AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 1(1) of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 5(1) of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 5 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 1(1) of the Act, Section 7 of the Act, Press and Registration of Books Act
  • Section 482 of the Code
  • Sections 500, 501, 502, 506, 507 and 114 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 1 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Sections 200 and 202 of the Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 1(1) of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 5(1) of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 5 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 1(1) of the Act, Section 7 of the Act, Press and Registration of Books Act
  • Section 482 of the Code
  • Sections 500, 501, 502, 506, 507 and 114 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 1 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867
  • Section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Sections 200 and 202 of the Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Gambhirsinh R. Dekare, was serving as a Taluka Mamlatdar and Executive Magistrate in Vadodara, Gujarat. A Vadodara-edition news item of the Gujarati daily newspaper “Sandesh” dated 28-09-1999 alleged that he was “caught red-handed” in an illicit relationship with a doctor’s wife. Claiming the report to be false and defamatory, he filed a private complaint before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Vadodara, against two accused: (1) Navinbhai Chauhan (Resident Editor, Vadodara) and (2) Falgunbhai Chimanbhai Patel (Editor, stationed at Ahmedabad).

The Magistrate took cognizance under Sections 500, 501, 502, 506, 507 and 114 of the Indian Penal Code and issued process against both accused. Respondent 1 (Accused 2, the Editor) moved the Gujarat High Court to quash the complaint, asserting lack of knowledge or involvement because the impugned article appeared only in the Vadodara edition overseen by the Resident Editor. The High Court accepted this contention and quashed the proceedings against him. The complainant sought special leave, which was granted, resulting in the present Supreme Court appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Gujarat High Court erred in quashing the criminal defamation complaint against the Editor (Accused 2) at the threshold.
  2. Whether the statutory presumption under Section 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867, attaches to a person whose name is printed as “Editor,” notwithstanding the existence of a separate Resident Editor for a local edition.
  3. Whether, at the stage of issuing process, the court can examine the truthfulness of the complainant’s allegations regarding the Editor’s knowledge and participation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The complaint specifically alleges that both accused gave “instructions and directions” for publishing the defamatory news, evidencing their deliberate involvement and knowledge.
  • The High Court wrongly concluded that no allegation existed against Accused 2, thus quashing the complaint on an erroneous factual assumption.
  • Because the newspaper prints Accused 2’s name as “Editor,” Section 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act raises a rebuttable presumption that he controlled the selection of the published matter and is prima facie liable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Accused 2 is stationed in Ahmedabad and plays no role in selecting news for the Vadodara edition, which is handled by the Resident Editor (Accused 1).
  • Relying on K.M. Mathew v. State of Kerala (1992) 1 SCC 217, the respondent asserted that liability cannot automatically attach to a Chief Editor/Editor absent specific material showing involvement.
  • Therefore, continuation of proceedings against Accused 2 would amount to misuse of the judicial process.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K.M. Mathew v. State of Kerala, (1992) 1 SCC 217 Presumption under Section 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act applies only to a person named as “Editor”; distinction between Editor and other designations like Chief Editor. The Court noted that the case actually supports liability of an “Editor” whose name is printed, and clarified that the portion of Mathew allowing Magistrates to recall process has since been overruled.
K.M. Mathew v. K.A. Abraham, (2002) 6 SCC 670 Section 7 raises a rebuttable presumption against the Editor; others may still be liable if knowledge is pleaded and proved. Cited to reinforce that naming a person as Editor prima facie establishes control over publication, subject to rebuttal at trial.
Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal, (2004) 7 SCC 338 Magistrates cannot recall an order issuing process; remedy lies under Section 482 CrPC. Invoked to clarify that the recall principle stated in K.M. Mathew (1992) regarding Magistrate’s power is no longer good law.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Supreme Court examined the complaint and found explicit allegations that the impugned news was published “as per the instructions and directions of the accused persons,” and that both accused “deliberately” published it knowing it would defame the complainant. At the pre-trial stage, courts must assume such averments to be true; assessing their truthfulness is reserved for trial.

2. The High Court’s conclusion that the complaint contained no allegation of Accused 2’s knowledge or involvement was therefore “palpably wrong” and based on an erroneous assumption of fact.

