Order
1. Delay condoned. Leave granted. Feeling dissatisfied with the nominal enhancement granted by the High Court MFA No. 11865 of 2005 in the amount of compensation awarded by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Maddur (Karnataka) in MVC No. 106 of 2003, the appellant has filed this appeal.
2. The appellant, who has suffered 90% permanent disability in his right leg which is paralysed and 50% to 60% disability of mouth and other parts of the body due to an accident which occurred on 28-2-2003, filed a petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) for award of compensation of Rs 21,50,000 with interest.
3. The case of the appellant is that on 28-2-2003 at about 11.30 a.m, he along with his wife, Savitha was travelling on a TVS moped bearing Registration No. KA 01 H 4236 on the left side of the road. He was waiting near T. Ballekere cross to take turn to go to Koppa. At that time, a lorry bearing Registration No. CNT 7206 driven by its driver in a rash and negligent manner with high speed came to the extreme left side of the road and dashed into the vehicle of the appellant and caused the accident. Due to the accident, the appellant fell down and sustained grievous injuries. He was shifted to the hospital and in course was given treatment at different hospitals.
4. The appellant contended that he was aged about 32 years on the date of the accident and was earning more than Rs 8000 per month. After the accident, he has suffered permanent disability and, therefore, he is not in a position to work as before. During the course of treatment in different hospitals, he had incurred medical expenses to the tune of Rs 4,50,000 so far. After the accident, he was immediately taken to Government Hospital, Koppa. Thereafter he was shifted to Mandya General Hospital and then he was taken to J.S.S Hospital, Mysore and from there he was further shifted to Mallige Hospital, Bangalore. Lastly, he was taken to St. John Medical College and Hospital, Bangalore where he was treated as indoor patient and underwent an operation of the right leg, mandible, right hip, left leg, stomach and jaw (face). In the said accident, the appellant lost all his teeth except 7 teeth in the upper jaw and 5 teeth in the lower jaw. After the operation he has become permanently disabled and will have to spend a huge amount towards medical expenses. The doctor has assessed the disability at 90% in his right leg which has permanently paralysed; 50% to 60% disability of his mouth and 20% to 25% disability of his whole body. There was amputation below the knee of the right leg.
5. The owner of the lorry did not contest the case before the Tribunal. The second respondent, New India Assurance Company Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “the Assurance Company”) disputed the claim and denied the allegations made by the appellant. However, it is admitted that the lorry was insured with the second respondent, the Assurance Company. The Assurance Company took a plea that the accident occurred due to the negligent driving of TVS moped by the appellant himself, who without giving any signal and without noticing the vehicle coming from the right side, dashed into the lorry and caused the accident. The Assurance Company also denied the quantum of amount spent in the treatment of the appellant.
6. On hearing the parties the Tribunal framed the following issues:
“1. Whether the petitioner proves that the accident was solely due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending vehicle as alleged?
2. Whether the petitioner proves that he sustained injuries due to the impact of the vehicle as alleged?
3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to get compensation? If so, to what amount and from whom?
4. To what order or relief the petitioner is entitled?”
7. In order to prove his case, the appellant examined eight witnesses including PW 2, N.K Narayanashetty, Sales Manager in Adiswara Marketing Company where the appellant was working since two-and-a-half years; PW 3, Dr N. Sundar, Parlour Surgeon of St. John Medical College and Hospital; PW 7, Dr Natashekara M., Assistant Professor of Kempegowda Dental College and Hospital; PW 6, Y.M Thimmaiah, Postman in Haralekere Post Office and PW 8, N.V Santosh, Manager of Adiswara Marketing Company. He also produced 27 exhibits including medical bills, discharge summary of the hospital, salary certificate/vouchers, vouchers of commission, etc.
8. The Tribunal on hearing both the parties and on appreciation of the evidence on record answered the first issue in the affirmative in favour of the appellant and held that the appellant sustained injuries due to the impact of the vehicle as alleged. The second issue relating to the entitlement of compensation was also decided in the affirmative in favour of the appellant but while deciding Issues 3 and 4, the Tribunal awarded total compensation of Rs 4,17,000 with interest @ 6% per annum against the following heads:
1.
Towards pain and sufferings
Rs
50,000
2.
