Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 304 Part II of the Penal Code
  • Section 209(a) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 2 of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 304 Part II of the Penal Code
  • Section 209(a) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 2 of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 10 August 1986 the appellant, Laxmichand @ Balbutya, asked the deceased, Gyaniram Mahajan—who was intoxicated and refused to leave the appellant’s house—to go home. After a verbal quarrel the appellant dragged the deceased outside and struck a single blow on his head with a spade, rendering him unconscious. The victim died on 17 August 1986.

An oral report was lodged by Tejram (PW 2); PSI Narkhede (PW 12) arrested the appellant at the police station and seized the spade. Following investigation, the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, committed the case to the Sessions Court, which acquitted the appellant of the murder charge on 29 July 1989. The State of Maharashtra appealed, and on 15 October 2004 the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) set aside the acquittal and convicted the appellant under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The present appeal, filed from jail, challenges that conviction before the Supreme Court under Section 2 of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution evidence—principally the testimony of two eyewitnesses and alleged extra-judicial confessions—proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant caused the death of Gyaniram Mahajan.
  2. If so, whether the appellant’s act amounted to “murder” under Section 302 IPC or, in the circumstances, constituted “culpable homicide not amounting to murder” punishable under Section 304 Part II IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The incident involved only a single blow delivered in the heat of a quarrel; there was no pre-planning or intention to kill, bringing the case within Section 304 Part II rather than Section 302.
  • No dying declaration or statement of the injured was recorded despite his survival for seven days, weakening the prosecution case.
  • Reliance on alleged extra-judicial confessions is unsafe and should not substitute for direct evidence.

The opinion does not detail specific arguments advanced by the State.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first assessed the reliability of eyewitnesses Fattu Madavi (PW 3) and Mahadeo (PW 4), finding no material omissions or contradictions. Their testimony showed that the deceased was drunk, refused to leave, was dragged outside, and was struck once with a spade.

The Court then considered corroborative evidence: (i) extra-judicial confessions made by the appellant to Tejram (PW 2), Govardhan (PW 7) and Udelal (PW 8); (ii) seizure of the blood-stained spade from the appellant at the police station; and (iii) medical testimony confirming that the head injury could be caused by such a spade and was the cause of death.

While these findings affirmed the appellant’s authorship of the fatal act, the Court examined his mental state. It emphasised that:

  • The quarrel arose spontaneously because the intoxicated deceased refused to leave the appellant’s house.
  • The appellant’s primary concern was to remove the deceased, not to kill him.
  • Only one blow was delivered, albeit on a vital part.

From these circumstances the Court inferred absence of intention to cause death or such bodily injury as was likely to cause death. Accordingly, the act satisfied the elements of culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part II IPC rather than murder under Section 302.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Conviction altered from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part II IPC; the appellant is sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for five years with set-off for the period already undergone. The appeal is allowed in part.

Implications: The decision provides relief to the appellant by reducing the conviction and sentence but does not establish new legal precedent; it applies settled principles on intention and single-blow cases to the specific facts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Laxmichand Alias Balbutya v. State Of Maharashtra .

    P. Sathasivam, J.— This appeal is filed by the appellant-accused, who is in jail, through the Superintendent, Nagpur Central Prison, Nagpur under Section 2 of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970 against the final order and judgment dated 15-10-2004 passed by the High Court of Bombay, Nagpur Bench, Nagpur in Criminal Appeal No. 48 of 1990 whereby the High Court allowed the appeal filed by the State and set aside the order of acquittal passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Gondia.

    2. The prosecution case is as follows: on 10-8-1986, at about 3.00 p.m, there was a quarrel between Laxmichand @ Balbutya—the accused and Gyaniram Mahajan—the deceased, who was in drunken state, at the house of the accused. The appellant-accused asked Gyaniram to go home but he was not acceding to his request. The accused brought Gyaniram from his house on the road by lifting him but he fell down. The accused struck him with a spade on his head. As a result, Gyaniram sustained injury on his head and had become unconscious.

