Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sec. 97 of cpc amendment act, 1976. Section 97 of the 1976 amendment act
  • act of 1976, the provisions of order 20 rule 11 clause 2
  • section 97 (1) of civil procedure code amendment act
  • provisions of s. 97 (3) of the amendment act of 1976,
  • sub - section (2) , the provisions of the principal act,
  • provisions of order 21 rule 72
  • sub - section (2) of section 97. (4)
  • 1976 act to order 21 rule 72
  • sub - section (3) of section 97
  • sub - section (2) of section 97
  • 20 rule 11 (2)
  • 21 rule 72
  • 21 rule 90
  • 20 rule 11
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sec. 97 of cpc amendment act, 1976. Section 97 of the 1976 amendment act
  • act of 1976, the provisions of order 20 rule 11 clause 2
  • section 97 (1) of civil procedure code amendment act
  • provisions of s. 97 (3) of the amendment act of 1976,
  • sub - section (2) , the provisions of the principal act,
  • provisions of order 21 rule 72
  • sub - section (2) of section 97. (4)
  • 1976 act to order 21 rule 72
  • sub - section (3) of section 97
  • sub - section (2) of section 97
  • 20 rule 11 (2)
  • 21 rule 72
  • 21 rule 90
  • 20 rule 11

    S. Prem Singh & Another v. M.B.S Purushotham .

    (1) The petitioner is a judgment debtor, who sought for instalments subsequent to the passing of the decree. The suit was filed in the year 1981. The court below dismissed the application on the ground that in view of the decision of this court in t. Chinna naidu vs. B. B. Doramasi the consent of the decree - holder is necessary for granting instalments at the execution stage and that, if there is no consent, the application cannot be allowed. The lower court, therefore, refused to grant instalments.

    (2) It is contended by sri koka raghava rao the learned counsel for the petitioner, that the above said decision requires reconsid eration inasmuch as the learned judge has not considered the applicability or otherwise of the madras amendment to order 20 rule 11 cpc which was in force prior to the commencement of the civil procedure code amendment act of 1976. On the other hand, it is contended by the learned counsel for the respondent decree holder sri g. Suryanarayana murthy that the madras amendment does not survive inasmuch as there is no positive inconsistency between the code as amended in the year 1976 and the earlier madras amendment. Prior to the amendment by the central act of 1976, the provisions of order 20 rule 11 clause 2 cpc read as follows : orerd 20 (11) (2) :

    "after the passing of any such decree the court may, on the application of judgment debtor and after notice to the decree holder. Order that payment of amount decreed shall be made by instalments on such terms as to the payment of interest, the attachment of property of judgment debtor of taking of security from him or otherwise as it thinks fit."

    However, after the 1976 amendment the civil procedure code under order 20 rule 11 (2) reads as follows :

    "after the passing of any such decree the court may, on the application of the judgment debtor and with the consent of the decree holder, order that payment of the amount decreed shall be postponed or shall be made by instalments on such terms as to the payment of interest, that attachment of the property of the judgment debtor, or the taking of security from him, or otherwise, as it thinks fit."

    The question for consideration is whether the madras amendment as sat out earlier is to be followed or whether the code as it stands after 1976 amendment has to be followed.

    (3) For this purposes, it is necessary to refer to the provisions of sec. 97 of cpc amendment act, 1976. Section 97 of the 1976 amendment act in so far as it is material for our purpose reads as follows :

    "97 : repeal and savings (1) any amendment made, or any provision inserted in the pricipal act by a state legislature or a high court before the commencement of this act shall except in so far as such amendment or provision is consistent with the provisions of the principal act as amended by this act, stand repealed. (2) notwithstanding that the provisions of this act have come into force or the repeal under sub - section (1) has taken effect, and without prejudice to the generality of the provisions of section 6 of the general clauses, 1897 (3) save as otherwise provided in sub - section (2) , the provisions of the principal act, as amended by this act, shall apply to every suit, proceeding, appeal or application, pending at the commencement, of this actor instituted filed offer such commencement not with standing the fact that the right, or cause of action, in pursuance of which such suit proceeding, appeal or application is instituted or filed, had been acquired or had accrued before such commencement."

    The abovesaid provision of the repealed act has recently been considered by the supreme court in relation to the amendments made in various high courts. In 'ganpathi vs. Ii additional district judge, balia the supreme court observed that the effect of section 97 (1) of civil procedure code amendment act was that all local amendments made to any of the provisions of the code either by state legislature or by the high court, which were inconsistent with the code as amended by the amended act, stood repealed irrespective of the fact whether the corresponding provision in the code had been amended or modified by the amending act and that was subject to only to what was found in sub - section (2) of section 97 cpc. In that case what happened was that order 21 rule 72 cpc was not specifically amended by the amending act 1976 and it was therefore contended that there was no specific amendment to order 21 rule 72 cpc and therefore the said rule namely order 21 rule 72 cpc as amended in uttar pradesh would continue to apply to the facts of the case. As per the uttar pradesh amendment under order 21 rule 72 cpc the decree holder was not obliged to seek permission of the executing court before offering the bid or for purchasing the property. The 1976 amendment required such permission. A special provision was however made in the case of mortgagee under order 21 rule 72 - a cpc introduced by the 1976 amendment that the mortgagee could bid without permission. It was argued that even in cases other than mortgage decrees, the provisions of order 21 rule 72 cpc (as amended in uttar pradesh) would continue to be applicable and that it was not necessary for the decree holder to seek the permission of the court to offer his bid or to purchase the judgment debtor's property. The above contention was rejected by the supreme court holding that even though there is no specific amendment in the 1976 act to order 21 rule 72 cpc as such, still it was clear that statutory permission for purchase was granted, after 1976 amendment, only to the mortgagee under order 21 rule 72 - a cpc. The supreme court pointed out that even though the amendment was only by addition of rule 72 - a to order 21 cpc, and not in order 21 rule 72 as such, still it must be treated that there was a positive inconsistency between the central act and the state amendment. On that the basis it was held that the sale in favour of the decree holder - auction purchaser, who was not a mortgagee, was liable to be set aside. In the course of the judgment it was clearly pointed out by the supreme court that sub - section (3) of section 97 cpc sets at rest any doubt in this regard inasmuch as it makes the code as amended by amending act applicable to all proceedings referred to therein subject to sub - section (2) of section 97.

    (4) A division bench of this court had occasion to deal with order 21 rule 90 of the madras amendment act in 'papamma vs. Margadarsi chit funds'. It was held that the amendment brought about by the madras high court in 1936 introducing the proviso of order 21 rule 90 and adopted by the high court of andhra pradesh stood repealed. The learned judge explained what was meant by inconsistency of repugnancy and referred to the question extensively with reference to several decided cases.

    (5) It is true that while holding that instalments cannot be granted unless consented to by the decree - holder in 't. Chinna naidu vs. B. B. Doramasi' (supra) the learned judge did not specifically refer to the question as to whether madras amendment still survives the central amendment act of 1976. In my view, having regard to the specific provisions of s. 97 (3) of the amendment act of 1976, and the decision of the supreme court, the madras amendment to order 20 rule 11 stands repealed and that it is the central act as it stood before the madras amendment that applies and the consent of the decree holder is the condition precedent for granting instalments after the passing of the decree.

    (6) The revision petition accordingly fails and is dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Prem Singh & Another v. M.B.S Purushotham .
    (Oct 8, 1987)