Sulaiman, C.J:— The question referred to the Full Bench is: “In the absence of any specific evidence as to custom, practice or agreement, what would be the fair ratio of distribution of the compensation awarded for agricultural land as between the landlord on the one hand and occupancy tenants on the other?”
A plot of land belonging to a zamindar and occupied by two tenants was acquired by the Government under the Land Acquisition Act. Separate compensations were awarded by the Collector to the zamindar and the tenants. It has been held that the tenants did not make a proper reference to the District Judge, and accordingly they have not been allowed to get any larger compensation. The zamindar objected, but his objection has been dismissed by the District Judge in appeal. A Bench of this Court has come to the conclusion that the full value of the compensation for the land acquired is Rs. 2,500, and has further held that the zamindar is entitled to only so much out of it as would represent adequate compensation for the acquisition of his interest in the land and that any excess amount which should have gone to the tenants can be retained by the Secretary of State.
In assessing the compensation the Bench has, on the strength of an earlier ruling of this Court in Rohan Lal v. Collector of Etah(1), and one of the Calcutta High Court in Collector of Jalpaiguri v. Jakpaiguri Tea Co.(2), proceeded on the principle that the market value of the land acquired, irrespective of any consideration as to how it is held by the various persons interested in it, should be first found out, and then the amount apportioned between the various claimants.
Such a view obviously gives much more to the zamindar than he would ever be able to get in an open market as consideration for his interest, when hampered by the rights of occupancy tenants. It also gives to the tenant a share in the enhanced value of the land on account of its becoming a building site, although the occupation by the tenant is for agricultural purposes only and he cannot build upon it. This seems somewhat unfair to Government. On the other hand, when the Government is forcibly acquiring land as a third party, it does not seem to be unfair that it should be called upon to pay the full value of the land which it can fetch if all the rights were to be simultaneously transferred free from all obstacles. The question of distribution among the claimants who can mutually settle their disputes among themselves does not directly concern the Government, nor does it seem just that the Government should take advantage of such a possible dispute. That question, however, has not been referred to us. The only question that arises for consideration is as to the apportionment of the compensation between the zamindar on the one hand and the tenants on the other.
The Board of Revenue have, in their Circulars, issued certain directions to Collectors fixing maxim both for the amount to be awarded to the zamindar and the amount to be awarded to an occupancy tenant in the case of culturable lands. An occupancy tenants allowed four times the rent-rate payable by a statutory tenant, plus 10 times the difference between that rate and the rent actually paid by the occupancy tenant; whereas the zamindar is allowed no more than 16 times his net profit. The method is not only a complicated one, but it is also difficult to see on what principles it is based.
In section 40 of the new Tenancy Act provision has been made for the acquisition of land by a landlord from an occupancy tenant, but that is for the special purpose of farming on improved lines, and before acquisition can be made the Collector has to be satisfied that reasonable grounds exist for ordering such an acquisition, and the Collector is bound to award to the tenant another land with similar advantages in the same village or, with his consent, in another village; and it is only to such extent as such land is not available that the Collector has to award monetary compensation. The rate of monetary compensation fixed is six times the annual rental value of the land calculated at rates prescribed for statutory tenants. But as non-occupancy tenants have become statutory tenants under the Act, the rents payable by statutory tenants are likely to approximate to rents payable by non-occupancy tenants. We do not think that this special provision can be of any help in fixing the proportion where land is acquired by Government from both the landlord and the tenant. The loss to the tenant is not represented by a multiple of the rent which he pays to the zamindar, but by a multiple of what he himself derives from the land.
The landlord can never sell his interest, subject to the rights of occupancy of tenants, at the full rate which the land would fetch if it were not hampered by occupancy rights. He is therefore not entitled to the entire compensation minus six times the rent. This would be ignoring the fact that without the surrender of the occupancy rights the utility of the land for building purposes is very small indeed, and the tenant is entitled to claim compensation for the surrender of his rights of occupation.
No doubt in Calcutta greater emphasis appears to have been laid in several cases on the fact that the zamindar is the owner of the land. As against this, it cannot be lost sight of that the occupancy tenant is in actual possession of the land and that the zamindar's possession is only constructive.
