AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 10-A of the Andhra Pradesh Wakfs Rules read with section 45 of the Wakfs Act.
  • Rule 10-A of the Andhra Pradesh Wakfs Rules
  • receivers.3. Section 45 of the Wakfs Act
  • fact, section 6 (1) of the Wakfs Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 10-A of the Andhra Pradesh Wakfs Rules read with section 45 of the Wakfs Act.
  • Rule 10-A of the Andhra Pradesh Wakfs Rules
  • receivers.3. Section 45 of the Wakfs Act
  • fact, section 6 (1) of the Wakfs Act

    Parvathi Bai v. Wakf Board, Circle No. 1, Hyderabad, A.P And 2 Others

    1. The petitioner is the owner of premises Nos. 21-1-816 to 21-1-820/3,. Patel Market, Hyderabad. She wanted to make certain constructions and applied to the Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad for permission and the latter directed her to get a ‘no objection certificate’ from the authorities of the mosque which adjoined her premises; she applied to the Wakf Board for the issue of such a certificate but the Board refused to issue such a certificate and addressed the Municipality not to give permission for the proposed construction. Later when she wanted to sell the property and advertised the buildings for sale, the Administrator of Wakfs, Hyderabad issued an interim injunction dated 20th November, 1967 restraining her from auctioning the mulgies Nos. 21-1-816 to 21-1-820/3 adjoining the mosque and from doing any act likely to cause damage to wakf property until the dispute about the ownership of the southern wall of the mosque was finally decided by the Administrator or until the southern wall was removed from the plan published by the petitioner and shown as belonging to the mosque. The Administrator purported to exercise the powers conferred under Rule 10-A of the Andhra Pradesh Wakfs Rules read with section 45 of the Wakfs Act. The petitioner thereupon appeared before the Administrator and requested him to vacate the injunction but the latter refused to do so and confirmed the order of interim injunction. Thereupon the petitioner has filed the present application for the issue of a writ of certiorari to quash the orders of the Administrator dated 20th November, 1967 and nth May, 1968.

    2. Sri Venkata Subbarao, learned Counsel for the petitioner, urges that the orders of the Administrator are wholly without jurisdiction as the Administrator is incompetent to decide questions of title arising between a wakf and a third party. There is considerable force in this submission. Rule 10-A of the Andhra Pradesh Wakfs Rules enables the Wakf Board or any person authorised in that behalf, while holding an enquiry under section 45 of the Wakfs Act, to exercise as far as practicable the same powers as are vested in a Civil Court in respect of the gi ant of temporary injunctions, interlocutory orders and appointment of receivers.

    3. Section 45 of the Wakfs Act empowers the Board either on an application received under section 44 or on its own motion to hold an enquiry in such manner as may be prescribed or to authorise any person to hold an enquiry in that behalf into any matter relating to a wakf and take such action as it thinks fit. Section 44 enables a person interested in a wakf to make an application to the Board to enquire into the administration of the wakf. The entire scheme of the Act indicates that the Wakf Board's jurisdiction is confined to matters of administration of the wakf and not to adjudication of questions of title. In fact, section 6 (1) of the Wakfs Act expressly states:

    “If any question arises whether a particular property is wakf property or not or whether a wakf is a Shia Wakf or Sunni Wakf, the Board of the mutawalli of the wakf or any person interested therein may institute a suit in a civil Court of competent jurisdiction for the decision of the question and the decision of the civil Court in respect of such matter shall be final.”

    4. It is evident that the Wakfs Act did not invest the Wakf Board with authority to decide the questions, whether a property belonged to a wakf or not, and certainly so, where the person claiming title is a stranger to the wakf. I am supported in this conclusion by the judgment of a Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court in Radhakrishnan v. State of Rajasthan . A.I.R 1967 Raj. 1., where it was held that disputes between strangers to a wakf and wakf cannot be adjudged by the Wakf Board and that Wakf Board cannot dispossess such strangers. They observed:

    “……… in our view, this (the present Act No. XiXIX of 1954) also does not empower the Board of Wakfs to decide the question whether a particular property is a wakf property or not if such a dispute is raised by a person who is a stranger to wakf. This view is further confirmed by the provisions of section 59 of the Act which lays down that in any suit or proceeding in respect of a wakf or any wakf property by or against a stranger to the wakf or any other person, the Board may appear and plead as a party to the suit or proceeding.”

    5. Later they again observed:

    “The object of section 6 is to narrow down the dispute between the Board of Wakfs, the Mutawalli and the person interested in the wakf as defined in section 3. In our view, it does not concern a dispute if it is raised by a person who is an utter stranger to the wakf.”

    6. I am therefore of the view that the Administrator of wakfs had no jurisdiction to issue the order of injunction that he did. The writ petition is accordingly allowed wkh costs and the orders dated 20th November, 1967 and nth May, 1968 are quashed. Advocate's fee Rs. 100.

    7. Petition allowed; Orders quashed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Parvathi Bai v. Wakf Board, Circle No. 1, Hyderabad, A.P And 2 Others
    (Feb 4, 1969)