AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 144
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Industrial Disputes Act and other similar legislative instruments
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Preamble of the Constitution
  • Section (i), (ii), (iii), and (iv) [no specific Act/Article mentioned]
  • Section 11-A of the Act
  • The 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text, but mentioned as a placeholder)
  • Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Articles 226 and/or 227 of the Constitution
  • Section 10 of the Act
  • Section 25-F of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 144
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Industrial Disputes Act and other similar legislative instruments
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Preamble of the Constitution
  • Section (i), (ii), (iii), and (iv) [no specific Act/Article mentioned]
  • Section 11-A of the Act
  • The 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text, but mentioned as a placeholder)
  • Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Articles 226 and/or 227 of the Constitution
  • Section 10 of the Act
  • Section 25-F of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was engaged as a daily-wage worker by the respondent on 1-6-1988. His services were terminated orally in December 1993 without notice, notice pay or retrenchment compensation under Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (“the Act”). After issuing an unreplied notice of demand on 30-12-1997, the appellant obtained a reference under Section 10 of the Act.

The Labour Court, Rohtak, after receiving pleadings and evidence from both sides, delivered an award on 18-7-2006 holding the termination illegal and directing reinstatement with continuity of service and 50 % back wages from the date of demand notice.

The respondent challenged the award in CWP No. 5257/2007 before the Punjab and Haryana High Court. On 9-12-2008 the High Court set aside the award and substituted a lump-sum compensation of ₹ 50,000. The present appeal challenges that High Court order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution, in substituting the Labour Court’s order of reinstatement with 50 % back wages by an award of ₹ 50,000 compensation.
  2. Whether the Labour Court’s grant of reinstatement with partial back wages was proper in view of the admitted violation of Section 25-F of the Act and the discretion conferred by Section 11-A.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The precedents relied upon by the High Court—Mahboob Deepak and GDA v. Ashok Kumar—involved facts (financial irregularities; absence of sanctioned post) not present in the instant case and therefore are inapplicable.
  • Non-compliance with Section 25-F renders the termination illegal, warranting reinstatement; the Labour Court correctly exercised its discretion in granting 50 % back wages.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The High Court correctly applied Mahboob Deepak and GDA v. Ashok Kumar to substitute compensation for reinstatement.
  • Reliance was also placed on State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) to contend that regularisation—and by implication reinstatement—was not appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harjinder Singh v. Punjab State Warehousing Corp. (2010) 3 SCC 192 High Court must respect Labour Court’s discretion; social-welfare orientation of the Act. Used to underline that interference with reinstatement orders is permissible only on narrow grounds.
Mahboob Deepak v. Nagar Panchayat, Gajraula (2008) 1 SCC 575 Enumerated factors (statutory compliance, period of work, vacancy, alternative employment) relevant to decide between reinstatement and compensation. Held inapplicable because none of those disqualifying factors were pleaded or proved against the appellant.
GDA v. Ashok Kumar (2008) 4 SCC 261 Where no sanctioned post exists, reinstatement should not be ordered. Distinguished; respondent never asserted non-existence of a sanctioned post.
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 Limits on regularisation of temporary employees in public service. Declared irrelevant because the case concerns reinstatement of a daily wager, not regularisation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court reiterated that Section 11-A confers wide discretion on Labour Courts to order reinstatement or other appropriate relief once termination is found unjustified. That discretion should not be lightly interfered with under writ jurisdiction.

2. It emphasized the social-welfare nature of the Industrial Disputes Act, echoing Harjinder Singh, and stated that interpretations must further rather than frustrate its objects.

3. Analysing the High Court’s reliance on Mahboob Deepak and GDA v. Ashok Kumar, the Court noted that: (a) the respondent never pleaded absence of sanctioned post, violation of recruitment rules, or alternative employment of the appellant; (b) therefore, the factual predicates for substituting compensation did not exist.

4. The Court found that the Labour Court’s findings—267 days of service in one year and non-compliance with Section 25-F—were unchallenged on merits. Hence, the termination was illegal.

5. In the absence of any vitiating factor, the High Court exceeded its certiorari jurisdiction by altering the well-reasoned relief granted by the Labour Court.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed. The High Court’s order dated 9-12-2008 is set aside; the Labour Court’s award is restored, directing reinstatement of the appellant as a daily wager with continuity of service and 50 % back wages.

Implications: The judgment reinforces that High Courts should exercise restraint when asked to modify Labour Court awards, especially where statutory violations like non-compliance with Section 25-F are established and no disqualifying circumstances exist. It underscores that compensation in lieu of reinstatement is not automatic and must be fact-driven.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Krishan Singh v. Executive Engineer, Haryana State Agricultural Marketing Board, Rohtak (Haryana) .