Towards loss of future earnings
Rs
1,55,000
3.
Towards medical expenses and other incidental charges
Rs
2,00,000
4.
Towards loss of income during treatment
Rs
12,000
Total
Rs
4,17,000
9. The High Court by the impugned order dated 28-9-2010 MFA No. 11865 of 2005 nominally enhanced the amount against different heads along with 6% interest as shown hereunder:
1.
Towards pain and sufferings
Rs
1,00,000
2.
Towards medical expenses
Rs
1,50,000
3.
Towards conveyance, nourishing food and attendant charges
Rs
40,000
4.
Towards loss of income during the laid-up period
Rs
18,000
5.
Towards loss of amenities
Rs
1,00,000
6.
Towards loss of future income
Rs
2,88,000
7.
Towards future medical expenses
Rs
30,000
Total
Rs
7,26,000
10. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant contended that the High Court has failed to appreciate the income of the appellant by calculating it to Rs 3000 though there was evidence on record to show that the earning of the appellant was much more than Rs 8000 per month. The High Court has failed to consider the permanent disability and loss of future income of the appellant who was working hard to earn the income of more than Rs 8000 per month.
11. It was further contended that taking into consideration the permanent disability of more than 90% of the leg and 60% disability of mouth, the High Court ought to have assessed permanent disability accordingly. Apart from this, the Tribunal and the High Court have also failed to grant appropriate amount towards medical expenses and other incidental charges apart from Rs 30,000 towards future medical expenses as granted.
12. In spite of the service of notice, nobody has appeared on behalf of the respondents to dispute the claim. We have considered the arguments as advanced on behalf of the appellant and perused the record. The questions which arise for consideration in this case are:
(i) What was the earning of the appellant prior to the accident and the permanent disability incurred during the accident to decide the quantum of loss of future earning and loss of income during the treatment/laid-up period? and
(ii) What amount the appellant is entitled towards medical expenses incurred, other incidental charges and future medical expenses?
13. The Tribunal has noticed and appreciated different evidence on record relating to earning and disability to decide the loss of future earning, the relevant portion of which reads as follows:
“(ii) Towards loss of future earning capacity: The petitioner contended that prior to the accident he was hale and healthy aged about 32 years on the date of accident. He was working as mail courier in Kowdle Post Office (Ddsmc) and getting Rs 2494 p.m since 1994. Apart from that work he was working in Adiswara Marketing Company as Deputy Sales Officer and getting commission of Rs 1500 to Rs 3000 p.m along with salary of Rs 2000 p.m He got 4th medal in the State. Apart from that he was working as an agent in PGF Ltd., Mandya getting Rs 2000 to Rs 3000 p.m From all he was earning Rs 8000 p.m His wife, mother and children were depending upon his income. So there is loss of future earning capacity. In this connection he has been examined as PW 1 and deposed about the services given by him.
PW 2, one N.K Narayanashetty, who is Sales Manager in Adiswara Marketing Company deposed that the petitioner is working in their company since 2½ years and getting Rs 2000 p.m apart from the commission of Rs 1500 to Rs 3000 p.m Now he is not working there. PW 5 Chikkathimmaiah who is Inspector in PGF Ltd., Mandya deposed that the petitioner was working as Assistant Agent and getting Rs 2000 p.m He has produced identity card at Ext. P-22. Commission vouchers were also produced at Ext. P-14. PW 6 Thimmaiah, who is Postman in Haralekere Post Office deposed that the petitioner was working as mail courier since 10 years and getting income.
PW 8 Manager of Adiswara Marketing Company deposed that the petitioner was working in their company and getting Rs 2000 p.m and also getting commission of Rs 4000 to Rs 5000 p.m He has issued certificates as per Ext. P-7. Now he is not working in the company, Ext. P-15 are his salary vouchers. Some commission vouchers of Adiswara Marketing Company Ltd. were produced. Ext. P-13 is the Postal Department certificate stating that he was working as mail courier, Ext. P-11 is the certificate of the Postal Department stating that from March 2003 to August 2003 they have not paid the salary. Ext. P-12 is the salary certificate of PGF Ltd. stating that he was paid with Rs 2000 monthly income. Ext. P-13 shows that he was working as mail courier since 1994. There are no specific details about his income. He was getting average commission.
