Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Court-fee on Declaratory Suit

Factual and Procedural Background

The Full Bench was asked to decide whether the payment of Rs. 10 court-fee by a plaintiff (a minor suing through a guardian) on his plaint was sufficient or whether a larger ad valorem court-fee was payable. The plaintiff's case alleged that in an earlier partition suit he had been ineffectively represented by his guardian (defendant 3 / Govind Prasad), resulting in a compromise and a decree (suit No. 65 of 1927, Subordinate Judge, Ghazipur) which, he claimed, was not binding on him because of gross negligence. The plaintiff sought: (a) a declaration that the prior decree was void and not binding; and (b) in addition to (a) any other relief which the Court deemed just. He valued the subject-matter at Rs. 45,308 for jurisdictional purposes but paid only Rs. 10 court-fee for a declaration. An attempted amendment to supply further valuation failed. The Division Bench referred the discrete question on sufficiency of the Rs. 10 court-fee to the Full Bench.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court-fee of Rs. 10 paid by the plaintiff on the plaint was sufficient for the reliefs claimed (treating the claim as for a mere declaratory decree), and if not, what would be the proper court-fee payable.
  2. Relatedly, whether a suit which asks only that a previous decree be declared void (and is not coupled with a specific prayer for cancellation or setting aside) is a suit for a mere declaratory decree (attracting the fixed Rs. 10 fee under Article 17(3) of the Second Schedule) or, in substance, a suit for substantive relief attracting an ad valorem fee.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Position

  • The plaint alleged that the previous decree was not binding upon the plaintiff because his guardian had been grossly negligent; the plaintiff sought a declaration that the decree was null and void and ineffectual.
  • The plaintiff paid Rs. 10 court-fee, treating the suit as one for a mere declaratory decree; no separate valuation for additional substantive relief was provided and an amendment attempt failed.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents, through their advocate, relied heavily on the Full Bench decision in Kalu Ram v. Babu Lal (AIR 193 All 485), arguing that when a plaintiff effectively seeks substantive relief (even if framed as a declaration or described as consequential relief), the Court can look to the real nature of the relief and demand the proper ad valorem court-fee.
  • They argued that when a plaintiff seeks to get rid of a decree which can be executed against him, the relief is, in substance, more than a mere declaration and should attract ad valorem fees under the Court-fees Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kalu Ram v. Babu Lal, AIR 193 All 485 Held that reliefs to have instruments adjudged void and cancelled, or reliefs which are substantive in nature though described as consequential, attract ad valorem court-fee; Court can look to the real nature of the relief to demand proper fee. The Full Bench considered and limited the scope of this decision: it accepted that where a plaintiff expressly seeks cancellation of a compromise or decree (or cancellation of instruments), that is more than a mere declaratory relief and ad valorem fee is due. But it held that Kalu Ram did not mean that a court can demand fee for a relief that the plaintiff has deliberately omitted to claim; Kalu Ram only applies where the plaintiff actually claims what in reality is a substantive relief.
Robert Fischer v. Secretary of State (1899) 22 Mad 270 Discussed the origin and purpose of declaratory decrees and Section 42 of the Specific Relief Act; recognized broader forms of declaratory relief than those contemplated by the Act's framers. The Court relied on this to show historical grounding for allowing declaratory decrees beyond a narrow statutory conception, and to explain the origin and purpose of Section 42 when distinguishing declaratory suits from substantive reliefs.
Partab Singh v. Bhabuti Singh (1913) 35 All 487 Example where minors were granted declarations that a prior decree obtained by fraud of a guardian was not binding; the relief amounted to setting aside the previous decree and restoring previous rights. Used to illustrate that declaratory reliefs have been used in the past to grant effective relief to minors in cases of fraud or misrepresentation by guardians, supporting the proposition that some declarations can have the effect of setting aside prior decrees.
Radha Krishna v. Ram Narain, AIR 1931 All 369 Part of a course of decisions in the Court holding that where nothing more than a mere declaration is sought, a suit is for a declaratory decree and no ad valorem court-fee can be charged. Relied upon as part of a consistent line of precedent supporting the rule that a mere declaration attracts only the fixed declaratory fee (Article 17(3)), reinforcing stare decisis.
Brij Gopal v. Suraj Karan, AIR 1932 All 560 Another recent decision in the same Court consistent with the rule that mere declaratory suits attract the fixed fee only. Relied upon as supporting authority for the proposition that suits seeking nothing more than a declaration are chargeable only with the Rs. 10 fee.
Lakshmi Narain Rai v. Dip Narain Rai, AIR 1933 All 350 Part of the Court's line of cases treating mere declaratory relief as not attracting ad valorem fees under the Court-fees Act. Adduced by the Court to demonstrate continuity of decisions holding that mere declaratory claims are governed by the fixed fee provision.
Muhammad Ismail v. Liyaqat Hussain, AIR 1932 All 310 Included among decisions affirming that a declaration alone does not require ad valorem court-fee. Used with the other authorities to support the view that the Court should not depart from its established practice by treating a pure declaratory suit as one that attracts ad valorem fees.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Full Bench proceeded through a structured analysis based strictly on the plaint and authorities:

