AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants instituted a suit for a perpetual injunction claiming ownership of 4.28 acres in Survey No. 1248 (near Bridge Paatra, Galla Mandi Road, Muttasil Jhirya Shifa Shah, Bhopal). The appellants trace title to an inayatnama (sanad) dated 5 June 1939, granted by the then ruler of Bhopal to an ancestor. After partition, the land devolved among appellants and their mother; upon her death a share devolved to the plaintiffs pursuant to a Tahsildar order dated 1/11/1972.

The plaintiffs alleged that on 27/8/1990 they discovered that trenches approximately 4' x 5' and breaking of a wall had been made about 20' inside their land by personnel of the Public Works Department, the Municipal Corporation and the Madhya Pradesh Electricity Board, and that these authorities had commenced works without formal acquisition. The plaintiffs sought a decree for perpetual injunction restraining respondents and their agents from damaging or interfering with the plaintiffs' possession, and (by amendment) claimed damages of Rs.15,000 and future compensation of Rs.1,000 per month from 22/8/1994 until restoration of possession.

Procedurally, Respondents 1, 2 and 4 did not file written statements. Respondent No.3 (Municipal Corporation, Bhopal) filed a written statement denying the plaint's averments and asserting that (a) no encroachment was made by respondents, (b) work was being undertaken over government land to the north of Survey No.1248 by the Public Works Department, (c) plaintiffs and others had encroached government land, and (d) the suit land's value exceeded Rs.10 lakhs but insufficient court fee had been paid. The trial court, after hearing oral and documentary evidence and relying on admissions by the plaintiffs' witness Mohd. Shahid (PW-1), dismissed the plaintiffs' suit by judgment and decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents encroached upon the appellants'/plaintiffs' land (Survey No.1248) such as to entitle the appellants to a decree for perpetual injunction and damages.
  2. Whether the trial court erred in refusing to admit a belated demarcation report and related documents under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC.
  3. Whether the appellants' application to amend the plaint to seek removal of an electric pole (and related relief) was permissible, or whether compensation and related remedies are governed by statutory provisions (Indian Telegraph Act / Electricity (Supply) Act) requiring a different forum or procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants asserted ownership of the disputed land based on historical sanad (inayatnama) and partitional devolution, and sought perpetual injunction and damages for alleged encroachment by public authorities.
  • The appellants sought to place on record a demarcation report (dated 24/10/2001 to 29/10/2001) together with panchnama, field book and map, arguing the trial court should have obtained or accepted survey/demarcation evidence (or issued a survey commission) to establish identity of the property.
  • The appellants filed an application to amend the plaint to include a prayer for removal of an electric pole allegedly fixed by Respondent No.4.

Respondent No.3 (Municipal Corporation) — Principal Contentions

  • Denied the plaint's allegations of encroachment by the respondents and stated the works were being carried out on government land to the north of Khasra No.1248 by the Public Works Department.
  • Contended that the plaintiffs and other persons had themselves encroached on government land, and that the suit was in the nature of an attempt to protect that encroachment.
  • Prayed for dismissal of the suit; also raised the issue of inadequate court fee by alleging the suit land's value exceeded Rs.10 lakhs.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shreepat v. Rajendra Prasad and others, 2000 (6) Supreme 389 Decision cited by learned counsel for the appellants (the opinion does not elaborate the specific principle relied upon from that decision). The court considered the citation but held that the decision in Shreepat was not applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis rests principally on the trial court's appreciation of oral and documentary evidence and specific admissions made by the appellants' witness Mohd. Shahid (PW-1).

Key factual-admissory findings relied on by the court include:

  • Mohd. Shahid admitted the government road lies to the north of the plaintiffs' land and that he had no knowledge of the khasra number of that government road.
  • He admitted there is a "nala" (drain) in the middle of the land of the plaintiffs and that the nala is on government land.
  • He acknowledged that municipal permission for construction contained a condition that 24 ft must be kept open on the north side, and that the sanctioned map (Ex. P/5) left 50 ft for something described as "shed well"; he further admitted constructing the house 22–24 ft from the nala and admitted non-compliance with certain conditions of sanction.
  • He admitted the width of the road to be around 40 ft whereas when the map was sanctioned the width was 20 ft; he also stated he demarcated the suit land and produced a revenue map (Ex. P/15) but he disavowed knowledge about whether the road fell in city survey no. 14615.

