Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 4 of the Andhra Pradesh Service Commission Rules of Procedure
  • rule 4 of the Procedural Rules of the Public Service Commission.13.
  • rule 34 of the Andhra Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules
  • rule 34 of the State and Subordinate Service Rules
  • Andhra Pradesh Forest Subordinate Service.6. Rule 3
  • rule 2 of the Andhra Pradesh Forest Service Rules,
  • rule 2 of the Forest Service Rules
  • sub-rule (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 4 of the Andhra Pradesh Service Commission Rules of Procedure
  • rule 4 of the Procedural Rules of the Public Service Commission.13.
  • rule 34 of the Andhra Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules
  • rule 34 of the State and Subordinate Service Rules
  • Andhra Pradesh Forest Subordinate Service.6. Rule 3
  • rule 2 of the Andhra Pradesh Forest Service Rules,
  • rule 2 of the Forest Service Rules
  • sub-rule (2)

    R. Samba Murthy v. State Of Andhra Pradesh

    Gopal Rao Ekbote, J.:— This is an appeal from the judgment of our learned brother, Chinnappa Reddy, J., given in W.P No. 1410 of 1965 on 31st July, 1968 whereby the learned Judge dismissed the writ petition.

    2. The matter arises thus: The petitioner was recruited as a Forest Ranger in 1944. He was regularised, after training, in 1956. He possessed the qualifications for being considered to the next higher post of Assistant Conservator of Forests. While the post of Forest Ranger is a non-gazetted post, the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests is a gazetted post. The complaint of the petitioner is that although he was qualified to be considered for the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests and although he was senior, for the last many years he has been overlooked. At least once the Public Service Commission had recommended his name. But subsequently the Public Service Commision itself withdrew the recommendation. It is because of these facts that he filed the Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution for the issue of a writ of certiorari to quash the order of the Chief Conservator of Forests, Government of Andhra Pradesh, dated 16th March, 1964, whereunder he was told that the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests is a selection post and that his case will be considered as and when vacancies arise. The learned Judge dismissed the writ petition holding that it is a selection post and the right which the petitioner has is only to be considered and therefore, refused to issue the writ of certiorari. It is this view that is now challenged in this appeal.

    3. It may be that from the day the petitioner qualified himself to be considered for the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests he was continuously ignored although several vacancies had arisen and although his juniors were promoted. We cannot do anything in that matter because the promotees are not made parties to this case and therefore, no arguments which are likely to affect those persons or any one of them can be heard and decided behind their back. The learned Advocate for the appellant also did not want any such promotion to be declared as illegal as against the petitioner.

    4. The question then remains about the future promotions, the only thing, which, according to him, comes in the way of (sic) the impugned letter by which the respondent has characterised the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests as selection post. What was contended before us by Mr. Vidyasagar, the learned Counsel for the petitioner is that as the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests is filled up by recruitment by transfer from amongst the Forest Rangers the post is not a selection post and that therefore, it can be filled in according to rule 34 of the State and Subordinate Service Rules by taking into consideration the seniority and not on merit. If this is done, he contends, the petitioner being the seniormost, his record being clean, he shall be transferred by recruitment to the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests.

    5. Now according to rule 2 of the Andhra Pradesh Forest Service Rules, category IV posts i.e, the posts of Asssitant Conservators can be filled in by direct recruitment or recruitment by transfer from among Forest Rangers from the Andhra Pradesh Forest Subordinate Service.

    6. Rule 3 which relates to selection posts declares the posts of Chief Conservator of Forests, Conservators of Forests and Deputy Conservators of Forests to be selection posts. The post of Assistant Conservator of Forests is not declared as a selection post by the said Rules.

    7. The question then is whether rule 34 of the Andhra Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules applied to such posts, as is contended by the learned Advocate for the appellant. Rule 34 relates to promotion. It is true that it lays down two different modes in case of promotion (i) when promotion is made to a selection category or grade, and (ii) the other promotions according to seniority. We do not, however, think that recruitment by transfer under rule 2 of the Forest Service Rules is a promotion attracting rule 34 of the State and Subordinate Service Rules. The term promotion is defined in paragraph 13 of the State and Subordinate Service Rules. It reads:

    “‘Pomotion’ means the appointment of a member of any category or grade of a service or a class of service to a higher category or grade of such service or such class of service.”