  1. Characterisation of the Pleadings: The Court examined the plaintiff's plaint and noted the specific prayers: (a) declaration that the earlier decree was not binding and was void; and (b) a general prayer for "any other relief which may... be just." The plaint was valued for jurisdiction but no separate valuation was given for any substantive relief, and an amendment to supply valuation failed.
  2. Examination of Kalu Ram: The Court closely read the Full Bench decision in Kalu Ram v. Babu Lal. It accepted Kalu Ram's holding that where a plaintiff claims substantive relief (for example, cancellation of an instrument or of a compromise decree) such relief is more than a mere declaratory relief and attracts ad valorem fee. It also accepted Kalu Ram's statement that courts may inquire into the real nature of a claimed "consequential" relief to determine the proper fee.
  3. Limiting Kalu Ram's Reach: The Court emphasised that Kalu Ram did not intend to allow courts to levy fees on substantive reliefs which the plaintiff deliberately omitted to claim. Kalu Ram applies where the plaintiff actually asks for a relief which, despite being labelled "declaratory" or "consequential," is in substance substantive.
  4. Distinction between Instruments and Decrees: The Court noted the point made in Kalu Ram that suits to cancel or adjudge registered instruments void are substantive (Section 39 Specific Relief Act). However, a suit to avoid or set aside a decree does not strictly fall within Section 39 and may not even fall within Section 42 of the Specific Relief Act. Nonetheless, if a plaintiff expressly asks for cancellation or setting aside of a decree (in addition to a declaration) he is asking for more than a mere declaration and can be called upon to pay ad valorem fee for that relief.
  5. Consideration of Competing Views: The Court acknowledged divergent views in other High Courts that treating a declaration that a decree is void as merely declaratory may be a legal fiction because in substance the plaintiff seeks to neutralise an enforceable decree. But it balanced that against the fiscal character of the Court-fees Act, which demands strict construction in favour of the subject, and against the Court's own long line of decisions holding that pure declaratory claims attract only the fixed fee.
  6. Reliance on Stare Decisis: Given the consistent course of decisions in this Court (citing several recent cases), the Full Bench held that stare decisis and precedent should not be disturbed. The Court therefore classified the instant suit as one seeking only a declaratory decree, falling under Article 17(3) of the Second Schedule.
  7. On the Vague General Prayer: The Court addressed the additional prayer for "any other relief which may... be just" and found it too vague and indefinite to be treated as a substantive claim that would change the nature of the suit or require additional court-fee. It held that such a general residual prayer merely reminds the Court of its power to grant other reliefs and does not convert a declaratory suit into a substantive one.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Full Bench answered the referred question in the affirmative: the court-fee of Rs. 10 paid by the plaintiff was sufficient because the plaint, viewed as filed, sought only a declaratory decree and thus fell under Article 17(3) of the Second Schedule.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The plaintiff's suit is to be treated as a suit for a mere declaratory decree; no ad valorem court-fee is due on the basis of the plaint as it stood and the Rs. 10 fee was sufficient.
  • On the additional vague prayer for "any other relief": The Court held that such a generic prayer did not change the nature of the suit and did not justify demand for additional court-fee.
  • On precedent and wider law: The Court expressly adhered to its prior line of decisions (stare decisis) and limited the scope of Kalu Ram to cases where substantive relief is actually claimed; the opinion does not purport to create a new broader principle beyond this clarification.

The answer is returned to the Bench concerned as directed by the Full Bench in the opinion.

    Sri Krishna Chandra v. Mahabir Prasad

    1. The following question has been referred to the Full. Bench for an answer:

    "Whether the court-fee of Rs. 10 paid by the plaintiff on the plaint as filed by him was sufficient, and it not, what would be the proper court-fee payable."

