Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions and conditions of the English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924,
  • Article 3, Cl. 6, English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act.
  • Article 3, Cl. 6 of the schedule to that Act
  • Sections 64 and 85 of the Sea Customs Act,
  • SEA CUSTOMS ACT
  • SECTION 28 CONTRACT ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions and conditions of the English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924,
  • Article 3, Cl. 6, English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act.
  • Article 3, Cl. 6 of the schedule to that Act
  • Sections 64 and 85 of the Sea Customs Act,
  • SEA CUSTOMS ACT
  • SECTION 28 CONTRACT ACT
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs, as holders for value of bills of lading for 27,398 bags of sugar loaded on a ship owned by defendant 1, sued defendants 1 and 2 on 27 June 1930 to recover damages for an admitted short delivery of 1,078 cwts., 2 quarters and 25 lbs. A separate claim in conversion for certain sweepings was abandoned at the hearing. The ship arrived on 4 May 1929 and was completely discharged on 8 May 1929. The pleadings initially filed by both parties were defective; the court allowed amendments to the plaint and the points of defence so that the disputes could be properly adjudicated.

Because the suit was not brought until 27 June 1930, the claim against defendant 1 was prima facie barred by Article 31 of the Limitation Act (one-year period). To meet this, plaintiffs pleaded (para. 9-A as amended) that defendant 1 had been absent from British India and relied, if necessary, upon an acknowledgment of liability in a letter from defendant 2 dated 24 January 1930; no argument was advanced on that latter contention. Defendant 1 relied on terms incorporated in the bills of lading—specifically Article 3, Clause 6 of the schedule to the English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924—providing that the carrier and ship are discharged from all liability unless suit is brought within one year after delivery.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the clause in the bills of lading incorporating Article 3, Clause 6 of the English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924 (requiring suit within one year of delivery) extinguishes the plaintiffs' rights where suit was not brought within that year, notwithstanding Section 28 of the Indian Contract Act.
  2. Whether the statutory declarations made by the ship's agent (defendant 2) under Sections 64 and 85 of the Sea Customs Act create an independent statutory liability enabling the plaintiffs to maintain a suit against the ship's agent even if the claim is extinguished against the carrier/ship by the bills of lading clause.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The plaintiffs relied on Section 28 of the Contract Act: "Every agreement by which any party thereto is restricted absolutely from enforcing his rights ... or which limits the time within which he may thus enforce his rights, is void to that extent." They argued that Article 3, Clause 6 (one-year limitation) in the bills of lading limited the time to enforce rights and was therefore void to that extent under Section 28.
  • As to defendant 2 (the ship's agent), plaintiffs argued that the statutory declarations under the Sea Customs Act (notably Ss. 64 and 85) imposed an independent statutory liability on the agent for "all claims for damage or short delivery" and that, under Article 120 of the Limitation Act, the suit against the agent would not be barred until six years from accrual; thus the plaintiffs contended they could enforce the claim against the agent even if barred as against the carrier.
  • Plaintiffs admitted they must rely on the bills of lading to establish ownership of the goods but contended that the agent's statutory liability was not affected by the one-year provision incorporated into the bills of lading.

Defendant 1's (Carrier/Ship) Arguments

  • Defendant 1 contended that the bills of lading incorporated the terms, provisions and conditions of the English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924, specifically Article 3, Clause 6, which discharges the carrier and ship from liability unless suit is brought within one year after delivery. Because the present suit was brought more than one year after delivery, defendant 1 asserted it was discharged from liability under the bills of lading.
  • Defendant 1 relied on the decision in Baroda Spinning and Weaving Co. Ltd. v. Satyanarayen Marine and Fire Insurance Co. Ltd., arguing that the principle in that case—concerning the effect of forfeiture/limitation clauses and the application of Section 28—supported the validity and effect of the one-year clause in the bills of lading.

