AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 45-N of the RBI Act, 1934
  • RBI Act, Section 45-QA, Section 45-A, Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act
  • Section 45-N of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934
  • Section 393(1)(a) of the Companies Act
  • Section 45-MB(1) of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934
  • Section 391, proviso of sub-section (2) of the Act
  • Section 22, Sick Industrial Companies Act, 1982
  • Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969, Section 33(1)(j)
  • Para 6, Chapter III-B of the RBI Act
  • Sections 391-393 of the Companies Act
  • The Contract Act
  • Section 45-N of the Companies Act
  • RBI Act, Amendment Act of 1963
  • Section 45-MB(2) of the RBI Act
  • Sections 235 to 251 of the Companies Act
  • Order 21 Rule 2 CPC (Code of Civil Procedure, 1908)
  • Sections 391 to 393 of the Companies Act
  • Section 58-A of the Companies Act
  • Section 45-QA(1) of the RBI Act
  • Section 45-Q and/or Section 45-QA of the RBI Act
  • Section 45 of the RBI Act
  • Section 391(1) of the Companies Act, 1956
  • Section 402, Companies Act
  • Chapter III-B of the Companies Act
  • Customs Tariff Act, 1975, Section 9-A
  • Sections 235-251 of the Companies Act
  • Chapter III-B of the RBI Act (inserted by Act 55 of 1963 w.e.f 1-12-1964)
  • Order 23 CPC (Code of Civil Procedure, 1908)
  • Bennion's Interpretation of Statutes, Section 288 on 'Textual Conflicts'
  • RBI (Amendment) Act, 1997
  • Section 45-QA(2) of the RBI Act
  • Section 45-A of the RBI Act, Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, Chapter III-B of the RBI Act, Companies Act (enacted in 1956), Amendment Act, Section 45-QA of the RBI Act
  • Section 391(1) read with Section 393(1) of the Companies Act
  • Section 391(2) of the Companies Act
  • RBI (Amendment) Ordinance, 1997
  • Section 391 of the Companies Act, Section 38 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, 1934
  • Section 393(1)(a), Section 391 sub-section (1) of the Act
  • Section 62, Contract Act, 1872
  • The RBI Act and the Companies Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Companies Act, Sections 391-394
  • the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the Companies Act”)
  • Section 45-MB(1) of the RBI Act, 1934
  • Section 391 of the Act
  • Section 391(2), Section 393 of the Companies Act
  • Section 391 of the Companies Act, 1956
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 45-N of the RBI Act, 1934
  • RBI Act, Section 45-QA, Section 45-A, Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act
  • Section 45-N of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934
  • Section 393(1)(a) of the Companies Act
  • Section 45-MB(1) of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934
  • Section 391, proviso of sub-section (2) of the Act
  • Section 22, Sick Industrial Companies Act, 1982
  • Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969, Section 33(1)(j)
  • Para 6, Chapter III-B of the RBI Act
  • Sections 391-393 of the Companies Act
  • The Contract Act
  • Section 45-N of the Companies Act
  • RBI Act, Amendment Act of 1963
  • Section 45-MB(2) of the RBI Act
  • Sections 235 to 251 of the Companies Act
  • Order 21 Rule 2 CPC (Code of Civil Procedure, 1908)
  • Sections 391 to 393 of the Companies Act
  • Section 58-A of the Companies Act
  • Section 45-QA(1) of the RBI Act
  • Section 45-Q and/or Section 45-QA of the RBI Act
  • Section 45 of the RBI Act
  • Section 391(1) of the Companies Act, 1956
  • Section 402, Companies Act
  • Chapter III-B of the Companies Act
  • Customs Tariff Act, 1975, Section 9-A
  • Sections 235-251 of the Companies Act
  • Chapter III-B of the RBI Act (inserted by Act 55 of 1963 w.e.f 1-12-1964)
  • Order 23 CPC (Code of Civil Procedure, 1908)
  • Bennion's Interpretation of Statutes, Section 288 on 'Textual Conflicts'
  • RBI (Amendment) Act, 1997
  • Section 45-QA(2) of the RBI Act
  • Section 45-A of the RBI Act, Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, Chapter III-B of the RBI Act, Companies Act (enacted in 1956), Amendment Act, Section 45-QA of the RBI Act
  • Section 391(1) read with Section 393(1) of the Companies Act
  • Section 391(2) of the Companies Act
  • RBI (Amendment) Ordinance, 1997
  • Section 391 of the Companies Act, Section 38 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, 1934
  • Section 393(1)(a), Section 391 sub-section (1) of the Act
  • Section 62, Contract Act, 1872
  • The RBI Act and the Companies Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Companies Act, Sections 391-394
  • the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the Companies Act”)
  • Section 45-MB(1) of the RBI Act, 1934
  • Section 391 of the Act
  • Section 391(2), Section 393 of the Companies Act
  • Section 391 of the Companies Act, 1956
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, an NBFC incorporated in 1983 and once profitable, faced regulatory action after the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) inspected its books in 2005 and found multiple violations of the RBI Act, 1934 and the NBFC Prudential Norms. On 18-1-2005 RBI prohibited the company from accepting fresh deposits or alienating assets. Seeking relief, the company proposed a “Scheme of Arrangement/Compromise” under Section 391 of the Companies Act, 1956 to convert deposit- and bond-holders into 6% secured convertible debenture-holders, ultimately to be given equity.

The Single Judge of the Madras High Court sanctioned the scheme on 19-8-2006, subject to conditions. Four appeals (including one by RBI) were allowed by a Division Bench on 30-4-2008, which set aside the sanction, holding the scheme contrary to Chapter III-B of the RBI Act and vitiated by non-disclosure of material facts. The company challenged that common judgment before the Supreme Court. Leave was granted and the present judgment dismisses the appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the non-obstante clause in Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, 1934 bars a High Court from sanctioning a scheme for NBFC deposit-holders under Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act, 1956.
  2. Whether failure to disclose RBI’s letter/notice dated 18-1-2005 to deposit- and bond-holders vitiated the statutory requirements of Sections 391(2) and 393 of the Companies Act.
  3. Consequently, whether the scheme, which substitutes repayment with conversion into debentures/equity, can be approved when it does not conform to Section 45-QA(1)’s mandate that deposits “shall be repaid in accordance with the terms and conditions of such deposit.”

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant Company & Supporting Intervenors

  • Scheme approved by an overwhelming majority of deposit-holders (≈79%) and bond-holders (≈78%), with no procedural irregularity.
  • RBI Act and Companies Act operate in separate fields; Section 45-QA does not oust the court’s jurisdiction under Section 391.
  • Non-obstante clause in Section 45-Q should receive limited construction; no clear inconsistency exists between Section 45-QA and Sections 391-394.
  • Non-disclosure of the 18-1-2005 RBI notice was immaterial: it was already publicised and, in any event, Section 391(2) requires disclosure only to the court, not to individual creditors.
  • Section 391 effects statutory novation; once sanctioned, a scheme binds even dissenting minorities (relying on J.K. (Bombay) and other authorities).

