AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Four hundred and forty-five daily-rated employees of the State of Karnataka sought regularisation of their services through Writ Petitions Nos. 39117-76 of 1999. On 15-12-1999 a learned Single Judge of the Karnataka High Court, relying on an earlier decision in H.S. Raghupathi Gowda v. State of Karnataka, allowed the petitions. The State’s writ appeals were dismissed on 24-01-2001 and its special-leave petitions were dismissed by the Supreme Court on 21-07-2005.

The State partially complied: 161 employees were regularised on 29-12-2005; 64 more on 08-03-2006; and another 55 on 18-04-2006. Seventy-four employees (the present respondents) remained unregularised. Contempt Petition No. 67 of 2006 resulted in a High Court direction of 20-06-2006 granting eight weeks to act, but no action ensued. The respondents therefore filed Civil Contempt Petition No. 669 of 2006.

By order dated 26-03-2007 the High Court found the appellants (State officials) prima facie guilty of contempt, granted two weeks to comply, and listed the matter for framing of charge if compliance failed. The State appealed to the Supreme Court, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants were in contempt of court for non-implementation of the High Court’s order directing regularisation of the respondents’ services.
  2. Whether the respondents were entitled to regularisation notwithstanding the principles laid down in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • Regularisations already effected (161, 64 and 55 employees) occurred before the Supreme Court’s decision in Umadevi (3).
  • After Umadevi (3), any pending claims must satisfy the conditions in para 53 of that judgment; the 74 respondents do not meet those conditions.
  • Consequently, refusal to regularise does not constitute willful disobedience but adherence to binding Supreme Court precedent.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • All litigation concerning their regularisation concluded before Umadevi (3); hence their claims were no longer sub judice when Umadevi (3) was decided.
  • Employees identically situated—161, 64, 55 and an additional 7 individuals—have already been regularised, some even after 10-04-2006 (the date of Umadevi (3)), establishing a right to parity.
  • Failure to extend the same benefit to the respondents constitutes contempt of the High Court’s earlier orders.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 Laid down conditions (para 53) governing regularisation of ad-hoc/temporary employees; protected past regularisations but mandated that pending claims satisfy specified criteria. The appellants relied on it to justify refusal; the Court held that, in view of subsequent regularisations and parity considerations, reliance on Umadevi (3) could not defeat the respondents’ claims.
H.S. Raghupathi Gowda v. State of Karnataka, WP No. 33541 of 1998 (Karnataka HC, 10-09-1999) Granted regularisation to daily-rated workers; served as the template for allowing the respondents’ writ petitions. Court noted that the State had implemented this decision, reinforcing the legitimacy of the respondents’ original entitlement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasised the principle of parity: the State had already regularised multiple batches of employees who were identically situated, including 55 employees on 18-04-2006, i.e. after the decision in Umadevi (3). Given this undisputed factual matrix, the Court found the State’s refusal to regularise the remaining 74 respondents “cannot appear to be sound or justified.”

Because the appellants’ stance stemmed from their interpretation of Umadevi (3), the Court declined to hold them in contempt. Nonetheless, it clarified that their interpretation was erroneous in the circumstances and directed immediate compliance with the earlier High Court orders.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is disposed of with a direction to the State to regularise the services of the 74 respondents forthwith and in any case within two months of receipt of the order.

Implications: The decision compels the State to extend regularisation on grounds of parity but stops short of a contempt conviction. It does not establish a new legal standard beyond confirming that selective implementation of court orders cannot be justified by misconstruing Umadevi (3). The primary effect is remedial, ensuring compliance for the affected employees.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Malathi Das (Retired) Now P.B Mahishy And Others v. Suresh And Others

    Ranjan Gogoi, J.— Leave granted. This appeal is against the order dated 26-3-2007 Civil Contempt Petition No. 669 of 2006 passed by the High Court of Karnataka in a contempt proceeding registered as CCC No. 669 of 2006. By the aforesaid order, the High Court, after holding the appellants, prima facie, guilty of commission of contempt has granted them two weeks' time to comply with the order in respect of which disobedience has been alleged failing which the matter was directed to be posted for framing of charge. Aggrieved, the appellants have filed the present appeal.

