AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • the provisions of Article 14 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • the provisions of Article 14 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1 (Union of India) issued a Request for Proposal (RFP) dated 17-6-2009 for supply of 20 Fast Patrol Vessels to the Indian Coast Guard. The RFP mandated a two-part bid: (i) technical proposal and (ii) commercial (financial) proposal, with the express stipulation that the price was to be “firm and fixed” for the entire contract period and not subject to escalation.

Petitioner 1, M/s Larsen & Toubro Ltd. (L&T), submitted its bid on 19-10-2009, explicitly claiming Exchange Rate Variation (ERV) in its commercial offer. Four other bidders, including Respondent 4 (Cochin Shipyard Ltd.), also participated. All five cleared the technical evaluation. When the commercial bids were opened on 11-1-2010, L&T’s price was the lowest (L-1) but was declared “non-responsive” because it violated the firm and fixed price clause by claiming ERV.

The Contract Negotiation Committee (constituted under Defence Procurement Procedure-2008) confirmed the non-responsiveness of L&T’s bid and treated Cochin Shipyard (originally L-2) as L-1, recommending award of the contract to it. L&T then attempted to withdraw the ERV element and match a firm price, but the Committee refused to consider the post-opening alteration.

L&T and its General Manager (Petitioner 2) filed Writ Petition (Civil) No. 3231/2010 before the Delhi High Court seeking directions to treat their bid as valid and to invite them for negotiations. The High Court dismissed the writ petition on 8-9-2010, upholding the rejection of L&T’s bid and imposing costs. The present Special Leave Petition challenged that High Court judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a bidder can amend its bid by withdrawing a condition that rendered the bid non-responsive after the bids have been opened.
  2. Whether, upon such withdrawal, a previously non-responsive bid must be treated as responsive and considered for award.
  3. Whether Respondent 4’s bid, which converted a foreign currency component into Indian rupees at the exchange rate prevailing on the bid-opening date, violated the “firm and fixed price” requirement.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners’ Arguments

  • The same foreign exchange variation element for which L&T’s bid was rejected was also present in Cochin Shipyard’s bid; applying different standards was arbitrary and violative of Article 14.
  • Part IV of the RFP mandated use of the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) method for evaluation; this was not followed, disadvantaging the petitioners.
  • Government contracts must be awarded fairly and without arbitrariness, relying on the principle in Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (1979) 3 SCC 489.
  • After withdrawing the ERV clause and offering a fixed price, their bid satisfied all tender conditions and should have been considered.

Respondent 4’s Arguments (Cochin Shipyard Ltd.)

  • Its quoted price was firm and fixed in Indian rupees as converted on the bid-opening date; no escalation was contemplated thereafter.
  • The petitioners’ situation was not comparable because L&T’s bid permitted post-opening price fluctuation, fundamentally breaching the tender condition.

Union of India’s Arguments

  • Once commercial bids were opened, bidders could not alter their offers; L&T’s subsequent withdrawal of ERV was impermissible.
  • Cochin Shipyard’s pricing complied with the “firm and fixed” clause; hence, treating it as L-1 was proper.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (1979) 3 SCC 489 Government authorities must adhere strictly to the standards laid down in tender documents; arbitrary deviation offends Article 14. The Court held that the precedent actually supported Respondent 4, underscoring that tender conditions (firm and fixed price) cannot be altered post-opening and must be uniformly enforced.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court agreed with the High Court’s conclusion that the “firm and fixed” pricing requirement was a critical tender condition. By submitting a bid contingent on ERV, L&T consciously deviated from that essential term, rendering its bid non-responsive from the outset. The later withdrawal of ERV could not cure the original defect because:

  • Tender integrity requires that all bids be evaluated on the same terms prevailing at the time of opening; post-opening modifications would undermine fairness.
  • The defence procurement framework (DPP-08) entrusts the Contract Negotiation Committee with determining responsiveness, and it had validly decided against the petitioners.
  • Cochin Shipyard’s bid, although it converted foreign currency content to Indian rupees, fixed the conversion rate as on the bid-opening date, ensuring no future escalation and therefore complied with the “firm and fixed” clause.
  • The DCF method was discretionary (“buyer reserves the right”) rather than mandatory; therefore, the evaluation method adopted did not violate the RFP.
  • Reliance on Ramana Dayaram Shetty supported the need to maintain the tender’s stated eligibility criteria without arbitrary relaxation.

