Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 312
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 312
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Renuka, the deceased, had been married to the first appellant (A-1) for about ten years. On 10-12-2005, the appellants (A-1 husband, A-2 brother-in-law, and A-4 sister-in-law), together with their mother (A-3) and grandmother (A-5), allegedly poured kerosene on Renuka and set her ablaze. Neighbours extinguished the flames and took her to Government Hospital, Bagalkot, where she gave a dying declaration before the Taluk Executive Magistrate (PW-12) in the presence of the attending doctor (PW-7). She died the same evening from 100% burn injuries.

The police registered an FIR at 7:15 p.m. on the day of the incident, completed investigation, and filed a charge-sheet on 23-1-2006. The Fast Track Court, Bagalkot, framed charges under Sections 498-A, 143, 147, 341, and 302/149 IPC. On 3-10-2006 it convicted all five accused and sentenced each to life imprisonment for murder and two years’ rigorous imprisonment for cruelty to wife.

On appeal, the High Court of Karnataka (4-10-2007) acquitted A-3 and A-5 but affirmed the convictions and sentences of A-1, A-2 and A-4 under Sections 498-A/34 and 302/34 IPC. The present Supreme Court appeal, filed by A-1, A-2 and A-4, challenges that affirmation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court was justified in convicting A-1, A-2 and A-4 for offences under Section 498-A/34 IPC and Section 302/34 IPC.
  2. Whether the sentences imposed on the appellants are sustainable.
  3. Whether the High Court rightly confirmed the convictions and sentences.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The five neighbours said to be present before Renuka was set on fire did nothing to stop the incident, casting doubt on their credibility.
  • The dying declaration (Exh. P-9) should be discarded because PW-12 (the Magistrate) did not obtain a formal medical certificate of Renuka’s fitness, nor verify her mental condition despite her 100% burns.

Respondent State’s Arguments

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined both documentary and oral evidence:

  • Dying declaration: PW-7 (treating doctor) affirmed that Renuka was in a fit state of mind when PW-12 recorded Exh. P-9, and both affixed their signatures/thumb impression. The Court held that absence of a written medical certificate is not fatal when the recorder is otherwise satisfied of the declarant’s fitness.
  • Eyewitness testimony: PW-3, PW-4 (hostile in part), and PW-6 consistently placed A-1, A-2 and A-4 at the scene. PW-6 stated that A-4 poured kerosene, A-2 lit the match, and A-1 held the victim, which corroborates Exh. P-9.
  • Motive and cruelty: Evidence from PW-3, PW-6, PW-9 (father) and PW-10 (elderly villager) showed ongoing harassment of Renuka, including A-4’s desire to marry her daughter to A-1.
  • Medical evidence: Post-mortem report (Exh. P-5) confirmed 100% burns and the presence of kerosene smell, supporting the prosecution narrative.
  • The Court found minor discrepancies immaterial and held that the collective evidence proved common intention and active participation of the three appellants.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The convictions under Sections 498-A/34 and 302/34 IPC and the sentences of life imprisonment (with associated fines) imposed on A-1, A-2 and A-4 are affirmed.

Implications: The decision maintains the appellants’ life sentences and provides no new legal precedent; it primarily reinforces the evidentiary value of a properly recorded dying declaration even in the absence of a formal medical certificate when corroborated by medical and eyewitness testimony.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Govindappa And Others v. State Of Karnataka .

    P. Sathasivam, J.— This appeal is directed against the final judgment and order dated 4-10-2007 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in Criminal Appeal No. 2573 of 2006 whereby the High Court partly allowing the appeal acquitted Laxmibai, A-3, the mother of the appellants herein and Bhagirathi, A-5, the grandmother of the appellants and affirming the sentence passed by the trial court convicted A-1, A-2 and A-4, the appellants herein, for the offences under Sections 498-A/34 IPC and Sections 302/34 IPC.

    2. The facts leading to the present appeal are as follows: the deceased, Renuka, was married to Appellant 1 about 10 years prior to the date of the incident. As per the prosecution case, on 10-12-2005, at about 12 noon, the appellants herein, along with their mother and grandmother tried to pour kerosene oil and lit fire on the deceased and because of that she raised hue and cry. On hearing her noise, five neighbours came and requested them not to do so but the accused persons asked them not to interfere in their family matter. Appellant 3 poured kerosene on the deceased and Appellant 2 set fire in the presence of the neighbours.