    A.K Patnaik, J.— Leave granted. The appellant worked as a daily wager under the respondent from 1-6-1988. His services were dispensed with in December 1993. He served a notice of demand dated 30-12-1997 on the respondent contending that his services were terminated orally without complying with the mandatory provisions of Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short “the Act”) and that he may be reinstated in service with full back wages from the date of illegal termination and he may be regularised according to the government policy.

    2. The respondent did not respond to the demand made by the appellant and by an order dated 23-7-1999, the State Government referred the dispute under Section 10 of the Act to the Labour Court. The appellant and the respondent filed their claim statement and the objection respectively before the Labour Court, Rohtak, and led evidence in support of their respective cases.

    3. Thereafter, the Labour Court passed the award dated 18-7-2006 holding that the appellant had admittedly completed 267 days from 1-6-1988 to 30-4-1989 and his services were terminated without any notice or notice pay and without payment of retrenchment compensation and the termination was, therefore, in violation of Section 25-F of the Act and the appellant was entitled to be reinstated in his previous post with continuity of service and 50% back wages from the date of demand notice i.e 30-12-1997.

    4. The respondent challenged the award of the Labour Court before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in a writ petition registered as CWP No. 5257 of 2007 and by order dated 9-12-2008, the High Court allowed the writ petition, set aside the award dated 18-7-2006 of the Labour Court and directed the respondent instead to pay compensation of Rs 50,000 to the appellant within a period of four months. Aggrieved by the order dated 9-12-2008 of the High Court, the appellant has filed this appeal.

    5. Shri Shekhar Prit Jha, learned counsel for the appellant, submitted that the High Court has relied on the decisions of this Court in Mahboob Deepak v. Nagar Panchayat, Gajraula (2008) 1 SCC 575 and GDA v. Ashok Kumar (2008) 4 SCC 261 for setting aside the award of the Labour Court.

    6. Shri Jha submitted that in Mahboob Deepak case (2008) 1 SCC 575 the workman was removed for financial irregularities, but the appellant in the present case was not removed for financial irregularities. He submitted that GDA v. Ashok Kumar (2008) 4 SCC 261 was not a case of violation of Section 25-F of the Act as in the present case. He submitted that the two decisions on which the High Court has relied upon to set aside the award of the Labour Court therefore do not apply to the facts of the present case.

    7. The learned counsel submitted that it is now well settled that if preconditions for retrenchment of a workman who has worked for more than a year stipulated in Section 25-F of the Act are not complied with, the termination of the service of the workman is illegal. He submitted that the Labour Court having found that these preconditions had not been complied with in the case had rightly directed reinstatement of the appellant with 50% back wages.

    8. Shri Randhir Badhram, the learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submitted that the High Court has rightly set aside the award of the Labour Court relying on the decisions of this Court in GDA v. Ashok Kumar (2008) 4 SCC 261 and Mahboob Deepak v. Nagar Panchayat, Gajraula (2008) 1 SCC 575. He also relied on State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 in support of his submission that this is not a fit case where the appellant could be regularised in service.

    9. The only question that we have to decide in this case is whether the High Court was right in setting aside the award dated 18-7-2006 of the Labour Court directing reinstatement of the appellant with 50% back wages and directing instead payment of compensation of Rs 50,000 to the appellant.

    10. We find that the dispute that was referred to by the State Government under Section 10 of the Act to the Labour Court was:

    “whether the termination of the services of the appellant was justified and if not, to what relief he was entitled to?”

    11. As per the claim statement filed by the appellant before the Labour Court, he was appointed by the respondent as a daily wager against a regular post on 1-6-1988 under the Junior Engineer at Meham and the appellant worked there for different periods until the respondent terminated his services in December 1993 without any notice and without complying with the provisions of Section 25-F of the Act.

    12. The respondent in its objections did not take a plea that the engagement of the appellant was either against a post which was not sanctioned or contrary to the statutory rules and admitted in the objections that the services of the appellant were engaged for different periods during 1988-1989, 1989-1990, 1990-1991 and 1992-1993. The respondent also furnished a statement of the works in which the appellant was engaged during the years 1988-1989 and 1989-1990, which was marked as Ext. MW 1.

    13. Taking into consideration Ext. MW 1, the Labour Court held that the appellant has completed 267 days from 1-6-1988 to 30-4-1989 and without any notice or notice pay and without retrenchment compensation. In the relief portion of the award, the Labour Court held that as the services of the appellant had been terminated illegally, he was entitled to be reinstated in his previous post with continuity of service and 50% back wages from the date of demand notice i.e 31-12-1997.