Defendant 2's (Ship's Agent) Position

  • Defendant 2 had executed statutory declarations under Sections 64 and 85 of the Sea Customs Act (Exs. C-1, C-2 and C-3, the material one being C-2 dated 21 March 1912) declaring that they "are answerable for discharge of all claims for damages or short delivery which may be established by the owners of any goods comprised in the import cargo ...".
  • Defendant 2's legal position, as treated by the court, was effectively that their liability under those declarations depended upon the existence of an enforceable claim that could be established against the carrier/ship; if no enforceable claim existed against the carrier/ship (because of the bills of lading clause), then no greater right could be established against the agent by virtue of the statutory declarations.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Baroda Spinning and Weaving Co. Ltd. v. Satyanarayen Marine and Fire Insurance Co. Ltd. Addressed the validity/effect of a forfeiture/limitation clause in an insurance policy and the relationship between such clauses and Section 28 of the Limitation/Contract Act; discussed distinction between rights and remedies and whether a conditional forfeiture extinguishes substantive rights in suits for money. The court applied the principle laid down in this decision to hold that incorporation of Article 3, Clause 6 into the bills of lading extinguished the plaintiffs' rights in relation to the claim, so Section 28 did not assist the plaintiffs and the claim against defendant 1 failed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in stages:

  1. Limitation and incorporation: The court noted the suit was brought more than one year after delivery, engaging Article 3, Clause 6 (the one-year suit limitation) incorporated in the bills of lading. Plaintiffs sought to avoid that bar by invoking Section 28 of the Contract Act (which renders void agreements that absolutely restrict enforcement of rights or limit the time within which rights may be enforced). Defendant 1 relied on the Baroda Spinning decision to support the validity/effect of the limitation clause.
  2. Application of precedent: The court accepted the principle from Baroda Spinning. It concluded that, on incorporation of Article 3, Clause 6 into the bills of lading, the plaintiffs' rights had been extinguished in respect of the present claim. Because the court found there were no rights left to enforce, the question of the remedy being barred under Section 28 did not arise; Section 28 therefore did not assist the plaintiffs.
  3. Statutory liability of the ship's agent (defendant 2): Plaintiffs argued that, under Ss. 64 and 85 of the Sea Customs Act and the declarations delivered by defendant 2, the agent had incurred an independent statutory liability and that the limitation applicable to such a statutory claim would be six years (Article 120, Limitation Act). The court analyzed the wording of Ss. 64 and 85 and the declarations, which made the agent "answerable for discharge of all claims for damages or short delivery which may be established by the owner ...".
  4. Meaning of "established" and comparative rights: The court emphasized that under the Sea Customs Act the agent is liable for claims "which may be established"—i.e., claims must be established in a manner recognized by law (by suit) and while such a suit might be resisted on various grounds, the agent's liability is not an independent substantive right greater than that of the carrier. The court found it implausible that the legislature intended to confer on the ship's agent greater rights (or longer enforceability) than the carrier/ship would have under the bills of lading: doing so would lead to anomalous results, such as the agent being liable while the carrier was discharged and yet the agent having to seek indemnity against a carrier whose liability had been extinguished.
  5. Conclusion on agent's liability: The court concluded that the purpose of the statutory scheme was to ensure someone within the jurisdiction could answer the same claims as the carrier would have had the carrier remained within jurisdiction, not to confer greater rights on the agent. Therefore, unless the claim could be established against the carrier or ship, it could not be established against the ship's agent who signed the declaration. Because the claim could not be established against defendant 1 (carrier/ship), the suit also failed against defendant 2.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Suit dismissed.

Implications (direct effect on the parties):

  • The plaintiffs' claim against defendant 1 (the ship/ carrier) fails because the rights of the holders under the bills of lading were extinguished by the incorporation of Article 3, Clause 6 (one-year suit limitation), and Section 28 of the Contract Act did not assist the plaintiffs in this situation.
  • The plaintiffs' claim against defendant 2 (the ship's agent) also fails because the statutory declarations made under Ss. 64 and 85 of the Sea Customs Act do not confer greater enforceable rights against the agent than those enforceable against the carrier; if the claim cannot be established against the carrier, it cannot be established against the agent.
  • The suit is dismissed with costs, including the costs of the chamber summons for directions. No order was made as to costs of the amendment of the plaint on 13 January 1931 because the court found no extra costs were incurred by that amendment.

