AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner purchased a double-storey shop (58 square meters) by a registered sale deed dated 21-3-1992 in the Sub-Registrar's office, Tehsil Kairana, District Muzaffarnagar, paying stamp duty calculated on the circle rate fixed by the District Magistrate. On 25-3-1992 the Sub-Registrar reported that the sale deed undervalued the property, asserting a market value of Rs. 3,60,000 instead of Rs. 1,70,000 and indicating a stamp duty deficiency of Rs. 27,550/-. On the Sub-Registrar's report, proceeding under Section 47-A of the Indian Stamp Act was initiated by the Additional District Magistrate (Finance & Revenue) (ADM (F&R)). The Tahsildar reported a market value of Rs. 1,80,400 (land Rs. 1,40,400 plus construction Rs. 40,000). The petitioner responded to the show cause notice, disputing non-payment and reliance on exemplars.

The ADM (F&R) by order dated 29-11-1995 rejected the Tahsildar's report and the petitioner's case, estimated value at Rs. 3,60,000 by presuming a monthly rent of Rs. 1,200 and applying Rule 341 (multiplication by 300). The petitioner challenged this by revision under Section 56 of the Indian Stamp Act; the revision was dismissed by order dated 29-11-1998. The petitioner thereafter filed the present writ petition seeking quashing of the impugned orders. While the writ petition was pending, this Court granted a conditional stay on 27-1-1999 subject to deposit of half the alleged deficiency.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Collector (or competent authority) had "reason to believe" within Section 47-A(3) Indian Stamp Act to determine that the market value of the property was understated in the registered instrument.
  2. Whether the report of the Sub-Registrar (and exemplars relied upon) constituted sufficient material to form the basis for an order under Section 47-A.
  3. Whether the ADM's method of valuation (presuming rent and applying Rule 341) was legally sustainable in the absence of supporting and comparable evidence.
  4. What burden of proof rests on the Collector once an instrument is registered and stamp duty measured by the Collector's prescribed minimum has been paid.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The sale consideration in the instrument was correctly set out and stamp duty was paid on the circle rate fixed by the District Magistrate.
  • The exemplars relied upon by the Sub-Registrar (documents Nos. 1485 of 1989 and 6960 of 1989) are inapplicable because the properties mentioned therein are differently situated; there is no evidence showing comparability.
  • Except for the Sub-Registrar's report, there was no material to show that the market value in the instrument was incorrect or that the parties deliberately undervalued the property.

Respondents' / State's Arguments (as represented by standing counsel)

  • The impugned orders and the valuation methodology applied by the ADM (and accepted in revision) were appropriate; the standing counsel supported the impugned orders.
  • Implicitly relied on the Sub-Registrar's report and exemplars to establish that the instrument was undervalued and that additional stamp duty was payable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramesh Chandra Bansal v. District Magistrate, AIR 1999 SC 2126 Section 47-A confers power upon a registering authority to deal with undervaluation of instruments. Used to confirm that Section 47-A empowers authorities to deal with under-valuation cases; cited in interpreting scope of Section 47-A.
Kaka Singh v. Additional Collector & District Magistrate (Finance & Revenue), 1986 ALJ 49 Section 47-A empowers the Collector to deal with deliberate undervaluation (market value set less than minimum under Rule 341) aimed at defrauding revenue. Relied upon to explain the Collector's power and to state the burden on the Collector once an instrument is registered and the prescribed duty has been paid.
State of Rajasthan v. Khandaka Jain Jewellers, AIR 2008 SC 509 Stamp Act is a fiscal statute and must be interpreted strictly; literal rule applies. Applied to emphasize that fiscal statutes like the Stamp Act require strict/literal interpretation without invoking equitable considerations.
A.V. Fernandez v. State of Kerala, AIR 1957 SC 657 Authority referenced in context of strict interpretation of fiscal statutes. Mentioned by the Court as an earlier authority referred to in the context of interpreting fiscal statutes strictly.
Government of A.P. & others v. Smt. P. Laxmi Devi, AIR 2008 SC 1640 / 2008 AIR SCW 1826 Referenced in the context of strict interpretation of fiscal statutes. Referred to alongside other Supreme Court authorities to support the proposition respecting literal interpretation.
S. Narayanappa & others v. CIT Bangalore, AIR 1967 SC 523 Phrase "reason to believe" is not purely subjective; belief must have rational connection to relevant material; not arbitrary. Used to interpret "reason to believe" in Section 47-A(3), holding that the Collector's belief must be based on relevant/material reasons and rational connection.
Kishore Chandra Agarwal v. State of U.P. & others, 2008 (104) RD 235 Wide powers have inherent limitations; discretion must be objective and tested for reasonableness; arbitrary action is ultra vires. Quoted to underline limits on public authorities' discretion under fiscal statutes and the need for reasonable, non-arbitrary exercise of power.
Hajari Lal Sahu v. State of U.P. & others, 2004 All LJ 1639 Supportive authority regarding the limits on exercise of revenue powers (similar view to Kishore Chandra Agarwal). Referred to as supporting the proposition that discretion under revenue statutes must be reasonably and fairly exercised.
Mahabir Prasad v. Collector, Cuttack, AIR 1987 SC 720 Definition of market value: what a willing purchaser would pay to a willing seller; concessional offers for inducement are not market value. Applied to clarify the meaning of "market value" for Section 47-A(3), and to exclude concessional/inducement prices from market valuation.
Ram Khelawan alias Bachcha v. State of U.P. through Collector, 2005 (98) RD 511 Report of the Tahsildar may be a relevant factor for initiating proceedings under Section 47-A but cannot be the sole basis for passing an order under that section. Applied directly: the Court held the Sub-Registrar's report (akin to Tahsildar's report) cannot by itself form the basis of an order under Section 47-A.
Prakashwati v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority Board of Revenue, Allahabad, 1996 (87) R.D. 419 Proximity or situation (e.g., near a decent colony) does not by itself make a property part of that area for valuation; valuation must be based on constructive materials. Relied on to support the proposition that valuation must rest on constructive/comparable materials and not on mere proximity or assumption.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first reproduced Section 47-A and identified two key phrases in sub-section (3): "reason to believe" and "market value." It explained that Section 47-A confers power on a registering authority/Collector to examine and determine market value within the statutory time limits, but the exercise of that power is subject to statutory limits.