    14. In a recent judgment of this Court in Harjinder Singh v. Punjab State Warehousing Corpn. (2010) 3 SCC 192, JT (2010) 1 SC 598, the Labour Court, Gurdaspur, by its award directed reinstatement of the workman with 50% back wages, but the award of the Labour Court was modified by a learned Single Judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in the writ petition and this Court has held that the order of the learned Single Judge of the High Court was liable to be set aside only on the ground that while interfering with the award of the Labour Court, the learned Single Judge did not keep in view the parameters laid down by this Court for exercise of jurisdiction by the High Court under Articles 226 and/or 227 of the Constitution.

    15. Learned Brother G.S Singhvi, J. in his opinion in Harjinder Singh (2010) 3 SCC 192, JT (2010) 1 SC 598, has observed that while exercising jurisdiction under Articles 226 and/or 227 of the Constitution, the High Courts are duty-bound to keep in mind that the Industrial Disputes Act and other similar legislative instruments are social welfare legislations and the same are required to be interpreted keeping in view the goals set out in the Preamble of the Constitution and the provisions contained in Part IV of the Constitution including Articles 38, 39(a) to (e), 43 and 43-A thereof. Learned Brother Asok Kumar Ganguly, J. agreeing with learned Brother G.S Singhvi, J. has also observed that this Court has a duty to interpret statutes with social welfare benefits in such a way as to further the statutory goal and not to frustrate it.

    16. Section 11-A of the Act clearly provides that:

    “11-A. Powers of Labour Courts, Tribunals and National Tribunals to give appropriate relief in case of discharge or dismissal of workmen.—Where an industrial dispute relating to the discharge or dismissal of a workman has been referred to a Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal for adjudication and, in the course of the adjudication proceedings, the Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal, as the case may be, is satisfied that the order of discharge or dismissal was not justified, it may, by its award, set aside the order of discharge or dismissal and direct reinstatement of the workman on such terms and conditions, if any, as it thinks fit, or give such other relief to the workman including the award of any lesser punishment in lieu of discharge or dismissal as the circumstances of the case may require:”

    17. Wide discretion is, therefore, vested in the Labour Court while adjudicating an industrial dispute relating to the discharge or dismissal of a workman and if the Labour Court has exercised its jurisdiction in the facts and circumstances of the case to direct reinstatement of a workman with 50% back wages taking into consideration the pleadings of the parties and the evidence on record, the High Court in exercise of its power under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India will not interfere with the same, except on well-settled principles laid down by this Court for a writ of certiorari against an order passed by a court or a tribunal.

    18. The High Court, however, has relied on the decision of this Court in Mahboob Deepak v. Nagar Panchayat, Gajraula (2008) 1 SCC 575 and on reading of the aforesaid decision, we find that this Court in the aforesaid decision has mentioned the following factors, which are relevant for determining whether an award of reinstatement should or should not be passed:

    “(i) whether in making the appointment, the statutory rules, if any, had been complied with;
    (ii) the period he had worked;
    (iii) whether there existed any vacancy; and
    (iv) whether he obtained some other employment on the date of termination or passing of the award.”

    This Court further held in the aforesaid decision that in the light of these principles the relief of reinstatement granted by the Labour Court in that case was wholly unsustainable and has accordingly directed payment of a sum of Rs 50,000 by way of damages to the workman with interest at the rate of 9% per annum.

    19. The High Court has also relied on the decision of this Court in GDA v. Ashok Kumar (2008) 4 SCC 261 and on reading of the aforesaid decision we find that the contention of the management before the Labour Court was that the post, in which the workman was working in that case, was not sanctioned after 31-3-1990 and this was not disputed by the workman and this Court held that if there did not exist any post, the Labour Court should not have directed reinstatement of the workman in service.

    20. The aforesaid two decisions of this Court in Mahboob Deepak v. Nagar Panchayat, Gajraula (2008) 1 SCC 575 and GDA v. Ashok Kumar (2008) 4 SCC 261 have no application to the facts in this case.

    21. In the present case, the respondent has not taken any stand before the Labour Court in his objections that the post in which the workman was working was not sanctioned or that his engagement was contrary to statutory rules or that he was employed elsewhere or that there was no vacancy. In the absence of any pleadings, evidence or findings on any of these aspects, the High Court should not have modified the award of the Labour Court directing reinstatement of the appellant with 50% back wages and instead directed payment of compensation of Rs 50,000 to the appellant.

    22. The decision of this Court in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1 cited by the counsel for the respondent relates to regularisation in public employment and has no relevance to an award for reinstatement of a discharged workman passed by the Labour Court under Section 11-A of the Act without any direction for regularisation of his services.

    23. In the result, we allow this appeal and set aside the impugned order dated 9-12-2008 of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in CWP No. 5257 of 2007 and direct that the appellant will be reinstated as a daily wager with 50% back wages forthwith. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishan Singh v. Executive Engineer, Haryana State Agricultural Marketing Board, Rohtak (Haryana) .
    (Mar 12, 2010)