Looking to the nature of the works stated by the petitioner it is not possible to do all those works everyday, he might have done work here and there. He has not stated from which time to which time he was working his particular job and whether they are continuous. Hence, considering all these aspects his income is considered at Rs 2000 p.m He is suffering from permanent physical disability of 90% in his right leg and 50% to 60% in his mouth, his face has become ugly and he cannot open his mouth, he is suffering from fracture of mandible and maxilla. He is inserted with plates and screws, his right leg is fractured, he cannot chew and he has become weak. The doctor has stated that he cannot work.
PW 3, the doctor who deposed about the disability in right leg at 90%, had not deposed what will be the disability comparing to the whole body. PW 7, dentist deposed that he was suffering from permanent physical disability of 50% to 60% in his face and comparing to the whole body it comes to 20% to 25%. Considering all these injuries his working capacity is reduced. Hence, it is found just and proper to consider disability remained with the petitioner at 40%. He stated that he was aged about 32 to 33 years at the time of accident. He has not produced any age proof documents. Medical certificate shows his age as 32 years. If that is so, the proper multiplier would be 16. If the income is considered at Rs 2000 p.m it comes to Rs 24,000 p.a, 40% of the same comes to Rs 9600. If the same is multiplied by 16 it comes to Rs 1,53,600. It is found proper to award Rs 1,55,000 under this head.”
(emphasis supplied)
14. From the evidence as recorded, it is evident that prior to the accident the appellant used to earn the following amount:
1.
Towards salary from Adiswara Marketing Company (as deposed by PW 8, Manager, Adiswara Marketing Company, cited at Ext. P-15)
Rs
2000 p.m
2.
Commission from Adiswara Marketing Company (Rs 4000 to Rs 5000) (as deposed by PW 8, Manager, Adiswara Marketing Company Ltd.)
Rs
4500 p.m (average)
3.
Towards salary as Assistant Agent from PGF Ltd., Mandya (as deposed by PW 5, Chikkathimmaiah; Inspector, PGF Ltd., Mandya)
Rs
2000 p.m
4.
As mail courier of Kowdle Post Office (as deposed by the appellant and corroborated by PW 6, Thimmaiah, Postman)
Rs
2495 p.m
Total
Rs
10,995
Therefore, it can safely be stated that the appellant was earning minimum Rs 8500 per month prior to the accident.
15. PW 3, the doctor deposed that the right leg is 90% disabled and is permanently paralysed. The leg is amputated. Apart from this, his face has been deformed and is disabled to the extent of 50% to 60%, due to which he is not in a position to open his mouth fully. Therefore, it can safely be stated that the appellant is 90% permanently disabled to earn any income. The Tribunal and the High Court failed to appreciate the facts and fixed the disability at a lower level of 40% or 50%.
16. Admittedly, the appellant was about 32 years of age at the time of the accident, therefore, the Tribunal was right in applying the multiplier of 16 to determine the compensation. Once the income is considered at Rs 8500 per month it comes to Rs 1,02,000 per annum, 90% of the same comes to Rs 91,800. If the same is multiplied by 16 it comes to Rs 91,800 × 16 = Rs 14,68,800. Therefore, it is proper to award Rs 14,68,800 towards “loss of future earning”.
17. So far as loss of income during the treatment is concerned, the Tribunal has noticed the nature of injuries and treatment taken by the appellant to come to the conclusion that the appellant might not have worked at least for six months. Even if such minimum period for treatment is accepted as six months, the appellant is entitled for a just and proper award of Rs 51,000 under the head of “loss of income during the treatment”.
18. So far as medical expenses and other incidental charges are concerned, the Tribunal appreciated the different evidence and observed as follows:
“(iii) Towards medical expenses and other incidental charges: The petitioner contended that he has taken treatment in several hospitals. Initially he was taken to Mandya General Hospital. Later in private car he was taken to J.S.S Hospital, Mysore. On the same day he was taken to Mahaveer Jain Hospital, Bangalore. He was operated on his right leg and discharged for higher treatment. He was admitted in Boring Hospital, Bangalore wherein he was (sic had) paid Rs 5000. From that hospital also he was discharged. Later he was admitted in St. John Hospital on 2-3-2003. He was operated on his hand, right leg, left leg and stomach. He was an inpatient for 2 months. Later he took treatment in Kempegowda Dental Hospital for mandible and he was indoor patient for 1 week. All his teeth were removed. He lost all teeth and left leg. He has become completely disabled.