Respondents (RBI & Depositors’ Association)

  • Chapter III-B forms a comprehensive regulatory code; Section 45-QA gives depositors an unwaivable statutory right to repayment as per original terms.
  • Non-obstante clause in Section 45-Q gives Chapter III-B primacy over any inconsistent law, including Section 391 schemes.
  • Company’s scheme is a device to evade repayment, hence contrary to public policy and the protective purpose of the RBI amendments.
  • Material suppression: the company failed to place the 18-1-2005 prohibition before creditors, undermining informed consent and statutory transparency.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Miheer H. Mafatlal v. Mafatlal Industries Ltd. (1997) 1 SCC 579 Lists parameters a court must satisfy before sanctioning a scheme under Section 391. Supreme Court applied these parameters to emphasise that courts must ensure compliance with law and public policy, holding the present scheme wanting.
Tata Motors Ltd. v. Pharmaceutical Products of India Ltd. (2008) 7 SCC 619 Special statute with non-obstante clause prevails over earlier general statute; concept of self-contained code. Cited to support view that Chapter III-B (special, later, self-contained) overrides Companies Act provisions.
Dhulabhai v. State of M.P. AIR 1969 SC 78 Jurisdiction of civil courts is not ousted unless statute so indicates. Relied on by appellants; Court distinguished, reaffirming explicit override in Section 45-Q.
J.K. (Bombay) (P) Ltd. v. New Kaiser-I-Hind Spg. & Wvg. Co. AIR 1970 SC 1041 Sanctioned scheme has statutory force and binds dissenting minorities. Cited by appellants; Court held principle inapplicable because underlying scheme itself violates overriding RBI provisions.
Administrator of the Specified Undertaking of UTI v. Garware Polyester Ltd. (2005) 10 SCC 682 Court may “pierce the veil” to test bona fides of a scheme. Used to justify judicial scrutiny beyond mere majority approval.
Haridas Exports v. A.I. Float Glass Mfrs. Assn. (2002) 6 SCC 600 Statutes can occupy distinct fields without conflict. Relied on by appellants; Court found facts distinguishable and rejected the analogy.
JIK Industries Ltd. v. Amarlal V. Jumani (2012) 3 SCC 255 Non-obstante clauses have contextual limits. Cited by appellants; Court held Section 45-Q’s wording and legislative intent demand full override here.
Aswini Kumar Ghose v. Arabinda Bose AIR 1952 SC 369; Madhav Rao Scindia v. Union of India (1971) 1 SCC 85; A.G. Varadarajulu v. State of T.N. (1998) 4 SCC 231; R.S. Raghunath v. State of Karnataka (1992) 1 SCC 335 General principles on interpreting non-obstante clauses and reconciling statutes. Discussed but not accepted as altering the clear overriding mandate of Section 45-Q.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Chapter III-B of the RBI Act, introduced through amendments aimed at protecting small investors from NBFC defaults, constitutes a “self-contained code.” Section 45-Q explicitly grants the chapter overriding effect over “any other law.”

2. The appellant’s scheme offends Section 45-QA(1), which mandates that every NBFC deposit “shall be repaid in accordance with the terms and conditions” unless renewed or extension is obtained from the Company Law Board. The scheme instead converts repayment obligations into debentures and equity, effectively avoiding repayment.

3. Applying Miheer H. Mafatlal, the Court confirmed that a company-court must ensure compliance with all applicable law and bona fide purpose. Where a scheme directly contravenes a later, overriding statute meant to protect depositors, judicial sanction is impermissible regardless of creditor majority.

4. On non-disclosure: the 18-1-2005 RBI prohibition and underlying inspection findings were “material facts” under Sections 391(1) and 393(1). Their suppression undermined informed voting and evidenced lack of bona fides.

5. Precedents on novation or majority binding power (e.g., J.K. (Bombay)) cannot save a scheme that is ultra vires a mandatory statutory command.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Division Bench, holding that any scheme for NBFC deposit-holders must comply with Chapter III-B of the RBI Act; non-compliant schemes cannot be sanctioned under Section 391 of the Companies Act, notwithstanding creditor approval. The decision reinforces depositor protection, clarifies that the RBI Act’s later, special provisions override earlier company-law mechanisms, and signals that courts will scrutinise schemes for statutory compliance and full disclosure. No new precedent was set on unrelated areas of company law.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Integrated Finance Company Limited v. Reserve Bank Of India And Others

    Surinder Singh Nijjar, J.— Leave granted. IA filed by Mr B. Ramanna Kumar for substitution in place of late Mr N. Mani is allowed. These appeals, arising out of SLPs (Civil) Nos. 12737-40 of 2008, are directed against the common order and judgment dated 30-4-2008 2008 SCC OnLine Mad 340, (2008) 5 MLJ 980, (2008) 3 LW 267 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature of Madras. Vide the aforesaid order, the order/judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 19-8-2006 passed in Company Petition No. 160 of 2005 was set aside.

    2. Company Petition No. 160 of 2005 was filed by the appellant Company herein under Section 391 of the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the Companies Act”), seeking approval for the Scheme of Arrangement/Compromise dated 10-8-2005. The said agreement was entered into between the appellant Company herein and its class of creditors, namely, its deposit-holders and bond-holders. The learned Single Judge, vide order dated 19-8-2006, was pleased to sanction the said Scheme, albeit with some conditions. This order was challenged in the High Court by way of four original side appeals, which were allowed by the Division Bench vide the order dated 30-4-2008 2008 SCC OnLine Mad 340, (2008) 5 MLJ 980, (2008) 3 LW 267 which has been challenged in this Court.

    Summary of facts

    3. The relevant facts giving rise to filing of the present appeals as narrated by the parties are as under.

    4. The appellant herein was incorporated as a non-banking finance company (hereinafter referred to as “NBFC”) under the Companies Act in 1983, and was engaged inter alia in the business of hire-purchase and leasing. Over the years the appellant Company has become one of the leading financial companies. It has 32 branches with over several hundred employees. The shares of the company are listed in two stock exchanges in India. It has 20,000 shareholders. Until 1995-1996, the appellant Company was a profit-making company and declared dividends to its shareholders continuously.

    5. That Reserve Bank of India (hereinafter referred to as “RBI” or/and “Respondent 1”), during 1997-2003, issued a series of circulars for regulating various activities of the non-banking financial companies. RBI also imposed certain conditions on these companies. The companies that did not comply with the aforesaid conditions were directed to stop accepting deposits from the investors and also to repay the deposits immediately.

    6. In exercise of its powers under Section 45-N of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 (hereinafter “the 1934 Act”), RBI inspected the books of accounts of the appellant Company in 2005. The inspection report of RBI disclosed the following violations of the provisions of the 1934 Act:

    6.1 On 31-3-2004, the net owned fund (NOF) of the appellant Company herein stood at negative (-) Rs 10666.06 lakhs, which was in excess of the reported NOF at Rs 2194.00 lakhs;

    6.2 The credit exposure of the appellant Company, as on 31-3-2004, to some of the companies was found to be in excess of 15% of its reported owned fund of Rs 2877.00 lakhs as on 30-9-2003. Thus, it violated the provisions of Para 12 of the NBFC Prudential Norms (Reserve Bank) Directions, 1998 (hereinafter referred to as the “Prudential Norms Directions”).

    6.3 The appellant Company did not classify its assets in accordance with the asset classification norms stipulated by RBI and thereby, violated the provisions of Para 7 of the Prudential Norms Directions.

    6.4 The gross non-performing assets of the appellant Company, assessed at Rs 15603.16 lakhs, stood at a very high level and constituted 69.31% of the total credit exposures of the appellant Company.

    6.5 The appellant Company was found to have not made adequate provision in respect of its non-performing assets. Resultantly, there was short provisioning to the extent of Rs 12575.33 lakhs. The aforesaid omission on the part of the appellant violated the provisions of Para 8 of the Prudential Norms Directions.

    6.6 The appellant Company was also found to be in violation of the provisions of Para 10 of the Prudential Norms Directions because the NOF of the appellant Company was negative and it did not maintain the minimum capital adequacy ratio.

    7. Subsequently on 20-1-2005, RBI, in exercise of its powers under Section 45-MB(1) of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 issued a circular to the appellant Company, prohibiting it from “accepting deposits from any person, in any form whether by way of fresh deposits or renewal of the existing deposits or otherwise, until further orders”. Further, the appellant Company was directed not to sell, transfer, create charge or mortgage, or deal in any manner with its properties, assets, without prior permission of RBI. The said notice was also advertised in the Indian Express dated 20-1-2005.

