Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 513
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 11-A of the Act
  • Section 9 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 6 of the Act, year 1986
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 513
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 11-A of the Act
  • Section 9 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 6 of the Act, year 1986
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 3 February 1970 the State of Maharashtra issued a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 to acquire land spread over 96 villages for the creation of a “New Bombay Project.” Among the lands notified were 53 acres (5300 sq m) in Village Wahal, District Raigad, belonging to the present appellants. A Section 6 declaration followed on 21 May 1971.

The Land Acquisition Collector passed an award on 30 June 1986. Dissatisfied, the claimants sought a reference under Section 18; the matter reached the District Judge, who on 30 January 1988 fixed compensation at Rs 5 per sq m (Rs 5 per sq m in most references; Rs 6 and Rs 10 per sq m in two connected references by applying a “belting” method).

Both the State and landowners appealed. The High Court dismissed the landowners’ appeals and allowed the State’s cross-appeals, standardising compensation at Rs 5 per sq m (reducing Rs 10 to Rs 7 in one case). The landowners then approached the Supreme Court in the present batch of civil appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the correct market value of the acquired lands in Village Wahal as on the Section 4 notification date (3-2-1970)?
  2. Whether the Reference Court and High Court erred in rejecting the expert valuation of Rs 15 per sq m offered by the appellants.
  3. Whether the “belting system,” adopted in other New Bombay compensation cases, should guide valuation in the present appeals.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The expert witness, Mr Jeevan Kulkarni, provided a “modest” valuation of Rs 15 per sq m that ought not to have been discarded.
  • The Bombay High Court decision in Unama Padu Hudar v. State of Maharashtra accepted belting and awarded Rs 20–25 per sq m for similarly situated villages (Panvel/Kamothe); by parity, Wahal merits at least Rs 20.
  • Subsequent notifications (1986) and later High Court awards as high as Rs 1,725 per sq m show rapid development, underscoring the land’s potential.

State’s Arguments

  • Supported the impugned High Court judgment affirming Rs 5 per sq m (Rs 7 in one reference) as adequate compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Unama Padu Hudar v. State of Maharashtra (Bombay HC) Use of “belting system” and rates of Rs 20–25 per sq m in neighbouring villages (Panvel/Kamothe) Considered as comparative guidance but distinguished due to distance (9 km) and lesser development in Village Wahal
Rao Narain Singh v. Union of India, (1993) 3 SCC 60 Building potentiality need not be evaluated when comparable-sales method is used Cited to emphasise choice of valuation methodology
Viluben Jhalejar Contractor v. State of Gujarat, (2005) 4 SCC 789 Compensation calculation factors; need for adjustments; permissible “guesswork” in absence of direct evidence Guided the Court in making a calibrated estimate (Rs 10 per sq m) despite limited data
State of Maharashtra v. Trimbak Joma Thakur, (2007) 5 Mah LJ 187 Later New Bombay references awarding Rs 200–230 per sq m based on 1986 notification Used only as contextual background; Court declined to apply those rates to a 1970 notification but adopted the belting approach acknowledged therein

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first noted the paucity of contemporaneous sale instances for Village Wahal and the admitted absence of industrial or commercial development in 1970. The Reference Court’s factual findings—no electricity, no railway station, grassy agricultural land—were accepted.

Evaluating the expert evidence, the Court held that Mr Kulkarni’s report lacked reliability: he visited the land only in 1986, relied on a 1978 MIDC pipeline lease (post-notification), and sourced sale data from other districts. Consequently, his Rs 15 valuation could not serve as a safe benchmark.

Turning to comparative awards, the Court observed that the High Court had earlier employed a belting system for nearby villages, awarding Rs 20–25 per sq m where lands abutted the Bombay–Pune Highway. Considering that Village Wahal is approximately 9 km from Panvel and lacked comparable infrastructure, the Court treated those awards only as indicative of method, not quantum.

Applying the principles in Viluben Jhalejar, the Court acknowledged that valuation involves “inevitable guesswork” when evidence is scant and that development charges and negative factors must be weighed. Balancing potentiality (proposed port, roads, future urbanisation) against prevailing rural conditions in 1970, the Court fixed compensation at Rs 10 per sq m—doubling the High Court figure yet well below the rates for more proximate, developed villages.

Holding and Implications

The appeals are allowed in part: compensation is enhanced and standardised to Rs 10 per square metre for the acquired lands in all appeals. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision raises compensation for the appellants while affirming the belting methodology as a reasonable tool for large-scale urban acquisitions. The ruling is fact-specific to Village Wahal’s 1970 circumstances and sets no new legal precedent beyond reiterating valuation principles previously recognised by the Supreme Court.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Avinash Dhavaji Naik v. State Of Maharashtra .