3. Statutory framework: Under Sections 5 and 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, every newspaper copy must print the names of its owner and editor; the editor is deemed to control selection of content. Section 7 creates a rebuttable presumption of responsibility against the named editor in civil or criminal proceedings.

4. Because Accused 2’s name appears as Editor, the statutory presumption applies, making him answerable unless he disproves control or knowledge during trial. The existence of a Resident Editor does not negate this initial presumption.

5. Precedent analysis: The Court distinguished the 1992 K.M. Mathew decision (which concerned a “Chief Editor” with no allegation of knowledge) and underscored that Mathew was partly overruled in Adalat Prasad concerning recall powers. The 2002 K.M. Mathew judgment was cited to support the rebuttable presumption against an editor.

6. Consequently, quashing the complaint at the threshold would amount to denial of a lawful trial and miscarriage of justice.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed; the Gujarat High Court’s order quashing the complaint and process against Accused 2 is set aside. The trial court shall proceed with the case according to law.

Implications: The decision reinstates criminal defamation proceedings against the Editor and reaffirms that the person whose name appears as “Editor” carries a rebuttable statutory presumption of responsibility for published content. It signals that editorial functionaries cannot avoid prosecution at the threshold merely by geographic separation from a local edition. No new doctrinal precedent is created, but the ruling clarifies and fortifies the statutory presumption under the Press and Registration of Books Act.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gambhirsinh R. Dekare v. Falgunbhai Chimanbhai Patel And Another

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Chandramauli Kr. Prasad, J.— The petitioner, Gambhirsinh R. Dekare, at the relevant point of time was serving as Taluka Mamlatdar and an Executive Magistrate in Vadodara Taluka in the State of Gujarat. A Gujarati daily newspaper Sandesh is published from different places i.e Surat, Valsad, Bharuch, Vadodara and other cities of India. Navinbhai Chauhan is the Resident Editor of Vadodara edition of Sandesh whereas Falgunbhai Chimanbhai Patel is the Editor of Sandesh. The newspaper published a news item in its Vadodara issue dated 28-9-1999 that the petitioner “is in love and keeping illicit relations with the wife of a doctor at Ajwa Road” with the following headlines:

    “Mamlatdar Shri Gambhirsinh Dekare is caught red-handed by the youngsters—Mamlatdar is indulged in illicit relations with the wife of doctor who is residing at Ajwa Road—Attempts to conceal the matter—Why the Government is not taking any action against the Mamlatdar?”

    2. According to the petitioner (hereinafter referred to as “the complainant”), the allegation published in the newspaper is false and defamatory. Accordingly, he filed a complaint in the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Vadodara. The complainant alleged that the news items are printed in the newspaper “as per the instructions and directions of the accused persons”. In Para 3 of the complaint the complainant alleged as under:

    “3. Accused 1 and 2 of this case have deliberately published the news on p. 12 of their daily newspaper Sandesh dated 28-9-1999 which is quite defaming and offending to us. The accused persons were in the knowledge that we the complainant shall be defamed in the society due to publishing of such news and with a view to vilify us as the person having bad character, the accused persons, in collusion with each other, have published the following news in the newspaper deliberately.”

    3. The complainant termed those allegations to be false and stated that the Editor and the Resident Editor have tried to prove him as a characterless person in the society and because of that he had faced shameful and disgraceful situation amongst the family members and friends. The news item further brought him in disrepute in the Department and the public. It has been alleged that the accused persons have published the news item without any evidence or proof. The complainant denied having any illicit relation with the doctor's wife. The complainant was examined on solemn affirmation in which he reiterated the allegation.

    4. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, taking into account the allegation made in the petition of complaint and the statement of the complainant on solemn affirmation, took cognizance of the offence under Sections 500, 501, 502, 506, 507 and 114 of the Penal Code, 1860 and issued process against both the accused.

    5. Accused 2 Falgunbhai Chimanbhai Patel, the Editor of Sandesh, aggrieved by the order taking cognizance and issuing process, filed an application before the High Court seeking quashing of the complaint filed before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Vadodara on 8-10-1999. He sought quashing of the complaint on the ground that he is the Editor of the newspaper, stationed at Ahmedabad and the offending news item was published in the Vadodara edition of the newspaper, of which Navinbhai Chauhan, Accused 1, is the Resident Editor. It was further contended that he was not aware of the offending news item being published in the newspaper nor for that matter had he any role to play in selection of such item for publication.