    8. Thereafter, the appellant Company started facing problems in running its operations because of the drop in its profitability. In order to overcome these problems, the appellant Company proposed a Scheme of Compromise with its creditors viz. the depositors and bond-holders, which was approved by the Board of Directors of the appellant Company on 19-5-2005. The relevant part of the aforesaid Scheme is as under:

    “4. payments to fixed deposit-holders/bond-holders
    4.1 The Company would settle all the deposit-holders up to maturity value of Rs 20,000 as and when it falls due.
    4.2 The Scheme would provide for the following:
    (a) Conversion of all the deposit-holders and bond-holders into secured convertible debentures carrying on interest of 6% p.a convertible into equity before the expiry of 1 year from the date of allotment with an option to the company to prepay the value of debentures before the due date of conversion. The conversion price will be determined taking into account the valuation laid down by SEBI Guidelines.
    (b) The debentures will be issued with periodical interest payment option to the deposit/bond-holders who are holding regular interest payment option presently and for those deposit/bond-holders holding payment of interest under cumulative option, interest will be added to the value of the debenture for conversion at the time of maturity.
    (c) By virtue of this Scheme, all the deposit-holders and bond-holders would become secured creditors in the books of IFCL at the first year. The Trustees for the bonds would be the debenture trustees in the post Scheme scenario and a Debenture Trust Deed charging the assets of Rs 125 crores of receivables, accrued interest, investments, assets and available stock on hire would also be made so as to comply with all the norms for the purpose of fully convertible debentures.
    4.3 By virtue of the conversion, the outflow of the company would be a quarterly payment of interest depending upon the type of deposit/bond held by the creditors. At the end of the tenure the debentures would either be redeemed or converted as equity shares at the given appropriate exit route as the Company is a listed company and a fairly large tradable market capitalisation being available for the liquidation of these converted shares. The conversion of deposit-holders/bond-holders into secured convertible debentures and thereafter into equity shares of the Company will ensure their benefits since the Company established new lines of business such as financial BPO and is in the process of expanding the same.
    ***
    4.6 The Scheme is not offered to the Banks since the stock on hire pledged/hypothecated is about Rs 80 crores as against their dues of Rs 62 crores. Since none of the banks interest is prejudiced nor any of the assets charged to them, this Scheme is not being offered to them and it is only the deposit-holders and bond-holders whose rights are being dealt with in the Scheme of Arrangement and Compromise. Thus there is no direct or indirect interest of the Banks being prejudiced or affected.
    5. Since this Scheme does not envisage cash outflow at the first instance and does seek to convert the depositors and bond over a period of time into shareholders there is no requirement of fresh infusion of cash.
    6. implementation of scheme
    6.1 The Scheme if approved by the deposit-holders and bond-holders with such modifications, as may be assented by the Company, shall be submitted to this Hon'ble Court for confirmation and if confirmed, shall become binding with all deposit-holders, bond-holders and the Company.
    6.2 On completion of the Scheme, the Company shall have discharged all the liability to fixed deposit/bond-holders.
    7. effect of the scheme
    7.1 In view of the above Scheme being offered, all the parties agree that:
    (a) With the terms of the Scheme all liabilities of the deposit-holders and bond-holders shall be deemed as fully discharged;
    (b) No claims shall be raised by any deposit-holder or bond-holder to whom this Scheme is offered; and
    (c) No claim can be made against any group companies of IFCL their associates or any other person, promoters, directors, past and present, in respect of matters relating to IFCL;
    (d) This Scheme if approved and ordered by this Hon'ble Court shall be binding on the Company and all parties to the Scheme.”

    9. The aforesaid Scheme of Compromise was presented under Section 391 of the Companies Act to the High Court. On 1-7-2005, the appellant Company was permitted by the learned Single Judge, in Company Applications Nos. 854 and 855 of 2005 in CP No. 160 of 2005, to convene a meeting of its deposit-holders at Chennai on 10-8-2005 at 2.30 p.m for the purpose of considering the said Scheme of Compromise and, if thought fit, approving the same with or without modifications. Also, Mr B. Ravi, a Practising Company Secretary, was directed to preside over the meeting. In the contingency of the failure of Mr B. Ravi to preside over the meeting, Mr George Kuruvilla, Managing Director of the appellant Company was directed to step into the shoes of the former. The learned Single Judge also gave some other directions in the aforesaid order to ensure that the relevant provisions of the Companies Act are complied with while conducting the said meeting.

    10. However, before the meeting could be held on 10-8-2008, Company Applications Nos. 1105 to 1110 of 2005 in CP No. 160 of 2005 came to be preferred before the High Court. In the aforesaid company applications, some depositors of the appellant Company inter alia sought the appointment of an “independent Chairman,” in place of the Chairman appointed vide order dated 1-7-2005. The said applicants also made a prayer that police protection should be granted to them during the said meeting. The learned Single Judge while disposing of the aforesaid company applications, vide order dated 5-8-2005, did not make any change pertaining to the Chairmanship of the originally appointed Mr B. Ravi. However, Mr R. Guruswamy, retired District Judge, was appointed as the observer for the said meeting. This appears to have been done for ensuring fair and free participation of all deposit-holders/bond-holders in the said meeting.

    11. The scheduled meeting was conducted on 10-8-2005, as per the orders of the learned Single Judge dated 1-7-2005 and 5-8-2005. The report of the meeting was published in various newspapers indicating that the Scheme had been approved by majority of the bond-holders and deposit-holders. A report concerning the said meeting was filed before the learned Single Judge along with the Observer's report. Thereafter, a petition was preferred before the High Court under Section 391(2) of the Companies Act, seeking sanction for the said Scheme of Compromise. In the aforesaid proceedings, the Integrated Finance Company Depositors Association, an Association representing the depositors of the appellant Company and several other depositors filed their objections and raised several contentions regarding the validity of the said Scheme. RBI also filed its objections. At the same time, certain other associations, representing the deposit-holders, debenture-holders also intervened in the aforesaid proceedings and supported the validity of the said Scheme. Similarly, an association of the employees of the appellant Company also intervened in the support of the Scheme. It is also relevant to note here that the appellant Company, during the pendency of Company Petition No. 160 of 2005, filed Company Applications Nos. 1409 & 1410 of 2005 inter alia to restrain Respondents 1 to 6 in such applications from initiating any proceeding either civil or criminal in nature against the Directors of the appellant Company.

    12. The learned Single Judge vide order dated 19-8-2006 overruled all the objections put forward against or in objection to the said Scheme and accorded approval to the same. While granting sanction the learned Single Judge made it clear that sanction of the said Scheme

    “will not exonerate or protect the Directors and those in charge of the affairs of the Company from any proceeding that may be contemplated either under the provisions of the Companies Act or under any other Act for any statutory violation.”

    13. The aforesaid order, as noticed earlier, was challenged before the Division Bench of the High Court by way of the following appeals: OSA No. 308 of 2006 was filed by Reserve Bank of India; OSA No. 309 of 2006 was filed by the Integrated Finance Company Depositors Association; OSA No. 312 of 2006 was filed by one M/s Popular Kuries Limited and OSA No. 91 of 2007 was filed by one Mrs Elizabeth Antony. While allowing the aforesaid appeals, the Division Bench set aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge vide common judgment/order dated 30-4-2008 2008 SCC OnLine Mad 340, (2008) 5 MLJ 980, (2008) 3 LW 267. This judgment is under challenge before us.

    Submissions

    14. We have heard the learned counsel on behalf of the parties.

    15. Mr Arvind P. Datar, learned Senior Counsel, appeared for the appellant Company and assailed the validity of the impugned order 2008 SCC OnLine Mad 340, (2008) 5 MLJ 980, (2008) 3 LW 267. Mr Iqbal Chagla, learned Senior Counsel, appeared for intervenors in IAs Nos. 29-32 of 2009 in SLPs (C) Nos. 12737-40 of 2008. Mr Shyam Divan, learned Senior Counsel, appeared for the intervenors in IAs Nos. 33-36 of 2009 in the aforesaid proceedings. Whereas Mr Parag P. Tripathi, learned Senior Counsel, appeared for the respondent RBI and Mr V. Parkash, learned Senior Counsel appeared for Respondent 1 Integrated Finance Depositors Association in SLP (C) No. 12738 of 2008.

