AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • fellows:(1) Rule 25 of the Kashmir Civil Service Rules (General).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • fellows:(1) Rule 25 of the Kashmir Civil Service Rules (General).

    Dr. Shanker Nath Ganju v. State Of Jammu And Kashmir .

    Shahmiri, J.:— This is a petition under article 32(2-A) of the Constitution of India, as applicable to the State of Jammu and Kashmir under the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 1954 for the issue of a writ of mandamus; or any other appropriate writ against the respondent directing that the appointment of Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta as the Chief Medical Officer is invalid and that the petitioner is entitled to that post. This writ petition challenges (1) the order of the Health Minister, dated 15th November, 1953, by which Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta was appointed as Chief Medical Officer in anticipation of the Cabinet sanction, (2) the Cabinet Order No. 684-C of 1954 dated 2nd June, 1954, by which the appointment of Dr. Gupta as Chief Medical Officer by the Health Minister in anticipation of the Cabinet sanction was confirmed and he was made S.P.T Chief Medical Officer and (3) the Cabinet Order No. 29-C of 1956, dated 6th January, 1956, by which Dr. Gupta was confirmed as Chief Medical Officer.

    2. We have heard arguments in this case. The main contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the petitioner was senior to Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta and as his merit and ability were also superior to him he should have been appointed as Chief Medical Officer in place of Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta. The Civil Service Rules which have a bearing on this case are as fellows:

    (1) Rule 25 of the Kashmir Civil Service Rules (General). It reads as under:—

    “25. Promotions, (a) All promotions shall be made by the appointing authority.

    (i) Promotions to a service or class or to a selection category or grade in such service or class shall be made on grounds of merit and ability and shall be subject to the passing of any tests that Government may prescribe in this behalf, seniority being considered only where the merit and ability are approximately equal.

    (ii) In the classification of the Gazetted Officers under the Rules relating to Recruitment to the Gazetted Services (Order No. 1328-C of 1939) Classes II and III of Medical Service, namely, State Surgeon, Chief Medical Officer, Tuberculosis Officer and Chemical Examiner, are to be appointed by transfer from class IV of the Medical Service which consists of Assistant Surgeons and obviously includes Medical Officers (vide clause (3) at page 1 and pages 2 and 8 of the aforesaid Rules).

    It may be stated here that now under the Cabinet Order No. 1630-C of 1955, dated 1st October, 1955 published in the Government Gazette dated 20th October, 1955, Chief Medical Officers have been put in Category (b) of Class II and Medical Officers have been put in Category (b) of Class III of Kashmir Health Service.

    (iii) The provision contained in the marginal heading ‘Method of Selection’ under the Rules relating to Recruitment to the Gazetted Services sub-clause (b) at page 11 provides “Recruitment by transfer shall be made on the basis of merit, ability and the previous record of the candidate, seniority being considered only in case of equality of merit, ability and excellence of record.”

    3. The record in this case shows that on 18th April, 1953, on the occasion of the retirement of Dr. Nila Kanth Dhar, Chief Medical Officer, Jammu, Col. Sir Ramnath Chopra, the then Director Health Services, in his letter to the Government stated that though Doctors S.K Shanglu, S.N Ganju (petitioner) and N.D Puri were senior to Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta, he did not consider these persons fit to hold the responsible appointment of Chief Medical Officer as they did not possess any practical knowledge of surgical work. He further remarked that Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta was an intelligent, smart and efficient officer and had picked up fairly good knowledge of surgical work, having worked as Surgeon in S.M.G.S Hospital, Jammu against the post of Surgeon Specialist for some years and as Medical Officer, Bhaderwah. Agreeing with the recommendation of the Director Health Services the Health Minister appointed Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta as Chief Medical Officer in anticipation of the Cabinet sanction (vide Government Order No. 289- Md/53 of 1953, dated 14th November, 1853). As already stated the action of the Health Minister in appointing Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta as Chief Medical Officer, Jammu, was confirmed by the Cabinet vide their order No. 684-C of 1954 dated 2nd June, 1954 and Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta was made S.P.T Subsequently the Director Health Services proposed confirmation of Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta and under Cabinet order No. 29-C of 1956 dated 6th January, 1956, Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta was confirmed as Chief Medical Officer.

    4. On behalf of the petitioner it is urged that on 10th April, 1951 also the Director Public Health had recommended the appointment of Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta as Chief Medical Officer ignoring the seniority of Doctors Nila Kanth Dhar, S.N Ganju, petitioner, and N.D Puri and this recommendation was turned down by the then Health Minister, Mr. Saraf. It is further urged that the academic record of the petitioner is better than that of Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta and that he was also qualified as Tuberculosis Officer.

    5. We have carefully considered all these arguments. But we feel that in the matter of promotion, i.e, what is technically described as transfer from a lower class of service to a higher class, the appointing authority has a wide discretion.

    6. These transfers, i.e promotions, under rules quoted above are to be made on the basis of merit and ability and seniority is to be considered only where merit and ability are approximately equal. Now who is the judge of merit and ability of the persons who possess the requisite minimum qualifications and from whom selection is to be made. It is clearly the appointing authority who is the judge of merit and ability and it is not the function of this Court to substitute its judgment for that of the appointing authority. We have already expressed this view in Mohd. Aslam Bach v. V.L Vishin, Writ Petn. No. 78 of 1955 D/- 29-10-1950: ((S) AIR 1957 J and K 8 (A)).

    7. In the present case the Director Health Services has arrived at the definite conclusion that Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta is more fit to hold the office of Chief Medical Officer than the petitioner and the appointing authority, i.e, the Cabinet has obviously agreed with this conclusion. The fact that a previous recommendation of the director Health Services regarding the appointment of Dr. Gupta as Chief Medical Officer was not accepted by the then Minister & the then cabinet cannot alter the fact that the present recommendation was accepted both by the Minister and the Cabinet. Col. Sir Ramnath Chopra, Director Health Services, under whom both the petitioner and Dr. Shiv Saran Gupta had worked for a number of years, had consistently held the view that the petitioner was not fit to hold the office of Chief Medical Officer & if the appointing authority in the past had considered another person, Dr. Nila Kanth Dhar, who has now retired, as a fit person to hold the office of Chief Medical Officer it does not mean that the present Minister and the Cabinet could not exercise their discretion or form their judgment in regard to the person whom they considered now as the best fitted, in point of merit and ability, to hold the job of Chief Medical officer whatever the rules, such tests, unless a particular mode of test is prescribed, are bound to be subjective in character. In this connection reference may be made to Balbir Singh v. State of M.P, AIR 1955 Nag 289 (B).

    8. In these circumstances it is clear that no service rule has been violated and there is no case for holding that the petitioner has been denied equality before the law or equal protection of the laws under article 14 of the Constitution. For the aforesaid reasons we dismiss this writ petition. We, however, leave the parties to bear their own costs.

    R.G.D

    9. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Shanker Nath Ganju v. State Of Jammu And Kashmir .
    (Dec 11, 1956)