    2. It may be necessary to briefly outline the relevant facts on the basis of which the allegations of commission of contempt have been made and the conclusions, indicated above, have been reached by the High Court.

    3. 445 daily-rated employees of the State serving in different departments, including the 74 respondents herein, had instituted WPs Nos. 39117-76 of 1999 claiming regularisation of service. By order dated 15-12-1999 WP No. 39117 of 1999, the High Court following an earlier order dated 10-9-1999 passed in H.S Raghupathi Gowda v. State of Karnataka WP No. 33541 of 1998 had granted the relief(s) claimed by the writ petitioner-respondents. The aforesaid order dated 15-12-1999 WP No. 39117 of 1999 of the learned Single Judge was affirmed by order dated 24-1-2001 Writ Appeal No. 5697 of 2000 passed in the writ appeals filed by the State. The petitions filed by the State seeking special leave to appeal against the order dated 24-1-2001 Writ Appeal No. 5697 of 2000 were dismissed by this Court on 21-7-2005 SLPs (C) CC Nos. 109-498 of 2003.

    4. Two significant facts need to be noted at this stage. Firstly, that the order dated 10-9-1999 passed in H.S Raghupathi Gowda v. State of Karnataka WP No. 33541 of 1998 which was followed by the High Court while deciding the writ petitions (Writ Petitions Nos. 39117-76 of 1999) filed by the respondents had been implemented by the State Government by granting regularisation to the petitioners therein. The second significant fact that would require to be noticed is that following the dismissal of the special leave petitions filed by the State by order dated 21-7-2005 SLPs (C) CC Nos. 109-498 of 2003, a Scheme dated 29-12-2005 was framed by the State Government to implement the order dated 15-12-1999 passed in Nagaraju v. State of Karnataka WP No. 39117 of 1999.

    5. 161 persons who had filed contempt proceedings for non-compliance of the order dated 15-12-1999 WP No. 39117 of 1999 were regularised on 29-12-2005. Thereafter, on 8-3-2006, 64 other persons, who were similarly placed to the aforesaid 161 persons as well as to the present 74 respondents, were also regularised. Such regularisation was made without the persons concerned having to initiate any contempt proceeding. The cases of the other petitioners in WPs Nos. 39117-76 of 1999 were, however, not considered.

    6. Consequently, 129 employees, including the 74 respondents herein whose cases were not being considered by the State instituted another contempt proceeding being CCC No. 67 of 2006. By Government Order dated 18-4-2006, 55 out of the aforesaid 129 employees were regularised while the claims of the remaining 74 employees (the respondents herein) were not responded to. Accordingly, the contempt petition (CCC No. 67 of 2006) was heard and closed by the High Court by its order dated 20-6-2006 Civil Contempt Petition No. 67 of 2006 granting the respondents “eight weeks' time to pass appropriate orders in accordance with law on the claim made by the complainants for regularisation of their services in the office of the respondent authorities….”. As no action was initiated pursuant to the aforesaid order of the High Court, the present contempt petition i.e CCC No. 669 of 2006 was lodged by the 74 respondents. During the pendency of the aforesaid contempt petition the claim of regularisation of the respondents was rejected by specific orders passed on the ground that the claimants do not fulfil the conditions for regularisation as laid down by this Court in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1. Some of the said orders/endorsements were illustratively brought on record which demonstrate that the stand of the authorities with regard to the 74 respondents herein is that none of them fulfil/satisfy the conditions enumerated in para 53 of the judgment in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 as essential for the purpose of regularisation.

    7. On a detailed consideration of the facts of the case, particularly, the fact that the writ petitions as well as the writ appeals arising therefrom as also the order of this Court dated 21-7-2005 SLPs (C) CC Nos. 109-498 of 2003 dismissing the special leave petitions filed by the State were prior in point of time to the decision of this Court in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 (decided on 10-4-2006), the High Court took the view, as already noted, in its order dated 26-3-2007 Civil Contempt Petition No. 669 of 2006 which has given rise to the present appeal.

    8. We have heard Shri K.N Bhat, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants and Shri Guru Krishna Kumar, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents.

