Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants were selected and appointed to posts (10 posts of Principal/Head Master and 28 posts of Assistant Teachers) in the Basti Region after advertisements published in June 2011 and selection proceedings held on 4.8.2011 with outcomes intimated on 11.8.2011. Complaints and challenges to selections across the State prompted the Director of Education to issue directions and to form a three-member enquiry committee to examine selections in the Basti Region.

On 4.12.2012 the Director of Education passed an order annulling the selections and appointments in the Basti Region on the ground that the selections were de hors the relevant rules and that the advertisement was contrary to the rules; consequentially the Joint Director of Education, Basti passed an order dated 12.12.2012 directing recovery of salary paid to the appellants. The appellants filed a writ petition challenging the orders of 4.12.2012 and 12.12.2012.

The learned single Judge granted a partial interim order dated 3.1.2013 protecting the appellants only from recovery of salary under the 12.12.2012 order and directed the respondents to file a counter affidavit; the single Judge did not allow the appellants to continue in post or draw salary pending final adjudication. The appellants filed this intra-court appeal complaining that the single Judge should have granted fuller interim relief (allowing continuation in post and receipt of salary) because the cancellation orders were passed without notice and in violation of principles of natural justice.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned orders dated 4.12.2012 (cancellation of selection and appointment) and 12.12.2012 (recovery of salary) were passed in violation of the principles of natural justice by failing to give notice and an opportunity of hearing to the appellants and the institutions concerned.
  2. Whether, as an interim measure, the appellants were entitled to continue in their posts and receive salary pending further proceedings, given the alleged violation of natural justice.
  3. Whether the Director of Education had correctly applied reservation rules and related Government Orders (including institution-wise applicability) when cancelling selections, and whether those questions require objective determination after hearing the appellants.
  4. Whether recovery of salary under the 12.12.2012 order could be implemented before affording the appellants an opportunity of hearing and before passing fresh orders.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The impugned cancellation orders were passed in violation of principles of natural justice because no notice or opportunity of hearing was given either to the institutions or to the appellants in person.
  • The advertisement and selection process complied with the Uttar Pradesh Madhyamik Sanskrit Shiksha Parishad Service Rules, 2009, and therefore the cancellations were factually incorrect and legally unsustainable.
  • The rule of reservation relied upon in the impugned order was wrongly applied; the advertisement was in consonance with the 2009 Regulations and vacancies were properly identified.
  • The orders cancelling selection and directing recovery of salary should be quashed because the stated grounds are factually nonexistent and legally untenable (paragraph 37 and paras 38–56 of the writ petition identify these grounds).

Respondents' (State) Arguments

  • The matter was still pending before the learned single Judge and the selections were alleged to be vitiated for non-compliance with the 2009 Rules; the impugned order would be subject to scrutiny by the single Judge.
  • Although no counter affidavit had been filed, the Standing Counsel stated he had no objection to final disposal of the matter at this stage.
  • On the specific relief sought (continuation in post and receipt of salary pending final decision), the State's position was that the appellants could not be permitted to continue on their posts or receive salary until the enquiry was finalized and appropriate orders were passed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Heera Lal v. State of U.P, Full Bench, 2010 (5) ALJ 379 Determining the extent of applicability of reservation institution-wise. The court observed that the Director had not taken notice of this Full Bench pronouncement when assessing reservation applicability; the appellants' contentions on reservation require an objective determination after a hearing.
Canara Bank v. Debasis Das, (2003) 4 SCC 557 (AIR 2003 SC 2041) Paras 23–24 Authority for allowing a post-decisional hearing/procedure in cases involving alleged irregularities. The court relied on this decision to justify directing a post-decisional hearing by the Director of Secondary Education given the magnitude of alleged irregularities; the procedure referenced was ordered to be followed here.
Union of India v. Rajesh P.U. Puthuvalnikathu, (2003) 7 SCC 285 (AIR 2003 SC 4222) Obligation of the authority to objectively deal with matters and to "separate the grain from the chaff". The court invoked this principle to require the Director to objectively examine grievances and distinguish genuine cases from those not warranting adverse action when affording the appellants a hearing.
State of U.P v. Pawan Kumar Singh, 2009 (3) ADJ 166 (Division Bench) Supportive authority for the approach of objective examination and careful separation of valid and invalid complaints in selection matters (as referenced alongside other authorities). Referenced along with the other authorities to reinforce the court's direction that the Director must objectively examine the appellants' grievances and not be influenced by prior conclusions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a stepwise analysis based on the record and submissions:

  1. Natural Justice: The court found as a factual and legal matter that the impugned orders dated 4.12.2012 and 12.12.2012 were passed without complying with the principles of natural justice. The court noted that the appellants had undergone the selection process, been appointed, and had received salary, and that the impugned orders cancelling those appointments and directing recovery of salary were issued without any recital that an opportunity had been given to the appellants or their institutions prior to passing the Director's order (para 14).
  2. Entitlement to Hearing: Given the absence of a hearing before cancellation, the court held that the petitioners were entitled to an opportunity of hearing before their rights to continue in post and to receive salary were finally determined (para 14).
  3. Reservation and Government Orders: The court observed that the Director had not taken notice of relevant Government Orders and pronouncements of the court, including the Full Bench judgment in Heera Lal, concerning the applicability of reservation institution-wise. The court concluded that contentions raised by the appellants in paras 38–56 of the writ petition raise questions that require objective determination after affording a hearing (para 15).
  4. Interim Effect on Recovery of Salary: The court held that the question of recovery of salary depends on the outcome of the hearing and that the Regional Joint Director of Education's order for recovery could not be implemented until appropriate orders are passed after hearing (para 15).
  5. Remedial Procedure Ordered: Recognizing the nature and alleged magnitude of irregularities, and relying on the approach in Canara Bank and other authorities, the court directed a post-decisional hearing: the Director of Secondary Education must grant opportunity to all appellants, who shall file written representations within three weeks; the Director must then examine grievances objectively and pass appropriate orders within three months of production of a certified copy of this order (para 16–17).
  6. Interim Restraint: Until the Director passes appropriate orders after the hearing, the Regional Joint Director was directed not to implement the recovery order dated 12.12.2012; the interim protection against recovery already granted by the single Judge was therefore continued (para 16).

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court held that the impugned orders dated 4.12.2012 and 12.12.2012 were passed without complying with the principles of natural justice and directed that the Director of Secondary Education must grant a post-decisional opportunity of hearing to the appellants, consider their written representations, and pass appropriate orders within three months after production of a certified copy of this order. The court also directed that the order for recovery of salary dated 12.12.2012 shall not be implemented until such fresh orders are passed. The appeal and connected writ petition (No. 68458 of 2012) were disposed of finally with the consent of the parties (paras 14–17).

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The appellants must file written representations within three weeks from the date of this order to avail the post-decisional hearing directed by the court (para 16).
  • The Director of Secondary Education is required to pass final and appropriate orders after considering those representations and without being influenced by conclusions in the earlier order dated 4.12.2012; this must be done within three months of production of a certified copy of the present order (para 17).
  • The Regional Joint Director of Education is restrained from implementing the recovery order dated 12.12.2012 until the Director passes fresh orders after the hearing; meanwhile the interim protection from recovery (granted by the single Judge) remains effective (paras 15–16).
  • The court did not purport to set a new legal precedent; rather it applied established principles (including those from the cited authorities) to direct corrective procedural steps in the particular factual matrix before it. The direct consequence is remedial: a hearing, reconsideration, and a stay on recovery pending that process.

Order dated and reported in the provided opinion: matter disposed of finally with the consent of the parties; detailed timelines and directions as summarized above appear at paragraphs 14–17 of the opinion.

    Anand Vardhan Mishra & Others v. State Of U.P & Others.

    1. This intra-court appeal has been filed with a grievance that the learned single Judge while entertaining the writ petition filed by the appellant-petitioners has not granted the entire interim relief as prayed for in the writ petition that is likely to cause, not only prejudice to the appellants, but also to some of the institutions that would be left with no teachers thereby affecting the educational career of the students of such institutions where the appellant petitioners had been selected and appointed.

    2. The appellants herein filed the writ petition challenging the orders dated 4.12.2012 passed by the Director of Education whereby the selection and appointment of the petitioner appellants has been annulled on the ground that the selections were de-hors the relevant rules and that the advertisement against which such selections and appointments were made being contrary to the rules were invalid. Accordingly, the entire selection process was nullified on the ground of violation of the provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Madhyamik Sanskrit Shiksha Parishad Service Rules, 2009. A consequential order passed by the Joint Director of Education, Basti dated 12.12.2012 in pursuance of the order of Director of Education was also questioned whereby recovery of salary from the appellants was directed. The respondents were called upon to file then-counter affidavit within one month with a direction to list the writ petition on 8th of February, 2013. The interim order dated 3rd of January, 2013 protected the petitioner appellants only from recovery of any salary that was sought to be made under the order dated 12.12.2012