Prior to 1929, there does not appear to have been any case of this Court in which any hard and fast rule for apportionment was laid down. In the case of Hirdey Narain v. Powell the High Court did not accept all the conclusions of the District Judge and did not find that the tenant had any transferable right or any absolute right to build upon the land, and yet it divided up the amount of the compensation between the zamindar and the tenant in the ratio of the net incomes derived by each. At page 13 the learned Judges observed: “in the absence of definite evidence as to the respective rights of the parties in the land, we think that the sum awarded should be divided between them in proportion to the values of the interests hitherto enjoyed by them, after making due allowance for the possibility of the rent being enhanced.” They accepted the finding of the District Judge that the annual value of the tenant's interest in the land was Rs. 22 and the annual value of the appellant's interest was Rs. 11 and then they divided the total sum in the proportion of two-thirds and one-third respectively.
In the case of Orde v. Secretary of State for India the occupancy tenants did not come up in appeal before the High Court and the zamindar alone was claiming a larger amount than what had been awarded. It had been found by the District Judge that the market value of the property was at the rate of Rs. 500 per bigha. The Collector had awarded to the tenant compensation at the rate of Rs. 108 per bigha and to the zamindar at 4 the rate of Rs. 213. The District Judge disallowed the claim of the zamindar to get more, on the ground that “as the land in question was hampered by the existence of the tenants' occupancy rights it had no value, other than the value calculated on its rent income, to a person who could not extinguish those occupancy rights.” The zamindar claimed the whole of the compensation minus what had been given to the tenant. A Division Bench of this Court (Piggott and Walsh, JJ.) held that had it been established that the occupancy tenants were prepared to surrender their rights to their proprietor for the time being in return for the sum awarded to them by the Collector, there might have been some basis for the contention that the award in favour of the zamindar should be increased by the difference between the market value of the land as a building site and the sum total of the compensation awarded by the Collector to both, but as there was no such evidence on the record, the mere acquiescence by the occupancy tenants in the Collector's award by means suggested as a necessary inference the fact that they would not have stood out for a higher price if they had found themselves bargaining with a proposed purchaser of the proprietary rights. In the result, they upheld the order of the District Judge under which the zamindar had got compensation at the rate of Rs. 213 per bigha, although the value of the land was found to be Rs. 500 per bigha. This also worked out at less than half.
The latest case of this Court is Rohan Lal v. Collector of Etah. The Division Bench, to which one of us was a party, clearly pointed out that there was a substantial disparity between the rights of a landlord and the rights of an occupancy tenant in these provinces. The following facts were particularly emphasised, at page 769, viz., (1) that an occupancy tenant's rent is liable to enhancement, although within statutory limits; (2) that the tenant is unable to transfer his rights; (3), that his right even to sublet is very much limited; (4) that in the case of rent falling into arrears from whatever reason, he is liable to be ejected: (5) that in the case of the tenant dying without one of the statutory heirs, the tenancy would lapse to the landlord. It was also added that the number of statutory heirs was small and the chances of the occupancy rights lapsing were not at all remote. The reference to the rights to the minerals may be disregarded. The learned Judges conceded that it was difficult to give a money value to the respective rights of the zamindar and the occupancy tenant; but that a fair estimate of the respective rights of the zamindar and the occupancy tenant was in the ratio of 10 annas and 6 annas in the rupee.
As against the points in favour of the zamindar, there are points in favour of the occupancy tenant as well:
1. (a) No doubt, an occupancy tenant's rent is liable to enhancement, but the enhancement of the rent of an occupancy tenant cannot be effected more than once in 20 years, and this, too, for not more than 25 percent, (sections 67 and 50 of the Tenancy Act).
(b) As against this, the Government revenue payable by the zamindar is also liable to 4 enhancement, though it cannot be enhanced within the period of the existing settlement.
2. Of course, the occupancy, tenant has no right to transfer his rights, whereas the zamindar can transfer his proprietary interest. But the value of the transferable interest of the zamindar is, for all practical purposes, governed by the rent which he receives from the tenant. Although he transfers his other contingent rights, he has no right of actual occupation.
3. The fight of a tenant to sublet the land is very much limited, but as against this the zamindar's right to sublet the land to anybody else and put him in possession does not exist so long as the occupancy tenant continues.
4. The tenant is liable to ejectment when the rent falls into arrears. Similarly the zamindar's proprietary interest can be sold if be does not pay the Government revenue.
5. In the case of the tenant's line becoming extinct or there being no other collateral sharing in the cultivation, the tenancy would lapse to the landlord. But such a contingency may be remote; and there is also a possibility of the zamindar dying heir less, in which case the land would escheat to Government.