    3. After pouring kerosene, the accused persons ran away from the house and the neighbours extinguished the fire and covered the deceased with blanket; and had taken her immediately to Government Hospital Bagalkot. At about 2.30 p.m, the doctor (PW 7) informed the police, and the Magistrate (Tahsildar) (PW 12) came to the Hospital at 4.30 p.m and recorded the dying declaration of the deceased which is filed as Ext. P-9. The police officer came to the Hospital after 7 p.m and took the statement of the deceased which was written by Govindagowda Patil, PW 11, the neighbour, and FIR was registered at the police station at 7.15 p.m which is Ext. P-10. The investigating officer, PW 17 came to the Hospital at 8.30 p.m and again tried to take the statement of the deceased but she was not in a position to give any statement and at 9.00 p.m, she died. The inquest panchnama was prepared at about 11.00 p.m

    4. On 11-12-2005, post-mortem was conducted by the doctor, PW 7, the report of which is Ext. P-5. The investigating officer filed the charge-sheet on 23-1-2006. On 26-6-2006, the Fast Track Court, Bagalkot framed the charges against all the five accused persons under Sections 498-A, 143, 147, 341, 302 read with Section 149 IPC.

    5. By order dated 3-10-2006, the Fast Track Court, Bagalkot convicted all the five accused for the offence punishable under Sections 498-A, 143, 147, 341, 302 read with Section 149 IPC and sentenced them to undergo rigorous imprisonment for two years and also sentenced them to pay a fine of Rs 2000 each in default, simple imprisonment for three months for the offence punishable under Section 498-A read with Section 149 IPC and further convicted them for the offences punishable under Sections 302/149 IPC and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs 10,000 each in default, simple imprisonment for one year. All of them filed a criminal appeal being Appeal No. 2573 of 2006 before the High Court.

    6. By order dated 4-10-2007, the High Court by partly allowing the appeal acquitted A-3 and A-5 of all the charges levelled against them and affirming the sentence passed by the trial court on A-1, A-2 and A-4 convicted them for the offence punishable under Sections 498-A/34 IPC and Sections 302/34 IPC. Aggrieved by the said order, Accused 1, 2 and 4 have preferred this appeal by way of special leave petition.

    7. We have heard Mr Sanjay Jain, learned counsel for the appellant-accused and Mr Sanjay R. Hegde, learned counsel for the respondent State. Points for consideration in this appeal are:

    (i) Whether the trial court was justified in convicting the appellant-accused A-1, A-2, and A-4 for the offences punishable under Section 498-A read with Section 34 IPC and Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC?
    (ii) Whether the sentence imposed upon the appellant-accused is justifiable?
    (iii) Whether the High Court is right in confirming the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellants?

    In this appeal, we are concerned only with A-1, A-2 and A-4, since the other accused A-3 and A-5 were acquitted by the High Court.

    8. Apart from various materials in the form of oral and documentary evidence, the trial court accepted the evidence of eyewitnesses, namely, PW 3, PW 4, PW 5, PW 6 as well as Dr. Uma Kant, PW 7 who treated Renuka; father of the deceased, PW 9; one elderly person of the village, PW 10 and Taluk Executive Magistrate, PW 12 who had recorded the dying declaration of Renuka.

    9. Learned counsel for the appellant-accused pointed out that as per the prosecution, there were five witnesses present at the spot of incident, even before the victim was burnt, but none of them stopped the accused or tried to prevent the incident. He also submitted that the trial court and the High Court committed an error in relying upon the dying declaration recorded by PW 12 since PW 12 has neither taken the certificate from the doctor nor asked any question to verify the mental condition of the deceased Renuka, particularly, when she suffered 100% burns as shown in the post-mortem report.

    10. At the foremost, let us verify the evidence of Dr. Uma Kant, PW 7 who treated the injured Renuka when she was brought to the hospital. Though, he had stated that injured Renuka had sustained 100% burn injuries, at about 4.45 p.m, according to him, she was in a fit state of mind to give statement. Based on the statement of the doctor PW 7, Taluka Executive Magistrate PW 12 recorded her statement in the presence of PW 7. It is further seen that after recording the statement, her left thumb impression was taken on the statement, the doctor PW 7 also subscribed his signature.