PW 7, Doctor Natarajshekar of Kempegowda Hospital deposed that he treated his dental problems and stated that from 9-7-2003 to 15-7-2003 he was indoor patient. All teeth were removed, and he decided to insert the entire set. On 10-7-2003 he was operated and again on 4-9-2003 he was operated for the second time. In this connection he has produced Ext. P-5, wound certificate issued by St. John Medical College and Hospital, Bangalore, Exts. P-6 and P-7 are medical bills and transporting charges. He has produced medical bills worth Rs 1,85,628 rounded off to Rs 1,86,000 and transportation charges worth Rs 27,230. Exts. P-9 to 16 case-sheet, patient record, discharge summary, Ext. P-17 is the case-sheet of St. John Medical College and Hospital, Bangalore for having taken treatment from 2-3-2003 to 28-4-2003 and also taken treatment from 29-3-2003 to 20-4-2003. Others are x-rays. Ext. P-25 is KIMS Hospital records. He further produced Ext. P-26, cash bills worth Rs 2590. On going through the records, Ext. P-6 the petitioner has taken into consideration double of hospital bills, which ought to have been reduced, which comes to Rs 1,85,000 and not Rs 4,83,000 as calculated. The bills are repeated as Items 8, 18, 19, 34, 36, 60. The only final bill worth Rs 73,000 is shown but he has considered the interval bills also including the final bills and it comes to Rs 1,85,628. On going through all the medical bills some of them are not supported with prescriptions and not properly explained by the petitioner.
Having regard to all the circumstances and treatment taken by him in different hospitals he might have spent for medical expenses. So it is better to consider medical expenses at Rs 1,50,000. On perusal of Ext. P-7, transportation charges receipts have been produced, but the person who provided the vehicle is not mentioned. However, he might have spent something for transportation. It is proper to consider Rs 10,000 for transportation. He was in hospital and had taken treatment, he might have spent attendant expenses and been on special diet, it is found just and proper to award Rs 10,000 for the same. PW 7, the doctor stated that he has to undergo in future operation of mandible by spending Rs 1,50,000 for insertion of implants since all the sets were removed. X-ray shows fracture of cants of left side. There is permanent disability in the mouth. Considering all these aspects it is found that he requires future medical expenses of Rs 30,000. Hence, the petitioner is entitled for compensation under this head at Rs 2,00,000.”
(emphasis supplied)
19. From the evidence on record the following amounts towards different medical bills are undisputed:
(1)
The amounts paid during the treatment shown as interval bills and final bills
Rs
1,86,000
(2)
Cash bill (Ext. P-26)
Rs
2590
In this background, the High Court and the Tribunal ought to have accepted the amount of Rs 1,86,000 towards medical bills, apart from transportation charges.
20. If the aforesaid amount is taken into consideration towards the abovesaid heads, then as per the High Court's calculation the break-up of the amounts is as follows:
1.
Towards pain and sufferings (as awarded by the High Court)
Rs
1,00,000
2.
Towards medical expenses (as determined above)
Rs
1,86,000
3.
Towards conveyance, nourishing food and attendant charges (as awarded by the High Court)
Rs
40,000
4.
Towards loss of income during the laid-up period (as determined above)
Rs
51,000
5.
Towards loss of amenities (as awarded by the High Court)
Rs
1,00,000
6.
Towards loss of future income (as determined above)
Rs
14,68,800
7.
Towards future medical expenses (as awarded by the High Court)
Rs
30,000
Total
Rs
19,75,800
21. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed and the impugned judgment and award passed by the Tribunal in MVC No. 106 of 2003 dated 9-9-2005 and the High Court in MFA No. 11865 of 2005 dated 28-9-2010 MFA No. 11865 of 2005 stands modified, awarding compensation of Rs 19,75,800 with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of the petition till realisation. The second respondent New India Assurance Company Ltd. is directed to pay immediately to the appellant total amount of Rs 19,75,800 with 6% interest, after deducting the amount already paid by them.