    3. The background in which this dispute arose appears to be that the Director of Education by a D.O Letter dated 18th of May, 2011 issued instructions to the Regional Directors of Education for taking steps under the 2009 Rules for selection and appointment. It appears that the posts in Basti Region were advertised in Hindi Daily Rashtriya Sahara on 16.6.2011 and The Times of India on 18.6.2011 Applications were invited against the vacancies of 10 posts of Principal/Head Master and 28 posts of Assistant Teachers in this region. The selection proceedings were held on 4.8.2011 and the outcome thereof was intimated to the concerned institutions and the District Inspector of Schools on 11.8.2011

    4. The Director of Education issued a Circular on 15th of September, 2011 to all the Regional Joint Directors of Education throughout the State informing that certain writ petitions had been filed before the Lucknow Bench where a challenge had been raised to the process of selection, and therefore keeping in view the orders passed in those pending writ petitions, the results of the selections shall not be declared without the prior approval of the Director of Education. Accordingly, the District Inspector of Schools sought further instructions on which clarifications were sought through various communications thereafter. The Regional Joint Director of Education, Basti was also called upon to submit his explanation and directions were issued not to make any further payment of salary. The Joint Director of Education, Basti Region thereafter sent his clarifications intimating the outcome of the selections and also the manner of the process of selection. The Regional Joint Director of Education further informed that the selections were held in accordance with the 2009 Rules. The District Inspector of Schools, Basti through his letter dated 19th of May, 2012 informed the Directorate that in view of the directions issued by the Regional Joint Director of Education, Basti, salary was being paid under the orders dated 21.10.2011

    5. It appears that certain complaints were again received whereupon the Regional Joint Director of Education, Basti was called upon to submit his further explanation and for taking action in the matter. This explanation was called for by the Director in view of the powers conferred under the 2009 Rules contained in Chapter II Para 15 where the Director of Secondary Education has been empowered to nullify any selection proceedings if they are found to be in violation of the prescribed rules.

    6. A three member committee is stated to have been constituted for carrying out the enquiry whereupon the documents pertaining to the selections of Basti Region were called upon that were submitted for enquiry.

    7. Several members of the State Legislative Council appear to have raised this question in respect of selections throughout the State in Sanskrit institutions which were also taken notice of and reports were called for Reflections were also cast on the functioning and the selections held during the regime of the previous elected Government in office. The Director of Education further found that action had been taken even in violation of the model code of conduct that was promulgated for the Assembly elections and then in the ultimate analysis the Director of Secondary Education upon a consideration of the said complaints and the alleged violations passed the impugned order on 4th of December, 2012. The order was also founded on the joint enquiry of the team that had been constituted and had submitted a report.

    8. The petitioners, out of whom some had been elected as head of an institution, and the majority of them as assistant teachers, had received salary who were called upon to refund the amount of salary received by them by the impugned order dated 12.12.2012 whereafter they challenged the order of cancellation dated 4.12.2012 and 12.12.2012 in the writ petition giving rise to the present special appeal.

    9. As noted above the learned single Judge granted a partial interim order staying the recovery against the appellants and called upon the respondents to file a counter affidavit. It is in this background that the appellants have come forward in this appeal to contend that the learned single Judge ought to have granted an interim relief of allowing the appellants to continue on their post and receive salary as the impugned order dated 4.12.2012 cancelling the selection and appointment was in violation of principles of natural justice, inasmuch as, no notice or opportunity was given either to the institutions where the appellants were appointed or to the appellants in person. It was thus alleged that this amounts violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. While narrating their cause the petitioner appellants in paragraph 37 of their writ petition have enumerated the grounds on which the impugned orders were passed and raised a challenge to the said grounds contending that none of them were legally sustainable.

    10. Sri Ashok Khare, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Sri Uma Nath Pandey for the appellants has reiterated those submissions and has urged that none of the said grounds could have been made the basis for passing of the impugned orders as they are factually nonexistent and legally unsustainable and further that the impugned orders having been passed in violation of principles of natural justice the orders deserve to be quashed.

    11. Replying to the aforesaid submissions leaned Standing Counsel urges that the matter is still engaging the attention of the learned single Judge and that the selections having been vitiated for non compliance of the 2009 Rules the impugned order will be subject to any scrutiny by the learned single Judge. Sri Shukla learned Standing Counsel who represents the State including the respondents 1 to 12 contends that no counter affidavit has been filed till date in the said writ petition but on the basis of the records he has no objection to the matter being disposed of finally at this stage itself. Learned counsel for the parties therefore agree that this appeal be disposed of to-gether with the pending writ petition No. 68458 of 2012.