Holding and Implications

Special Leave Petition DISMISSED.

Direct Effect: The contract awarded to Cochin Shipyard Ltd. stands affirmed; L&T’s challenge fails and no costs are imposed by the Supreme Court (the High Court’s cost order remains undisturbed).

Broader Implications: The judgment reinforces the principle that essential tender conditions, especially pricing rigidity, cannot be altered post-opening. Although it applies settled law rather than creating new precedent, it serves as a clear reminder that bidders must strictly conform to explicit procurement terms to remain eligible.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Larsen And Toubro Limited And Another v. Union Of India And Others

    Altamas Kabir, J.— This special leave petition has been filed by M/s Larsen and Toubro Ltd. and one Lt. Col. Ajay Bhatia (Retired), challenging the judgment and order passed by the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court on 8-9-2010, dismissing Writ Petition (Civil) No. 3231 of 2010, filed by the petitioners herein.

    2. In the writ petition, a prayer had, inter alia, been made for an appropriate writ, order or direction upon Respondents 1 to 3 to consider the bid of Petitioner 1 in response to Request For Proposal (RFP) No. TM (M)/0025.CG/FPV dated 17-6-2009 and to invite the said petitioner for negotiation, since the said bid was the lowest bid, and, thereafter, to accept the same in terms of the said RFP.

    3. On 17-6-2009, Respondent 1 sent an RFP to Petitioner 1 for supply of 20 fast patrol vessels (FPV) for the Indian Coast Guard. Similar requests were also sent to other persons as well. According to the normal procedure, the RFP was to be submitted by the intending bidders in two parts. The first part was to consist of the technical proposal and the second part was to be the commercial proposal or financial bid.

    4. In response to the said RFP, Petitioner 1 submitted its bid on 19-10-2009, containing a technical proposal and a commercial proposal in two parts. In its commercial offer, the petitioner had indicated that it intended to avail of the exchange rate variation benefit. The petitioner and four others, including Respondent 4, proved to be successful in the technical bid and, thereafter, the commercial bids were opened on 11-1-2010, in the presence of the bidders and/or their representatives. Although, the offer of Petitioner 1 was found to be the lowest (L-1), its bid was held to be non-responsive, because, despite the tender condition that the price was to be firm and fixed for the entire duration of the contract and would not be subject to escalation, Petitioner 1 had claimed the benefit of foreign exchange rate variation. On the other hand, Respondent 4, M/s Cochin Shipyard Ltd., a public sector undertaking, was found to be the second lowest bidder (L-2).

    5. Apart from the fact that the Technical Evaluation Committee, which had been constituted on 21-10-2009, found that the price quoted by the petitioner had a variable foreign content, it was also found that in order to determine the foreign exchange content, the petitioner had attached a copy of the rate card of State Bank of India along with the commercial bid, which contained various exchange rates of different foreign currencies. The petitioner, however, did not specify as to which foreign currency was the basis of the foreign exchange component in its commercial bid.

    6. Since the commercial offers had to be firm and fixed and since the petitioner had claimed the benefit of the foreign exchange variation component, the Contract Negotiation Committee, which was constituted in accordance with the Defence Procurement Procedure 08 (DPP), concluded that the commercial offer of the petitioner was non-responsive. The petitioner thereupon withdrew its offer and offered the quoted price without the foreign exchange rate variation content. The Contract Negotiation Committee, however, declared the bid of the petitioner as non-responsive and awarded the contract to Respondent 4, which was declared as L-1.

