediately poured kerosene on her and set her on fire. In the dying declaration at Exh-24, the deceased for the first time alleges that the appellant in drunken condition had set her on fire.
12. PW-10 PSI Sudhakar Suradkar has stated that one Head Constable Bagul had recorded the statement of deceased Durgabai. According to him, he got the statement verified by confronting the same with Durgabai. In the cross-examination, he has admitted that Head Constable Bagul had recorded the dying declaration of the deceased in the hospital. He has further admitted that he had given oral instructions to Head Constable Bagul to visit the hospital and make inquiry after receiving the message. The dying declaration recorded by Head Constable Bagul has been suppressed by the prosecution. That was the first dying declaration in the point of time and the dying declaration at Exh.24 came to be recorded subsequently. We are at loss to understand as to why if in a dying declaration recorded by Head Constable Bagul, the deceased had stated that the appellant had burnt her, why no offence against the appellant was registered on that basis. Apparently, it seems that the dying declaration recorded by Head Constable Bagul did not support the prosecution, and therefore, that dying declaration was never produced during the trial. It was on the basis of the dying declaration at Exh-24 recorded by PW-7 Bharatsingh that the offence came to be registered.
13. The dying declaration at Exh.24, according to us, can not be relied upon as the statement was never read over to deceased Durgabai and there is no endorsement to that effect. When the declaration was not read over to Durgabai and she had not admitted the contents thereof to be correct, according to us, the dying declaration can not be made foundation for sustaining the conviction.
14. In the present case, there is another perplexing situation. Admittedly, the relations between deceased Durgabai and the appellant were normal. There are no allegations that the appellant had ill-treated the deceased on account of any reason whatsoever. Deceased Durgabai used to frequently visit her parents house and there is no history of Durgabai having complained about the appellant to them. Deceased Durgabai has not been able to suggest the reason as to why the appellant would set her on fire. Merely because the appellant stated that she was pretended to be ill whereas she was not, would not, according to us, be sufficient reason for the appellant to have set her to fire. When the appellant came home on the day of incident is stated for first time in Exh-24, that the appellant was drunk. The drunkenness of the appellant is not alluded to in the oral dying declarations made to PW-1 Namdeo and PW-4 Janabai. For all these reasons, according to us, the dying declaration does not inspire confidence.
15. The prosecution has also examined PW-6 Dr. Achut Lele, who had diagnosed that Durgabai was suffering from Typhoid and had prescribed some medicines. The evidence of PW-6 Dr. Lele does not advance the prosecution case any further. The defence of the appellant that when Durgabai caught fire, he was coming home and responding to her cry for help and he attracted the people and tried to put off the fire by his hands. He states that he had also received burn injuries on his hand. PW-2 Kamalbai, in her cross-examination, has admitted that the accused was also trying to extinguish the flames. PW-3 Tulsabai has admitted that the accused and Durgabai were living a happy life. She also states that the appellant/accused tried to extinguish the fire.
16. For the reasons stated above, we find that the there is no convincing evidence for sustaining conviction of the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the I.P.C. Accordingly, we allow the appeal and quash and set aside the conviction and sentence passed on the appellant by the Trial Court. The appellant is acquitted of the offence with which he was charged and convicted. The appellant is in jail and he be released forthwith, if not wanted in any other case. Fine if paid, be refunded to the appellant.
Appeal allowed.