Based on the record and these admissions, the trial court concluded that the respondents had not encroached the appellants' land; rather the appellants had encroached upon government land and the construction of a road was being carried out over government land. The appellants failed to prove that the defendants had encroached by about 20 feet as alleged. Consequently, the trial court dismissed the suit for perpetual injunction and denied damages.

On the appellants' attempt to bring in the demarcation report (I.A. No. 368/2004) under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, the appellate court analyzed the statutory test under that provision: the appellants had to show that notwithstanding due diligence, the evidence was not within their knowledge or could not, after due diligence, have been produced in the trial court. The court found:

  • The appellants had ample opportunity to obtain demarcation earlier but filed the report only on the ground that it was subsequent to the date of the judgment.
  • The demarcation report did not show installation of permanent pillars and appeared to have been obtained to fill lacunae in the case; the report did not establish appellants' ownership of the disputed land or that respondents had encroached.
  • Accordingly, none of the conditions of Rule 27, Order 41 CPC were satisfied, and the application to place the demarcation report on record was dismissed as devoid of merit.

With respect to the application to amend the plaint (I.A. No. 367/2004) to seek removal of an electric pole fixed by Respondent No.4, the court reasoned:

  • The demarcation report did not show any encroachment by the respondents; consequently the proposed amendment seeking removal of the electric pole could not be allowed on the basis of that report.
  • The court observed that where a sanctioned scheme leads the State Electricity Board to exercise powers by virtue of Section 42 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948, such exercise becomes subject to the obligation to pay full compensation as provided in proviso (d) to Section 10 of the Indian Telegraph Act. In case of dispute over sufficiency of compensation, Section 16(3) of the Indian Telegraph Act permits resolution by the District Judge.
  • The proposed amendment would change the nature of the case and introduce a new cause of action; it was therefore unnecessary for determining the real controversy before the court and was rejected as lacking merit.

Finally, the court observed there was "no dispute with regard to the identity of the land" and, given the admissions and the evidence on record, found no legal error in the trial court's dismissal of the suit.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The trial court's judgment and decree dismissing the appellants'/plaintiffs' suit for perpetual injunction and damages is upheld. The appellate court also dismissed I.A. No. 368/2004 (application to admit demarcation report) and rejected I.A. No. 367/2004 (application to amend the plaint).

Consequences and practical implications:

  • The plaintiffs/appellants remain without the injunction or damages they sought; the respondents are not restrained by the decree sought in the suit.
  • The demarcation report filed after the judgment was not admitted; the court found it did not satisfy the conditions of Order 41 Rule 27 CPC and did not alter the trial court's factual findings.
  • The proposed amendment to seek removal of the electric pole was rejected. The court indicated that statutory compensation remedies (under the Indian Telegraph Act and the Electricity (Supply) Act) are available where appropriate, and disputes over adequacy of compensation may be determined by the District Judge under Section 16(3) of the Indian Telegraph Act.
  • No new legal precedent was laid down by this opinion. The decision affirms the trial court's factual findings based on witness admissions and documentary evidence and resolves the procedural applications (admission of belated evidence; amendment of plaint) against the appellants in accordance with established principles reflected in Order 41 Rule 27 CPC and procedural requirements for amendment of pleadings.

Costs: The appeal was dismissed with costs throughout. Counsel fee awarded: Rs.3,000 if pre-certified.

    Peer Mohammad Saeed And Others v. State Of M.P And Others

    (1) The appellants had instituted a suit for perpetual injunction on the ground that they are the owner of an area 4. 28 acre of survey no. 1248 situated near bridge paatra, galla mandi road, muttasil jhirya shifa shah, bhopal. This land was granted by his highness late nawab haji hamesdullah khan, the then ruler of bhopal state along with other land of khasra no. 8006/1, area 0. 34 acre jahangirabad, bhopal to janab hazrat shah mohd. Yaqoob sahib, son of peer abu ahmad sahib. The grant is by inayatnama (sanad) duly signed and certified by secretary, govt. Of bhopal dated 5th june, 1939. The land of khasra no. 1248 measuring 4. 28 acre is bounded as under : east : land of khasra no. 1279 and pastra river. West : land of khasra no. 1249 and slaughter house. North : road from pul bobda to bharat talkies. South : nala.