Interpreting "reason to believe," the Court relied on precedents to hold that this phrase does not permit purely subjective or arbitrary satisfaction. The belief must be held in good faith, have a rational connection to relevant material, and be based on reasons which are relevant and material. Therefore the Collector's power, though wide, is not plenary and cannot be exercised on mere suspicion of evasion.

The Court described "market value" as the price at which willing buyer and seller would transact, taking into account local advantages and developmental potential; concessional rates or inducements are not market value.

Applying these legal principles to the facts, the Court observed:

  • The only material relied upon to conclude undervaluation was the Sub-Registrar's report (and exemplars/documents). The Tahsildar's report was rejected by the authorities below.
  • There was no material on record to demonstrate that the petitioners deliberately undervalued the property or that the exemplars were comparable to the property in question.
  • The ADM's assumed rent figure (Rs. 1,200 per month) and the multiplication by 300 under Rule 341 to reach Rs. 3,60,000 lacked supporting discussion or evidence showing comparability with the exemplars relied upon.
  • Authority and prior case law (notably Ram Khelawan and Kaka Singh) indicate that reports such as Tahsildar's or Sub-Registrar's may initiate inquiry but cannot themselves constitute the decisive material to pass an order under Section 47-A.
  • Once an instrument is registered and the prescribed minimum stamp duty has been paid, the burden to prove that market value exceeds that minimum rests on the Collector; the Sub-Registrar's report alone does not discharge that burden.

Because the requisite rational connection and relevant material to form a "reason to believe" under Section 47-A(3) were absent, and because the valuation methodology and exemplars were not shown to be comparable, the Court concluded that the impugned orders could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: THE WRIT PETITION IS ALLOWED; THE IMPUGNED ORDERS DATED 29-11-1995 AND 19-11-1998 ARE QUASHED.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The Court held that the petitioners are not liable to pay any further stamp duty on the instrument in question.
  • In view of an earlier conditional stay (27-1-1999) under which the petitioner deposited half the alleged deficiency, the respondents are directed to refund the amount deposited by the petitioner along with accrued interest within one month from production of a certified copy of the Court's order.
  • If the respondents fail to refund within that period, they shall pay interest at 10% per annum thereafter on the sum due until actual payment.
  • No order as to costs was made.

Broader implications: The Court emphasized that powers under Section 47-A(3) must be exercised on relevant and material grounds and that mere reports (Sub-Registrar/Tahsildar exemplars) without comparability or supporting material do not justify a determination that an instrument is undervalued. The decision reinforces the requirement that "reason to believe" be rationally grounded and that valuation be supported by constructive/comparable materials; however, the Court did not purport to lay down new law beyond applying and following the precedents cited.

