Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure and that section
  • section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • SECTION 95 EVIDENCE ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure and that section
  • section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • SECTION 95 EVIDENCE ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant mortgaged zamindari property in the village "Nawadiya Zamania Nagla," but due to an accidental slip, the mortgage deed described the property as situated in "Nagla Zamania Nawadiya." There is no village by that latter name, nor did the mortgagor have any interest there. Despite this error, the mortgagee brought a suit based on the mortgage, obtained a preliminary decree upheld on appeal, a final decree, and conducted a sale where the mortgagee himself purchased the property. Throughout these proceedings, the erroneous description persisted. The mistake became apparent when the mortgagee applied to the revenue court for mutation as purchaser, which was refused due to the incorrect property description. The mortgagee then sought amendment of the decree under section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Subordinate Judge declined jurisdiction, stating the decree had merged in the District Judge’s decree. The District Judge also refused jurisdiction, indicating the applicant should have appealed the Subordinate Judge’s order. The mortgagee filed a revision petition to the High Court; a Bench held the District Judge had jurisdiction and remanded the matter. After taking evidence confirming the misdescription, the District Judge granted the amendment application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure permits correction of mistakes made by the parties themselves, as opposed to clerical errors made by the court or its officers.
  2. Whether the District Judge had jurisdiction to amend the final decree passed by the Subordinate Judge, which was not appealed against.
  3. Whether the court could call for evidence to ascertain the existence of a misdescription in the mortgage deed.
  4. Whether the court’s power to amend extended beyond the decree to related documents such as the plaint, sale certificate, and dakhalnama.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • Section 152 applies only to mistakes made by the court or its ministerial officers, not to mistakes made by the parties.
  • The District Judge lacked jurisdiction to amend the final decree passed by the Subordinate Judge which was not appealed.
  • The District Judge had no jurisdiction to call for evidence to verify the alleged misdescription.

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • Section 152’s language is broad enough to cover correction of mistakes made by the parties themselves.
  • Precedents support correction of the plaint, decree, and connected documents where a misdescription exists.
  • The court has inherent powers under sections 151 and 153 of the Code of Civil Procedure to make necessary corrections for the ends of justice beyond the strict confines of section 152.
  • The District Judge had jurisdiction to hear and decide the application as held by the High Court in revision.
  • Under section 95 of the Evidence Act, the court was entitled to call evidence to establish the true description of the property.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Chandar Sarup v. Mazhar Hussain Section 152 deals with amendments of clerical errors in court orders or decrees; distinction between clerical errors and substantial amendments. The Court distinguished this precedent because the correction sought here was a mere misdescription, not a substantial amendment; also noted the precedent acknowledged jurisdiction to correct mistakes made by parties on questions of fact.
Balaprasad v. Kanoo Consideration of whether section 152 applies to mistakes originating prior to the suit. The Court disagreed with the restrictive interpretation in that case and held the plain language of section 152 covers such corrections.
Sheo Balak Pathak v. Sukhdei Amendment of proceedings from plaint through decree to correct errors. Cited as support for allowing amendments to various documents to reflect true facts.
Sarju Kumar Mukerji v. Sheikh Enayat Husain Correction of plaint, decree, and connected documents for misdescription. Facts similar to current case; Court ordered correction, supporting the present amendment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the scope of section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure, concluding that its language is sufficiently broad to permit correction of mistakes made by the parties themselves, not solely clerical errors by the court. It distinguished the precedent in Ram Chandar Sarup v. Mazhar Hussain by noting that the correction there involved a substantial amendment, unlike the present case which involved a simple misdescription. The Court rejected the restrictive view expressed in Balaprasad v. Kanoo, favoring the plain and literal interpretation of section 152. It further recognized that the court’s powers to amend are not confined to section 152 but extend to inherent powers under sections 151 and 153 of the Code, allowing correction of related documents beyond the decree. Jurisdictional objections regarding the District Judge’s authority to amend the final decree were foreclosed by the High Court’s earlier ruling affirming such jurisdiction. The Court also upheld the District Judge’s authority to call evidence under section 95 of the Evidence Act to verify the true description of the property. Ultimately, the Court emphasized that the correction was necessary to give effect to the parties’ true intentions and to uphold justice, characterizing the misdescription as an accidental slip unnoticed throughout prior proceedings.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED the applicant’s revision petition and upheld the order of the District Judge amending the mortgage decree and connected documents to correct the misdescription of the property.