    11. It is true that in the cross-examination it was elicited that the tongue of the deceased was swollen and protruded and lips were burnt. Though this suggestion has been admitted by PW 7, the fact remains that at the time of recording her statement PW 7 was satisfied that Renuka was in a fit condition and in a fit state of mind to make a statement. There is no reason to disbelieve the version of PW 7 who made initial treatment and he was very well present during the entire period of recording the statement (Ext. P-9).

    12. We hold that the evidence of PW 7 coupled with PW 12 is acceptable and supports the case of the prosecution.

    13. Now, let us discuss the other eyewitnesses, first and foremost is PW 3. According to him, he is residing in a house adjacent to the deceased Renuka. He explained that he knew the family members of the appellants and the deceased. He also explained that the sister-in-law of the deceased A-4 desired to give her elder daughter in marriage to A-1 and because of that Renuka was being assaulted by the appellants.

    14. PW 3 deposed that on 10-12-2005 at 12 o'clock he heard a crying sound from the house of the appellants. He along with others went to the house of the appellants and they found A-1, A-3 and A-5 holding Renuka. A-2 had a matchbox in his hand and A-4 was holding kerosene can. Though he requested not to cause any harm to Renuka, according to him, the accused persons were holding Renuka and the sister-in-law (A-4) poured kerosene. He further asserted that after setting fire by pouring kerosene accused A-1 to A-4 ran away from the scene of occurrence.

    15. Though PW 3 also implicated A-3 and A-5 in the commission of offence but in the absence of further corroboration, the High Court has rightly acquitted them. However, there is no reason to disbelieve the evidence of PW 3 insofar as A-1, A-2 and A-4 appellants herein that they were responsible for the cause of the death of Renuka.

    16. The next witness is Govindappa, PW 4, who witnessed the incident and partly supported the case of the prosecution. He explained how the deceased was humiliated and harassed by the appellants. According to him, this was narrated to him by Renuka during her lifetime and on several occasions she had gone to her native place due to ill-treatment meted out to her at the hands of the appellants. He also explained that on 10-12-2005 at about 12 o'clock, when he was in his house, he heard cries from the house of the appellants. He rushed to their house and saw in the first floor Renuka was ablaze.

    17. As rightly observed by the High Court, though, PW 4 did not support the entire case of the prosecution and he had been treated as hostile witness, his evidence to the extent of A-2 and A-4 participating in the commission of offence is proved. To this extent, the High Court has rightly accepted his testimony.

    18. The next eyewitness examined by the prosecution is one Prakash, PW 6. He explained how Renuka was humiliated and harassed by the appellants and on the relevant date and time and after hearing the cries he went to the first floor and found that A-1, A-2 and A-5 were holding Renuka, A-4 was holding kerosene can and A-2 was holding a matchstick. He further deposed that the accused informed him that it is their family matter and none should interfere. At that time, A-4 poured kerosene on the body of Renuka and A-2 lighted matchstick and set fire to Renuka and immediately all the accused ran away from the scene of occurrence.

    19. As observed by the High Court, the evidence of PW 6 shows that A-4 poured kerosene and A-2 lit the fire. The above statement of PW 6 finds support from the dying declaration, Ext. P-7 (sic Ext. P-9). His assertion that A-1 was holding Renuka also finds corroboration from the dying declaration, Ext. P-9. In other words, the evidence of PW 6 clearly proves the participation of A-1, A-2 and A-4 in the commission of offence.

    20. Krishnappa, father of the deceased was examined as PW 9. He explained how his daughter was harassed and humiliated by the appellants. He also explained the desire of A-4 sister-in-law of the deceased to give her elder daughter to A-1. His evidence gets support from the dying declaration, Ext. P-9 and to this extent the same is acceptable and rightly relied on by the High Court. An elderly person from the same village had been examined as PW 10 and he also narrated how the deceased Renuka was humiliated and harassed at the instance of the appellants.