    7. Challenging the said decision of the respondents, the petitioners filed Writ Petition No. 3231 of 2010 before the Delhi High Court. As has been recorded in the impugned judgment of the High Court, when the writ petition was taken up for admission on 14-5-2010, the fact that the petitioners had withdrawn the condition with regard to the provision of foreign exchange rate variation was considered and it was also observed that such subsequent withdrawal could not affect the bid of the petitioners.

    8. However, on the submission made on behalf of the petitioners that the aforesaid condition was also included in the RFP submitted by Respondent 4, notice was issued in the matter. Consequently, while taking up the writ petition for final disposal, the issues framed for deciding the writ petition were centred round the said question. In fact, the first issue which was framed was whether a bidder could amend its bid by withdrawing a condition of the bid document, whereby the bid was considered to be non-responsive. The second issue, which is an offshoot of the first issue, is whether a bidder would be entitled to contend that a non-responsive bid be treated as responsive since the offending condition was withdrawn after the bid documents had been opened. The third issue raised was with regard to the bid submitted by Respondent 4 and whether the same could be treated as responsive, although, the price offered by the said respondent contained a foreign exchange rate component which was to be considered at a particular rate as applicable on a future date at the time of opening of the bid.

    9. In deciding the said issues, the High Court held that since the terms and conditions of the price to be firm and fixed was one of the more important ingredients of the tender, the submission of a bid which violated the said condition rendered the bid non-responsive. The High Court observed that this was not a case of clerical mistake in the bid documents, but a conscious change in the terms and conditions of the bid as submitted by the petitioners, which could not cure the initial disqualification when the bids were submitted.

    10. The High Court took note of the fact that the bid of Respondent 4 contained the condition that its price would be in Indian rupees with a foreign component which would be converted in Indian rupees as on the date of opening of the bid. The High Court observed that the same did not violate the conditions of the RFP and that the said condition ensured that the price would be firm and fixed during the period of performance of the contract. Accordingly, the High Court held that the said condition satisfied the condition regarding price being firm and fixed and could not, therefore, be treated on the same footing as the conditions offered by the petitioner.

    11. The High Court also rejected the petitioner's contention that as per the bid documents the discounted cash flow (DCF) method was required to be used to arrive at the actual and final cost which would be payable by Respondents 1 to 3, for the contract in question. Taking note of the different conditions relating to the evaluation and acceptance process and the terms of payment, the High Court took the view that once the contract had been awarded, the submission made on behalf of the petitioner that the DCF mechanism had to be applied had little force. Furthermore, it was also observed that the adoption of the ECF method could not be said to be mandatory, as the relevant clause provides that the buyer reserved its right to apply the DCF method if it wished to do so.

    12. On its aforesaid findings and strongly deprecating the practice of submitting a foreign currency rate card with the rates of various currencies, without specifying the currency in respect of which the foreign exchange rate was to be considered, the High Court was of the view that the entire exercise was mala fide and while dismissing the writ petition, imposed costs both in favour of Respondents 1 to 3 and Respondent 4.

    13. Mr S. Ganesh, learned Senior Advocate, who appeared for the petitioners, submitted that the same ground on which the petitioners' bid documents had been rejected, was also applicable to the bid documents submitted by Respondent 4, inasmuch as, the foreign exchange rate variation factor had also been projected by the said respondent in the column relating to foreign exchange conversion rates contained in the commercial bid. Mr Ganesh submitted that different yardsticks had been used in the case of the petitioners and Respondent 4. While accepting the commercial bid documents of Respondent 4 as valid, Respondent 1, Union of India, ought not to have rejected the commercial bid documents submitted by the petitioners on the basis of the same objection.