    S.B Sinha, J.— These appeals involving similar questions of fact and law were taken up for hearing together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.

    2. By reason of a Notification dated 3-2-1970, the State of Maharashtra expressed its desire to acquire a large chunk of land situated in 96 villages for the purpose of forming a new twin city near Bombay called as “the New Bombay Project”. By reason of the said notification, 53 acres of land i.e 5300 sq m belonging to the appellants herein and situated in Village Wahal in the district of Raigad, Maharashtra was sought to be acquired. A declaration in terms of Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act (for short “the Act”) was made on 21-5-1971.

    3. A notice under Section 9 of the Act was issued pursuant whereto the appellant claimants filed their applications for payment of enhanced compensation. The Land Acquisition Collector made his award. Aggrieved by and dissatisfied therewith, the appellants filed applications before the Collector for reference in terms of Section 18 of the Act pursuant whereto reference was made to the Court of the District Judge in the year 1986.

    4. Before the Reference Court, the parties adduced their respective evidence. The appellants examined one Jeevan Kulkarni (PW 2) as an expert witness. He made valuation of the lands in question. He visited the land on or about 20-6-1987 and prepared a report estimating the value of the land at the rate of Rs 15 per square metre i.e Rs 60,000 per acre. By reason of the award dated 30-1-1988, the Reference Court awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 5 per square metre with all other benefits.

    5. In reference cases involved in Civil Appeals Nos. 4260-61 of 2002 (Ramdas Dattatraya Naik v. State of Maharashtra) and Civil Appeals Nos. 4264-65 of 2002 (Dattatraya Krishna Naik v. State of Maharashtra), however, compensation was awarded upon adopting the belting method at the rate of Rs 6 and Rs 10 per square metre respectively. Both the parties preferred appeals and cross-appeals thereagainst.

    6. By reason of the impugned judgment, whereas the appeal preferred by the appellants had been dismissed, the cross-appeals preferred by the State in Civil Appeals Nos. 4260-61 of 2002 and in Civil Appeals Nos. 4264-65 of 2002 were allowed holding that compensation determined at the rate of Rs 5 per square metre was justified. However, in Civil Appeals Nos. 4264-65 of 2002 where the trial court awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 10 per square metre, it was reduced to Rs 7 per square metre by reason of the impugned judgment.

    7. Mr Uday U. Lalit, learned Senior Counsel, in support of these appeals, would contend that the Reference Court as also the High Court could not have rejected the testimony of Mr Jeevan Kulkarni who made a modest estimate in regard to valuation of the land at the rate of Rs 15 per square metre. Drawing our attention to a judgment of the Bombay High Court in Unama Padu Hudar v. State of Maharashtra, the learned counsel urged that in respect of Villages Panvel and Kamothe, the High Court itself adopted belting system and granted various amounts of compensation depending upon the proximity of the village from the national highway running between Bombay and Pune to the following effect:

    “Group No. First Appeal No. Rate granted per sq m I. Abutting the highway 754 of 1986 763 of 1986 25 II. Within 800 m 751 of 1986 (Part) 756 of 1986 23 III. Abutting Kamothe-Z.P Road to 1200 m 753 of 1986 751 of 1988 (Part) 752 of 1986 22 IV-A. 800 m to 2200 m from Bombay-Pune Highway 755 of 1986 20 IV-B. 20 m from Z.P Road and Gaothan to 640 m from Z.P Road and Gaothan 743 of 1986 20”

    8. Our attention was also drawn to the fact that in some cases where award could not be made and published within a period of two years from 24-9-1984 from which date Section 11-A was inserted in the Act, a fresh notification was issued in the year 1986. Recently, the Bombay High Court by reason of a judgment and order dated 21-6-2007 has granted compensation at the rate of Rs 1725 per square metre. It was urged that in these views of the matter and keeping in view the fact that the appellant in Civil Appeal No. 4259 of 2002 has paid great fees for obtaining compensation at the rate of Rs 20 per square metre, this Court may award compensation suitably.

    9. Mr Sanjay V. Kharde, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State, on the other hand, supported the impugned judgment.

    10. For the sake of convenience, we may hereto below place the relevant details:

    Civil Appeal No. Area Award Reference Court High Court 4259 of 2002 5300 sq m Re 1 Rs 5 Rs 5 4266 of 2002 13,600 sq m Re 1 Rs 5 Rs 5 4262 of 2002 23,300 sq m Re 1 Rs 5 Rs 5 4260-61 of 2002 19,800 sq m Re 1 Rs 6 Rs 5 4263 of 2002 22,490 sq m Re 1 Rs 5 Rs 5 4264-65 of 2002 5 acres 2 guntas Re 1 Rs 10 Rs 5 (in one case Rs 7)

    11. The purpose for acquisition of land was building a new city. A vast tract of land was sought to be acquired. Indisputably, in terms of Section 23 of the Act, the market value of the land was required to be determined as was obtaining in the year 1970 when the notification under Section 4 of the Act was issued. It is unfortunate that despite the fact that Notification was issued under Section 4 of the Act as far back as on 3-2-1970 and a declaration under Section 6 of the Act was issued on 21-5-1971, the award came to be passed only on 30-6-1986 and that too probably, only having regard to the consequences ensuing in terms of Section 11-A of the Act.