    12. The respondent Nos. 13 to 30 are the respective managements of those institutions where the appellants had been appointed and appear to be supporting the cause of the appellants. We therefore do not propose to issue any notice to those respondents at this stage keeping in view the nature of the order this is proposed to be passed.

    13. Sri Ashok Khare contends that the order being in violation of principles of natural justice, the Director of Education can be commanded to hear the appellants and then pass appropriate orders after giving an opportunity of hearing. To this proposal of Sri Ashok Khare, the learned Standing Counsel contends that the matter can be disposed of finally but the appellants cannot be permitted to continue on their post or receive salary till such enquiry is finalised and orders are passed.

    14. In view of the aforesaid position that emerges and with the consent of the parties the court finds that the impugned orders dated 4.12.2012 and 12.12.2012 have been passed without complying with the principles of natural justice. The appellants had admittedly undergone the selection process after having applied against the post in question and had been appointed. It is also stated that they had received salary for some time but the same was stopped and ultimately the impugned orders have been passed for even recovering the said salary that had been paid to the appellants. This in our opinion could not have been done without following the elementary rules of natural justice, inasmuch as, once the Director of Education had undertaken an enquiry and had relied upon an enquiry report then the appellants were entitled to an opportunity of hearing prior to the cancellation of their selection and appointment. The order of cancellation and appointment therefore suffers from the violation of principles of natural justice. From a perusal of the orders impugned in the writ petition we do not find any recital that opportunity had been given to the appellants or to their institutions prior to the passing of the impugned order by the Director. This being the position, we hold that the petitioners were entitled for an opportunity of hearing before determining their rights to continue and receive salary on the post in question.

    15. The appellants have urged that the advertisement was in consonance with the 2009 Regulations and had been issued after identifying the vacancies and selections were held after following the process in accordance with law. They also urged that the rule of reservation as indicated in the impugned orders were not applicable and the same have been wrongly applied while passing the impugned order. We find that the Director of Education has not taken notice of the relevant Government Orders as also the pronouncements of this court including the judgment of the Full Bench in the case of Heera Lal v. State of U.P, reported in 2010 (6) ADJ Pg. 1 (F.B) : (2010 (5) ALJ 379) to determine the extent of applicability of reservation institution-wise. The contentions therefore made by the appellants in paragraphs 38 to 56 of the writ petition raise grounds that require an objective determination after giving an opportunity of hearing to the appellants. Apart from this the question of recovery of salary would be dependent upon such a decision being taken in accordance with law and therefore the court also finds that the order passed by the Regional Joint Director of Education for recovering salary cannot be implemented so long as appropriate orders are not passed as observed hereinabove.

    16. However keeping in view the nature of the alleged irregularities that have been referred to in the impugned order it would be appropriate that all the appellants are given a post decisional hearing by the Director of Secondary Education who shall now grant an opportunity to all the appellants which they shall avail of by filing their written representations within a period of three weeks from today. The magnitude of the alleged irregularities impels us to allow this procedure to be accepted as observed by the Apex Court in Canara Bank v. Debasis Das, (2003) 4 SCC 557 Paras 23 and 24 : (AIR 2003 SC 2041 Paras 23 and 24). Nonetheless it is the obligation of the authority to objectively deal with such matters by separating “the grain from the chaff” as observed by the Apex Court in the case of Union of India v. Rajesh P.U, Puthuvalnikathu, (2003) 7 SCC 285 : (AIR 2003 SC 4222) and in the Division Bench judgment of our court in the case of State of U.P v. Pawan Kumar Singh, 2009 (3) ADJ Pg. 166. The Director thereafter shall proceed to examine the grievance of the appellants in the light of the observations made hereinabove and after giving an opportunity of hearing to them and proceed to pass an appropriate order without being influenced by the conclusions drawn by him in the order dated 4.12.2012 We further direct that till such orders are passed as observed hereinabove, the Regional Joint Director of Education shall not proceed to implement the order dated 12.12.2012 for recovery of salary from the appellants which had been stayed by the learned single Judge under the interim order dated 3.1.2013

    17. The Director of Secondary Education shall proceed to pass appropriate orders within three months of the date of production of a certified copy of this order before him. This appeal and writ petition No. 68458 of 2012 stands disposed of finally with the consent of the parties. A copy of this order shall be placed on the records of writ petition No. 68458 of 2012 by the office as the said petition has also been disposed of by us today.

    18. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anand Vardhan Mishra & Others v. State Of U.P & Others.
    (Jan 21, 2013)