The opinion does not discuss broader legal or doctrinal implications beyond the direct effect on the parties; it does not announce or purport to establish a new general precedent beyond the application of existing authority to the facts of this case.

K.N/R.K

    Haji Shakoor Gany v. H.E. Hinde & Co. Ltd.

    1. On 27th June 1930, the plaintiffs as the holders for value of bills of lading for 27,398 bags of sugar loaded on a ship owned by defendant 1 brought this suit to recover from defendants 1 and 2 damages in respect of a short delivery of 1078 cwts., 2 quarter and 25 lbs. This short delivery is admitted. The suit was also framed in conversion in respect of certain sweepings. That claim and the issues raised thereon were abandoned at the hearing.

    2. The pleadings as originally framed were defective on both sides, and I allowed certain amendments both of the plaint and of the points of defence in order that all the matters in dispute between the parties might be properly determined. The ship arrived on 4th May 1929 and was completely discharged on 8th May 1929. Having regard to Article 31, Lim. Act, the suit against defendants 1 was prima facie barred; the suit not having been brought until 27th June 1930. In order to meet this difficulty the plaintiffs pleaded in para. 9-A of the plaint as amended that defendants 1 had at all material times been absent from British India, and that the suit was not barred against them by reason of section 13 of the lim. act. In that paragraph the plaintiffs also stated that they would, if and so far as might be necessary, contend that their claim was not barred by limitation by reason of an acknowledgment of liability contained in defendants 2's letter dated 24th January 1930. No argument has been submitted to me upon this allegation in that paragraph. It was thereupon contended as regards the alleged liability of defendants 1 that the plea raised in para. 9-A of the plaint would not avail the plaintiffs, inasmuch as the bills of lading incorporated all the terms, provisions and conditions of the English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924, and that they were thereby discharged from liability in respect of the claim in this suit. The provisions relied upon as regards the alleged liability of defendants 1 is Article 3, Cl. 6 of the schedule to that Act the material part of which is as follows:

    “In any event the carrier and the ship shall be discharged from all liability in respect of loss or damage unless suit is brought within one year after delivery of the goods or the date when the goods should have been delivered.”

    3. They contend that as the suit was not brought within one year after the delivery of the goods they are discharged from liability under the terms of the bills of lading which incorporated this provision. In answer to this contention the plaintiffs rely upon Section 28 of the Contract Act, which runs thus:

    “Every agreement by which any party thereto is restricted absolutely from enforcing his rights under or in respect of any contract, by the usual legal proceedings in the ordinary tribunals or which limits the time within which he may thus enforce his rights, is void to that extent.”

    4. The plaintiffs submit that the words relied upon by defendants 1 in Cl. 6, Article 8 limit the time within which the plaintiffs may enforce their rights, and that the agreement is to that extent void. In reply to this argument, defendants 1 rely upon the decision of the appeal Court in Baroda Spinning and Weaving Co. Ltd. v. Satyanarayen Marine and Fire Insurance Co. Ltd. (1), and submit that the principle laid down in this decision applies to the facts of the present case. In that case the facts were that the S. insurance company granted a policy of insurance against fire to the B company on certain property of the latter, the policy containing a clause to the effect that if a claim were made and rejected and an action or suit were not commenced within three months after such rejection, all benefit under the policy should be forfeited. Damage was caused to the property of the B company thus insured, and a claim was made by that company on the S insurance company which was rejected by the latter. More than three months after such rejection the B company filed a suit against the S insurance company to recover the amount of their claim. In the judgment of Scott, C.J, at p. 352, that learned Judge said as follows:

    “The argument of the appellants' counsel was that the forfeiture clause was equivalent to an agreement that no Court should entertain any suit on the policy unless commenced within three months of the rejection of the claim. The steps in his argument were: section 3 of the lim. act, indicates that the law of limitation cannot be modified by agreement of parties as it can in England; that there is no distinction under that Act between rights and remedies; and that a conditional agreement to forfeit rights within the period within which the remedy is not barred by the limitation law is a void agreement.