The decision directly resolves the dispute between the parties by validating the amendment of the decree and related documents to reflect the true property description. No new precedent was established beyond reaffirming the broad remedial scope of section 152 and the court’s inherent powers to correct accidental slips for the ends of justice.

    Aziz Ullah Khan v. Collector Of Shahjahanpur

    King and Thom, JJ.:— This is an application in revision against an order passed by the District Judge to the effect that a mortgage decree and certain connected documents be amended.

    The applicant before us mortgaged certain zamindari property in a village called “Nawadiya Zamania Nagla”, but by an accidental slip the property was described in the mortgage deed as being situated in the village “Nagla Zamania Nawadiya”. The words are the same, but the order has been inverted by an accidental slip. It is admitted that there is no village bearing the latter name or, at least, that there is no village of that name in which the mortgagor has or ever had any interest. There was never any doubt as to the identity of the mortgaged property. The mortgagee brought a suit upon the basis of the mortgage, obtained a preliminary decree, which was upheld by the appellate court, obtained a final decree and brought the property to sale. The mortgagee himself purchased the property at the auction sale, obtained a sale certificate and obtained formal delivery of possession. Throughout all these proceedings the property was described erroneously as being situated in “Nagla Zamania Nawadiya” in accordance with the wording of the mortgage deed. It was not until the mortgagee, as auction purchaser, applied to the revenue court to have his name mutated as purchaser of the share that the mistake came to light. The revenue court refused the application for mutation on the ground that the auction purchaser, according to the sale certificate, had not purchased the property in Nawadiya Zamania Nagla.

    The mortgagee then applied to the trial Judge asking him Under section 152 to amend the decree. The Subordinate Judge rejected the application on the ground that his decree had become merged in that of the District Judge and he had no jurisdiction to amend the decree. The mortgagee then applied to the District Judge for amendment of the decree and the connected proceedings, but the District Judge also held that he had no jurisdiction to decide the application as the applicant should have appealed from the order of the Subordinate Judge. The mortgagee then went up to the High Court in revision. A Bench of this; Court decided that the District Judge had jurisdiction to hear and decide the application and returned the application to him for disposal. The District Judge having taken evidence to satisfy himself that there was, in fact, a misdescription of the property, granted the application for amendment.

    It has been argued before us, firstly, that the court below purports to take action under section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure and that section applies only to mistakes made by the court or by its ministerial officers and not to mistakes made by the parties to the suit. The language of that section is, in our opinion, wide enough to cover the correction of mistakes made by the parties themselves. The applicant has relied upon a decision of this Court in Ram Chandar Sarup v. Mazhar Hussain (1). In the judgment of that case their Lordships remarked: “Section 152 deals with amendments of clerical errors in orders or decrees of the court itself which are drawn up not properly representing what the court, decides.” In our opinion this decision can be distinguished upon the facts. The correction which the applicant in that case desired was not the correction of a mere misdescription of property but a very substantial amendment. The applicant had, as a creditor, filed a claim for Rs. 3,418 against the insolvent and had supported his claim by an affidavit. His claim was allowed to that extent. About two years later he applied to the insolvency court stating that the real amount of his debt was about Rs. 6,000 and by mistake he had stated that it was only Rs. 3,418. The insolvency court decided that there had been no mistake and that the debt should remain entered in the schedule at foe amount claimed by the applicant himself. Subsequently the applicant made a second application for correction to the same court. The insolvency court rejected the application, and it was held in revision by a Bench of this Court that section 152 did not apply so as to enable the insolvency court, in the circumstances of that case, to make the amendment desired. The amendment in that case was, as we have already noted, of a very different nature from the amendment now in question. It was a very substantial and important amendment which would involve taking further evidence to ascertain the correct amount of the debt. This ruling, moreover, cannot be taken as a clear authority for the proposition that the court is unable to correct a mistake made by the parties themselves. In an earlier portion of the judgment the court observed: “No doubt the insolvency court has the same jurisdiction that the ordinary courts of law possess under the Code of Civil Procedure to correct any mistake either of a clerk or of the parties themselves upon a question of fact, when a mistake is established.” This ruling therefore is no clear authority against the action taken by the court below in making the amendment.