    16. Mr Datar, learned Senior Counsel, submitted that the Scheme of Compromise of the appellant Company has been approved by 1708 out of 2177 (79%) deposit-holders and 5628 out of 7143 bond-holders (77.73%), present and voting; which shows that it was approved by an enormous majority. According to him, the appellant Company has complied with all the statutory requirements relating to the said Scheme. This, he submits, is evident from the fact that neither the Single Judge nor the Division Bench of the High Court found any procedural irregularity in the arrangement of the said Scheme. Thus according to Mr Datar, the only issues that now require consideration are:

    “(i) Whether the non obstante clause in Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, 1934 prohibits the High Court from sanctioning any Scheme for the deposit-holders of an NBFC?
    (ii) Whether the petitioner had failed to disclose the RBI Letter dated 18-1-2005 before the learned Company Judge as per the provisions of Section 391(1) of the Companies Act, 1956?”

    17. According to Mr Chagla, the crucial issue which arises for the consideration of this Court is as to whether Section 391 of the Companies Act does not apply to NBFCs in view of Section 45-QA of the RBI Act. He also supplemented the second issue, as framed by Mr Datar, by submitting that this Court has to determine that whether non-disclosure of the Letter dated 18-1-2005 violates the provisions of Section 391(2) and/or Section 393 of the Companies Act. These submissions are reiterated by Mr Shyam Divan, learned Senior Counsel.

    18. Mr Datar has further submitted that a Scheme under Sections 391 to 394 is an exception to the rule that a contract can be novated only with the consent of the individual parties. The resolution passed by the requisite majority sanctioning the Scheme in question, which gets sanction from the Court will be binding equally on the dissenting minority. In this context, the learned Senior Counsel relied upon J.K (Bombay) (P) Ltd. v. New Kaiser-I-Hind Spg. and Wvg. Co. Ltd. AIR 1970 SC 1041, (1969) 2 SCR 866 and Administrator of the Specified Undertaking of the UTI v. Garware Polyester Ltd. (2005) 10 SCC 682

    19. Mr Shyam Divan, while explaining the scope of Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act, has drawn our attention to the principle of novation, which allows the parties to a contract to rework or re-agree the terms of the contract. He submits that this principle is recognised in Section 62 of the Contract Act, 1872. Further, the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 allows compromise during the pendency of the proceedings (see Order 23 CPC); and also by adjustment of a decree (Order 21 Rule 2 CPC). Relying on the provisions contained in Section 22 of the Sick Industrial Companies Act, 1982 and Section 402 of the Companies Act, Mr Divan has submitted that Chapter V of the Companies Act provides another statutory method of varying contracts. Chapter V allows even solemn contractual obligations to be varied by a particular class of similarly placed members/creditors, provided there is requisite majority. The learned Senior Counsel argued that a Scheme under Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act is not merely a commercial agreement, but it is statutorily binding on all members and creditors of a company.

    20. Mr Datar, Mr Chagla and Mr Divan have unanimously submitted that Section 45-QA of the RBI Act is not a bar to a scheme under Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act. The learned Senior Counsel advanced the following reasons for substantiating the said submission:

    20.1 First, the RBI Act and the Companies Act must be read in their own spheres since both operate in different fields, altogether.

    20.2 Second, Section 45-QA of the RBI Act and Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act can be read harmoniously and there is no inconsistency between the said provisions.

    20.3 Third, the legislature did not intend to exclude the application of Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act in relation to the NBFCs.

    21. Elaborating upon these propositions, it was submitted that the RBI Act and the Companies Act operate in distinct and different fields, altogether. Mr Chagla argued that the RBI Act is regulatory in nature and is enacted to regulate the operation of the Banking Companies and NBFCs. The RBI Act is merely supplementary to the Companies Act and does not supplant it. To support the said submission, Mr Datar relied upon Bennion's Interpretation of Statutes, Section 288 on “Textual Conflicts.” Reliance is also placed on Haridas Exports v. All India Float Glass Manufacturers' Assn. (2002) 6 SCC 600 Mr Datar further pointed out that the special provisions relating to a Scheme under the Companies Act will prevail over a special statute, if the special statute has no provisions to deal with the said matter. He relied upon the principle of law laid down in Icici Bank Ltd. v. Sidco Leathers Ltd. (2006) 10 SCC 452 In this context, Mr Chagla relied upon the judgments of this Court in Aswini Kumar Ghose v. Arabinda Bose AIR 1952 SC 369 and Madhav Rao Jivaji Rao Scindia v. Union of India (1971) 1 SCC 85. Further, the RBI Act, according to Mr Chagla, is not a complete code by itself.

    22. Mr Datar also pointed out that the RBI Act will apply for the regulation of collection of deposits, for minimum net owned funds, terms of deposits, etc. but will not apply to cases of a scheme under the Companies Act which are not barred by the former. The latter will continue to apply in the circumstances where matters relating to running of a company are concerned, like the provisions relating to schemes and arrangements of the company. Thus, it was submitted that the RBI Act has no application in matters covered by Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act and therefore, Section 45-QA of the RBI Act is not a bar to a scheme under Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act.

    23. Secondly, it was submitted that since there is no inconsistency between Section 45-QA of the RBI Act and Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act, it will not be applicable in the present case because of the non obstante clause contained in Part III-B of the RBI Act. Mr Divan has submitted that the ambit of Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act is very wide. In fact, arrangements with debenture-holders involving: (i) extension of time of payment; (ii) accepting cash payment of lesser face value; and (iii) exchanging debentures for shares have been accepted since the late 1800's (see Charlesworth's Company Law, 18th Edn., p. 772). On the other hand, Chapter III-B of the RBI Act contains whole set of detailed provisions pertaining to regulation of NBFCs. Mr Chagla added that the object of the 1997 Amendment to the RBI Act which added Section 45-Q indicates that a remedy was to be granted to deposit-holders for approaching the Company Law Board for repayment of deposits held by a NBFC when the same are not repaid in accordance with the terms and conditions of the deposit. However, the jurisdiction of the Company Law Board is not exclusive and the jurisdiction of a civil court or, for that matter, of a company court is not ousted. Reliance was placed upon the law laid down in Dhulabhai v. State of M.P AIR 1969 SC 78

    24. Further, the learned Senior Counsel relied heavily on the principles laid down by this Court in relation to the interpretation of a non obstante clause to argue that Section 45-QA is neither applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case nor is it a bar to a scheme under Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act. Mr Datar relied upon JIK Industries Ltd. v. Amarlal V. Jumani (2012) 3 SCC 255 wherein it was held that:

    “62. Under the Scheme of the modern legislation, non obstante clause has a contextual and limited application.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    Reliance was also placed upon R.S Raghunath v. State of Karnataka (1992) 1 SCC 335, (1992) 19 ATC 507 wherein it was held that:

    “… There should be a clear inconsistency between the two enactments before giving an overriding effect to the non obstante clause. But the non obstante clause need not necessarily and always be co-extensive with the operative part so as to have the effect of cutting down the clear terms of an enactment and if the words of the enactment are clear and are capable of a clear interpretation on a plain and grammatical construction of the words the non obstante clause cannot cut down the construction and restrict the scope of its operation.”

    It was also submitted that the Court must try to find out the extent to which the legislature had intended to give one provision overriding effect over another. Such intention of the legislature is to be gathered from the enacting part of the section. The counsel relied upon A.G Varadarajulu v. State of T.N (1998) 4 SCC 231

    25. It was further argued by Mr Chagla that Part III-B was introduced in the RBI Act by Amendment Act of 1963. The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the said Amendment Act indicates that it was not intended to override the provisions of the Companies Act. Since the legislative intention behind such insertion was to regulate the functioning of NBFCs in general and to prohibit multiple partnership firms from taking deposits from the general public, in particular; it cannot be interpreted in the manner so as to exclude the application of Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act. According to Mr Chagla, Section 45-QA simply states in general terms that every loan shall be repaid in accordance with the terms and conditions of such loan. This provision does not prohibit a depositor from agreeing to accept the full amount of principal without interest or an amount less than the full amount of principal or to accept in kind rather than in cash. In other words, novation of the contract entered into between the company and the depositor is not prohibited.

    26. Further, it was submitted that the provision of Section 45-QA are in pari materia if not identical with Section 58-A of the Companies Act. Schemes under Section 391 of the Companies Act are presented and approved by the Company Court in respect of deposits under Section 58-A of the Companies Act. Premising on the aforesaid submission, Mr Datar argued that if a Scheme of Arrangement is not prohibited under the latter section it cannot be prohibited under the former i.e Section 45-QA of the RBI Act. This submission has also been reiterated and elaborated by Mr Chagla.

