Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Des Raj v. Ram Singh

    1. This is an application under Section 14 of the Limitation Act asking that a certain period of time during which the plaintiff had been prosecuting another civil proceeding against the defendant may be excluded in computing the period of limitation prescribed for the suit. The suit is for possession of certain land and ancillary relief of injunction. The dispossession of the plaintiff is stated to have taken place on 3-6-1945. It is common ground that the period of limitation prescribed for the suit is 12 years from the date of dispossession. This will take us to 3-6-1957. The suit was first instituted in the High Court on 31-8-56. The value of the property was stated in the plaint to be only Rs. 11925/-. The value being less than Rs. 20,000/-, the plaint was returned by the High Court on 11-9-56 for being presented to the proper Court having jurisdiction. The plaint was next presented to the District Judge Jammu on 1-10-56 and was transferred to the Addl. District Judge on the same day.

    2. The defendants contended that the suit was grossly undervalued. The Addl. District Judge decided on 26-8-1957 that the market value of the suit property was Rs. 53224/-. On the same day, the plaint was returned to the plaintiff for being presented to the proper Court. The plaintiff, however, appealed to the High Court against the order of the Addl. District Judge. On 19-11-58 a Division Bench of the High Court affirmed the finding of the Addl. District Judge on the question of valuation of the property. The plaint was thereafter presented to the High Court on 8-12-58.

    3. The suit would admittedly be barred by limitation on 8-12-58 unless the plaintiff is able successfully to invoke the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act. The plaintiff, therefore, filed an application under Section 14 of the Limitation Act for excluding the period during which he was prosecuting the previous proceedings, in computing the period of limitation. That period is from, 1-10-56 to 19-11-58. The period between 19-11-58 and 8-12-58 has in any event to be counted against the plaintiff.

    4. The plaintiff will be entitled to the benefit of S. 14 only if he is able to show that from 10-1-56 to 19-11-58 he has been litigating in good faith and with due diligence. Some of the earlier decisions under S. 14 seem to have proceeded on the footing that if it is not shown that the plaintiff was acting dishonestly or mala fide, he will be entitled to the benefit of S. 14. This approach is no longer tenable in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Madhav Rao v. Ram Krishna, AIR 1958 SC 767. It has been unmistakably pointed out in that decision that the real question material for the purpose of S. 14 is not whether the plaintiff was dishonest or that his acts or omissions were mala fide, but whether he acted with due care and attention. The burden of bringing his case within S. 14 thus lies on the plaintiff. He has to establish that he acted with due care and attention and also with due diligence. It he fails to make that out affirmatively, the benefit of S. 14 cannot be extended to him.

    5. The case on hand is one of gross undervaluation. The value to which the plaintiff struck for a considerably long time was Rs. 11925/-, whereas the Addl. District Judge's Court as well as the High Court found that the correct value was Rs. 53224/-. The difference between the amount which the plaintiff claimed to be the correct value and what the Courts found to be the proper value is quite considerable. In such a case unless there are good reasons to show that the plaintiff in spite of due care and attention could have believed that what he stated in the plaint was the correct and the proper value, he cannot successfully invoke Section 14 of the Limitation Act.

    6. In the instant case, there does not appear to be any good ground which can reasonably be said to have led the plaintiff, despite all due care and attention on his part, to believe that a sum of Rs. 11925/- was the proper value of the property in suit. It is remarkable that the application of the plaintiff invoking the aid of S. 14 is not even supported by an affidavit. It is very difficult to believe that if the plaintiff had exercised due care and attention which S. 14 enjoined upon him, he would not have known that the property-was much more valuable than what was shown in the plaint. Even if there was a difference of, say, Rs. 15,000/- or Rs. 20,000/- one may perhaps stretch a point and say that the plaintiff could, in spite of due care and attention, have considered that the property was of lesser value. This, one may perhaps do with some show of justification even in a case where the proper value of the property was two or three times the value stated in the plaint. But in present case the difference between the value stated and the value found exceeds Rs. 40,000/-, and is much more than four times the original value given in the plaint.

    7. These facts, if anything, seem to point to the conclusion that the plaintiff did not act with due care and attention. I would, therefore, hold that this is a case of gross under valuation deliberately made. In Ramchandra Singh v. Mt. Khcdaijatul Kubra, AIR 1945 Pat 369, a Division Bench of the Patna High Court following an earlier Division-Bench of the same Court in Bibi Sairah v. Mt. Golab Kuar, AIR 1919 Pat 345 held that where the plaintiff has given in the plaint a, gross understatement of the value of the suit property, he is not entitled to the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act. I do not think it necessary to cite other authorities because the point appears to me to be clear. I may, however, state that the Division Bench of the Madras High Court reported as Chandrayya v. Seethanna, AIR 1940 Mad 689, is also against the plaintiff-applicant. At p. 691 the learned Chief Justice observed:

    “He cannot claim the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act, because he deliberately under-valued his relief in the first instance. If he had not done this, I should have had no hesitation in granting relief under that section. He has however put himself out of Court.”

    8. In view of what I have stated, I am not able to see my way to allow the application under Section 14 of the Limitation Act.

    9. The question then is whether the suit also should be dismissed as barred by limitation. There does not appear to be any averment in the plaint intended to bring the case within Section 14 of the Limitation Act. For this purpose, the plaintiff has relied exclusively on the application filed by him under that section. Issues have not yet been framed in the suit. Both sides agreed that the application may be taken up even before the framing of an issue in the suit on the question of limitation. To dismiss the application filed by the plaintiff under Section 14 of the Limitation Act and to leave the suit to be decided later on, on the question of limitation may perhaps work some hardship on the plaintiff. It would also make for unnecessary protraction of proceedings. I, therefore, deem it proper and necessary to dismiss the suit itself as barred by limitation on the ground that the application under Section 14 of the Limitation Act has to be disallowed and that no other ground exists or is urged on behalf of the plaintiff to save limitation. (Vide section 3 of the Limitation Act). It is admitted that the prayer for injunction has no independent existence. In the result, the application under Section 14 of the Limitation Act is dismissed as also the suit. I however, make no order as to costs in the somewhat peculiar circumstances of this case.

    G.D/R.G.D

    10. Application and suit dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Des Raj v. Ram Singh
    (Dec 29, 1959)