Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8(1) of the Abkari Act
  • Section 8(1) read with Section 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act
  • Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act
  • Section 428 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8(1) of the Abkari Act
  • Section 8(1) read with Section 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act
  • Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act
  • Section 428 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 12-3-2005 at approximately 11:15 a.m., the police observed an autorickshaw (Reg. No. KL-03-F-3146) occupied by three individuals—Accused 1 Narayanan and the two present appellants (Accused 2 and 3). Upon noticing the police, all three fled, abandoning the vehicle. A search revealed two 20-litre cans containing a total of 40 litres of arrack, leading to their prosecution under Section 8(1) read with Section 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act.

The Additional District and Sessions Judge (Ad hoc), Fast Track Court-I, Pathanamthitta, convicted the accused on 22-6-2010 in Sessions Case No. 682 of 2006, sentencing each to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹1,00,000, with a one-year default sentence.

On appeal, the Kerala High Court maintained the conviction but reduced the substantive sentence to 18 months’ rigorous imprisonment and the default sentence to six months, while granting set-off under Section 428 CrPC (Judgment dated 4-8-2011).

Accused 1 accepted the High Court decision. The present further appeal before the Supreme Court is by Accused 2 and 3; leave was granted and the matter decided in the judgment summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether any grounds existed to interfere with the concurrent findings of the trial court and High Court holding the appellants guilty under Section 8(1) of the Kerala Abkari Act.
  2. Whether, assuming the conviction stood, the sentence of 18 months’ rigorous imprisonment (with six months’ default imprisonment) imposed by the High Court should be further reduced in light of mitigating circumstances.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the trial and appellate records and agreed that both lower courts had “meticulously” evaluated the evidence, correctly concluding that the appellants possessed 40 litres of arrack in violation of Section 8(1). Consequently, the conviction required no interference.

Turning to sentence, the Court reproduced and endorsed the High Court’s observations that:

  • At the time of the crime the accused were aged 42, 48 and 57; six years had elapsed since the incident.
  • The prosecution had not alleged that the accused were habitual offenders.
  • An 18-month term would ordinarily suffice to “meet the ends of justice.”

Nonetheless, the Supreme Court considered additional mitigating factors:

  • The quantity of arrack and mode of transport indicated the accused were “small-time operators,” merely the “weakest link” in a larger illicit trade.
  • Section 8(2) prescribes a minimum fine of ₹1,00,000 with no upper limit, placing poor offenders at a disadvantage because inability to pay converts into lengthy default imprisonment.

In light of these considerations, the Court exercised discretion to further reduce the custodial sentence and the default period. It also noted parity demanded extending the same relief to Accused 1 Narayanan, who had not appealed to the Supreme Court, presumably due to poverty.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed to a limited extent. Conviction under Section 8(1) read with Section 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act is affirmed, but the sentence is modified as follows: substantive imprisonment reduced from 18 months to one year; default imprisonment for non-payment of the ₹1,00,000 fine reduced from six months to 15 days. The same relief is extended to Accused 1 Narayanan.

Implications: The decision directly benefits all three accused by shortening their incarceration. The Court’s remarks highlight concerns over the high statutory minimum fine under Section 8(2) and its disparate impact on indigent offenders, but no binding precedent altering the statutory scheme was set.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sasikumar And Another v. State Of Kerala .

    Aftab Alam, J.— Leave granted. The two appellants (who are Accused 2 and 3), along with one Narayanan (Accused 1) have been convicted under Section 8(1) read with Section 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act. They were sentenced by the trial court to rigorous imprisonment for three years and a fine of Rs 1,00,000 with the default sentence of one year's rigorous imprisonment. In appeal the High Court, though maintaining the conviction, reduced the sentence to rigorous imprisonment for 18 months and the default sentence for failure to pay the fine, to rigorous imprisonment for a period of six months. The High Court also directed that the accused would be entitled to get the benefit of set-off under Section 428 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

    2. According to the prosecution case, on 12-3-2005 at about 11.15 a.m the accused were seen coming in an autorickshaw bearing Registration No. KL 03 F 3146. The autorickshaw belonged to and it was being driven by Appellant 2. On seeing the police party, all the three occupants ran away leaving the autorickshaw at the spot. On its inspection, the police found two (2) 20 litre cans containing 40 litres of arrack lying inside the autorickshaw and, thus, according to the police, the accused had committed the offence under Section 8(1) of the Abkari Act. The three accused were tried by the Court of the Additional District and Sessions Judge (Ad hoc), Fast Track Court I, Pathanamthitta who, by his judgment and order dated 22-6-2010 in Sessions Case No. 682 of 2006 convicted and sentenced them, as noted above.