    “I cannot accept the proposition that there is no distinction in India between rights and remedies. section 28 of the lim. act, shows the cases in which the loss of the remedy will destroy the right but that does not cover suits for money such as we are now concerned with. On the other hand the loss of the right always involves the disappearance of the remedy; a very material consideration in the case of a conditional forfeiture of all benefit under a policy.”

    5. In my opinion the effect of the incorporation of Article 3, Cl. 6, into the bills of lading in this case is that the rights of the holders have been extinguished in respect of the claim made in this case. As therefore the plaintiff's have no rights to enforce, there is in my view no question of the remedy being barred, and Section 28 of the Contract Act does not assist the plaintiffs. I think that the principle laid down in the case to which I have referred applies to the facts of the present case, and that the plaintiffs' claim against defendants 1 consequently fails. The plaintiffs however contend that in any event they have good claim against defendants 2 by reason of a statutory obligation which they contend that defendants 2 have incurred under the Sea Customs Act. The sections relied upon are Ss. 64 and 85. S. 64 begins with these words:

    “The Customs Collector may refuse port clearance to any vessel until….”

    6. Then follow certain provisions which do not affect this case, the material provisions which it is necessary to refer to being (c) and (d). Cl. (c) is as follows:

    “The ship's agent (if any) delivers to the Customs Collector a declaration in writing to the effect that he will be liable for any penalty imposed under S. 167, No. 17, and furnishes security for the discharge of the same.”

    7. Clause (d) is as follows:

    “The ship's agent (if any) delivers to the Customs Collector a declaration in writing to the effect that such agent is answerable for the discharge of all claims for damage or short delivery which may be established by the owner of any goods comprised in the import cargo in respect of such goods.”

    8. The section then continues in these words:

    “A ship's agent delivering a declaration under Cl. (c) of this section shall be liable to all penalties which might be imposed on the master under S. 167, No. 17, and a ship's agent delivering a declaration under Cl. (d) of this section shall be bound to discharge all claims referred to in such declaration.”

    9. Section 85 of the Act empowers the Customs Collector upon the terms therein mentioned to permit the master of any vessel to discharge the cargo of such vessel or any portion thereof into the custody of the ship's agents if willing to receive the same. The material part of S. 85, for the purpose of this case, is as follows:

    “Any ship's agent so receiving such cargo or portion shall be bound to discharge all claims for damage or short delivery which may be established in respect of the same by the owner thereof, and shall be entitled to recover from such owner his charges for service rendered but not for commission or the like, where any agent for the landing of such cargo or portion has been previously appointed by the owner and such appointment is unrevoked.”

    10. It is admitted that defendants 2 made declarations to the customs authorities, and that they apply to the present case. They have been put in as Exs. C-1 C-2 and C-3. The material declaration for the present purposes is Ex. C-2 dated 21st March 1912, whereby defendants 2 declare (inter alia) that they.

    “are answerable for discharge of all claims for damages or short delivery which may be established by the owners of any goods comprised in the import cargo of each such vessels in respect of such goods.”