    12. A finding of fact was arrived at by the learned Reference Judge that no sale instance was available for the lands situated in Village Wahal and there was no industrial or commercial development therein. The Pune-Bombay Highway was constructed in the year 1978. The MIDC pipeline was constructed in the year 1978. There was no railway station nearby the village. The villagers did not obtain any electricity connection. The land was a grassy land. In the absence of any example of sale being available, the Reference Court was required to take recourse to other methods of valuation. We do not find that enough materials had been brought on record to establish the yield of the lands sought to be acquired, which are admittedly agricultural in nature. In all fairness, the State should have brought on record the requisite information viz. the nature of the crop, the annual average yield, availability of irrigation facilities, etc. so as to enable the Reference Court to arrive at a correct decision in regard to grant of compensation under the Act.

    13. Although the lands in question were agricultural in nature, they were being used for making a town like Bombay. A new port known as Nhava Sheva Port had come into being which is a few kilometres away from the village. The roads were being constructed. The road to Nhava Sheva Port from Bombay is a district board road which is within 7 km from the village in question. A copy of the New Bombay Development Plan has been placed before us to point out construction of the national highway i.e Bombay-Pune Road as also the other district board roads.

    14. The potentiality of a land for the purpose of development as also for building purposes would depend upon a large number of factors. For the said purpose, the court may not only have to bear in mind the purpose for which the lands were sought to be acquired but also the subsequent events to some extent.

    15. In a case of this nature the court may proceed on the presumption that such a vast tract of land viz. 96 villages were sought to be acquired at the same time for construction of New Bombay. We are not unmindful of the fact that development in the entire area was not possible at one point of time. Development of the area must have taken place in phases. We are also not unmindful of the fact that the price of the land may skyrocket depending upon the development as also future potentiality.

    16. The High Court, as noticed hereinbefore, in respect of Village Kamothe adopted a belting system. It awarded compensation varying from Rs 20 to Rs 25 per square metre depending upon the proximity from the national highway. In respect of Village Panvel, however, although the lands were not proximate to the national highway but a standard was adopted for the purpose of grant of compensation on the proximity from the district board roads. If that criterion is to be adopted, in our opinion, some subsequent events may also be taken into consideration therefor. In search of legal principles of valuation of land, we may notice some decisions.

    17. In Rao Narain Singh v. Union of India (1993) 3 SCC 60 this Court held:

    “8. Building potentiality of the acquired land, claimed to be possessed by the acquired land, can assume no significance in the instant case as ‘the comparable sales method’ of valuation of land is resorted to by the High Court. Such method is resorted to, as the acquired land was found to be comparable in its essential features with land(s) respecting which evidence of certain sale deed(s), was produced. Hence, the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant raised to establish that the acquired land had building potentiality at the time of its acquisition, need not engage our consideration.”

    18. Yet again in Viluben Jhalejar Contractor v. State of Gujarat (2005) 4 SCC 789, it was held:

    “20. The amount of compensation cannot be ascertained with mathematical accuracy. A comparable instance has to be identified having regard to the proximity from time angle as well as proximity from situation angle. For determining the market value of the land under acquisition, suitable adjustment has to be made having regard to various positive and negative factors vis-à-vis the land under acquisition by placing the two in juxtaposition. The positive and negative factors are as under:

    Positive factors Negative factors (i) smallness of size (i) largeness of area (ii) proximity to a road (ii) situation in the interior at a distance from the road (iii) frontage on a road (iii) narrow strip of land with very small frontage compared to depth (iv) nearness to developed area (iv) lower level requiring the depressed portion to be filled up (v) regular shape (v) remoteness from developed locality (vi) level vis-à-vis land under acquisition (vi) some special disadvantageous factors which would deter a purchaser (vii) special value for an owner of an adjoining property to whom it may have some very special advantage

    21. Whereas a smaller plot may be within the reach of many, a large block of land will have to be developed preparing a layout plan, carving out roads, leaving open spaces, plotting out smaller plots, waiting for purchasers and the hazards of an entrepreneur. Such development charges may range between 20% and 50% of the total price.”

    19. Applying the aforementioned legal principles to the facts of the present case, we are of the opinion that if the belting system is taken recourse to, compensation at the rate of Rs 10 per square metre would subserve the ends of justice.