    (2) After partition, land of khasra no. 1248 devolved and divided between the appellants and their mother batul begum. After the death of smt. Batul bagum, her share devolved upon the plaintiffs in pursuance to the order passed by tahsildar on 1/11/1972. It is contended that on 27/8/1990 when plaintiff no. 1 visited the spot then he came to know that in the land of plaintiffs approximately about 20' inside the land tranches of size about 4' x 5' along with the land of them are being made. The wall was broken. The said trenches are made by the men of public works department, municipal corporation and m. P. Electricity board for erection of roads. The said authorities without any acquisition started the said work. The appellants/ plaintiffs prayed to grant a decree for perpetual injunction restraining the respondents/defendants, its agents and servants to cause any sort of damage to the plaintiffs' property and land and to refrain from interfering with the plaintiffs' enjoyment of peaceful possession thereof. By way of amendment, the appellants/plaintiffs also claimed damages worth rs. 15,000/ - and compensation with a decree for future compensation @ rs. 1,000/ - per month w. E. F. 22/8/1994 to the date of restoration of actual possession of the suit land.

    (3) Respondents 1, 2 and 4 have not filed any written statement before the trial court. Respondent no. 3/defendant no. 3 (municipal corporation, bhopal) filed its written statement and denied the averments made in the plaint. In the written statement it is specifically stated that no encroachment has been made and the work is going on over the government land towards north side of khasra no. 1248 by the public works department. It is also contended that plaintiffs and other persons had encroached the government land and just to remove the said encroachment filed the present suit. It is also contended that value of the suit land is more than rupees ten lacs but no court fee has been paid. With the above pleadings respondent no. 3 prayed for dismissal of the suit.

    (4) Mohd. Shahid (pw - 1) in para - 7 of his statement has very categorically admitted that government road is towards the north side of the land of plaintiff. This witness has admitted that he has no knowledge about the khasra number of government road. This witness also admitted that there is 'nala' in the mid of the land of plaintiffs. 'nala' is on government land. This witness has no knowledge about the width of the government road. In para - 8, this witness has further admitted that when he applied for grant of permission for construction of house, respondent no. 3 - municipal corporation granted permission subject to condition that toward north side the appellants will not make any construction and keep open the land of 24 ft. This witness also admitted that map (ex. P/5) was sanctioned after leaving 50 ft land for shed well. He also admitted that he constructed the house after 22 - 24 ft. From the 'nala' and he has not constructed the house as per the sanction granted by the municipal corporation nor he left any open land as per the terms and conditions of the sanction. This witness in para - 8 further admitted that width of the road is around 40 ft. And when the map was sanctioned vide ex. P/5, the width of the road was 20 ft. In para - 9, this witness has deposed that suit land was demarcated by him and ex. P/15 is the map issued by revenue authority. In para - 11 he has further pleaded his ignorance as to whether the road is in city survey no. 14615 of north side.

    (5) Learned trial court after appreciating the oral and documentary evidence of the parties and on the basis of the admission made by mohd. Shahid (pw - 1) in his cross - examination has held that no encroachment has been made by the respondents/defendants and it is the appellants who have encroached the area of government land. It has also been held by trial court that construction of road is going on over the part of the land which is government land and on survey no. 1248. The appellants by oral and documentary evidence failed to prove that defendants encroached an area of 20 ft. The construction of road is going over the government land for the public interest, therefore, it has been held that no case for grant of perpetual injunction, as prayed by the appellants, is made out nor the appellants are entitled for any damages. With the above, the trial court by the impugned judgment and decree dismissed the suit of the appellants/plaintiffs.