    6. The High Court by the impugned order allowed the application and while doing so observed as follows:

    “6. In the complaint itself, the petitioner is described as Editor of the newspaper and his address is shown at Ahmedabad. Original Accused 1 is described as a Resident Editor of Baroda of the same newspaper. It is not in dispute that the newspaper in question has its registered office at Ahmedabad and Baroda edition of the newspaper is being separately published from Baroda. It is also not in dispute that the offending news item was carried in Baroda edition of the newspaper only.”

    7. The High Court further went on to observe as under:

    “10. In the present case also, I find that there is nothing in the complaint to suggest that the petitioner herein was aware about the offending news item being published or that he had any role to play in selection of such item for publication. In absence of any material disclosed in the complaint and in view of the admitted fact that the petitioner is an Editor of the newspaper stationed at Ahmedabad and the news item was carried in its Baroda edition alone where the newspaper has a separate Resident Editor, the petitioner cannot be proceeded against for the offence of defamation of the complainant.”

    8. The High Court came to the conclusion that prosecution of Accused 2 would amount to miscarriage of justice and, accordingly, quashed the complaint and the process issued against him. It is against this order that the complainant has preferred this special leave petition.

    9. Leave granted. Mr Huzefa Ahmadi, Senior Advocate appears on behalf of the complainant (the appellant herein) whereas Accused 2 (Respondent 1 herein) is represented by Mr Dushyant Dave, Senior Advocate.

    10. Mr Ahmadi submits that according to the complainant, Accused 2 was the Editor stationed at Ahmedabad and there is specific allegation against him that the news items are published in the newspaper “as per the instructions and directions of the accused persons”. The complainant has further alleged in the complaint that both the accused i.e the Editor (Accused 2) and the Resident Editor (Accused 1) had deliberately published the news in their Gujarati daily newspaper Sandesh which is defamatory. The complainant went on to say that the “accused persons were in the knowledge that the complainant shall be defamed in the society due to publication of such news”. In the face of the aforesaid allegation, Mr Ahmadi points out that the High Court committed a serious error by observing that “there is nothing in the complaint to suggest that” Accused 2 “was aware about the offending news item being published or that he had any role to play in selection of such item for publication”.

    11. Mr Dave, however, submits that, according to the complainant's own showing, Accused 2 was the Editor of the newspaper stationed at Ahmedabad and the offending news item having been published at Vadodara for which there is admittedly a separate Resident Editor, it has to be assumed that Accused 2 was not aware of the same and had no role to play in the selection of such item for publication.

    12. We have bestowed our consideration to the rival submissions and we do not find any substance in the submission of Mr Dave. The complainant has specifically averred in the complaint that the news item was printed in the newspaper as per the instructions and directions of the accused persons. The complainant had specifically alleged that Accused 1 and 2 have deliberately published the offending news and it was within their knowledge. At this stage, it is impermissible to go into the truthfulness or otherwise of the allegation and one has to proceed on a footing that the allegation made is true. Hence, the conclusion reached by the High Court that “there is nothing in the complaint to suggest that the petitioner herein was aware of the offending news item being published or that he had any role to play in the selection of such item for publication” is palpably wrong. Hence, in our opinion, the High Court has quashed the prosecution on an erroneous assumption of fact which renders its order illegal.

    13. Mr Ahmadi further submits that the impugned order is vulnerable on another count. He points out that according to the complainant, the present accused was the Editor and his name has been printed as such in the publication and, therefore, he is responsible for the publication of the news item. Mr Dave, however, submits that there being Resident Editor for the Vadodara edition of the newspaper, the present accused, who is the Editor and stationed at Ahmedabad, cannot be held responsible for the publication. He emphasises that it would be the Resident Editor who shall be responsible for the contents of the Vadodara edition. In support of the submission he has placed reliance on a decision of this Court in K.M Mathew v. State of Kerala (1992) 1 SCC 217.