    21. Another important witness is H.N Nagaraj, PW 12, Taluka Executive Magistrate. He deposed before the court that he had recorded the dying declaration of Renuka and the same was recorded after ascertaining her condition from PW 7 Dr. Uma Kant. After noting that Renuka was in a fit state of mind from Dr. Uma Kant, PW 7 and she was in a position to make the statement, in the presence of PW 7 he recorded her statement on 10-12-2005 at 4.45 p.m He denied the suggestion that Renuka was not in a position to make a statement.

    22. About the dying declaration, Ext. P-9, we have already adverted to the evidence of Dr. Uma Kant (PW 7), Government District Hospital, Bagalkot. He explained that on 10-12-2005 at 2.20 p.m injured Renuka, w/o Govindappa Macha was brought with history of burns on the same day at 1.00 p.m and she was admitted in the hospital and treatment was given to her. When Taluka Executive Magistrate (PW 12) came to the hospital at about 4.45 p.m, he enquired about the mental condition of the patient and whether she is capable of giving statement for which PW 7 informed that the patient is in a fit state of mind to give statement. Accordingly, the statement was recorded in his presence and then Renuka put her left thumb impression on the said statement and both the doctor and the Magistrate also signed on the said statement. It is true that on the same night at 9.00 p.m the injured expired due to burn injuries and post-mortem was conducted.

    23. On examination of body, PW 7 Dr. Uma Kant found superficial (epidermal burns) all over the body. Hyperaemic skin, singeing of hair present, burn 100% few small blisters are seen over the face containing serous ferrous fluids, skin is red and hyperaemic, singeing of hair present on head, dura mater is leathery, brain is shrunken and yellow. All the internal organs were congested, coal particles are seen in nose, mouth, trachea and oesophagus. Found smell of kerosene oil on her body. He is of the opinion that death is due to shock as a result of 100% burns, time since death is within 4 to 24 hours. Accordingly, he issued the post-mortem report as per Ext. P-5, which bears his signature. PW 7 has also denied the suggestion that the deceased Renuka was in semi-coma till death.

    24. Though, it was argued that PW 12 Tahsildar had not obtained the certificate from the Medical Officer regarding the condition of the deceased, that itself is not sufficient to discard the dying declaration (Ext. P-9). What is essentially required is that the person who recorded the dying declaration must be satisfied that the deceased was in a fit state of mind. The certification by the doctor is essentially a rule of caution and, therefore, the voluntary and truthful nature of the declaration can be established otherwise. The evidence of the doctor (PW 7) clearly shows that the deceased was in a sound state of mind while giving the statement before the Tahsildar (PW 12).

    25. In such circumstances, we are of the view that such a dying declaration has got due weight in the evidence.

    26. Further, as stated earlier, the doctor has explained that though the deceased Renuka sustained 100% burn injuries, she was in a position to talk. In such circumstances, her statement cannot be rejected on the ground that she sustained severe burn injuries. Normally, the person on the verge of death will not implicate somebody falsely.

    27. Even if we accept some contradiction in Ext. P-7 complaint, in the light of Ext. P-9 dying declaration coupled with the evidence of eyewitnesses, there is ample evidence on record to hold that the appellants ill-treated the deceased Renuka and subjected her to cruelty by giving both mental and physical torture and in furtherance of their common intention only to commit the murder of the deceased, poured kerosene and set fire on her who ultimately succumbed to the injuries on the same day in District Hospital, Bagalkot. In our view, dying declaration (Ext. P-9) fully corroborates the evidence of the doctor and the Tahsildar who recorded it.

    28. The analysis of the prosecution witnesses, particularly, PW 3, PW 4, PW 10 elderly person of the village and PW 12 Taluk Executive Magistrate who recorded the dying declaration of Renuka clearly proves the involvement of the appellants in the commission of the offence as charged and they were rightly awarded sentence of life imprisonment. Though, it was pointed out that there were certain discrepancies, according to us, they all are minimal and it had not affected the case of the prosecution.

    29. As discussed earlier, in view of the oral evidence of PW 3, PW 4, PW 6, PW 7, PW 9, PW 10, PW 12 coupled with the dying declaration, Ext. P-9, we hold that the prosecution has fully established its case against the appellants and we are in entire agreement with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court.

    30. In the light of the above discussion, we do not find any merit in the appeal, consequently, the same is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Govindappa And Others v. State Of Karnataka .
    (May 11, 2010)