    Vijay Kumar & Anr. v. Commissioner, Meerut Division & Anr.

    Judgement

    By means of a registered sale deed registered on 21-3-1992 in the office of Sub Registrar, Tehsil Kairana, District Muzaffarnagar, the petitioner purchased a double-storey shop measuring 58 square meter situate in Mohalla Dhimanpura, M.S.K Road Shamli, District Muzaffarnagar from one Manohar Singh for a sum of Rs. 1,70,000/- and paid the stamp duty thereon as per the circle rate fixed by the District Magistrate. The Sub Registrar, Tehsil Kairana District Muzaffarnagar on 25-3-1992 sent a report to the Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue) that the valuation of the property has not been correctly disclosed in the sale deed. According to him the market value of the property is Rs. 3,60,000/- instead of Rs. 1,70,000/- on which a sum of Rs. 52,200/- was payable as stamp duty. In other words according to him there was a deficiency of stamp duty of Rs. 27,550/-. Proceedings under Section 47-A of Indian Stamp Act was initiated by the Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue) on the basis of the said report. He also called for a report regarding the market value of the property in question from the Tahsildar who reported that the market value of the land is around Rs. 1,40,400/-and the cost of the construction standing there on is approximately Rs. 40,000/-. Thus the total value of the property sold as per his report was Rs. 1,80,400/- while it was shown as Rs. 1,70,000/- in the instrument i.e the sale deed.

    2. The petitioner, in response to the show cause notice, appeared before the ADM(FandR) and contended that the sale consideration in the instrument has been properly and correctly set out. The stamp duty has been paid as per the circle rate fixed by the District Magistrate. He further submitted that the exemplar referred to in the report of the Sub Registrar are not applicable to the facts of the present case as properties mentioned there in are differently situated.

    3. The ADM (FandR) by the order dated 29-11-1995 rejected the report of the Tahsildar as well as the case of the petitioner and presumed that at the time of the transfer, the monthly rent of the property in question could not have been less than Rs. 1,200/-and by multiplying it by 300/-as provided for under Rule 341 of Indian Stamp Rule, it estimated the valuation at Rs. 3,60,000/-. This order was challenged by way of revision No. 4 of 1995-1996 before the Commissioner, Meerut Division, Meerut, under Section 56 of the Indian Stamp Act. The revision having been dismissed by the impugned order dated 29-11-1998, the present writ petition has been filed for quashing the impugned orders.

    4. Heard and considered the respective submissions of the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    5. Section 47-A of the Act, for the sake of convenience, is reproduced below :-

    47-A Undervaluation of instrument- (1)(a) If the market value of any property, which is the subject of any instrument, on which duty is chargeable on market value of the property as set forth in such instrument is less than even the minimum value determined in accordance with the rules made under this Act, the registering officer appointed under the Registration Act, 1908 shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the said Act immediately after presentation of such instrument, and before accepting it for registration and taking any action under Section 52 of the said Act, require the person liable to pay stamp duty under Section 29, to pay the deficit stamp duty as computed on the basis of the minimum value determined in accordance with the said rules and return the instrument for presenting again in accordance with Section 23 of the Registration Act, 1908. (b) When the deficit stamp duty required to be paid under clause (a), is paid in respect of any instrument and the instrument is presented again for registration, the registering officer shall certify by endorsement thereon, that the deficit stamp duty has been paid in respect thereof and the name and the residence of the person pay them and register the same. (c) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other provisions of this Act, the deficit stamp duty may be paid under clause (a) in the form of impressed stamps containing such declaration as may be prescribed. (d) If any person does not make the payment of deficit stamp duty after receiving the order referred to in clause (a) and presents the instrument again for registration, the registering officer shall, before registering the instrument refer the same to the Collector for determination of market value of the property and the proper duty payable thereon.

    (2) On receipt of a reference under sub-section(1), the Collector shall, after giving the parties a reasonable opportunity of being heard, and after holding an inquiry in such manner as may be prescribed by rules made under this Act, determine the market value of the property which is the subject of such instrument, and the proper duty payable thereon.