    20. The Reference Court in another case (State of Maharashtra v. Trimbak Joma Thakur (2007) 5 Mah LJ 187) fixed the amount of compensation at Rs 230 per square metre. The Reference Court in the instant case, having regard to the non-agricultural potential of the land, made the valuation at the rate of Rs 5 per square metre. It was held:

    “… Admittedly those lands are not from Village Wahal. Considering this type of evidence of an expert, I certainly conclude that bearing in mind the distance of the acquired lands from Panvel which is far expanding city, this land has certainly NA potentiality in the year 1970 also. There are other industrial developments and particularly Nhava Sheva Port Trust, Navy; the lands would have certainly fetched the price more than the awarded price.
    In the circumstances, from the evidence on record, I say that the opponent has paid less compensation and it is necessary to increase the amount of compensation…. Thus, considering the evidence before me, I can guess the possible correct rate of compensation and according to me, it is necessary to award compensation at the rate of Rs 5 per square metre for the present acquired lands.”

    21. We have arrived at the rate of Rs 10 per square metre of land for the purpose of grant of compensation because the distance between Village Panvel and Village Wahal is about 9 km. Panvel was a municipal area, Wahal was a Gram Panchayat. We have noticed hereinbefore that even the electricity had not reached Village Wahal.

    22. The appellant in Civil Appeal No. 4259 of 2002, in his deposition categorically admitted the factors to which we have taken note of heretobefore as regards non-development of the land. The expert opinion of the valuer also could not be fully relied upon as not only had he visited the village in the year 1986 but also in his evidence he admitted:

    “… In my valuation report, I have taken capitalisation method. While taking income capitalisation method, I have noted that in the Indian context, it is very difficult to prove the agricultural income because of the heart (sic high) percentage illiteracy and no accounts are maintained by the agriculturist….”

    It is in that view of the matter, the Reference Court did not rely upon his evidence, stating:

    “I found that Mr Kulkarni has not considered the aspect of capitalisation properly. For the purpose of capitalisation, he mainly relied upon the lease in favour of MIDC. In fact MIDC had installed the pipeline in the year 1978 as stated by the claimant. So on the date of notification, the lease instance was not available. Consequently, the conclusion drawn by Mr Kulkarni on the strength of capitalisation will not be helpful to determine the price of the land as on the date of notification.
    Further, Mr Kulkarni has considered the sale instances from villages in Thane District. Mr Kulkarni has fairly admitted that he could not get any sale instance from Village Wahal or the adjoining villages. He has further admitted that there were no industrial or commercial activities in Village Wahal in 1970. Thus, his guesswork, with regard to NA potentiality is based on the sale instances and the awards which he has considered. From his report it appears that he has considered sale instance from Village Shahabaj which is 3 to 4 km away from Village Wahal. The rate paid in the sale instance is Rs 7.77 per square metre. The awards which he has considered also show that amounts of Rs 8 to Rs 15 per square metre were awarded by various courts for adjoining lands….”

    23. Another aspect of the matter cannot also be lost sight of. In the instant case, the Land Acquisition Collector valued the lands at 35 paise per square metre, the Reference Court opined that valuation would be Rs 5 per square metre. Whereas in First Appeal No. 754 of 1986 decided on 26-2-1993, the Land Acquisition Collector himself valued the land at the rate of Rs 6 per square metre wherewith the Reference Court did not differ and the belting system for the first time was adopted by the High Court itself in First Appeal No. 646 of 1995 decided on 21-6-2007 (2007) 5 Mah LJ 187, the Land Acquisition Collector valued the lands at the rate of Rs 200 to 230 per square metre which was upheld by the Reference Court. In that case, notification under Section 6 of the Act was issued in the year 1986. Within a span of 16 years, a lot of development had taken place. The lands in question in that case involved commercial lands and deeds of sale were available for the purpose of determination of the amount of compensation.

    24. However, if not the judgment dated 21-6-2007 (2007) 5 Mah LJ 187, the judgment dated 26-2-1993, in our opinion, can be put to use at least for a limited purpose viz. option of belting method and grant of compensation on the basis of the proximity of the national highway and the other.

    25. Keeping in view the aforementioned principles in mind, we have arrived at the aforementioned figure of Rs 10 per square metre.

    26. In a case of this nature, in our opinion, some guesswork is inevitable. (See Viluben Jhalejar Contractor (2005) 4 SCC 789.) We must, however, add that the judgment rendered by the High Court in Civil Appeals Nos. 4264-65 of 2002 may be a safe guide particularly when the Reference Court itself opined that the valuation of the land should be determined at Rs 10 per square metre. Thus, the said valuation adopted may be considered as providing for some guideline.

    27. The appeals are allowed in part and to the extent mentioned hereinbefore. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Avinash Dhavaji Naik v. State Of Maharashtra .
    (Apr 15, 2009)