    3. The accused proceeded towards the house of one Police Patel. While going there, he made disclosure to some persons that he had killed Gyaniram Mahajan. One Ghanshyam, who was in the employment of Fulchand and who had heard the utterances of the accused to the above effect, informed Tejram (PW 2) who was sitting in the house of Fulchand that the appellant-accused was telling that he had killed Gyaniram. Tejram went towards the Gram Panchayat. The accused was coming from the side of the house of Police Patel. He again made similar utterances and informed Tejram that he had killed Gyaniram and further asked him to scribe a report. Tejram advised him to go to the police station.

    4. Tejram went to the police station and lodged an oral report that he was informed by the accused that he had killed Gyaniram. The oral report was reduced into writing by PSI Narkhede (PW 12) under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860. By the time the accused reached there along with spade, PSI Narkhede (PW 12) arrested him and seized the spade. Thereafter, he went to the spot and noticed that Gyaniram was lying unconscious. Spot panchnama was prepared and the samples of bloodstained earth and plain earth were collected.

    5. Gyaniram was sent to the hospital in the cart of Primary Health Centre, Tirora. The doctor examined him at 9.45 p.m and found a lacerated wound on his forehead with underlying bone fractured into pieces. As Gyaniram was unconscious, the PSI could not take his statement. On 17-8-1986, ASI Sahare received a message from Dr. Jaiswal of K.T.S Hospital, Gondia that Gyaniram had expired. On the same day itself the post-mortem was conducted.

    6. After the investigation, the charge-sheet was sent to the Court of JMFC, Gondia. The JMFC committed the case under Section 209(a) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 to the Court of Session for trial of the accused. The charge for the offence under Section 302 IPC was framed against the accused. The Sessions Judge, Gondia, vide his judgment dated 29-7-1989, acquitted the accused of the charges framed against him.

    7. Against the said judgment of acquittal, the State filed an appeal before the High Court of Bombay, Nagpur Bench. The High Court, vide its judgment dated 15-10-2004, set aside the order of acquittal and convicted the appellant-accused for offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. Aggrieved by the judgment of the High Court, the appellant-accused has filed this appeal from jail through the Superintendent, Nagpur Central Prison, Nagpur before this Court.

    8. Heard Mr Sushil Karanjakar, learned amicus curiae for the appellant and Mr Shankar Chillarge, learned counsel for the State.

    9. As far as the incident and the involvement of the appellant-accused is concerned, the prosecution has mainly relied on the evidence of Fattu Madavi (PW 3) and Mahadeo (PW 4) who are the two eyewitnesses. Apart from these two eyewitnesses, the prosecution has also relied on the extra-judicial confession said to have been made by the accused to some of the witnesses.

    10. It is seen from the evidence of Fattu (PW 3) that the accused gave a call to him and said that Gyaniram, the deceased was under the influence of liquor and he was not willing to leave his house. There was a quarrel between the accused and the deceased at the house of the accused. At the time of quarrel, Mahadeo (PW 4), who was present in the nearby house of Bhaurao Neware, was witnessing the same. It is also seen from the evidence of Fattu (PW 3) and Mahadeo (PW 4) that in the course of quarrel, the accused dragged Gyaniram outside of his house and gave a stroke of spade on his head.

    11. From the evidence of PWs 3 and 4, the prosecution has established that the quarrel was going on between the accused and the deceased and the deceased was under the influence of liquor and he was adamant and refused to leave the house of the accused which forced the accused to drag him outside his house and also inflicted injuries with the spade. As rightly observed by the High Court, there is no reason to disbelieve the version of eyewitnesses, PWs 3 and 4, in this regard. On perusal of their evidence, we found no material omission or contradiction to disbelieve their version. On the other hand, we agree with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court as regard to the reliability of the two eyewitnesses.