    (3) The Collector may, suo motu, on a reference from any Court or from the Commissioner of Stamps, or an Additional Commissioner of Stamps or a Deputy Commissioner of Stamps or an Assistant Commissioner of Stamps or any officer authorised by the State Government in that behalf, within four years from the date of registration of any instrument, on which duty is chargeable on the market value of the property not already referred to him under sub-section (1), call for and examine the instrument for the purpose of satisfying himself as to the correctness of the market value of the property, which is the subject of such instrument, and the duty payable thereon and if after such examination he has reason to believe that the market . value of such property has not been truly set forth in such instrument, he may determine the market value of such property and the duty payable thereon :

    Provided that, with the prior permission of the State Government an action under this sub-section may be taken after a period of four years but before a period of eight years from the date of registration of the instrument on which duty is chargeable on the market value of the property.

    Explanation .......................

    Sub-sections (4-A) to (6) are not relevant."

    6. Section 47-A refers to minimum value determined in accordance with Rules made under the Act, as held by the Apex Court in Ramesh Chandra Bansal v. District Magistrate, AIR 1999 SC 2126 : (1999 All LJ 1547) confers power upon a registering authority to deal with the case of under valuation. Section 47-A uses the words minimum value determined in accordance with any Rules made under the Act in sub clause (1) of Section 47-A. A Division Bench of this Court in Kaka Singh v. The Additional Collector and District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue) Bulandshahr and another, 1986 ALJ 49 has held that Section 47-A empowers the Collector to deal with those cases where the parties by arrangement deliberately under valued the property while setting forth the market value less than the minimum value determined under Rule 341 with a view to defraud the Government of legitimate revenue by way of stamp duty. In the present case, it is not disputed by the respondents that the petitioners have not paid even the minimum value fixed under the Rules i.e. circle rate. The power appears to have been exercised under sub section (3) of Section 47-A. It may be noticed that in sub section (3) of Section 47-A, power has been conferred on the Collector to examine any instrument within four years from the date of registration on which duty is chargeable on a market value of the property. The Collector, if after such examination, has reason to believe that the market value of such property has not been truly set forth, he may determine the market value of such property and duty payable thereon. On a close reading of sub section (3) of Section 47-A the words used therein are reason to believe and market value of such property. These are key words.

    7. The Stamp Act is a fiscal statute and it has to be interpreted strictly and construction of hardship or equity has no role to play in its construction. It is a taxing statute and has to be read as it is. In other words, the literal rule of interpretation applies to it. See-State of Rajasthan v. Khandaka Jain Jewellers, AIR 2008 SC 509. In this case the Supreme Court has referred its earlier judgment in the case of A.V. Fernandez v. State of Kerala AIR 1957 SC 657. Also Government of A. P. and others v. Smt. P. Laxmi Devi 2008 AIR SCW 1826 : AIR 2008 SC 1640.

    8. In the above background the phrase reason to believe occurring in sub-section (3) of Section 47-A has to be considered. Identical phrases have been placed in almost every fiscal statutes such as Income-tax Act, Sales Tax Act etc. With reference to the expression reason to believe used in Section 34 of the Old Income-tax Act it has been held that they do not mean purely subjective satisfaction on the part of the Income Tax Officer. The belief must have been held in good faith, it cannot be merely a pretence. To put it differently it is open to Court to examine the question whether the reasons to believe have a rational connection or a relevant bearing to the formation of belief and are not extraneous or irrelevant to the purpose of section, as held in S. Narayanappa and others v. CIT Bangalore, AIR 1967 SC 523. The words reason to believe are stronger than the expression for satisfaction Belief must not be arbitrary or irrational. It must be reasonable or must be based on reasons which are relevant and material.

    9. In view of the fact that expression reason to believe has been used in sub-section (3) of Section 47-A of the Act, the power conferred under this section though is wide but they are not plenary. The power cannot be exercised when the Collector has reason to suspect that there is evasion of proper stamp duty.

    10. A Division Bench of this Court in Kishore Chandra Agarwal v. State of U. P. and others 2008 (104) RD 235 has held as follows :

    "25. Every wide power, the exercise of which has far reaching repercussion, has inherent limitation on it. It should be exercised to effectuate the purpose of the Act. In legislations enacted for general benefits and common good the responsibility is far graver. It demands purposeful approach. The exercise of discretion should be objective. Test of reasonableness is more strict. The public functionaries should be duty conscious rather than power charged. Its actions and decisions, which touch the common man, have to be tested on the touchstone of fairness and justice. An arbitrary action is ultra vires."

    11. In Hajari Lal Sahu v. State of U. P. and others, 2004(1) AWC 899 : 2004 All LJ 1639 a learned Single Judge of this Court has taken the similar view.