    27. It was further submitted that wherever the applicability of Section 391 of the Companies Act was excluded by the legislature, it was done so expressly. To illustrate, the learned Senior Counsel relied upon Section 38 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 which provides that Section 391 of the Companies Act will not be applicable in winding up of a banking company by the High Court. It was further submitted that the legislative intent cannot be interpreted in the manner which will discriminate against the depositors of NBFCs as against the depositors of public limited companies and depositors of banking companies. Section 391 of the Companies Act can be availed of in case a NBFC is going into liquidation but if the interpretation given in the impugned order 2008 SCC OnLine Mad 340, (2008) 5 MLJ 980, (2008) 3 LW 267 is accepted, the same provision would not be available for revival of the same company. This, it was argued, would lead to an anomalous situation. In the light of the aforesaid, it was collectively argued by the learned Senior Counsel that the non obstante clause in Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, 1934 does not prohibit the High Court from sanctioning any Scheme for the deposit-holders of an NBFC. Therefore, the Division Bench of the High Court committed a serious jurisdictional error in setting aside the order of the learned Single Judge.

    28. The second issue framed by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant Company and intervenors is that whether non-disclosure of the Letter/Notice dated 18-1-2005 issued by RBI to the appellant is violative of the provisions of Section 391(2) and/or Section 393 of the Companies Act? Mr Datar has submitted that the said Letter dated 18-1-2005 was widely advertised by RBI in various newspapers, including the Indian Express dated 20-1-2005. And, therefore, the contents of this Letter were in the public domain. It was also argued that the facts that are inconsequential for the approval of the Scheme need not be disclosed. The counsel relied upon Bharti Mobinet Ltd., In re (2004) 111 DLT 554.

    29. The learned counsel further submitted that even otherwise the disclosure under the proviso to Section 391(2) of the Companies Act is to be made only before the Court that sanctions the Scheme and not to the creditors or the shareholders with whom the Scheme is entered into. The counsel relied upon Employees' Union v. Hindustan Lever Ltd. 1995 Supp (1) SCC 499 and HCL Infosystems Ltd., In re (2004) 121 Comp Cas 861 (Del).

    30. Mr Chagla was at pains to emphasise that Section 391(2) of the Companies Act requires a company to disclose to the court all material facts relating to the company “such as the latest financial position of the company, the latest Auditor's Report on the accounts of the company, the pendency of any investigation proceedings in relation to the company under Sections 235 to 251, and the like” (emphasis supplied by the learned Senior Counsel). He argued that the order of RBI dated 18-1-2005 is not akin to the provisions of Sections 235 to 251 of the Companies Act. Thus, it was argued that the Division Bench erroneously held that the appellant Company should have disclosed the letter/order issued by RBI before the creditors.

    Respondents' submissions

    31. Mr Tripathi, learned Senior Counsel, appearing for RBI submits that the Division Bench of the High Court has correctly interpreted the provisions of Chapter III-B of the RBI Act. He emphasised that an amendment was required to strengthen the regulatory mechanism in relation to the NBFCs. The said Chapter III-B has evolved an elaborate Scheme of regulations, enabling RBI even to seek winding up of a NBFC in appropriate circumstances. Section 45-Q of the RBI Act provides that Chapter III-B thereof shall override any other law inconsistent therewith. Section 45-QA gives a statutory right which cannot be waived by anyone. Under this provision, every deposit accepted by NBFC has to be renewed and repaid in accordance with the terms and conditions of such deposit. No subsequent agreement can permit the conditions to be waived of or varied. Section 45-QA(2) enables NBFCs to seek extension in time for repayment before the Company Law Board. There is no other provision in Chapter III-B which can dilute the effect of Section 45-QA. The High Court, according to Mr Tripathi, has rightly held that the Scheme in question of the appellant Company is not in compliance with Chapter III-B and, therefore, cannot be approved.

    32. Countering the submissions of the appellants with regard to the interpretation of non obstante clause contained in Section 45-QA, Mr Tripathi submitted that the provisions contained in Chapter III-B have to prevail over the provisions of the Companies Act. He relies on the judgment of this Court in Tata Motors Ltd. v. Pharmaceutical Products of India Ltd. (2008) 7 SCC 619

    33. Mr V. Prakash, learned Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of Respondent 1.Integrated Finance Depositors Association in SLP (C) No. 12738 of 2008, submitted that the provisions contained in Section 45-QA(1) of the RBI Act are mandatory and cannot be diluted. Elaborating on the factual circumstances, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that the appellant Company led a very aggressive advertising campaign which was aimed to make the general populace believe that it was supported by leading companies such as MRF Ltd., Malayala Manorama, etc. for soliciting deposits from public in Kerala. And then suddenly to the shock of the public, the order dated 18-1-2005 was published in the newspapers, which prohibited the appellant from accepting or renewing any further deposits but the appellant continued to accept deposits even after the said notice. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the Scheme of Arrangement presented before the Company Law Board was not bona fide; it failed to disclose various directions issued by RBI restricting the functioning of the appellant as a NBFC. The High Court has correctly held that the Scheme proposed by the appellant is not bona fide and is in fact contrary to public policy.

    34. We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties. We may here briefly notice the conclusions that have been arrived at by the High Court.

    Findings of the High Court

    35. Whilst examining the scope of Sections 391 to 393 of the Companies Act, the High Court relied on the analysis of the aforesaid sections as rendered by this Court in Miheer H. Mafatlal v. Mafatlal Industries Ltd. (1997) 1 SCC 579 The analysis given in the aforesaid judgment is as under:

    “(1) The sanctioning court has to see to it that all the requisite statutory procedure for supporting such a Scheme has been complied with and that the requisite meetings as contemplated by Section 391(1)(a) have been held.
    (2) That the Scheme put up for sanction of the Court is backed up by the requisite majority vote as required by Section 391 sub-section (2).
    (3) That the meetings concerned of the creditors or members or any class of them had the relevant material to enable the voters to arrive at an informed decision for approving the Scheme in question. That the majority decision of the class of voters concerned is just and fair to the class as a whole so as to legitimately bind even the dissenting members of that class.
    (4) That all necessary material indicated by Section 393(1)(a) is placed before the voters at the meetings concerned as contemplated by Section 391 sub-section (1).
    (5) That all the requisite material contemplated by the proviso of sub-section (2) of Section 391 of the Act is placed before the court by the applicant concerned seeking sanction for such a Scheme and the court gets satisfied about the same.
    (6) That the proposed Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement is not found to be violative of any provision of law and is not contrary to public policy. For ascertaining the real purpose underlying the Scheme with a view to be satisfied on this aspect, the court, if necessary, can pierce the veil of apparent corporate purpose underlying the Scheme and can judiciously x-ray the same.
    (7) That the Company Court has also to satisfy itself that members or class of members or creditors or class of creditors, as the case may be, were acting bona fide and in good faith and were not coercing the minority in order to promote any interest adverse to that of the latter comprising the same class whom they purported to represent.
    (8) That the Scheme as a whole is also found to be just, fair and reasonable from the point of view of prudent men of business taking a commercial decision beneficial to the class represented by them for whom the Scheme is meant.
    (9) Once the aforesaid broad parameters about the requirements of a Scheme for getting sanction of the court are found to have been met, the court will have no further jurisdiction to sit in appeal over the commercial wisdom of the majority of the class of persons who with their open eyes have given their approval to the Scheme even if in the view of the court there would be a better Scheme for the company and its members or creditors for whom the Scheme is framed. The court cannot refuse to sanction such a Scheme on that ground as it would otherwise amount to the court exercising appellate jurisdiction over the Scheme rather than its supervisory jurisdiction.”