    2. The plaintiff in this case was a minor suing through a guardian and his case was that in a previous suit brought for the partition of a joint Hindu family property he was not effectively represented by his guardian who was very negligent and careless and did not properly look after his case. The suit was referred to arbitration which resulted in an award which was incorporated in the decree of the Court, The plaintiff prayed for the following reliefs specifically: (a) It may be held that Govind Prasad, defendant 3rd party, did not in any way look after the rights of the plaintiff during the pendency of suit No. 65 of 1927, in the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Ghazipur, and that he was guilty of gross negligence on account of which the plaintiff was greatly deprived of his rights, and it may be declared that the decree No. 65 of 1927 is not in any way binding upon the plaintiff and is altogether void and ineffectual, (b) In addition to relief (a) any other relief which may, in the opinion of the Court, be just, may also be granted to the plaintiff against the defendants, together with the costs of this suit.

    3. He valued the subject-matter of the suit for purposes of jurisdiction at Rs. 45,308 but paid a Court fee of Rs. 10 for the declaration that the decree is null and void. No separate valuation was given for the reliefs claimed. An attempt to supply it by way of amendment proved infructuous. The question that arose before the Division Bench was whether the payment of Rs. 10 as Court fee, treating the relief claimed as one for obtaining a mere declaratory decree, was sufficient or whether the plaintiff was claiming something more, i.e., a substantial relief for which an ad valorem Court fee should be charged. Recently a Bench of five Judges has had to consider some provisions of the Court-fees Act in Kalu Ram v. Babu Lal AIR 193 All 485. In that case the plaintiff had asked for reliefs for adjudging a certain mortgage deed void and ineffectual and for its cancellation and also for the cancellation of a compromise decree which resulted in a preliminary decree. The Full Bench pointed out that the reliefs claimed were something more than a mere declaratory decree and that the payment of Rs. 10 was not sufficient.

    4. The learned advocate for the respondents has relied strongly on a passage in Kalu Ram v. Babu Lal AIR 193 All 485, at p. 690 (of 1932 A.L.J.) where it was remarked that if a substantive relief is claimed though clothed in the garb of a declaratory decree with a consequential relief, the Court is entitled to see what is the real nature of the relief and if satisfied that it is not mere consequential relief but a substantive relief it can demand the proper Court fee on that relief, irrespective of the arbitrary valuation put by the plaintiff in the plaint on the ostensible consequential relief. Obviously the Full Bench did not 'intend to lay down that where the plaintiff deliberately omits to claim a consequential relief and contents himself with claiming a mere declaratory decree, the Court can call upon him to pay Court fees on the consequential relief which he should have claimed although he has omitted to do so. What was held was that if the plaintiff does not ask for a mere declaratory decree: but also asks for a relief which he calls "consequential" relief, the mere fact that he calls it so would not prevent the Court from demanding full court-fee; if in reality the additional relief claimed was a substantive relief and. not a mere consequential relief. We do not think that the observation was. intended to go further than this.

    5. On the other hand, there is no doubt that so far as the suits relating to the cancellation of instruments are concerned, the Full Bench in Kalu Ram v. Babu Lal AIR 193 All 485, on p. 689 of 1932 A.L.J. clearly held that a relief to have a registered instrument adjudged void or voidable with the possible result of its being delivered up and cancelled and a copy of the decree being sent to the registration office for a note to be made by the registering officer in his books, is much more than a mere declaratory relief. It is undoubtedly a substantial relief of a nature differing from a declaratory one. It was. clearly pointed out that it was not incumbent on a plaintiff to ask in express terms a relief for the instrument to be delivered up and cancelled and that he might merely ask for its being adjudged void or voidable. Nevertheless a suit which falls under Section 39 of the Specific Relief Act, was held to be not a suit for obtaining a mere declaratory decree, but one for obtaining a substantive relief not otherwise provided for. The case of a decree stands on a different footing, because a suit to avoid it does not strictly fall under Section 39 of the Specific Relief Act. Strictly speaking, it would not even fall within the scope of Section 42, Specific Relief Act. Where the plaintiff chooses to ask for a definite relief for the cancellation of a decree or for the setting aside of that decree in addition to a declaration that the decree is not binding upon him, he is professedly asking for something more than a mere declaratory decree. At the stage at which the question of Court fee arises, it is immaterial to consider whether such relief is superfluous, redundant or useless or even impossible to be granted. Obviously, he has asked for more and so long as he does not amend his plaint and abandon this relief he can be called upon to pay Court fee for the relief asked for.

