1. These are two applications, one by the Union of Irfdia through Mr. B.L Suri under Sac. 14 of the Arbitration Act for making the award a rule of the Court and another by Messrs Lakshmi Ice Factory through Mr. I.D Grover to set aside that award. In this judgment the Lakshmi Ice Factory will be described as the petitioner and the Union of India as respondent. Both these applications will be disposed of by this order.
2. The facts which gave rise to these applications briefly stated are these:
3. Messrs Lakshmi ice Factory, Pacca Danga, was given a contract for supply of ice to the Army at a certain rate. The petitioner could not supply the quantity of ice required by the Army authorities and the contract with the petitioner for supply of ice was, therefore, rescinded and the ice was purchased from other ice factories at a higher rate. The total loss suffered by the Army on account of breach of contract was claimed from the petitioner. A dispute arose between the Army authorities and the petitioner in regard to the amount claimed. A suit was filed by the petitioner in the Court of the Additional District Judge seeking injunction against the Army authorities restraining them from recovering the amount claimed on account of the loss suffered by them.
4. The suit was resisted by the respondent on the ground that the dispute according to the contract ought to have been referred to arbitration. This plea found favour with the Additional District Judge and it was ordered that the dispute be referred to arbitration, in terms of Cl. 21 of the contract between the parties. Lt. General Varma invited claims of the parties and fixed 16th December, 1960 for proceeding with the reference but before this date Lt. General Varma proceeded on leave and Major General Gupta issued notice to the parties calling upon them to appear before him on 16th December the date already fixed by Lt. General Varma. On 5th December clarification was sought on behalf of the petitioner whether Major General Gupta was acting as an arbitrator. On 10th December, 1960 Major General Gupta was appointed as an arbitrator and information of his appointment reached the petitioner on the 15th. Mr. Grover put in its appearance on behalf of the petitioner before the arbitrator on 16th December. It is common ground that a prayer was made on behalf of the petitioner that an opportunity be given for acducing evidence. The arbitrator refused to do so and proceeded with the reference. He examined claims of the parties and gave an award allowing Rs. 26,954.33 nP. to the respondent against the petitioner.
5. Mr. Grover on behalf of the petitioner has challenged this award on the ground that refusal on the part of the arbitrator to afford opportunity to the petitioner to produce evidence amounted to legal misconduct and vitiated the award. Counsel appearing for the respondent raised a preliminary objection that no direct application under Sec. 30 or Sec. 33 lies without initial application being filed under Section 14 of the Arbitration Act. This contention is without any force. There is already an application made by the respondent praying that the award be made rule of the Court. In face of this application it was not necessary for the petitioner to file an application under Section 14 of the Arbitration Act. The petitioner has taken all the grounds in his application challenging the award which is sought to be made a rule of the Court. The preliminary objection is, therefore, overruled.
6. The question for consideration is whether the refusal on the part of the arbitrator to afford the petitioner an opportunity to adduce documentary and oral evidence, in support of the allegation in the claim petition amounts to judicial misconduct and vitiates the award. The petitioner filed three applications; in one of which he named the counsel whom he wanted to engage and prayed that the arbitration proceedings be conducted at Jammu so that he may not be put to unnecessary expense by taking his counsel and witnesses outside Jammu; by the second application he wanted to know as to who was appointed an arbitrator and in the third he specifically prayed that he may be allowed an opportunity to adduce evidence in support of his contentions. No reply was received by him in regard to these applications. It appears that Lt. General Varma went on leave and a notice was received from Major General Gupta informing the parties to appear on 16th December at Udhampur at 11 A.M to enable him to proceed with the reference.
7. The petitioner wrote a letter pointing out that under Cl. 21 of the agreement when an arbitrator vacates his office or proceeds on leave another person has to be appointed to act as an arbitrator, and as no such Appointment was made, notice from Major General Gupta was not valid. The petitioner was informed by telegram that Major General Gupta was appointed an arbitrator and this fact was confirmed by another letter which was received by the petitioner on 15th December. The petitioner appeared before the arbitrator on 16th and on that date written statement was filed on behalf of the respondent in which all the points in support of the claim put forward by the military authorities against the petitioner Were mentioned. On behalf of the petitioner request was made to the arbitrator to afford him opportunity to adduce evidence, it is common ground that the request on the part of the petitioner was not acceded to and the award was made by the arbitrator allowing the claim of the respondent against the petitioner to the extent of Rs. 26,954.33 nP. The learned counsel for the respondent argued that the petitioner already knew the case which was contained in the written statement filed by the respondent and it was not necessary to adjourn the case to some other date for affording opportunity to the petitioner to produce evidence. There is no substance in this argument. The written statement on behalf of the respondent was filed before the arbitrator on the 16th December and on that date the petitioner came to know about the contents of that written statement. It was not possible for the petitioner to have produced evidence in regard to the matters contained in the written statement of which he had no previous knowledge. After all it cannot be gainsaid that the petitioner was informed about the appointment of the arbitrator on the 15th December and in the notice already served on him there was no indication that the parties should produce evidence, if they so desire on the 16th of December. The words used in the notice were only these “appear before the arbitrator.”
8. It is true that strict rules of evidence and procedure are not applicable to arbitration proceedings but there is a thing known as natural justice and it would be contrary to fundamental principles of natural justice 11 a person be refused an opportunity to adduce evidence in support of his claim and without proper enquiry liabilit; for a large sum is fixed on him. In my opinion if are award is made without proper enquiry and without allowini a party, if he so desires, to adduce evidence in suppor of its contentions, it amounts to judicial mis-conduct of the part of the arbitrator. In this view I am fortified by a ruling of the Punjab High Court Prem Nath v. Om Parkash, AIR 1956 Punj 187 in which it has been held’
“It is a well-known proposition of law that althougl an arbitrator is allowed considerable latitude in the pro cedure adopted by him at the hearing it is essential that he should afford the parties reasonable opportunist of being heard and of presenting their case. If he make an award without complying with this essential require many he does so at the peril of his award being declarer invalid and inoperative in the eye of law.”
9. To the same effect is a ruling of the Andhra Pradesi High Court Chinoy Chalani and Co. v. Y. Anjiah, AIR 195 Andh Pra 384 in which if is laid down:
“Arbitrators should perform their quasi-judicial functions in a judicial manner and should not make a fare of the enquiry before them. They should give full opportunity to the parties to adduce their evidence and also allow them to be heard.
Where the defendant was given an opportunity ??? file the statement within three days and though the statement was filed the arbitrators without going throug the same and without giving an opportunity to the defendat to be heard or fixing a further date for hearing gave their award and no date was fixed even for the award
Held that it was impossible to hold that the awar was passed after full enquiry and, therefore, the arbitrator were guilty of judicial misconduct”
10. In the present case the arbitrator refused the prayer ??? the petitioner to produce oral and documentary evidence ??? support of his contentions, without any valid reason Under these circumstances the arbitrator has clearly misconducted himself and his award cannot be allowed to stand. I, therefore, allow the application of the petitions and set aside the award. The application made by the Unit of India is dismissed. The parties are left to bear the own costs.
BF/D.R.R
11. Order accordingly.