    36. The High Court notices the well-settled legal positions that whilst examining the Scheme under Sections 391-393 of the Companies Act neither the Company Court nor the appellate court ought to go into the nitty-gritty of the various suggestions in the Scheme. The High Court recognised that it is difficult for the Company Court or the appellate court to consider the financial wisdom of a particular proposal. This is so as the Courts do not have the necessary expertise to examine the commercial wisdom of the Scheme of Arrangements, especially when it is approved by an overwhelming majority of the bond-holders and depositors. The Court is not expected to substitute its own wisdom for that of the stakeholders, who give consent to a particular Scheme. The High Court also holds that, by or otherwise, a Scheme is ordinarily beyond the jurisdiction of the Company Court and the appellate court except in those rare cases where one can see that the Scheme itself is on the face of it so unreasonable that no man of ordinary prudence can accept it. The High Court concludes that: (Integrated Finance Co. Ltd. case 2008 SCC OnLine Mad 340, (2008) 5 MLJ 980, (2008) 3 LW 267, MLJ p. 987, para 12)

    “12.3 In the facts of the present case, we do not think that we can characterise the Scheme as so outrageously improper as to invite the wrath of the court.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    The High Court rejected the submission of some of the deposit-holders that meetings for approving the Scheme should have been held within the State of Kerala.

    37. Upon examination of the question as to whether the Company should have disclosed the aspects arising out of the RBI Letter/Order dated 18-1-2005 to enable the depositors and the bond-holders to take an informed decision, the High Court has concluded that the Company is guilty of such non-disclosure.

    38. On the interpretation of the provisions of Section 45 of the RBI Act, the Division Bench has concluded that by virtue of the non obstante clause in Section 45-Q of the RBI Act, Chapter III-B of the RBI Act will prevail over Sections 391-393 of the Companies Act. It is held that the provision contained in Section 45-QA which is intended to protect the depositors must have primacy over any other law inconsistent with such provision. It is further held that the Scheme of Arrangement or Compromise even if presented by an NBFC would have to conform to the provisions contained in Chapter III-B of the RBI Act. The Division Bench also concluded that not only is the Scheme contrary to the specific provisions contained in Chapter III-B of the RBI Act; it is also against public policy. With these observations the Division Bench had declined to approve the Scheme and set aside the order passed by the Company Court.

    39. In our opinion, the aforesaid conclusions of the High Court do not require any interference. Even according to the appellant since its incorporation in 1983, the appellant had grown into a gigantic NBFC; it had 20,000 shareholders. Its shares were listed in two Stock Exchanges in India. Till 1995-1996, it was a profit-making company and declared dividends to its shareholders continuously.

    40. RBI issued a series of circulars during 1997-2003 regulating the activities of NBFCs, strict restrictions were placed on the NBFCs for accepting deposits. The companies which did not comply with the aforesaid directions were directed to stop accepting deposits and to repay the same immediately. It is also an accepted case of the Company that RBI, in exercise of its power under Section 45-N, inspected the books of accounts of the appellant Company in 2005. The inspection report disclosed the violations of the RBI Act, 1934, committed by the Company which we have noticed in the earlier part of the judgment. It is also accepted that on 18-1-2005, RBI in exercise of its powers under Section 45-MB(1) of the RBI Act, issued a circular to the appellant Company prohibiting it from “accepting deposits from any person, in any form whether by way of fresh deposits or renewal of the existing deposits or otherwise until further orders”. The appellant Company was also directed not to sell, transfer, create charge of mortgage or deal in any manner with its properties, assets, without prior permission of RBI. It is also accepted that the aforesaid notice was advertised in the Indian Express on 20-1-2005. The notice highlights the purpose of the notice as “Integrated Finance Company Limited, Chennai prohibition for accepting of deposits and alienation of assets”.

    41. The appellant claimed that NBFC started facing problems in running its operations as a direct consequence of the restrictions and the publicity generated by the notice dated 18-1-2005/20-1-2005. Since the company was facing severe problems in running its operations because of the drop in its profitability, it proposed a Scheme of Compromise with its creditors viz. the depositors and bond-holders. This Scheme was approved by the Board of Directors of the appellant Company on 19-5-2005. We have reproduced earlier the salient features of the Scheme, which was presented to the Company Court under Section 391 of the Companies Act in the High Court of Madras.

    Our conclusions

    42. The primary issue that arises before us is as to whether such a Scheme of Arrangements could have been presented in view of the provisions contained in Chapter III-B of the RBI Act? Even if it could be presented, could it be sanctioned without complying with the provisions contained in Section 45-QA of the RBI Act? The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the High Court has in terms concluded that the Scheme cannot be characterised “as so outrageously improper as to invite the wrath of the court”. The High Court also rightly concluded that the Company Court is not expected to substitute its own wisdom for that of the stakeholders. The High Court has also found that all the procedural requirements for sanctioning a Scheme under Sections 391-394 have been complied with. The High Court also accepts that an overwhelming majority of the deposit-holders have approved this Scheme, yet the relief was not granted to the appellant on the grounds that the Scheme does not comply with the provisions contained in Chapter III-B of the RBI Act.

    43. We are unable to accept the submission of the learned counsel that Section 45-QA of the RBI Act is not a bar to a Scheme under Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act. Under Section 391 of the Companies Act, whilst approving the scheme, the Company Court does not act as a rubber stamp. The Companies Act has to be satisfied that the meetings concerned of the creditors have been duly held. It has to be satisfied that in the meetings concerned, the creditors or members of any class have been provided with relevant material to enable them to take an informed decision as to whether the scheme is just and fair. The Court is also required to conclude that the proposed scheme of Compromise or Arrangement is not violative of any provision of law and is not contrary to public policy. Furthermore, the Court has to be satisfied that members or class of members or creditors who may be in majority are acting bona fide and have not coerced the minority into agreement. Above all, the Court has to be satisfied that the scheme is fair and reasonable from the point of view of a prudent man of business taking commercial decisions, which are beneficial to the class represented by them. [See Miheer H. Mafatlal (1997) 1 SCC 579.] It is true that whilst sanctioning the scheme, the Company Court is not required to act as a Super Auditor. No doubt whilst considering the proposal for approval, the Company Judge is not required to examine the scheme in the way of a carping critic, a hair-splitting expert, a meticulous accountant or a fastidious counsel. However at the same time, the Court is not bound to superficially add its seal of approval to the scheme merely because it received the approval of the requisite majority at the meeting held for that purpose. The Court is required to see that all legal requirements have been complied with. At the same time, the Court has to ensure that the scheme of arrangement is not a camouflage for a purpose other than the ostensible reasons. (See Administrator of the Specified Undertaking of the UTI (2005) 10 SCC 682, para 32.) If any of the aforesaid requirements appear to be found wanting in the scheme, the Court can pierce the veil of apparent corporate purpose underlying the scheme and can judiciously x-ray the same. (See Miheer H. Mafatlal (1997) 1 SCC 579.)

    44. In view of the aforesaid, it needs to be considered as to whether a scheme which does not comply with the provisions of Section 45-QA of the RBI Act can be sanctioned. The High Court on a careful consideration of the entire matter has concluded that the Scheme must fail as it does not comply with the provisions contained in Section 45-QA(1) of the RBI Act. To get over this difficulty, the learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that Chapter III-B of the RBI Act is not a complete code. This apart, the RBI Act and the Companies Act must be read in their own sphere since both operate in different fields, altogether. We are unable to agree with the aforesaid submission of the learned Senior Counsel for the parties.