    (6) Learned counsel for the appellants drew my attention to the report regarding demarcation between24/10/2001 to 29/10/2001 filed along with application for taking the additional documents on record and has submitted that learned trial court should have got identity of property established by issuing survey commission which has not been done in the present case and, therefore, the demarcation report along with panchnama, field book and map be taken on record and the matter be remanded to the trial court for its adjudication afresh. The appellants were given sufficient opportunities before the trial court to apply for demarcation with regard to the identity of the land in dispute and whether the land in dispute is the part of survey no. 1248 owned by the appellants/plaintiffs or not. On perusal of demarcation report dated 24/10/2001 to 29/10/2001, i find that the demarcation has not been made by installing permanent pillar and this report has been obtained by the appellants/plaintiffs just to fill up the lacuna of the case.

    (7) Under order 41 rule 27, cpc the appellants have to establish that notwithstanding the exercise of due diligence, such evidence was not within his knowledge or could not, after the exercise of due diligence, be produced by them during pendency of the proceedings before the trial court. Though they had sufficient opportunities to call for the report, the application has been filed only on the ground that demarcation report is subsequent to the date of judgment and, therefore, the same be taken on record. From the said demarcation report it cannot be said that appellants/plaintiffs are the owner of the disputed land over which encroachment has been made by the respondents. The respondents constructed the road over the government land. The said documents will not help in any way to the appellants. None of the conditions of rule 27 of order 41 of cpc has been satisfied by the appellants. The application filed by the appellants has no merit. Accordingly, i. A. No. 368/2004 is dismissed.

    (8) I. A. No. 367/2004 has been filed by appellants for amending the plaint on the ground that nazool officer in presence of respondents demarcated the whole land and prepared the demarcation report, panchnama, demarcation map, field book and established the boundaries on the spot. From the report it does not show that the respondents have encroached the area in question and, therefore, the proposed amendment to the effect that the electric poll fixed by respondent no. 4 be directed to be removed, cannot be allowed because when in pursuance of a sanctioned scheme the state electricity board by virtue of section 42 of electricity (supply) act, 1948 exercises the powers under part iii, telegraph act it becomes subject to the obligation to pay full compensation to all persons interested for all damages sustained by them as provided in proviso (d) to section 10 of the telegraph act and in case of dispute as to the sufficiency of compensation the obligation is to pay such compensation as may be determined by the district judge under section 16 (3) of the indian telegraph act. Thus, in case if it is found that the land of the appellants have been encroached by respondent no. 4 - electricity board they are entitled for compensation under section 10 of the indian telegraph act and if they dissatisfied with the amount of compensation, they can file application under section 16 (3) of the indian telegraph act for determination of compensation before the district judge who is the competent authority to entertain the application and decide it in accordance with law. The proposed amendment will change the nature of the case and will make out a new case and the said amendment is not necessary for the purpose of determining the real controversy between the parties. The application (i. A. No. 367/2004) for amendment filed by the appellants has no merit and is hereby rejected.

    (9) On consideration of evidence on record and in view of the admission made by mohd. Shahid (pw - 1) in his cross - examination, the trial court dismissed the suit. In the present case there is no dispute with regard to the identity of the land. The court below dismissed the suit of appellants/ plaintiffs on the basis of oral and documentary evidence and on the basis of the admission made by the plaintiffs' witness it has been held that the suit land has not been encroached by the respondents nor the suit land was found part of survey no. 1248. Mohd. Shahid (pw - 1) in his statement has very categorically stated that area was demarcated by the revenue authorities and on the basis of the demarcation report, map (ex. P/15) was filed. Since there was no dispute with regard to the area and boundaries of the land in question nor there is any dispute with regard to identify, the decision cited by learned counsel for the appellants in the case of shreepat v. Rajendra prasad and others, 2000 (6) supreme 389, is not applicable in the present facts and circumstances of the case. The appellants failed to establish that suit land is not a government land and the trenches situated over the land are owned by the appellants/plaintiffs. It is a government land and part of the government road. On perusal of the material available on record and for the above mentioned reasons, i am of the considered view that the trial court has not committed any legal error in dismissing the suit of the appellants/plaintiffs.

    (10) The appeal filed by the appellants is hereby dismissed with costs throughout. Counsel fee rs. 3,000/ - if pre - certified.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Peer Mohammad Saeed And Others v. State Of M.P And Others
    (Apr 16, 2009)