    12. Apart from the two eyewitnesses, the prosecution has examined one Tejram as PW 2 who made a complaint to the police. The accused has made an extra-judicial confession to him. Tejram (PW 2) is the person who lodged the report (Ext. 21). The perusal of the above report strengthened the evidence of Tejram (PW 2) about the statement said to have been made to him by the accused.

    13. It is also seen from the evidence of Narkhede, PSI (PW 12) that when he was scribing the report, the accused arrived at the police station with a spade and immediately he arrested him and seized the spade. Though not much importance needs to be given to the statement of Tejram (PW 2) but if we consider the same along with other materials, there is no reason to reject his version.

    14. Another person before whom the accused has made a confessional statement is Govardhan (PW 7). The accused had gone to his place and informed him about the incident. In the same way, one Udelal, who was examined as PW 8, also apprised the court about the admission of guilt by the accused. Though there is no need to attach importance to the statements of PWs 7 and 8, as observed earlier, if we consider all the materials together, they prove the case of the prosecution that it was the accused who was responsible for the death of Gyaniram, the deceased.

    15. It was submitted that though the injured was alive for seven days but no attempt was made to record his statement about the incident. It is seen from the evidence of Narkhede, PSI (PW 12) that he was not allowed to record his statement by the doctors as the victim was not in a position to give the statement. It is relevant to note that an attempt was made to record his statement by the Special Executive Magistrate, that also could not be done. The evidence of Dr. Arvind Manwatkar (PW 1), Medical Officer attached to Primary Health Centre, Tirora also supports the version of the prosecution. He also issued a certificate (Ext. 19) that the injured person was not able to give any statement. When Dr. Arvind Manwatkar (PW 1) was shown the spade at the time of examination in court, he opined that it would be possible that such injury could be caused with spade.

    16. As observed by the High Court, the medical report, evidence of the doctor and the statement of the eyewitnesses support the case of the prosecution. Dr. Pradip Kumar Gujar (PW 9) who conducted the post-mortem on the dead body of Gyaniram also found that the cause of death was head injury, laceration of the brain matter, resulting into neurogenic shock and peripheral circulatory failure. All the above materials including oral and documentary evidence clearly prove the case of the prosecution and we agree with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court.

    17*. Coming to the argument that instead of convicting the accused for culpable homicide amounting to murder, his case would fall in the category of culpable homicide not amounting to murder as even according to the prosecution one blow alone was caused by the accused that too in a quarrel, we have already pointed out and it is clear from the evidence of PWs 3 and 4 eyewitnesses that prior to the incident, there was a quarrel between the accused and the deceased inside the house of the accused and the deceased consumed liquor and was adamant not to leave the house of the accused which necessitated the accused to drag him out of his house and inasmuch as the deceased still refused to accede to the request of the accused, he inflicted a blow on the head with the spade. As pointed out by the appellant-accused, he had no pre-plan or intention to kill the deceased and his main worry was to get the deceased out of his house, who had consumed excessive liquor.

    18. Considering all these aspects, particularly, the conduct of the deceased in not leaving the house of the accused, he dragged him out of his house, put him on the road and assaulted him with a spade, we are of the view that the accused has no intention to kill the deceased. It is true that the blow given by the accused on the deceased was at the vital part because of which he was unconscious for seven days and ultimately succumbed to his injuries. However, as discussed earlier, the accused had no intention to commit the offence.

    19. Considering all the materials and reasons, we feel that the commission of offence attributed to the appellant-accused would come under Section 304 Part II of the Penal Code. Taking note of the fact that the incident had occurred in the year 1986 and the accused had no intention to kill the deceased but due to the reasons and circumstances stated above, we feel that the ends of justice would be met by awarding sentence of rigorous imprisonment for five years. The accused is entitled to have the benefit of deduction of the period already undergone.

    20. With the above modification, the appeal is allowed in part.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Laxmichand Alias Balbutya v. State Of Maharashtra .
    (Jan 6, 2011)