    14. A news item has the potentiality of bringing doomsday for an individual. The Editor controls the selection of the matter that is published. Therefore, he has to keep a careful eye on the selection. Blue-pencilling of news articles by anyone other than the Editor is not welcome in a democratic polity. Editors have to take responsibility of everything they publish and to maintain the integrity of published record. It is apt to remind ourselves the answer of the Editor of The Scotsman, a Scottish newspaper. When asked what it was like to run a national newspaper, the Editor answered “Run a newspaper! I run a country”. It may be an exaggeration but it does reflect the well-known fact that it can cause far-reaching consequences in an individual and country's life.

    15. The scheme and scope of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) also brings forward the same conclusion. Section 1 of the Act is the interpretation clause and the expression “Editor” has been defined as follows:

    “1. Interpretation clause.—(1) In this Act, unless there shall be something repugnant in the subject or context—
    ‘Editor’ means the person who controls the selection of the matter that is published in a newspaper;”

    16. Section 5 of the Act provides for rules as to publication of newspapers and prohibits its publication in India except in conformity with the rules laid down. Section 5(1) of the Act which is relevant for the purpose reads as follows:

    “5. Rules as to publication of newspapers.—No newspaper shall be published in India, except in conformity with the rules hereinafter laid down:
    (1) Without prejudice to the provisions of Section 3, every copy of every such newspaper shall contain the names of the owner and editor thereof printed clearly on such copy and also the date of its publication.”

    From a plain reading of the aforesaid provision, it is evident that every copy of every newspaper published in India is mandated to contain the names of the owner and Editor thereof. It is in the light of the aforesaid obligation that the name of Accused 2 has been printed as Editor.

    17. Section 7 of the Act makes the declaration to be prima facie evidence for fastening the liability in any civil or criminal proceeding on the Editor. Section 7 of the Act reads as follows:

    “7. Office copy of declaration to be prima facie evidence.—In any legal proceeding whatever, civil as well as criminal, the production of a copy of such declaration as is aforesaid, attested by the seal of some court empowered by this Act to have the custody of such declarations, or, in the case of the editor, a copy of the newspaper containing his name printed on it as that of the editor shall be held (unless the contrary be proved) to be sufficient evidence, as against the person whose name shall be subscribed to such declaration, or printed on such newspaper, as the case may be that the said person was printer or publisher, or printer and publisher (according as the words of the said declaration may be) of every portion of every newspaper whereof the title shall correspond with the title of the newspaper mentioned in the declaration or the editor of every portion of that issue of the newspaper of which a copy is produced.”

    18. Therefore, from the scheme of the Act it is evident that it is the Editor who controls the selection of the matter that is published in a newspaper. Further, every copy of the newspaper is required to contain the names of the owner and the Editor and once the name of the Editor is shown, he shall be held responsible in any civil and criminal proceeding. Further, in view of the interpretation clause, the presumption would be that he was the person who controlled the selection of the matter that was published in the newspaper. However, we hasten to add that this presumption under Section 7 of the Act is a rebuttable presumption and it would be deemed a sufficient evidence unless the contrary is proved. The view which we have taken finds support from the judgment of this Court in K.M Mathew v. K.A Abraham (2002) 6 SCC 670, in which it has been held as follows:

    “20. The provisions contained in the Act clearly go to show that there could be a presumption against the Editor whose name is printed in the newspaper to the effect that he is the Editor of such publication and that he is responsible for selecting the matter for publication. Though, a similar presumption cannot be drawn against the Chief Editor, Resident Editor or Managing Editor, nevertheless, the complainant can still allege and prove that they had knowledge and they were responsible for the publication of the defamatory news item. Even the presumption under Section 7 is a rebuttable presumption and the same could be proved otherwise. That by itself indicates that somebody other than editor can also be held responsible for selecting the matter for publication in a newspaper.”