    14. Mr Ganesh drew our attention to the response of Respondent 4 in the column relating to foreign exchange conversion rates included in the commercial bid documents. It has been indicated therein on behalf of Respondent 4 that the costing of the vessel had been carried out by converting the foreign currencies into Indian currency with conversion rate as on the date of costing. The said rates and the contents of foreign currency had been disclosed in the commercial offer and the exchange rate of those currencies as on the date of the opening of the bid would be applicable for the respective foreign currencies to determine the price of the vessel. There could, therefore, be price variation till the commercial bids were opened.

    15. Mr Ganesh contended that Part IV of the request for proposal dealt with evaluation and acceptance criteria which included evaluation of commercial proposals. Under the instructions with regard to evaluation of commercial proposals, it has been categorically stated that the shipyard/shipbuilder quoting the lowest price (L-1) as determined by the Contracts Negotiation Committee would be invited for negotiations and that the discounted cash flow method would be used for evaluation of the bids.

    16. Mr Ganesh submitted that while awarding the contracts, the Government has to be completely fair and above all arbitrariness, as was laid down by this Court in Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India (1979) 3 SCC 489. Mr Ganesh also submitted that, in any event, the petitioners had withdrawn the condition regarding foreign exchange rate variation and had substituted the same with a fixed rate offer. Accordingly, the petitioners' tender documents ought not to have been rejected and the High Court erred in holding otherwise.

    17. The stand taken on behalf of the petitioners was strongly opposed on behalf of Respondent 4, to whom the contract had been awarded. Mr Ashok H. Desai, learned Senior Advocate, pointed out that the condition relating to the foreign exchange rate variation and the proposal of Respondent 4 in relation thereto indicated a firm rate of exchange as on the date of the opening of the commercial bids and there would be no escalation of such offer during the subsistence of the contract, as envisaged in the tender documents.

    18. It was urged that the rate quoted by Respondent 4 was firm and fixed as on the date of opening of the commercial bids and was not subject to any variation during the period of the contract. Mr Desai submitted that the averments made on behalf of the petitioners to the contrary, as far as the commercial bid of Respondent 4 was concerned, were erroneous and misconceived and were in no way similar to the offer made by the petitioners.

    19. Learned Additional Solicitor General, Ms Indira Jaising, took much the same stand as Mr Desai and contended that since the commercial offers had already been opened, the changed offer made on behalf of the petitioners regarding the foreign exchange rate variation condition, could not be taken into consideration and had to be rejected on that ground. Furthermore, as submitted by Mr Desai, the offer made by the petitioners and that made by Respondent 4 on the question of firm and fixed pricing, were different and could not be said to be on the same footing.

    20. Having heard the learned counsel for the respective parties, we are satisfied that the High Court did not commit any error in dismissing the writ petition filed by the petitioners, since in the absence of compliance with the terms and conditions relating to firm and fixed price offer, the petitioners stood excluded from consideration. The offer in this regard made by Respondent 4 satisfies the requirements of a firm and fixed offer, since once the commercial bids were opened, there was no further scope of the rates being altered, which was not so in the case of the petitioners, which tried to make its bid responsive by withdrawing the initial offer and substituting the same with another.

    21. As far as the decision in Ramana Dayaram Shetty case (1979) 3 SCC 489 is concerned, the same does not in any way help the petitioners' case and, on the other hand, has very clearly laid down that where tenders are invited for grant of government contract, the standard of eligibility laid down in the notice for tenders could not be changed arbitrarily as that would be hit by the provisions of Article 14 of the Constitution. It was also observed by this Court that an executive authority has to be rigorously held to the standards by which it professes its actions to be judged and it must scrupulously observe those standards on pain of invalidation. It has been repeatedly stated by this Court that every action of the executive Government must be informed with reason and should be free from arbitrariness, the same being the very essence of the rule of law. The said decision, in fact, supports the case of Respondent 4.

    22. We, therefore, find no reason to interfere with the judgment and order of the High Court impugned in this special leave petition and the same is, accordingly, dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Larsen And Toubro Limited And Another v. Union Of India And Others
    (May 5, 2011)