    8. The term “Service” is defined in paragraph 18 of the said Rules which means “a group of persons classified by the State Government as State or Subordinate Service, as the case may be.” If we read these two definitions it becomes plain that whenever a person is recruited by transfer from Subordinate service to a State service, it cannot be called a case of promotion. In order to apply that term a person belonging either to the Subordinate service or State service, as the case may be, if he is appointed to a higher post in the same service then it can be said to be a case of promotion; that is to say from a lower category of Subordinate service if a person is appointed to a higher category in the same service it would be a case of promotion and not otherwise. The State and Subordinate Services are two distinct services. This is, therefore, not a case of promotion and consequently Rule 34 would not apply.

    9. What must follow from what is said above is that although the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests is not declared in the Forest Service Rules as selection post, it is not a post to which promotion can be made with the assistance of rule 34 of the State and Subordinate Service Rules.

    10. What then is the method of recruitment by transfer? Admittedly there is no specific rule either in the State and Subordinate Service Rules or in the Forest Rules. It cannot also be in doubt that in the absence of any rule, recruitment by transfer can be on the basis of seniority or can also be on the basis of selection. In the instant case, however, it is not doubted that recruitment to the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests falls within the purview of the Public Service Commission. Once that is conceded then it is rule 4 of the Andhra Pradesh Service Commission Rules of Procedure which shall be attracted to such a case. The Public Service Commission in cases of recruitment by transfer is bound to follow the procedure laid down in rule 4. It reads, so far as it is relevant, as follows:

    “Subject to the provisions of Part III of the Andhra Pradesh Public Service Commission Regulation, 1963, where recruitment to a State service is to be made by transfer from a Subordinate Service from which such recruitment is normally made, the Commission shall,—

    (i) consider the claims of as many candidates eligible, in its opinion, for such transfer as it considers necessary together with any recommendations made by the Head of the Department; and

    (ii) forward to the appointing authority a list arranged in order of merit consisting of such number, as such authority may fix, of the candidates whom the Commission considers suitable for appointment.”

    11. In accordance with sub-rule (2) of that rule, when considering the suitability of candidates under the first sub-rule, if the Commissioner feels any doubt about the candidate's fitness or when there is difference of opinion between the Head of the Department and the Commission, the Commission shall summon the candidates for interview.

    12. What is plain from rule 4 however, is that in the case of recruitment by transfer from Subordinate service to a State service, the Commission is bound to consider the claims of as many candidates eligible in its opinion for such transfer as it deems necessary. What must follow from the said rule is that when the claims of more than one candidate are required to be considered then the recruitment by transfer cannot be on the basis of seniority. Persons eligible and belonging to the class of Forest Rangers shall have to be considered by the Public Service Commission and the proper person recommended in that behalf. Rule 4 therefore, introduces a factor of competition and virtually makes the recruitment by transfer a selection post although it is not so declared under the Forest Rules. The other method of recruitment, that is to say by seniority is ruled out in view of rule 4 of the Procedural Rules of the Public Service Commission.

    13. This is the procedure which the Government and the Public Service Commission have been following so far as in making appointments to the post of Assistant Conservation of Forests from among the Forest Rangers category or class. We do not therefore, think that the impugned letter is in any manner contrary to the position of law as found above. It could not have been quashed by issue of a writ of certiorari.

    14. The learned Judge has already observed that the petitioner is a senior person and has been consistently ignored and hoped that his case at least in future would be considered for recruitment by transfer to the post of Assistant Conservator of Forests. We have no reason to suppose that the Government would not keep in view the observation of the learned Judge. For the reasons mentioned above, we dismiss the appeal. In the circumtances of the case, however, we make no order as to costs.

    15. G.S.M

    16. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    R. Samba Murthy v. State Of Andhra Pradesh
    (Jun 28, 1971)