The outstanding facts are that the landlord's right is limited in practice to the collection of rent whereas the tenant is in actual physical possession of the land, and on the other hand the proprietary interest in the land vests exclusively in the zamindar and not in the tenant. If the zamindar were to sell his land occupied by occupancy tenants in open market he cannot get a higher price than what would be calculated on the basis of the rent realised by him, because the occupation by the occupancy tenant stands in the way of his building upon it. On the other hand, it is also clear that an occupancy tenant has no right to build upon the land without the permission of the zamindar, and such permission would not ordinarily be obtained without the payment of a heavy nazrana. The tenant's right is primarily confined to the occupation of the land for agricultural purposes. He can always get his full subletting value, but not ordinarily its value as a building site. But he is also entitled to surrender value of the land, that is to say, the compensation which he can demand from the landlord before be would agree in surrender his occupancy rights. When land is acquired compulsorily, the tenant loses his physical possession whereas the zamindar loses his proprietary interest and constructive possession. It therefore follows that the benefit of the enhanced value of the and should go both to the zamindar and the tenant. The question, in what proportion it should go, is a difficult one.
It seems to be very difficult to say definitely that in every case the bundle of rights possessed by the zamindar would necessarily outweigh the bundle of rights possessed by an occupancy tenant and even if they do so outweigh, it is still more difficult to value the excess of the rights possessed by the zamindar.
For instance, there may be a tenant who has a large family of sons and grandsons, and there is no prospect of his line becoming extinct, and he may also be fairly well off so that there is no fear of his being ejected for non-payment of rent. In such a case the prospective chance of the zamindar of obtaining the occupancy tenancy is almost negligible. On the other hand, thee may be an old Hindu widow as an occupancy tenant, who has no daughter, daughter's son or collateral of her deceased husband joint with her in the cultivation. In such a case the chance of the tenancy lapsing to the zamindar would be very great, and the value of the interest of the zamindar, therefore, fairly high.
The method adopted by Griffin and Chamier, JJ., in Hirdey Narain's case was that in the absence of definite evidence as to the respective rights of the parties in the land the apportionment should be in the ratio of the annual values of their interests, i.e in the ratio of the net profits to the zamindar and the net profits to the tenant. The net profits of the zamindar are to be determined by the difference in the amount of rent received and the amount of Government revenue paid by him; and the net profit of the occupancy tenant would be the difference between the rent which he would get by subletting the land and the rent which he pays to the zamindar. This method puts the zamindar and the tenant on the same footing so far as the enhanced value is concerned. But in most cases such a method of distribution of the compensation would result in giving to the zamindar slightly more than what the tenant would get and may approximate to the ratio of 10 annas and 6 annas in the rupee.
There can, therefore, be no great objection to the adoption of the rough rule of practice which was laid down in Rohan Lal's case when there are no other considerations and there is no other definite evidence to the contrary. It must, however, be clearly understood that this rough and ready rule is not accepted by me as any rule of law, but merely as a rule of practice for the purpose of forming a rough estimate of the respective rights of the zamindar and the tenants, to be a guide only when both the parties have failed to adduce, any definite evidence to show other considerations and circumstances which would lead to a more satisfactory assessment of their respective rights. When the parties have failed to adduce any evidence and the court has to apportion the amount, it cannot but act in a somewhat arbitrary manner in trying to make a fair estimate. I think that in such an event the court is not likely to be far wrong if it were to accept the ratio suggested in the latest case of this Court, prima facie as a just proportion. In the absence of definite evidence the court may presume that the interest of the landholder and that of the occupancy tenant are in the ratio of 10 to 6; but if there are other considerations and circumstances, that presumption may be rebutted. Of course, where either the landholder or the tenant proves that a specific amount has been spent on an extraordinary improvement of the land by him exclusively, compensation equal to that amount will have to be fixed separately for such improvement.
This is my answer to the question referred.
Mukerji, J.:— I agree with the Chief Justice and King, J., that as a rough and ready means of dividing the compensation between the landlord and the occupancy tenant the ratio of 10 to 6 is a fair ratio. I, however, wish to say a few words.
