Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 76(3) of the Travancore CPC (corresponding to S. 96(3) of the Indian Code),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 76(3) of the Travancore CPC (corresponding to S. 96(3) of the Indian Code),

    B. Meerakutty And Others v. K. Meerakutty And Others

    Subramania Iyer, J.:— This is an appeal filed against the decree, based on a compromise, passed by the Court below. The petition for compromise filed in the Court below was signed by the plaintiffs as also by defendants 1, 3, 5, 7 and S. The appellants before this Court are defendants 1 to 4, 6, 8 and 9. Of these defendants, 1, 3 and 8 are signatories to the compromise petition. It is stated that these signatories resiled from the compromise subsequent to the filing of the petition in Court. Regarding the other appellants, except the 9th defendant, their names were struck off the array of parties by the Court below. Mr. Govindan Nair on behalf of the respondents takes a preliminary objection that the decree being one passed on a compromise Section 76(3) of the Travancore CPC (corresponding to S. 96(3) of the Indian Code), prohibits this appeal. The answer to this objection given by Mr. Narayana Pillai on behalf of the appellants is that in a case where certain signatories to the compromise petition have resiled from the compromise, the provisions of S. 76(3) will not be attracted. The question as to whether, when there is a compromise and the Court acts upon it and passes a decree on the compromise the signatories to the compromise should continue to abide by the terms of the compromise until the decree is passed in order that the prohibitory provision of S. 96(3) should be attracted, has come up for consideration of the Indian High Courts. All the High Courts except the Nagpur High Court have taken the view that if a Court is found to have based the decree on compromise, then notwithstanding the fact that before the date of the decree some or all the parties to the compromise have resiled therefrom, would not be a reason why the provisions of S. 96(3) should not be attracted. It is not necessary to refer to the decisions in detail. Suffice it to say that this view gains support from the decision of the Privy Council reported in ‘Zahirull Said Alvi v. Leachhmi Narayan’, AIR (19) 1932 PC 251, though this question did not directly arise there for decision. We are in respectful agreement with the view expressed by the majority of the High Courts in India and taking that view, we hold that this appeal is not maintainable as it is prohibited by Section 76(3) of the Travancore CPC.

    2. Mr. Narayana Pillai on behalf of the appellants raised another contention that in cases where the compromise comprised not merely matters which are the subject-matter of the suit but those beyond the scope of the suit, an appeal is competent. Whether the compromise in was particular case does not comprise matters foreign to the litigation is not considered by the Court below nor is a ground in this regard taken by the appellant in the appeal memorandum.

    3. We are not therefore inclined to allow the appellant to argue the point. Yet another point taken by Mr. Narayana Pillai on behalf of the appellants is that the 9th defendant was not a party to the compromise and therefore the appeal so far as he is concerned, should be regarded as maintainable. The 9th defendant filed a written statement in the Court below and he was agreeable to a decree being passed in favour of the plaintiffs. It is in terms of that plaint that the compromise appears to have been filed and the decree was passed. Assuming however that the 9th defendant feels that he may be prejudiced by that decree Mr. Govindan Nair, appearing on behalf of the respondents plaintiffs is agreeable to have the name of the 9th defendant struck off the file as was done in the case of certain other defendants in the case. We direct that the name of the 9th defendant appellant be struck off the array of parties.

    4. The litigation being one relating to a trust and the individual defendants not having separate or individual rights in the subject-matter of the suit i.e, in matters dealt with in the compromise, even if some members be not signatories to the compromise petition, a compromise entered into on behalf of the institution, that is the Trust by some representatives of that Institution may bind the Institution. The mere fact that some parties interested who are defendants in this case have not signed the compromise petition may not make the decree any the less binding upon the Institution. It is however not necessary in this case to give a definite decision upon this matter. The appeal should therefore be dismissed with costs, subject to the direction given above that the name of the 9th defendant-appellant be struck off the array of parties.

    5. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    B. Meerakutty And Others v. K. Meerakutty And Others
    (Mar 14, 1951)