    3. The three accused came to the High Court in two separate appeals, being Criminal Appeal No. 1338 of 2010 preferred by the two appellants before this Court and Criminal Appeal No. 2198 of 2010 submitted to the High Court as jail appeal on behalf of Accused 1 Narayanan. The High Court disposed of both the appeals by judgment and order dated 4-8-2011 Criminal Appeal No. 1338 of 2010. It maintained their conviction but modified and reduced their sentence, as noted above. Accused 1 Narayanan apparently accepted the judgment of the High Court and has not preferred any special leave petition against the High Court judgment. The other two accused i.e the appellants are before this Court in the present appeal.

    4. We have heard Mr R. Basant, learned counsel for the appellants and we have gone through the materials on record. We find that both the trial court and the High Court have meticulously considered the evidences led by the prosecution and have rightly arrived at the conclusion in regard to the appellants' guilt. Insofar as the conviction of the appellants under Section 8(1) of the Abkari Act is concerned, there is no scope for any interference and we uphold the conviction of the appellants as recorded by the trial court and affirmed by the High Court. Mr Basant, however, urged before us to take a lenient view in regard to the sentence awarded to the appellants.

    5. On the question of sentence, the High Court in para 19 of its judgment has made the following observations:

    “It is relevant to note that at the time of registration of the crime, the first accused was at the age of 57 and Accused 2 and 3 were at the age of 42 and 48 respectively. Now six years are over. Therefore, the first accused will be at the age of 63, the second accused at the age of 48 and the third accused at the age of 54. The prosecution has no case that the accused are habitual offenders. Having regard to the above facts and the mitigating circumstances, I am of the view that the substantial sentence imposed against the accused requires reconsideration. Thus, according to me, 18 months' rigorous imprisonment will be sufficient to meet the ends of justice. While confirming the sentence of fine, the default sentence can be reduced to six months. In the result, in modification of the sentence imposed by the trial court, the accused are sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 18 months each and to pay a fine of Rs 1 lakh each and in default, each of them is directed to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of six months instead of one year's rigorous imprisonment ordered by the trial court. The appellants are entitled to get the benefit of set-off under Section 428 CrPC.”

    We agree with the view taken by the High Court.

    6. We would like to further observe that from the facts of the case it is evident that the appellants and the other accused in this case are not the real men behind the nefarious trade of illicit intoxicants in the State. From the quantity seized from the possession of the accused and the manner in which it was being carried, it is evident that the three accused were only small-time operators in the illicit trade of arrack and though visible, they constitute the weakest link in the chain of illicit trade in arrack. In these circumstances, we think a further reduction of the sentence would be quite in order. We, accordingly, reduce the sentence of imprisonment from 18 months, as awarded by the High Court, to one year and further reduce the sentence in default of payment of fine from six months to fifteen days.

    7. Accused 1 Narayanan is not before this Court presumably on account of poverty, as his appeal to the High Court was also a jail appeal. We find there is no distinction between the case of the appellants and the case of Accused 1 and, accordingly, extend the relief granted to the two appellants to Accused 1 Narayanan as well.

    8. Before parting with the record of the case, we would like to point out that Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act does not fix any upper limit for the fine but lays down that the fine shall not be less than Rs 1,00,000. Since the minimum amount of fine prescribed by the law is kept so high, the courts naturally give the default sentence of imprisonment for a substantially longer period. As noted above, the trial court has given the default sentence of one year which was reduced by the High Court to six months. We may note that in cases where poor people like the appellants who may only be the carriers of the arrack or who may be trying to eke out a living from the illegal trade are caught committing the offence, they are hardly in a position to pay the fine of Rs 1,00,000 and for them the default sentence becomes an additional period of incarceration. In a way, fixing the minimum fine at such a high amount, regardless of the countless possible variables in the commission of the offence under Section 8(1), leads to discrimination in favour of those convicts who have sufficient means to pay the fine and, thus, avoid any default imprisonment and the small fries for whom the default sentence would invariably mean an additional sentence of imprisonment. To our mind, it is desirable to leave the Court free in exercise of judicial discretion in the matter of imposition of fine.

    9. In the light of the discussion made above, the appeal is allowed to the limited extent, as directed above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sasikumar And Another v. State Of Kerala .
    (Dec 4, 2012)