AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 981
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 981
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Rajendra Singh and Karvendra Singh, both Sub-Registrars in the Revenue Service of Uttar Pradesh, were transferred by Office Order dated 31 July 2007 issued by the Inspector General of Registration:

  • Karvendra Singh: Ghaziabad IV → Hapur II
  • Rajendra Singh: Hapur II → Ghaziabad IV

Karvendra Singh filed a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench) challenging his transfer. On 22 August 2007 the High Court upheld his own transfer but quashed the transfer of Rajendra Singh. Both officers obtained special-leave and appealed to the Supreme Court, leading to the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court exceeded the permissible scope of judicial review by quashing Rajendra Singh’s transfer.
  2. Whether either transfer was tainted by mala fides, violation of statutory rules, or other legal infirmity.

Arguments of the Parties

Karvendra Singh (Writ Petitioner)

  • Had been posted at Ghaziabad IV for only a month; the fresh transfer was arbitrary.
  • Order allegedly stemmed from a private complaint (Radhey Lal) and was stigmatic and issued without application of mind.
  • Questioned Rajendra Singh’s suitability, citing a pending vigilance enquiry and a 2005 adverse entry.

State Government

  • Ghaziabad IV is an important sub-district; transfers were made purely on administrative grounds.
  • Denied any mala fides or punitive intent.

Rajendra Singh (Respondent 5)

  • Relied on extensive experience at Allahabad, Kanpur, Varanasi, and Ghaziabad.
  • Vigilance enquiry had been closed; the 2005 adverse entry was under appeal and not operative.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P. v. Gobardhan Lal (2004) 11 SCC 402 No vested right to remain at a particular post; transfer is an incident of service. Emphasised that both officers could be moved in administrative exigency.
Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar, 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659 Court should not interfere with a transfer made in public interest unless violative of rules or mala fide. Used to criticise the High Court’s interference.
N.K. Singh v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 98 Judicial review of a transfer is confined to mala fides or breach of specific provisions. Reinforced the narrow scope of review.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • The High Court strayed beyond the limited scope of judicial review by evaluating the comparative integrity and competence of the officers.
  • No evidence of mala fides, statutory violation, or incompetence of the authority issuing the transfer was shown.
  • Assessing Rajendra Singh’s suitability was the exclusive prerogative of the State, not the judiciary.
  • Comments by the High Court cast an unwarranted stigma on Rajendra Singh, potentially affecting pending departmental proceedings.
  • Karvendra Singh’s transfer involved no loss of pay, status, or service conditions and thus required no judicial intervention.

Holding and Implications

Rajendra Singh’s appeal allowed; Karvendra Singh’s appeal dismissed.

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order quashing Rajendra Singh’s transfer, thereby restoring both transfers dated 31 July 2007. The judgment reaffirms the executive’s prerogative in personnel transfers and the narrow grounds for judicial interference, cautioning High Courts against assessing an employee’s competence or integrity in transfer litigation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Rajendra Singh And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others

    R.M Lodha, J.— Leave granted. These two appeals are directed against the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Allahabad at Lucknow on 22-8-2007 whereby the High Court although upheld the order of the transfer of Karvendra Singh (hereinafter referred to as “the writ petitioner”) but quashed the order of transfer of Rajendra Singh (hereinafter referred to as “Respondent 5”). Both, the writ petitioner and Respondent 5, are aggrieved by the order of the High Court and hence, these two appeals by special leave.

    2. The writ petitioner and Respondent 5 are in the Revenue Service of the State of Uttar Pradesh. Both of them are Sub-Registrars. By an Office Order dated 31-7-2007 issued by IG, Registration, the writ petitioner, working as Sub-Registrar, Ghaziabad has been transferred to Hapur II while Respondent 5, working as Sub-Registrar, Hapur II has been transferred to Ghaziabad IV.

    3. The transfer order dated 31-7-2007 came to be challenged by the writ petitioner before the High Court of Allahabad, Lucknow Bench. While challenging the legality of the transfer order, the writ petitioner set up the grounds that he joined as Sub-Registrar, Ghaziabad, Sadar IV only a month back; that the transfer order has been issued on the complaint of one Radhey Lal, Sanyojak, Dalit Morcha Sangharsh Samiti, Lucknow and that the order of transfer was arbitrary, stigmatic and suffers from non-application of mind.

    4. The writ petitioner also set up the case that Respondent 5, who has been transferred in his place as Sub-Registrar, Ghaziabad IV did not have good service record; that there was vigilance enquiry pending against Respondent 5 on charges of corruption and that his service record bears adverse entry in the year 2005.

    5. Respondent 5 as well as the State Government vehemently opposed the writ petition.

    6. On behalf of the State Government, it was submitted that although a complaint came to be received from one Radhey Lal against the writ petitioner but Ghaziabad IV being an important sub-district from the point of view of registration of deeds/instruments as well as revenue collection, the transfer of the writ petitioner from Ghaziabad IV to Hapur II was done on administrative grounds. The State Government emphatically refuted the allegation of mala fides and denied that the order of transfer was stigmatic or punitive.

    7. Respondent 5 filed a separate counter-affidavit in opposition to the writ petition. He set up the plea that he has rich experience as Sub-Registrar having worked at places such as Allahabad, Kanpur, Varanasi and Ghaziabad. He stated that vigilance enquiry against him has been closed and his appeal against the adverse entry made in his service record in 2005 is pending and that pending disposal of that appeal, no effect has been given to the said adverse entry.