    19. Now reverting to the authority of this Court in K.M Mathew v. State of Kerala (1992) 1 SCC 217, relied on by Mr Dave, in our opinion, the same instead of supporting his contention, goes against him:

    19.1 In the said case it has been observed as follows: (K.M Mathew case (1992) 1 SCC 217)

    “9. In the instant case there is no averment against the Chief Editor except the motive attributed to him. Even the motive alleged is general and vague. The complainant seems to rely upon the presumption under Section 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867 (‘the Act’). But Section 7 of the Act has no applicability for a person who is simply named as ‘Chief Editor’. The presumption under Section 7 is only against the person whose name is printed as ‘Editor’ as required under Section 5(1). There is a mandatory (though rebuttable) presumption that the person whose name is printed as ‘Editor’ is the Editor of every portion of that issue of the newspaper of which a copy is produced. Section 1(1) of the Act defines ‘Editor’ to mean ‘the person who controls the selection of the matter that is published in a newspaper’. Section 7 raises the presumption in respect of a person who is named as the Editor and printed as such on every copy of the newspaper. The Act does not recognise any other legal entity for raising the presumption. Even if the name of the Chief Editor is printed in the newspaper, there is no presumption against him under Section 7 of the Act.”

    19.2 In K.M Mathew case (1992) 1 SCC 217 the accused was the Chief Editor of Malayalam Manorama and there was no allegation against him in the complaint regarding knowledge of the objectionable character of the matter published. In the absence of such allegation, the Magistrate decided to proceed against the Chief Editor. On an application by the Chief Editor, the process issued against him was recalled. The High Court, however, set aside the order of the Magistrate and when the matter travelled to this Court, it set aside the order of the High Court. This Court made distinction between “Editor” and “Chief Editor”. In no uncertain terms the Court observed that the Press and Registration of Books Act recognises “Editor” and the presumption is only against him. The Act does not recognise any other legal entity viz. Chief Editor, Managing Editor, etc. for raising the presumption. They can be proceeded against only when there is specific allegation.

    19.3 We may here observe that in that case, this Court has held that the Magistrate has the power to drop proceedings against an accused against whom he had issued process in the following words: (K.M Mathew case (1992) 1 SCC 217)

    “8. It is open to the accused to plead before the Magistrate that the process against him ought not to have been issued. The Magistrate may drop the proceedings if he is satisfied on reconsideration of the complaint that there is no offence for which the accused could be tried. It is his judicial discretion. No specific provision is required for the Magistrate to drop the proceedings or rescind the process. The order issuing the process is an interim order and not a judgment. It can be varied or recalled. The fact that the process has already been issued is no bar to drop the proceedings if the complaint on the very face of it does not disclose any offence against the accused.”

    19.4 However, this Court in Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal (2004) 7 SCC 338 has specifically overruled K.M Mathew (1992) 1 SCC 217 in regard to the power of the Magistrate to recall its order issuing process. It has been observed as follows:

    “15. It is true that if a Magistrate takes cognizance of an offence, issues process without there being any allegation against the accused or any material implicating the accused or in contravention of provisions of Sections 200 and 202, the order of the Magistrate may be vitiated, but then the relief an aggrieved accused can obtain at that stage is not by invoking Section 203 of the Code because the Criminal Procedure Code does not contemplate a review of an order. Hence in the absence of any review power or inherent power with the subordinate criminal courts, the remedy lies in invoking Section 482 of the Code.
    16. Therefore, in our opinion the observation of this Court in K.M Mathew v. State of Kerala (1992) 1 SCC 217 that for recalling an erroneous order of issuance of process, no specific provision of law is required, would run counter to the scheme of the Code which has not provided for review and prohibits interference at interlocutory stages. Therefore, we are of the opinion, that the view of this Court in Mathew case (1992) 1 SCC 217 that no specific provision is required for recalling an erroneous order, amounting to one without jurisdiction, does not lay down the correct law.”

    19.5 Thus, our reference to K.M Mathew (1992) 1 SCC 217 may not be construed to mean that we are in any way endorsing the opinion, which has already been overruled in Adalat Prasad (2004) 7 SCC 338.

    20. Thus the impugned judgment of the High Court is indefensible both on facts and law. Any observation made by us in this judgment is for the decision in this case. It does not reflect on the merit of the allegation, which obviously is a matter of trial.

    21. In the result, the appeal is allowed, the impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside and the court in seisin of the case shall now proceed with the trial in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gambhirsinh R. Dekare v. Falgunbhai Chimanbhai Patel And Another
    (Mar 11, 2013)