    45. Chapter III-B of the RBI Act was incorporated through the RBI (Amendment) Ordinance, 1997, subsequently replaced by the RBI (Amendment) Act, 1997. The Statement of Objects and Reasons make it abundantly clear that before the amendment, the unincorporated bodies circumvented the statutory restrictions by floating different partnership firms as and when a firm reached the level of 250 depositors. It was also reiterated that several unincorporated bodies were advertising aggressively through various media, soliciting deposits from public by offering high rates of interest and other incentives. The Amendment Act provides several safeguards for NBFCs so as to ensure their viability. This includes compulsory registration of NBFCs with RBI, stipulation of minimum need in the funds requirements, creation of reserved funds and transfer of certain percentage of profits every year to the fund; and prescription of liquidity requirements. The RBI has also been vested with powers to issue guidelines intended to ensure sound and healthy operations and the quality of assets of these companies. The RBI was also empowered to issue directions to Auditors of NBFCs to order special audits in NBFCs, prohibited acceptance of deposits by NBFCs and make applications for winding up of NBFCs. It is specifically noticed that earlier the only recourse available to the depositors was to approach the court of law for redressal of grievances. However by the amendment, powers have been vested with the Company Law Board for directing the defaulter NBFCs to make repayment for the deposit interest with a view to protect the interest of the depositors. The NBFCs have been totally prohibited from accepting deposits for the purpose other than for personal use, if unincorporated. They have been permitted to continue to take deposit after incorporating themselves within the regulatory framework. The unincorporated bodies have also been specifically prohibited for issuing any advertisements in any form. The real intent is set out in Para 6, which is as under:

    “6. There are reports of several finance companies and unincorporated bodies having failed to repay the deposits collected from unsuspecting depositors who have been tempted by the attractive returns and incentives offered. Concern has been expressed in several quarters on the need to take urgent steps to regulate the activities of such companies and unincorporated bodies.”

    46. Keeping in view the aforesaid Objects and Reasons, it becomes evident that Chapter III-B of the RBI Act is a self-contained code. It is not possible for us to accept the submissions of the learned counsel for the appellants that the RBI Act and the Companies Act operate in distinct and different fields. We are unable to accept the submission of the learned counsel for the appellants that the provision contained in the RBI Act being regulatory in nature will not apply to cases of Schemes submitted for approval under the Companies Act. We may also notice here that the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant relied on Haridas Exports (2002) 6 SCC 600 in this context. In the aforesaid case, this Court upon a comprehensive analysis of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969 and the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 concluded that the said two Acts substantially operate in different fields and, therefore, the provisions of Section 9-A of the Customs Tariff Act cannot be implied to repeal the provisions of Section 33(1)(j) of the MRTP Act, 1969. Since the main issue involved in the matter before us is different from Haridas Exports (2002) 6 SCC 600, the said case is of no assistance to the appellant Company.

    47. We are also not able to accept the submission of the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant and the intervenors in support of the appellant that the non obstante clause in Section 45-QA will not have an overriding effect over the provisions contained in the Companies Act in Sections 391-394. We are also not able to accept the additional submission of Mr Chagla that if overriding effect is given to Section 45-QA, the provisions contained in Section 391 would be rendered nugatory so far as NBFCs are concerned. We are not persuaded to accept the submissions of the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant that the non obstante clause contained in Section 45-A ought to be given a limited application. Even applying the ratio of the judgments cited by the learned Senior Counsel, there is no justification for lessening the scope of the applicability of the non obstante clause in Section 45-Q of the RBI Act. It states in categorical terms that provisions of Chapter III-B shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any other law. The overriding effect extends not only to any other law for the time being in force but also to any instrument having effect by virtue of having such law. The reasons for giving such categorical overriding effect are evident from the objects and reasons given in the Amendment Act. The magnitude of the exploitation of the poor sections of the society, leading to utter destruction of innumerable families was the underlying impetus to bring the NBFCs under strict control. Therefore, we have no hesitation in concluding that Chapter III-B of the RBI Act is a complete code in itself. The Companies Act is a prior enactment as the same was enacted in the year 1956, whereas, Chapter III-B was inserted in the RBI Act (55 of 1963) w.e.f 1964. Section 45-QA was inserted by Act 23 of 1997 w.e.f 9-1-1997. Thus, provisions of the RBI Act would prevail over the Companies Act, it being a later enactment. It is a settled proposition of law that a later enactment will override the earlier enactment.

    48. We may usefully make a reference here to the relevant paras of Tata Motors Ltd. (2008) 7 SCC 619, which are as under:

    “21. It was conceded by Mr Sundaram SICA being a special law vis-à-vis the 1956 Act, it shall prevail over the latter. The learned counsel, however, qualifies his submission by contending that SICA only excludes the provisions of the Companies Act when they are inconsistent with each other.
    22. The provisions of a special Act will override the provisions of a general Act. The latter of it (sic Act) will override an earlier Act. The 1956 Act is a general Act. It consolidates and restates the law relating to companies and certain other associations. It is prior in point of time to SICA.
    23. Wherever any inconstancy (sic inconsistency) is seen in the provisions of the two Acts, SICA would prevail. SICA furthermore is a complete code. It contains a non obstante clause in Section 32.
    24. SICA is a special statute. It is a self-contained code. The jurisdiction of the Company Judge in a case where reference had been made to BIFR would be subject to the provisions of SICA.”

    49. In our opinion, Chapter III-B has been given an overriding effect over all other laws including the Companies Act by incorporating Section 45-Q with a clear intention to ensure that in a case of NBFC, a Scheme under Section 391 of the Companies Act cannot be entertained unless it is in conformity with the provisions of Section 45-QA of the RBI Act.

    50. We may briefly notice here the judgments relied on by the learned counsel for the appellant in support of the submission that the non obstante clause in Section 45-Q of the RBI Act will not have an overriding effect over Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act. Reliance was placed on Aswini Kumar Ghose AIR 1952 SC 369; Madhav Rao Jivaji Rao Scindia (1971) 1 SCC 85; A.G Varadarajulu (1998) 4 SCC 231; Icici Bank Ltd. (2006) 10 SCC 452; R.S Raghunath (1992) 1 SCC 335, (1992) 19 ATC 507 and JIK Industries Ltd. (2012) 3 SCC 255 The said cases undoubtedly reiterate the settled law on the manner in which a particular non obstante clause ought to be interpreted. In Aswini Kumar Ghose AIR 1952 SC 369, this Court held that:

    “16. … a non obstante clause [must be construed strictly and] the court must try to find the extent to which the legislature had intended to give one provision overriding effect over another provision.” (A.G Varadarajulu case (1998) 4 SCC 231)

    51. Similar observations were reiterated by this Court in the other cases relied on by the appellant. Since it has been already noticed by us that Parliament clearly intended to give an overriding effect to Chapter III-B of the RBI Act over Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act, the aforesaid observations will not be of any help to the appellants in support of their submission that Section 45-Q and/or Section 45-QA of the RBI Act will not override Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act.

    52. We, therefore, endorse the opinion expressed by the High Court that the Scheme has been introduced only with a view to avoid repayment to the small depositors as it contemplates that instead of repaying of amount in accordance with the terms and conditions of the deposit, such amount shall be considered as convertible debentures with interest @ 6%, which would be converted into equity shares within a period of one year. Such a provision is clearly contrary to the mandatory requirements under Section 45-QA(1) which requires that:

    “45-QA. (1) Every deposit accepted by a non-banking financial company, unless renewed, shall be repaid in accordance with the terms and conditions of such deposit.”

    This ingenious effort by the appellants in fact justifies the insertion of the amendment, which has been obviously incorporated with a view to protect the depositors and to avoid exploitation of these hapless and poor depositors from exploitation by the non-banking financial institutions, such as the appellant. It is for this reason that Chapter III-B clearly provides that the provisions contained therein shall override all other laws, which are inconsistent with the same. This will also be applicable to Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act.

    53. The Companies Act as well as the RBI Act are Central Acts. Chapter III-B, which was inserted by Act 55 of 1963 w.e.f 1-12-1964 being a later enactment clearly has to prevail. We are unable to agree with the submissions of the learned counsel for the appellant that if such an interpretation is given to Section 45-QA, it would render Sections 391-394 nugatory.

    54. Faced with this situation, Mr Shyam Divan learned counsel for the appellant had submitted that in fact there is no inconsistency between Section 45-QA of the RBI Act and Sections 391-394 of the Companies Act. It is submitted that a scheme of arrangement under Sections 391 to 394 is a form of novation of a contract. Under the Contract Act, each individual party is entitled to vary the terms and conditions of the Contract. Therefore, debenture-holders accepting cash payment of lesser face value or exchanging debentures for shares would only be continuance of a practice which has been in vogue since late 1800s. He makes this submission relying on Charlesworth's Company Law, 18th Edn., 771-72, which are as follows:

    “The word ‘arrangement’ has a very wide meaning, and is wider than the word ‘compromise’. An arrangement may involve debenture-holders giving an extension of time for payment accepting a cash payment less than the face value of their debentures, giving up their security in whole or in part, exchanging their debentures for shares in the company, or in a new company, or having the rights attached to their debentures varied in some other respect. Creditors may take cash in part-payment of their claims and the balance in shares or debentures in the company. Preference shareholders may give up their rights to arrears of dividends, agree to accept a reduced rate of dividend in the future, or have their class rights otherwise varied.”