    11. The argument on behalf of the plaintiffs, is that defendants 2, by signing this declaration have incurred a statutory liability independent of the contract contained in the bills of lading, and that Tinder Article 120, Lim. Act, the suit against defendants 2 would not be barred until the expiration of six years from the time when the right to sue accrued. The plaintiffs admit that they must rely upon the bills of lading in order to prove that they are the owners of the goods. They however submit that they are not affected by the provision in the bill of lading incorporated by virtue of Article 3, Cl. 6, English Carriage of Goods by Sea Act. The plaintiffs contend that once they establish that they had a claim for short delivery at the time when defendants 2 received the goods from the ship, they are now entitled to enforce that claim against defendants 2. They submit that the time for ascertaining whether an enforceable claim exists is the time of delivery. In my opinion this argument of the plaintiffs is unsound. By virtue of Sections 64 and 85 of the Sea Customs Act, and the declarations made thereunder, defendants 2 are answerable for the discharge of all claims for damages or short delivery which may be established by the owner of any goods comprised in the import cargo in respect of such goods. It is to be observed that until a claim is established, defendants 2 are not answerable. Unless a claim is admitted, it must be established in a manner recognized by law, that is, by a suit, and that suit might be resisted upon a number of grounds. If the defendants to such a suit were to set up only the defence that the claim could not be established upon the ground that their liability was discharged at the time at which it was sought to establish it, because they were confident that such a defence would succeed, it seems to me impossible to say that they might not have had other valid defences which they might have set up if the claim had sought to be established at an earlier date. It is plain, in my opinion that the object of Cl. 6, Article 3, is to prevent the carrier or the ship being harrassed with claims brought more than one year after the delivery of the goods, because the carrier and the ship after such a distance of time might be placed in the very greatest difficulty in obtaining the necessary evidence to rebut such a claim. Various defences might be open to them under the terms of the bills of lading, but in order to establish such defences, they would of course have to procure the necessary evidence. That I think, is clearly the object of the provision. Further it is to be observed that the sections of the Sea Customs Act do not speak of establishing the claim as a claim enforceable at the date of delivery. They speak of establishing the claim. I think that the Court in giving effect to the words of those sections must be satisfied that there is an enforceable claim existing at the date of the suit.

    12. In my opinion, in the present case there was no such enforceable claim. It seems to me plain that the legislature could not have intended to confer upon the owner of goods claiming under the bills of lading greater rights against the ship's agent than they would have had against the carrier or the ship. In this connexion it may be observed that the penalty referred to in S. 64(c) as being imposed under S. 167, No. 17, is a penalty imposed upon the master of the vessel, and it is the penalty so imposed upon the master of the ship that the ship's agent by virtue of the declaration binds himself to be liable for. To hold that greater rights were conferred upon the holders of bills of lading by the statutory obligation imposed on the ship's agent than are imposed upon the carrier or the ship by virtue of the bills of lading would, in my opinion, lead to startling results. For instance, if the ship's agent was compelled to discharge a claim established for short delivery, he ought to be entitled to be indemnified by the carrier. Yet if the plaintiffs are right in their argument, although the claim might not be established against the carrier by reason of the provisions of the bills of lading, it could nevertheless be established against the ship's agent by reason of a statutory liability imposing an obligation upon the agent greater than that incurred by the carrier under the contract. In my opinion, this was not the intention of the legislature. I think that the object of the legislature was to authorize the customs authorities to release the ship, provided that there was some person within the jurisdiction who would be answerable for such claims as either the ship would have been answerable for, if she had remained within the jurisdiction, or the carrier would have been answerable for, if he had been within the jurisdiction. I think that no greater rights were intended to be conferred against the ship's agent signing the declaration. It follows therefore if I am right in my view, that unless the claim can be established against the carrier or the ship, it cannot be established against the ship's agent who has made the declaration under the Sea Customs Act. As in my opinion this claim cannot be established against defendants 1 it follows that this suit also fails against defendants 2.

    13. Accordingly I dismiss this suit with costs, costs to include the costs of the chamber summons for directions. With regard to the costs of the amendment of the plaint made on 13th January 1931, inasmuch as no extra costs were, in my opinion incurred by reason of that amendment, although I had reserved the costs of the amendment, I make no order in reference thereto.

    K.N/R.K

    14. Suit dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Haji Shakoor Gany v. H.E. Hinde & Co. Ltd.
    (Jan 14, 1931)