    Another ruling, Balaprasad v. Kanoo , has been cited to support the applicant's contention. In that case a certain field was mortgaged and in the mortgage-deed the field was described by a wrong number. The error was not noticed by the parties throughout the proceedings in the subsequent mortgage suit and a decree-was given for sale of the mortgaged property described by the wrong number. When the error was discovered in the course of the execution proceedings the decree-holder instituted a suit for amendment of the decree. It was held by a single Judge of the Judicial Commissioner's court of Nagpur that the suit was maintainable. Incidentally the question was discussed whether the plaintiff had a remedy under section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The learned Judge expressed a very hesitating opinion on that point: “I am inclined to think that section 152 applies to mistakes which had an origin not anterior to the filing of the suit.” With due deference to the learned Judge we see no reason why the plain and literal meaning of the words should be restricted in the manner suggested.

    For the opposite party we have been referred to a ruling of this Court in Sheo Balak Pathak…Applicant v. Sukhdei…Opposite Party . (2), in which the Court ordered the amendment of the proceedings starting from the plaint right down to the decree. We have also been referred to an unreported decision of a Bench of this Court (of which one of us was a member) in Sarju Kumar Mukerji v. Sheikh Enayat Husain . The facts of that case were very similar to the facts of the case before us and the Court ordered the correction of the documents in question, namely the plaint, the decree and other documents. We see no reason why these decisions of this Court should not be followed, as they are in accordance with the ordinary meaning of the language in section 152.

    It has been further argued that the court below purports to act under section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure only and that section can only apply in terms to the amendment of the decrees and not to the amendment of the plaint, sale certificate and dakhalnama. This contention, no doubt, is correct, but the power of the court to make corrections necessary for the ends of justice is not confined only to powers exercisable under section 152. Extensive powers may be exercised also under sections 151 and 153. We consider that this is eminently a case in which the accidental slip should be corrected, as the correction is necessary for the ends of justice.

    A further objection raised on behalf of the applicant is that the District Judge had no jurisdiction to amend the final decree which was passed by the Subordinate Judge and was not appealed against. In answer to this, we think it is enough to say that it has been decided between the parties by the order of the High Court that the District Judge had jurisdiction to dispose of this application upon the merits and this point cannot be raised at this stage.

    The learned advocate for the applicant has also submitted that the District Judge had no jurisdiction to call for evidence to satisfy himself whether there had, in fact, been a misdescription of the property in the mortgage deed. In our opinion, this contention has no force, as under section 95 of the Evidence Act the court had jurisdiction to call evidence for the purpose of showing that the mortgage deed did, in fact, relate to the property in Nawadiya Zamania Nagla.

    This is a clear case of an accidental slip in the description of property. The misdescription was not even noticed by the parties throughout the whole course of the proceedings in the mortgage suit. There was never any doubt as to the identity of the property. In the circumstances we think this is clearly a case in which the court should exercise its inherent power of making such corrections as are necessary for the ends of justice. It would be a blot upon the judicial administration if the courts were powerless to do justice in a case of this sort, where corrections are necessary in order to give effect to the intentions of the parties themselves and to the true meaning of the mortgage decrees.

    We dismiss the application with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Aziz Ullah Khan v. Collector Of Shahjahanpur
    (Apr 19, 1932)