    6. The case before the Full Bench was of such a type. There the plaintiff had in express terms asked for the cancellation of the compromise and the preliminary decree. Ad valorem court-fee on the consolidated prayer for the cancellation of the compromise and the decree was accordingly held to be due. As regards the case where the plaintiff stops short of asking anything more than a mere declaration that a certain decree is not binding upon him, opinion in the various High Courts is divided. There is no doubt that Section 42, of the Specific Relief Act is not exhaustive so as to exclude all other forma of declaratory suits. Indeed, in several cases their Lordships of the Privy Council have entertained declaratory suits and granted declarations which strictly speaking did not fall within the purview of Section 42, of the Specific Relief Act. In Robert Fischer v. Secretary of State (1899) 22 Mad 270, (at p. 282), their Lordships pointed out that that suit was to have the true construction of the statute declared and to have an act done in contravention of the statute, rightly understood, pronounced void and of no effect. Their Lordships observed that that is not the sort of declaratory decree which the framers of the Act had in their mind. In Partab Singh v. Bhabuti Singh (1913) 35 All 487, their Lordships granted to minors, against whom a decree had been obtained by the fraud and misrepresentation of their de facto guardian and manager, a declaration that the decree was not binding upon them. The actual form of the decree was a decree setting aside the previous decree and declaring that the agreement of compromise and the decree based upon it were not binding upon the minors or either of them, and that they were entitled to such rights as they had before their previous suit was dismissed.

    7. The origin and purpose of Section 42, of the Specific Relief Act and the history how declaratory decrees came to be granted have been set out in the judgment of their Lordships in Robert Fischer's case (1899) 22 Mad 270. No doubt there has "been some laxity in allowing plaintiffs to frame their plaints by asking for declarations of all sorts. But where a plaintiff expressly asks for something more than a mere declaration, for example, cancellation or the setting aside of a decree, it is difficult to hold that the claim is one merely for obtaining a declaratory decree. The difficulty arises only where he simply asks that it be declared that a certain decree which has been passed against him previously is null and void and is not binding upon him.

    8. The view taken in some cases of the other High Courts is that in such a suit the plaintiff is trying to get rid of a decree which stands in his way and which is capable of being executed against him and that without having that decree set aside or cancelled the plaintiff would have no right to resist its execution, and accordingly such a relief is not one merely for obtaining a declaratory decree but is for obtaining a mere substantive relief, which is not specifically provided for in the Court-fees Act and would accordingly fall under Article 1, of the Schedule 1. It cannot be denied that there is something to be said for such a view because in substance the object of the plaintiff is to frustrate a decree which has been passed against him and to nullify it and to get it out of his way. On the other hand, the Court-fees Act is a fiscal measure and is to be construed strictly and in favour of the subject There is also no' doubt that there is a long course of decisions in this Court in which it has been laid down consistently, and over and over again, that where nothing more than a mere declaration is sought for, the suit is one for obtaining a declaratory decree and no ad valorem court-fee for such a relief can be charged. We may in this connection refer only to the recent cases of this Court in Radha Krishna v. Ram Narain AIR 1931 All 369; Brij Gopal v. Suraj Karan AIR 1932 All 560, Lakshmi Narain Rai v. Dip Narain Rai AIR 1933 All 350 and Muhammad Ismail v. Liyaqat Hussain AIR 1932 All 310.

    9. We accordingly think that on the principle of stare decisis, if nothing else, this course of decisions should not now be disturbed. We accordingly hold that inasmuch as the plaintiff in this case merely asked for a declaration that the previous decree was not in any way binding upon him and was altogether void and ineffectual, his suit was one for obtaining a declaratory decree only and falls under Article 17(3)" of the second schedule. The learned Advocate for the respondents has further urged that inasmuch as the plaintiff added relief (b) which was to the effect that in addition to relief (a) any other relief which may, in the opinion of the Court, be just, may also be granted to the plaintiff against the defendants, he must be deemed to have claimed more than a mere declaratory decree. But such a relief is unnecessarily added in most plaints and is not intended to mean anything more than reminding the Court of its power to grant other reliefs even though not specifically asked for. As the words are too vague and indefinite, and no specific and definite relief is referred to therein, we cannot regard it as one which requires the demand of additional court-fee nor do we consider that coupled with the declaratory relief it changes the nature of the relief claimed. Our answer to the question referred to us is in the affirmative. Let the answer be returned to the Bench concerned.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sri Krishna Chandra v. Mahabir Prasad
    (Apr 27, 1933)