    9. Shri Bhat, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants has drawn the attention of the Court to the fact that regularisation in terms of the initial order of the High Court dated 10-9-1999 passed in H.S Raghupathi Gowda v. State of Karnataka WP No. 33541 of 1998 as well as regularisation in part i.e 161, 64 and 55 number of employees out of the 445 petitioners who had instituted Writ Petitions Nos. 39117-76 of 1999, were prior to the judgment of this Court in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1. Shri Bhat has submitted that in terms of the directions in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 while regularisations already made are not to be reopened, matters sub judice are to be governed by the conditions mentioned in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 and only on existence thereof regularisation could be made. According to the learned counsel as none of the respondents herein satisfy the said conditions the impugned refusals to regularise the service of the respondents have been made by the authorities of the State.

    10. On the other hand, Shri Guru Krishna Kumar, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents, has submitted that the writ petitions as well as the writ appeals and the special leave petitions filed in connection with the regularisation of the respondents stood concluded on 15-12-1999 WP No. 39117 of 1999, 24-1-2001 Writ Appeal No. 5697 of 2000 and 21-7-2005 SLPs (C) CC Nos. 109-498 of 2003 respectively, all of which dates are prior to the decision in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1. It is contended that as all the proceedings concerning the regularisation of the respondents had attained finality prior to the decision of this Court in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 the regularisation of the respondents cannot be understood to be sub judice. The learned counsel has further urged that 161, 64 and 55 number of persons from the batch of 445 writ petitioners who are identically placed as the respondents have been regularised. In fact, according to the learned counsel, the batch of 55 employees have been regularised on 18-4-2006 i.e after 10-4-2006 [the date of decision in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1].

    11. The learned counsel has also submitted that during the pendency of the present proceeding as many as 7 other persons, out of the batch of 445 writ petitioners, have also been regularised. It is accordingly submitted that in such circumstances on the principle of parity itself the entitlement of the respondents to be regularised cannot be doubted or disputed. The appellants, therefore, are clearly guilty of contempt and the impugned order Civil Contempt Petition No. 669 of 2006 of the High Court does not warrant any interference.

    12. It is not in dispute that the original batch of employees who had filed Writ Petitions Nos. 33541-71 of 1998 on the basis of which the writ petitions filed by the respondents herein (WPs Nos. 39117-76 of 1999) were allowed by the order dated 15-12-1999 WP No. 39117 of 1999 have been regularised. It is also not in dispute that out of the 445 employees who had filed Writ Petitions Nos. 39117-76 of 1999, by separate government orders, the service of 161, 64 and 55 employees have been regularised in three batches. The records placed before the Court would indicate that 7 other persons have been regularised during the pendency of the present appeal. In a situation where a Scheme had been framed on 29-12-2005 to give effect to the order of the High Court dated 15-12-1999 WP No. 39117 of 1999 passed in the writ petitions filed by the respondents herein and many of the similarly situated persons have been regularised pursuant thereto the action of the appellants in not granting regularisation to the present respondents cannot appear to be sound or justified. The fact that the regularisation of 55 employees, similarly situated to the present respondents, was made on 18-4-2006 i.e after the decision of this Court in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 is also not in serious dispute though Shri Bhat, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants, has tried to contend that the said regularisations were made prior to the decision in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1. The date of the order of regularisation of the 55 persons i.e 18-4-2006 will leave no doubt or ambiguity in the matter.

    13. In the aforesaid undisputed facts it is wholly unnecessary for us to consider as to whether the cases of persons who were awaiting regularisation on the date of the decision in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 is required to be dealt with in accordance with the conditions stipulated in para 53 of Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 inasmuch as the claims of the respondent employees can well be decided on principles of parity. Similarly placed employees having been regularised by the State and in case of some of them such regularisation being after the decision in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 we are of the view that the stand taken by the appellants in refusing regularisation to the respondents cannot be countenanced. However, as the said stand of the appellants stems from their perception and understanding of the decision in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 we do not hold them liable for contempt but make it clear that the appellants and all the other competent authorities of the State will now be obliged and duty-bound to regularise the services of the respondents (74 in number) which will now be done forthwith and in any case within a period of two months from the date of receipt of this order.

    14. The appeal shall stand disposed of in the above terms.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Malathi Das (Retired) Now P.B Mahishy And Others v. Suresh And Others
    (Mar 7, 2014)