    In our opinion, these observations would be of no avail to the appellants in view of our conclusions recorded earlier that the present arrangement is not bona fide.

    55. We are further of the opinion that there can be no question of novation in the face of the categorical provisions contained in Section 45-Q, which has an overriding effect over all other laws, which would necessarily negate the principle of novation contained in the Contract Act also. Since we have already negated the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant that it was open to each individual depositor to vary the contract i.e novate the contract, it would not be possible to accept the subsequent submission of the learned counsel that since the Scheme has been approved by the requisite majority and sanctioned by the Court, it is binding on the minority as well. In support of this submission, the learned counsel has relied on the observations made by this Court in J.K (Bombay) (P) Ltd. AIR 1970 SC 1041, (1969) 2 SCR 866 and Administrator of the Specified Undertaking of the UTI (2005) 10 SCC 682. On the basis of the aforesaid, it is submitted that if the parties could have novated the terms and conditions individually, there is no bar on such novation through a scheme. The observations relied upon are as follows: [J.K (Bombay) (P) Ltd. case AIR 1970 SC 1041, (1969) 2 SCR 866, AIR p. 1057, para 35]

    “35. … The principle is that a Scheme sanctioned by the court does not operate as a mere agreement between the parties: it becomes binding on the company, the creditors and the shareholders and has statutory force, and therefore, the joint-debtor could not invoke the principle of accord and satisfaction. By virtue of the provisions of Section 391 of the Act, a Scheme is statutorily binding even on creditors and shareholders who dissented from or opposed to its being sanctioned. It has statutory force in that sense and therefore cannot be altered except with the sanction of the Court even if the shareholders and the creditors acquiesce in such alteration (Premila Devi v. Peoples Bank of Northern India Ltd. (1938) 4 All ER 337, (1939) 49 LW 444). The effect of the Scheme is ‘to supply by recourse to the procedure thereby prescribed the absence of that individual agreement by every member of the class to be bound by the Scheme which would otherwise be necessary to give it validity’. (Palmer's Company Law, 20th Edn., p. 664) Sub-section (2) of Section 391 of the Act allows the decision of the majority prescribed therein to bind the minority of creditors and shareholders and it is for that reason that a Scheme is said to have statutory operation and cannot be varied by the shareholders or the creditors unless such variation is sanctioned by the court.”

    56. We are unable to accept the aforesaid submission. The aforesaid observations reiterate the settled position of law that a scheme duly sanctioned after fulfilling all the legal formalities would be binding on all the shareholders. In the present case, the Scheme is in the teeth of Section 45-Q and it has rightly not been approved by the High Court. This apart, the Scheme has been rightly held to be lacking bona fides, as well as being contrary to public policy. It has been proposed with the oblique purpose of avoiding the mandate of Section 45-QA(1) of the RBI Act.

    57. We are also not inclined to accept the submission of the appellant that Section 45-QA of the RBI Act is in pari materia if not identical with Section 58-A of the Companies Act. It was further argued that if a scheme of arrangement is not prohibited under the latter section; it cannot be prohibited under the former i.e Section 45-QA of the RBI Act. The issue concerning Section 45-QA being in pari materia with Section 58-A of the Companies Act does not arise since, in our considered opinion, the provisions of the RBI Act will override the provisions of the Companies Act. Thus, this submission is also rejected.

    58. In view of the aforesaid, we reject the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant that the Scheme of Arrangement could be approved even though there is a non-compliance with the provisions of Chapter III-B of the RBI Act in particular Section 45-QA(1). We may notice here that the appellants had an opportunity to approach the Company Court under Section 45-QA(1) to seek further time for making payment. It appears that no such application was made and, therefore, there is a complete infringement of Section 45-QA(1). This would lead to an inevitable conclusion that the Scheme of Arrangements could not be approved.

    The effect of non-disclosure of the Notice dated 18-1-2005

    59. The aforesaid notice has been sent to the Company under Section 45-MB(1). Such notice is only sent if any NBFC violates the provisions of any section or fails to comply with any direction or order given by RBI under any of the provisions of Chapter III-B. Under these provisions, RBI has the power to prohibit the NBFC from accepting any deposit. Under Section 45-MB(2), in order to protect the interest of the depositors, RBI is also empowered to direct the non-banking financial company not to sell, transfer, create charge or mortgage or deal in any manner with its property and assets without prior permission of the bank. It is an accepted fact that the orders directing the Company not to accept deposits have been duly published in the Indian Express on 20-1-2005. The learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that it is an accepted fact that on inspection of the books of accounts of the appellant Company under Section 45-N of the RBI Act, 1934, numerous violations were disclosed. The details of the violations have been extracted in the earlier part of this judgment. Whilst the investigation was being conducted into all the irregularities that have been committed by the company, the Scheme of Arrangement was presented to the Company Court on or about 19-5-2005. It is an accepted fact that the Notice dated 18-1-2005 was not disclosed to the shareholders, who were present in the meetings which had been convened on the directions of the Company Court. According to the learned counsel for the appellants, such a non-disclosure was not required under the provisions of the proviso to Section 391(2) of the Companies Act. In any event, according to the learned counsel, the Notice dated 18-1-2005 had been widely advertised by RBI in various newspapers. Therefore, the whole information was in public domain. Consequently, the requirements of proviso to Section 391(2) would be deemed to be complied with. Furthermore, according to Mr Datar, proviso to Section 391(2) only requires disclosure to the Court sanctioning the Scheme and not to the creditors or the shareholders with whom the Scheme is made. The disclosure requirement to the shareholders or the creditors is specified under Section 393(1) and is much narrower. The learned Senior Counsel has placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in Employees' Union v. Hindustan Lever Ltd. 1995 Supp (1) SCC 499 in support of this submission. This case is, however, distinguishable from the present case and circumstances. It was held therein that:

    “58. In the facts of this case, considering the overwhelming manner in which the shareholders, the creditors, the debenture-holders, the financial institutions, who had 41% shares in Tomco, have supported the Scheme and have not complained about any lack of notice or lack of understanding of what the Scheme was about, we are of the view, it will not be right to hold that the explanatory statement was not proper or was lacking in material particulars.”

    The preceding excerpt makes it clear that the Scheme therein was not objected to by any of the interested persons. Thus, the reliance on the said case is misconceived.

    60. In our opinion, the High Court has correctly concluded that even if no investigation was pending under Sections 235-251 of the Companies Act, it was incumbent on the Company to disclose the violations pointed out by RBI on inspection of its books under Section 45-N, which led to the issuance of the Notice dated 18-1-2005. This, in our opinion, would clearly reflect on the lack of bona fides of the Company in proposing Scheme of Arrangement. In our considered opinion, non-disclosure of the action taken and initiated by RBI as apparent from the Letter dated 18-1-2005, amounted to non-disclosure of material facts which are required to be disclosed under Section 391(1) read with Section 393(1) of the Companies Act. The Company Court whilst examining the fairness and the bona fide of a Scheme of Arrangement does not act as a rubber stamp. It cannot shut its eyes to blatant non-disclosure of material information, which could have a major influence/impact on the decision as to whether the Scheme has to be approved or not. In our opinion, the High Court has not committed any error of jurisdiction in rejecting the submission of the appellant that the non-disclosure of the Letter dated 18-1-2005 was not material.

    61. For the aforesaid reasons, we find no justification to interfere with the judgment and order 2008 SCC OnLine Mad 340, (2008) 5 MLJ 980, (2008) 3 LW 267 passed by the High Court. The appeals are accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Integrated Finance Company Limited v. Reserve Bank Of India And Others
    (Jul 16, 2013)