    8. A government servant has no vested right to remain posted at a place of his choice nor can he insist that he must be posted at one place or the other. He is liable to be transferred in the administrative exigencies from one place to the other. Transfer of an employee is not only an incident inherent in the terms of appointment but also implicit as an essential condition of service in the absence of any specific indication to the contrary. No Government can function if the government servant insists that once appointed or posted in a particular place or position, he should continue in such place or position as long as he desires (see State of U.P v. Gobardhan Lal (2004) 11 SCC 402).

    9. The courts are always reluctant in interfering with the transfer of an employee unless such transfer is vitiated by violation of some statutory provisions or suffers from mala fides. In Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659, AIR 1991 SC 532 this Court held:

    “4. In our opinion, the courts should not interfere with a transfer order which is made in public interest and for administrative reasons unless the transfer orders are made in violation of any mandatory statutory rule or on the ground of mala fide. A government servant holding a transferable post has no vested right to remain posted at one place or the other, he is liable to be transferred from one place to the other. Transfer orders issued by the competent authority do not violate any of his legal rights. Even if a transfer order is passed in violation of executive instructions or orders, the courts ordinarily should not interfere with the order instead affected party should approach the higher authorities in the department. If the courts continue to interfere with day-to-day transfer orders issued by the government and its subordinate authorities, there will be complete chaos in the administration which would not be conducive to public interest. The High Court overlooked these aspects in interfering with the transfer orders.”

    10. In N.K Singh v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 98, (1994) 28 ATC 246 this Court reiterated that:

    “6. … the scope of judicial review in matters of transfer of a government servant to an equivalent post without any adverse consequence on the service or career prospects is very limited being confined only to the grounds of mala fides and violation of any specific provision….”

    11. Insofar as the transfer of the writ petitioner from Ghaziabad IV to Hapur II is concerned, the High Court found that the transfer order has not affected his service conditions and pay and other benefits attached to the post which was held by him. As a matter of fact, the High Court did not find any flaw in the transfer of the writ petitioner from Ghaziabad IV to Hapur II.

    12. As regards Respondent 5, the High Court considered the matter thus:

    “… in our view, it is evident that Respondent 5 also cannot be said to be an officer having a better conduct and integrity in comparison to the petitioner justifying his posting at Ghaziabad and in this regard, it appears that IG (Stamps) did not give correct information to the Principal Secretary. However, it cannot be held that Respondent 1 in passing the order dated 31-7-2007 has acted maliciously or for extraneous reasons amounting to mala fide. Once the basic ground of challenge to the impugned order of transfer that the same is malicious in law falls, we do not find any reason to interfere with the impugned order of transfer, transferring the petitioner from Ghaziabad to Hapur.
    It is not the case of the petitioner that his transfer is contrary to rules or has been issued by an authority who is not competent. It is well settled that an order of transfer is amenable for judicial review on limited grounds, namely, it is contrary to rules or has been passed by an incompetent authority or is a result of mala fide. In view of admission on the part of Respondent 1 in his counter-affidavit that Respondent 5 has been found guilty of serious misconduct for causing loss to the Government Revenue by acting without jurisdiction and colluding evasion of stamp duty, in our view transfer of Respondent 5 to Ghaziabad cannot be sustained in view of further admission on the part of Respondent 1 that the interest of the Department requires posting of an honest and efficient person at Ghaziabad.”

    13. It is difficult to fathom why the High Court went into the comparative conduct and integrity of the petitioner and Respondent 5 while dealing with a transfer matter. The High Court should have appreciated the true extent of scrutiny into a matter of transfer and the limited scope of judicial review. Respondent 5 being a Sub-Registrar, it is for the State Government or for that matter the Inspector General of Registration to decide about his place of posting. As to at what place Respondent 5 should be posted is an exclusive prerogative of the State Government and in exercise of that prerogative, Respondent 5 was transferred from Hapur II to Ghaziabad IV keeping in view administrative exigencies.

    14. We are pained to observe that the High Court seriously erred in deciding as to whether Respondent 5 was a competent person to be posted at Ghaziabad IV as Sub-Registrar. The exercise undertaken by the High Court did not fall within its domain and was rather uncalled for. We are unable to approve the direction issued to the State Government and the Inspector General of Registration to transfer a competent officer at Ghaziabad IV as Sub-Registrar after holding that Respondent 5 cannot be said to be an officer having a better conduct and integrity in comparison to the petitioner justifying his posting at Ghaziabad IV. The High Court entered into an arena which did not belong to it and thereby committed serious error of law.

    15. The only question required to be seen was whether transfer of Respondent 5 was actuated with mala fides or otherwise in violation of statutory rules. The transfer of Respondent 5 was not found to suffer from any of these vices. The High Court went into the competence and suitability of Respondent 5 for such posting. It is here that the High Court fell into a grave error. As a matter of fact, the impugned order of the High Court casts stigma on the service of Respondent 5 which may also act prejudicial to his interest in the pending appeal against the adverse remarks.

    16. We may also observe that transfer of the writ petitioner from Ghaziabad IV to Hapur II cannot be said to be stigmatic and any observation made in the impugned order about the work and conduct of the writ petitioner shall not be read adversely by the authorities against the writ petitioner.

    17. Consequently, the order dated 22-8-2007 passed by the High Court quashing the transfer of Respondent 5 from Hapur II to Ghaziabad IV is set aside. Appeal of Rajendra Singh is allowed while appeal of Karvendra Singh stands dismissed with clarification as indicated above. The parties shall bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajendra Singh And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others
    (Jul 31, 2009)