    12. The other phrase used in sub-section (3) of Section 47-A is market value. The market value means what a willing purchaser would pay to a willing seller for the property having regard to the advantages available to the land and the development activities which may be going in the vicinity and potentiality of the land and as such, an offer of sale of land to an industrialist on concessional rate with a view to induce him to set up industry in a particular area is not market value. See Mahabir Prasad v. Collector, Cuttack, AIR 1987 SC 720.

    13. The market value of land means a price at which both buyers and sellers are willing to do business; the market or current price.

    14. Having noticed the imports of the aforesaid two expressions used in sub section (3) of Section 47-A now the facts of the present case may be looked upon.

    15. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that indisputably the shop in question was not let out at any point of time. Except the report of the Sub Registrar, there is no material on record to show that the market value set out in the instrument is incorrect. He further submits that the said report of the Sub-Registrar cannot be relied upon for the purposes of determining the deficiency if any in payment of Stamp Duty under Section 47-A of the Act as the said report is not relevant or admissible for passing the order thereunder. Elaborating the argument he submits that the exemplars were wrongly relied upon being document 1485 of 1989 and 6960 of 1989 wherein the rent of that property has been shown at Rs. 800/- and 1200/- per month. The submission is that there is no evidence to show that the property in question is similarly situate as those of the properties referred in the aforesaid two documents. In substance, the document Nos. 1485 of 1989 and 6960 of 1989 cannot be treated as exemplar in the absence of material to show that they are comparable with the property in question. The learned standing counsel on the other hand supports the impugned orders.

    16. The sole basis of the impugned orders holding that proper stamp duty has not been paid by the petitioners is the report of the Sub Registrar, reporting the matter to the ADM (FandR) that proper stamp duty has not been paid. Except the said report, there is no material on record to show that the petitioners by arrangement deliberately under valued the property while setting forth the market value in the instrument.

    17. In Ram Khelawan alias Bachcha v. State of U. P. through Collector, Hamirpur and another, 2005(98) RD 511, it has been held that report of Tahsildar may be a relevant factor for initiation of proceedings under Section 47-A of the Act but it cannot be relied upon to pass an order under the aforesaid section. In other words the said report cannot form itself basis of the order passed under Section 47-A of the Act. As already pointed out above, the only material is the report of Sub Registrar. It may also be noticed that the report of the Tahsildar was rejected by the authorities.

    18. The learned counsel for the petitioners rightly pointed out that in the two impugned orders, there is no such discussion to show that the shop in question is similarly situate as the shops mentioned in document No. 1483 of 1989 or 6960 of 1989. These documents therefore, cannot be relied upon as exemplar.

    19. In the case of Prakashwati v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority Board of Revenue, Allahabad, 1996 (87) R.D.419 "Honble the Apex Court has held that situation of a property in an area close to a decent colony not by itself would make it part thereof and should not be a factor for approach of the authority in determining the market value. According to said decision, valuation has to be determined on constructive materials, which could be made available before the authorities concerned.

    20. There is another aspect of the case. The sine qua non for invoking the provisions of Section 47-A(3) of the Act is that the Collector has reason to believe that the stamp duty has not been properly set forth in the instrument as per market value of the property. Once the instrument is registered and the prescribed stamp duty as prescribed by the Collector has been paid, the burden to prove that the market value is more than the minimum as prescribed by the Collector under the rules, is upon the Collector. The report of the Sub Register or Tahsildar itself is not sufficient to discharge that burden. Reference can be made to a Division Bench judgment of this Court in Kaka Singh v. The Additional Collector and District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue) Bulandshahr and another, 1986 ALJ 49.

    21. Viewed as above, the impugned orders cannot be sustained and they are liable to be quashed. This Court while entertaining the writ petition granted a conditional stay order on 27-1-1999 wherein it was provided that on deposit of half of the deficiency within one month, the further recovery shall be stayed. It was further directed that the amount so deposited shall be subject to the decision of the writ petition.

    22. In view of the above order, the respondents are liable to refund the amount thus deposited by the petitioner along with the accrued interest within a period of one month from the date of production of a certified copy of this order failing which they shall be liable to pay the interest @ 10% per annum thereafter on the sum due to the petitioner, till the date of actual payment.

    23. In the result, the writ petition succeeds and is allowed. The impugned orders dated 29-11-1995 (Annexure-5) and 19-11-1998 (Annexure-7) are hereby quashed and it is held that the petitioners are not liable to pay any further stamp duty on the instrument in question. No order as to costs.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vijay Kumar & Anr. v. Commissioner, Meerut Division & Anr.
    (Mar 27, 2008)