When the Government acquires a piece of land, it must pay the legitimate value of it, irrespective of the fact who holds the land and in what shares. The land may be held by, say, 100 petty sharers and it may again be held by tenants and sub-tenants. The proprietors may find it extremely difficult to agree among them selves as to whether they should sell the land, and therefore it may be well nigh impossible for them to sell the land to a private purchaser. Again, for the reason that some of the actual holders of the land are tenants without any right of transfer and for the reason that the landlord and the tenant can not agree to give a transferee good title and possession, there may be practical difficulty in transferring the property to a private individual. But these considerations can not be relevant in finding out the price which the Government must pay in acquiring the land. If these considerations were relevant, the Government would pay different prices for the same land in different circumstances which have nothing to do with the intrinsic worth of the land or the market value of it.
When the price payable by the Government has been determined, the question of apportionment will arise and then we must find out the proportionate values of the interests of the people who have anything to do with the land. This will have to be done, whether the land has any value as a building site or not. I am unable to discover any valid reason for making a distinction between methods of apportionment in these two cases. The argument that there were difficulties in the way of the proprietors or the holders of different interests in the land to give a perfect title and possession to a private purchaser does hold good in both cases and in both cases the difficulty is removed by the fact, of compulsory acquisition of all interests in the property. In the case of Rohan Lal v. Collector of Etah, to the decision in which I am a party, no distinction was drawn between a land fit for building site and land fit only for agricultural purposes, and, I respectfully submit, no such distinction exists. I may also mention by the way that in the said case the mention of the right of the landlord to the minerals was made in a general way and not having regard to the rights of landlords in these provinces, where there is only a temporary settlement. In another case, to the decision of which I was also a party, Khushal Singh v. Secretary of State for India, it was held that the Government and not the zamindar in these provinces was the owner of the minerals.
As regards the rules framed by the Board of Revenue for the assessment of the values of the interests of the tenant and the landlord in lands held and used for agricultural purposes, it is enough to say that those rules are not binding on the civil courts, and where they are in conflict with the right view of things they must give way.
I agree to the answer proposed by the Chief Justice.
King, J.:— I agree that the suggested ratio of 10 to 11 may be adopted as a rough and ready rule of practice in the absence of any evidence to the contrary, in exceptional cases, like the present one, where the land hag a special value as a potential building site.
In my opinion the ratio suggested has no application to ordinary cases where only the agricultural value of the land has to be considered. In such cases the question of apportionment between landlord and occupancy tenant does not arise. The Collector makes his award in accordance with the instructions contained in chapter XV of the Manual of the Revenue Department. The sums payable as compensation to the landlord and to the tenant respectively are separately assessed. The landlord's compensation is calculated in accordance; with paragraphs 467 to 474, and the occupancy tenant' compensation in accordance with paragraph 485. The point that I mean to emphasize is that the compensation payable to the landlord and to the tenant calculated separately and independently. The result is that there is no lump sum, or joint assessment, which has to be apportioned between the landlord and the tenant. It would no doubt be possible to work out the average ratio of the landlord's interest to the tenant's interest by comparing the sums paid as compensation to landlords and to tenants respectively in a large; number of cases. We have no materials for calculating the average ratio and I do not see what useful purpose would be served by such a calculation. In practice the courts are not called upon to divide any lump sura between the landlord and the tenant. If a reference is made to the court by the landlord, or by the tenant, then the court has to decide whether the compensation awarded to the landlord or to the tenant, as the case may be, is fair and adequate, but there is no question of apportionment of a lump sum between landlord and tenant.
It is only in exceptional cases, where the land has a special value as a potential building site, that the question of apportionment arises. I quite agree with the Chief Justice that this special building value should be divided between the landlord and the tenant. The land does not become available to a third party for building purposes unless the landlord transfers his interest and the occupancy tenant also surrenders his occupancy rights. Thus, both landlord and tenant are clearly entitled to a share in the special value. This principle is also expressly recognized in paragraph 491 of the Manual. Where the land has a special building value the assessment has to be made in a lump sum and both landlord and tenant are entitled to a share. So it is only in exceptional cases of this class that the question of apportionment between landlord and tenant irises. I see no reason to dissent from the suggested ratio of 10 to 6, but I would restrict the application of the ratio to cases where the land has a special value, as a building site, in addition to its agricultural value. It should also be understood that the suggested ratio applies only to temporarily settled estates.
By the Court:— In the absence of definite evidence the court may presume that the interests of the landlord and of the occupancy tenant, exclusive of specific amounts spent on extraordinary improvements of the land, are in the ratio of 10 to 6; but if there are other considerations or circumstances, that presumption may be rebutted.